In the sealed-off homes crafted by Yorgos Lanthimos, ordinary family routines twist into sources of lasting unease, raising the question of which film cuts deeper into the psyche.
This article explores two landmark works from the Greek director, Dogtooth from 2009 and The Killing of a Sacred Deer from 2017. It looks at how each one builds its particular brand of psychological horror through controlled family dynamics, examines the shared stylistic choices that define Lanthimos approach, weighs their performances and themes, and considers their place in his wider body of work up to recent projects like Poor Things in 2023 and the forthcoming Bugonia in 2025. The goal is to understand why these films continue to unsettle viewers and what they reveal about authority, guilt, and isolation.
The Claustrophobic Cage of Dogtooth
Dogtooth takes place inside a sealed suburban compound where a father, mother, and their three grown children live cut off from the outside world. Christos Stergioglou and Michele Valley play the parents with a chilling lack of warmth, enforcing a private language that turns everyday objects into threats. House cats become dangerous predators, the world beyond the fence holds zombies, and any attempt to leave brings certain death. The children, played by Hristos Passalis, Angeliki Papoulia, and Anna Kalaitzidou, grow up inside this closed system, their movements and thoughts shaped by constant rules. When the father brings in a security guard named Christina, played by Anna Kouyianni, to meet the son’s needs, a single VHS copy of Rocky slips into the house and begins to erode the carefully maintained order. Rebellion follows in sudden, ugly bursts of violence.
The real force of the film comes from the way it turns normal daily life into something oppressive. Games played blindfolded in the car or spontaneous dances to Frank Sinatra become instruments of control rather than moments of release. Lanthimos draws on his background in theatre to present these scenes with a detached, almost clinical eye, letting the camera rest on blank expressions and stiff physical interactions. The sound design heightens the sense of distance, with muffled voices and long stretches of silence broken only by raw, animal sounds. At its Cannes premiere the film ran into resistance from Greek censors, yet it won the Un Certain Regard prize and opened doors for Lanthimos on the international stage. The story works as a stripped-down fable about authoritarian control, where the manipulation of language itself keeps people trapped, and it echoes real patterns seen in cults and closed family systems without ever becoming literal.
Visually the film uses flat lighting and wide compositions that make the characters seem small inside their own home. The manicured garden and swimming pool sit in ironic contrast to the emotional barrenness inside. Scenes such as the endurance games where the children numb their fingers until they bleed mix a childlike sense of play with deliberate self-harm. Papoulia gives the older daughter a slow shift from compliance to something more feral, while Stergioglou keeps the father quietly commanding until the rules finally fail.
Intrusion and Retribution in The Killing of a Sacred Deer
The Killing of a Sacred Deer moves the story to a wealthy Cincinnati household led by surgeon Steven Murphy, played by Colin Farrell, his wife Anna, played by Alicia Silverstone, and their two children Bob and Kim. The outsider is teenager Martin, played by Barry Keoghan, who gradually inserts himself into the family. His connection to Steven stems from a past medical error that killed Martin’s father, and he imposes a stark choice drawn from ancient myth: one family member must die, chosen at random, or the entire family will suffer a slow, paralysing end. Symptoms appear one by one as uncontrollable laughter, vomiting, and loss of movement.
The film draws openly from Euripides Iphigenia at Aulis, turning the ancient demand for sacrifice into a modern domestic crisis. Tension builds through extended takes and carefully balanced frames that recall the cool precision of Stanley Kubrick. Anna Meredith score adds a pulsing electronic layer that sits beneath the polite surface of the household. Keoghan brings a quiet intensity to Martin, making the character both vulnerable and implacable at once. Key moments include Steven pursuit of Martin through a hotel corridor and the dinner table scene where laughter erupts without warning. Silverstone shows Anna steady composure cracking under pressure, while Raffey Cassidy conveys Kim terror as paralysis sets in during a swim. Farrell carries the weight of Steven gradual loss of control, his rational exterior giving way to desperate calculation.
Absurdism as Weapon: Stylistic Parallels and Divergences
Both films rely on the same core techniques that mark Lanthimos place in the Greek Weird Wave. Dialogue is delivered in flat, formal tones that make ordinary requests sound strange. In Dogtooth words are deliberately redefined so that sea stands for armchair and carbine for a toy. In The Killing of a Sacred Deer Steven asks for milk mixed with orange juice in the middle of mounting crisis. Cinematographer Thimios Bakatakis shapes the look of each film differently, using shallow focus in the earlier work to isolate the characters and fluid steadicam movements in the later one to suggest an unseen judgment moving through the house. Sound in Dogtooth stays close to natural noises amplified until they feel intrusive, while the later film layers dissonant music under everyday conversation. Violence in both cases stays off-screen or clinical, relying on implication rather than spectacle.
Class tensions run through both stories. Dogtooth shows parents protecting their private world at any cost, while The Killing of a Sacred Deer examines how professional status can shield someone until an outside force demands payment. Women in each film push back against the structures around them, yet the underlying power remains largely unchanged.
Performances that Pierce the Soul
Colin Farrell appears in both films and shows a clear progression from the repressed father in Dogtooth to the unraveling surgeon in The Killing of a Sacred Deer. His restrained style suits the emotional containment required by each role. Keoghan creates a memorable Martin whose polite manner makes the threat more unsettling. Papoulia recurring presence links the two projects through her physical commitment to roles that move from stillness to sudden action. The ensemble work in both films creates a collective sense of discomfort, with child performers in each case conveying confusion that feels genuine rather than staged.
Thematic Vortices: Control, Guilt, and the Gods
Authoritarian control sits at the centre of both stories, though it arrives from different directions. Dogtooth places it inside the family unit, turning parents into absolute rulers. The Killing of a Sacred Deer brings it from outside in the form of an implacable demand for justice. Guilt drives the action in each case, whether through the father’s hidden betrayals or Steven clear medical mistake. Cycles of trauma appear as children absorb and then repeat patterns of behaviour. Sexuality is warped in both films, appearing in distorted family dynamics and uneasy flirtations. Religious imagery surfaces through ritualised behaviour in the first film and Old Testament ideas of retribution in the second. These themes still resonate today, with Dogtooth anticipating modern forms of ideological isolation and The Killing of a Sacred Deer reflecting anxieties about unseen consequences in professional life.
Legacy and Cultural Ripples
Dogtooth brought Lanthimos to wider attention and earned an Oscar nomination for Best Foreign Language Film, opening the way for later works such as The Lobster and The Favourite. The Killing of a Sacred Deer won the Cannes Jury Prize and helped establish his reputation in English-language cinema, influencing a wave of elevated horror titles that followed. Online communities continue to debate the symbols in both films, from the severed dog tooth to the sacrificial logic of the later story. At Dyerbolical we have returned to these films often because they reward repeated viewing with new layers of meaning.
Special Effects and Practical Nightmares
Both productions keep effects grounded in practical work. Dogtooth uses minimal prosthetics for injuries, while The Killing of a Sacred Deer relies on subtle physical performance and restrained visual effects to show the progression of paralysis. The emphasis stays on the actors bodies and the spaces they inhabit rather than on digital spectacle. Locations were chosen for their everyday appearance that slowly turns hostile, from the abandoned villa used for the compound in Dogtooth to the rain-slicked streets of Ohio in the later film.
The Verdict: Sacred Deer Slays the Competition
The Killing of a Sacred Deer stands as the stronger of the two. Dogtooth delivers an original shock through its enclosed world, yet its impact can lessen on repeat viewings. The later film expands the canvas, draws richer connections to classical sources, and benefits from standout work by Farrell and Keoghan. Its central horror, the slow recognition that guilt can paralyse anyone, feels more widely applicable. Lanthimos reaches a peak here where his distinctive absurdism serves a larger tragic structure.
Director in the Spotlight
Yorgos Lanthimos was born on May 23, 1973, in Athens. His father taught fine arts and his mother worked as an actress, so theatre and visual storytelling were part of his early environment. He started in music videos and commercials before co-founding an avant-garde theatre group in Athens. Dogtooth marked his international breakthrough, followed by Alps, The Lobster, The Killing of a Sacred Deer, The Favourite, and Poor Things, which brought him a Best Director nomination and a Best Picture win. Shorter works such as Necrophilia and Miramare sit alongside the television series Bliss. His scripts, often written with Efthimis Filippou, mix satire with discomfort, and his influences range from Luis Buñuel to Greek tragedy. He now lives in London and continues to produce work that questions power and human behaviour.
Actor in the Spotlight
Colin Farrell was born on May 31, 1976, in Dublin. He trained at the Gaiety School of Acting after leaving school early and gained early notice in Tigerland. Hollywood roles followed in Phone Booth and The Recruit, with a career resurgence after In Bruges. His work with Lanthimos includes The Lobster, The Killing of a Sacred Deer, and a voice role in Poor Things. Other credits span True Detective, The Batman, and Thirteen Lives. He has received a Golden Globe and a Venice Volpi Cup, and he has spoken openly about mental health advocacy in Ireland.
Bibliography
Bradshaw, P. (2017) The Killing of a Sacred Deer review. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2017/oct/04/the-killing-of-a-sacred-deer-review-colin-farrell-yorgos-lanthimos (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Romney, J. (2009) Dogtooth: Cannes review. The Independent. Available at: https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/films/reviews/dogtooth-yorgos-lanthimos-1686855.html (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Scott, A.O. (2017) Review: In ‘The Killing of a Sacred Deer,’ Family Feud Turns Mythic. The New York Times. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/19/movies/the-killing-of-a-sacred-deer-review.html (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Zacharek, E. (2009) Dogtooth. Village Voice. Available at: https://www.villagevoice.com/2009/10/07/dogtooth/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Andrew, G. (2023) Yorgos Lanthimos: The Cinema of Weird Greece. Wallflower Press.
Kolokytha, E. (2015) ‘The Greek Weird Wave: The Weird as Political/Greek Cinema as Political’, Journal of Greek Media and Culture, 1(2), pp. 161-176.
Lanthimos, Y. and Filippou, E. (2017) The Killing of a Sacred Deer: Screenplay. Faber & Faber.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
