There’s a real thrill in revisiting those battered VHS tapes of Conan the Barbarian and Excalibur, where the clatter of swords and the weight of destiny still feel fresh decades later. These two films arrived at the start of the 1980s and carved out very different paths through fantasy cinema, one built on raw survival and the other on ancient legend coming alive. This article compares their tones directly, looking at how John Milius and John Boorman each shaped heroism, violence, and wonder while keeping every original detail and reference from the source material intact.
Picture a world where chainmail grinds against stone and enchanted blades hum with otherworldly power. The early 1980s birthed two cornerstone films that captured the era’s hunger for mythic escapism: Conan the Barbarian (1982) and Excalibur (1981). Directed by John Milius and John Boorman respectively, these epics stand as polar forces in the sword-and-sorcery genre, one a forge of raw savagery, the other a tapestry of Arthurian dreamscape. This exploration pits their tones head-to-head, revealing how each sculpted the fantasy landscape in profoundly different ways.
- Conan’s unyielding grit and visceral combat sequences forge a tone of relentless barbarism, contrasting Excalibur’s poetic mysticism rooted in Celtic lore.
- Both films master visual poetry through practical effects and lush cinematography, yet diverge in their portrayal of heroism and destiny.
- Their legacies endure, influencing modern blockbusters while cementing 80s nostalgia as a golden age of epic fantasy.
The Forge of Fury: Conan’s Savage Origins
John Milius channels the pulp vigour of Robert E. Howard’s tales into a cinematic battering ram. Conan the Barbarian opens with the Cimmerian’s village razed by Thulsa Doom’s snake cult, thrusting young Conan into a life of slavery, gladiatorial combat, and vengeance. Arnold Schwarzenegger embodies the warrior as a mountain of muscle and minimal words, his journey a brutal odyssey across Hyborian lands. Subotai the thief and Valeria the pirate queen join him, forming a ragtag band driven by loyalty forged in blood. The narrative pulses with themes of strength worship, where Crom, the stoic god, offers no aid – only the will to survive matters.
This tone sets Conan apart as a fantasy epic stripped to its primal bones. No lofty quests for honour here; instead, revenge simmers like a cauldron. Milius infuses Howard’s atheism with a Nietzschean edge, portraying civilisation as corrupt and barbarism as pure. The film’s centrepiece, the Battle of the Mounds, erupts in a frenzy of severed limbs and guttural roars, practical effects by Carlo Rambaldi lending grotesque realism. Audiences in 1982 gasped at the unfiltered violence, a stark rebellion against the sanitized fantasies of prior decades. That raw approach still resonates with collectors today who hunt for uncut prints and appreciate how it paved the way for later gritty series like Game of Thrones.
Yet beneath the gore lies philosophical heft. Conan’s mantra – “What is steel compared to the hand that wields it?” – echoes through every clash, elevating the film beyond mere hack-and-slash. The score by Basil Poledouris swells with tribal drums and choirs, mirroring the hero’s inexorable rage. This sonic brutality cements the tone: anthemic, masculine, unapologetic. Fans often point out how the music turns simple fights into something ritualistic, a detail that keeps drawing new viewers even after restorations in the 2020s.
Mists of Myth: Excalibur’s Enchanted Dream
John Boorman, fresh from Deliverance, reimagines Arthurian legend through a psychedelic lens. Excalibur weaves from Uther Pendragon’s carnal pact with Merlin, birthing Arthur amid swirling fog and Wagnerian motifs. The Lady of the Lake bestows the sword, igniting cycles of unity, betrayal, and redemption. Lancelot’s forbidden love fractures Camelot, Mordred rises in shadow, and the king’s final charge against doom pulses with operatic tragedy.
The tone radiates ethereal grandeur, less a linear tale than a fever-dream cycle. Boorman’s visuals drink deeply from Celtic mythology, with mists parting to reveal armoured knights and glowing runes. Practical effects shine in the sword’s forging – molten metal poured into a stone mould under lunar light – evoking ancient rites. Nigel Terry’s Arthur evolves from boy-king to weary sage, his quiet nobility clashing against Nicol Williamson’s mercurial Merlin, whose spells crackle with mischievous wonder. Many modern viewers at places like Dyerbolical note how these dreamlike sequences still hold up better than most digital effects today.
Music by Trevor Jones and Wagner interpolations elevate the mythic pulse. The film’s rhythm mimics legend itself: birth, rise, fall, rebirth. Where Conan revels in isolation, Excalibur throbs with communal destiny, the Round Table a fragile beacon against chaos. This romanticism captivated 80s viewers seeking transcendence amid Reagan-era anxieties, and its influence shows up in everything from Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings visuals to recent Arthurian-inspired games and streaming adaptations.
Grit Versus Grace: Tonal Titans Collide
At their core, the tones diverge like thunder from mist. Conan’s barbarism revels in the body’s supremacy – sweat-slicked torsos, arterial sprays, the crunch of axe on bone. Milius crafts a world hostile and indifferent, where sorcery corrupts and steel redeems. Excalibur, conversely, drapes fantasy in silken poetry; love’s agony births Mordred, chivalry’s code elevates even the fallen. Boorman’s palette glows with verdant greens and golden armour, his camera gliding like Merlin’s magic.
Heroism manifests differently too. Schwarzenegger’s Conan is self-made, muscles honed in pits, his growl a testament to endurance. Arthur, sword-gifted, grapples with divine burden, his arc a meditation on kingship’s frailty. Combat styles reflect this: Conan’s brawls are chaotic melees, axes whirling in slow-motion savagery; Excalibur’s duels are balletic, blades singing in choreographed fury, slow-motion underscoring fateful blows. The contrast still sparks lively debates among fans who collect both films on special edition Blu-rays.
Cultural context sharpens the contrast. Conan tapped sword-and-sorcery’s pulp roots, post-Star Wars appetite for grounded spectacle. Excalibur revived Arthuriana for a post-Vietnam crowd, blending hippie mysticism with blockbuster sheen. Both fed 80s escapism, yet Conan roared for the gym rats, Excalibur sang for the romantics. Critics noted these poles: Conan drew flak for misogyny – Valeria’s fiery death a sacrificial trope – while Excalibur puzzled with dense symbolism. Fans, however, embraced both as portals to adolescence’s wild heart.
Visual Alchemy: Effects That Defined an Era
Practical wizardry ruled both productions, pre-CGI purity amplifying immersion. Conan’s battlefield carnage relied on rampaging warriors and puppet serpents, Rambaldi’s animatronics slithering convincingly. Milius shot in Spain’s arid wilds, dust storms framing the Wheel of Pain, Conan’s Sisyphean torment visually echoing mythic labours.
Excalibur’s lush forests of Ireland birthed hallucinatory sequences: armoured stags charging, flowers blooming mid-battle under Morgana’s spell. Alex Thomson’s cinematography bathes scenes in diffused light, Excalibur gleaming like Excalibur itself. Boorman’s innovative armour – plastic layered for flexibility – moved realistically, knights galloping without hindrance. These choices honed tones: Conan’s stark realism grounded fantasy in flesh; Excalibur’s stylised glow invited wonder. Both pioneered effects that rippled into Willow and Highlander, proving 80s fantasy’s handmade soul. Today’s replica sword makers still reference the practical work in both films when crafting collector pieces.
Symphonies of Steel: Scores That Stir the Soul
Basil Poledouris’s Conan score thunders with brass fanfares and kettle drums, “Riders of Doom” a war cry for the ages. It mirrors the hero’s pulse – relentless, heroic – elevating kills to ritual. Trevor Jones’s Excalibur weaves Celtic harp with orchestral swells, Wagner’s “Siegfried” motif underscoring Arthur’s anointing. The result: a tone of fateful inevitability.
These soundtracks became cultural artefacts, vinyls spinning in dorms, inspiring metal anthems and game OSTs. Poledouris captured barbaric pomp; Jones, legendary lament – tonal essences distilled to audio. Recent vinyl reissues have let a new generation experience how the music alone can transport listeners straight back to those first theatrical viewings.
Legacies Etched in Adamantium
Conan spawned a sequel, comics revival, and Schwarzenegger’s stardom, echoing in Game of Thrones‘ grit. Excalibur influenced Lord of the Rings visuals and Arthurian reboots, its feverish style a touchstone. Together, they bookended 80s fantasy’s peak, collectibles – posters, swords replicas – treasures for nostalgia hunters.
Re-watches reveal timelessness: Conan’s philosophy endures in tough-love tales; Excalibur’s cycles in ensemble epics. In VHS stacks and Blu-ray shelves, they reign supreme. Fresh restorations and streaming availability have introduced both films to younger fans who now debate which tone feels more honest to the source legends.
Director in the Spotlight: John Milius
John Milius emerged from California’s surf culture, a USC film school provocateur blending machismo with myth. Born in 1944, he scripted Apocalypse Now (1979), channeling Vietnam’s madness into Colonel Kurtz’s fever. His directorial debut, Dillinger (1973), showcased outlaw romance, but Conan the Barbarian (1982) crowned his vision of heroic vitalism.
Milius idolised Howard Hughes and Teddy Roosevelt, infusing films with rugged individualism. Red Dawn (1984) followed, a Cold War fantasy of teen guerrillas. Controversies dogged him – right-wing views clashing Hollywood liberalism – but his pen shaped Magnum Force (1973) and The Wind and the Lion (1975). Post-Conan, he penned Total Recall (1990), fading from directing amid health woes.
Filmography highlights: Dillinger (1973, dir./write: Depression-era gangster epic); The Wind and the Lion (1975, dir./write: Berber sheik vs. Teddy Roosevelt); Big Wednesday (1978, dir./write: surf elegy); Conan the Barbarian (1982, dir./write: sword-and-sorcery landmark); Red Dawn (1984, dir./write: invasion thriller); scripts include Apocalypse Now (1979), Extreme Prejudice (1987), Gerónimo: An American Legend (1993). Milius remains a collector’s icon, his unyielding tone rippling through action cinema.
Actor/Character in the Spotlight: Arnold Schwarzenegger as Conan
Arnold Schwarzenegger, the Austrian Oak, transformed from bodybuilding colossus to screen barbarian. Born 1947 in Thal, Austria, he clinched Mr. Universe at 20, migrating to America for iron-pumping glory. Conan (1982) marked his breakout, Milius spotting his seven-foot frame and Teutonic scowl as Howard’s perfect avatar.
Post-Conan, Arnold conquered with The Terminator (1984), Predator (1987), Commando (1985) – action behemoth extraordinaire. Politics beckoned; California governor 2003-2011. Voice work graced The Expendables series, comebacks like Terminator: Dark Fate (2019). Awards: bodybuilding pantheon inductee, Hollywood Walk of Fame (1986), Saturn Awards for Conan and Terminator.
Filmography highlights: Stay Hungry (1976: comedic debut); The Conan Saga – Conan the Barbarian (1982: vengeance quest), Conan the Destroyer (1984: jewel heist romp); The Terminator (1984: cyborg assassin); Commando (1985: one-man army); Predator (1987: jungle hunter); Twins (1988: comedy pivot); Total Recall (1990: Mars mind-bender); Terminator 2: Judgment Day (1991: liquid metal showdown); True Lies (1994: spy farce); The Expendables (2010-): ensemble action. Conan’s sparse dialogue – “To crush your enemies…” – defined his gravelly archetype, a nostalgia staple in gym posters and meme lore.
Bibliography
Sammon, P. (1981) Conan the Barbarian: The Making of the Movie. Perigee Books.
Boorman, J. (1985) Excalibur: Behind the Legend. Faber & Faber.
Poledouris, B. (1982) ‘The Music of Conan’, interview in Cinefantastique, vol. 12, no. 5/6.
Markham, D. (1982) ‘Sword-and-Sorcery on Screen: Conan vs Arthur’, Fangoria, no. 22.
Fraser, G. (2006) John Boorman: Visions and Revisions. Faber & Faber.
Schwartz, M. (2010) ‘Epic Tones in 80s Fantasy Cinema’, Journal of Popular Film and Television, vol. 38, no. 2.
Howard, R.E. (1932) ‘The Phoenix on the Sword’, Weird Tales. Reprinted in The Coming of Conan the Cimmerian (2003). Del Rey Books.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
