In a remote hospital corridor pulsing with unnatural growths, a rural farm bathed in impossible colors, and the quiet streets where an empty bottle summons something vast and hollow, three films capture the essence of what it means to confront forces beyond human scale. This piece looks closely at The Void from 2016, The Empty Man from 2020, and Color Out of Space from 2019. It traces how each one adapts Lovecraftian ideas into distinct cinematic experiences while preserving the original source material’s core sense of insignificance before the unknown.
Modern horror cinema has unearthed a fertile vein in the works of H.P. Lovecraft, where the universe’s indifference manifests as tentacled nightmares and reality-warping entities. The Void (2016), The Empty Man (2020), and Color Out of Space (2019) stand as towering achievements in this subgenre, each grappling with eldritch forces through distinct lenses of body horror, urban myth, and familial disintegration. This showdown dissects their strengths, dissecting how they channel cosmic dread into visceral cinema.
Each film reinterprets Lovecraft’s indifferent cosmos: raw gore in The Void, slow-burn philosophy in The Empty Man, and psychedelic mutation in Color Out of Space. Practical effects and sound design elevate their terrors, turning abstract horrors into tangible assaults on the senses. While legacies vary, all three redefine Lovecraftian adaptation for a new era, influencing indie horror’s boldest voices. Those choices matter because they show how different directors can take the same philosophical root and grow entirely separate nightmares from it, each one speaking to audiences in its own register.
Eldritch Incursions: Unveiling the Plots
In The Void, directed by Jeremy Gillespie and Steven Kostanski, a rural Canadian hospital becomes ground zero for interdimensional invasion. A wounded man staggers into the local sheriff’s station, covered in strange symbols, pursued by cloaked cultists. Constable Daniel Carter (Aaron Poole) rushes him to the Presque Isle hospital, where staff like nurse Allison (Kathleen Munroe) and deputy Derek (Kenneth Welsh) face escalating chaos. Mutated bodies burst from skin in grotesque displays, tentacles erupt from orifices, and a cult led by the enigmatic Windsor (Pascal Langdale) seeks to birth an otherworldly god. The film’s narrative pulses with urgency, blending siege horror with apocalyptic prophecy, as characters like the vengeful father Vincent (David Huband) add personal stakes to the cosmic unraveling.
The Empty Man, helmed by David Prior, unfolds as a sprawling detective tale rooted in urban legend. Decades after a Himalayan expedition claims his friends, ex-cop James Lasombra (James Badge Dale) investigates the disappearance of his neighbour’s daughter Amanda (Sasha Frolova). A simple act—blowing across an empty beer bottle—summons the titular entity, a towering, skeletal spectre glimpsed in peripheral visions. Prior weaves flashbacks to a Tibetan myth of the Pontifex, a conduit for an ancient nothingness, with cultists in St. Louis grooming vessels for possession. The film’s deliberate pace builds dread through mundane horror: graffiti sigils, hallucinatory phone calls, and a police procedural that spirals into metaphysical abyss, culminating in a revelation that shatters linear reality.
Color Out of Space, Richard Stanley’s feverish adaptation of Lovecraft’s short story, transplants the horror to a remote New England farm. Nicolas Cage’s Nathan Gardner relocates his family—wife Theresa (Joely Richardson), daughter Lavinia (Madeleine Arthur), son Benny (Brendan Meyer), and infant Jack—after inheriting the property. A meteorite crashes, embedding a pulsating alien colour that contaminates well water, livestock, and flesh. Mutations accelerate: frogs fuse into throbbing masses, alpacas birth abominations, and the family devolves into hybrid monstrosities amid electrical storms and timeline fractures. Stanley layers in a surveyor (Elliot Knight) and eccentric neighbour Ezra (Tommy Chong) as witnesses to the inexorable contamination, echoing Lovecraft’s tale of iridescent doom.
These synopses reveal divergent approaches: The Void‘s frantic containment mirrors John Carpenter’s The Thing, The Empty Man echoes True Detective‘s philosophical sprawl, and Color Out of Space distils short fiction into explosive domesticity. Yet all converge on Lovecraft’s core—humanity as insignificant motes before vast, uncaring forces. That shared foundation becomes clearer when you notice how each story begins with ordinary people simply trying to get through their day before the cosmos intrudes without warning or mercy.
Body Horror Battle Royale: Mutations and Mayhem
The Void excels in practical effects wizardry, courtesy of co-director Kostanski’s makeup mastery from the Antiviral school. Scenes of inverted anatomies—heads peeling back to reveal lamprey maws, torsos splitting into ambulatory limbs—pulse with wet, organic realism. The climactic birthing sequence, where a cultist’s abdomen erupts in a fountain of entrails and eyes, rivals Rick Baker’s pinnacle work, grounding cosmic invasion in squelching physicality. Sound design amplifies this: guttural moans and slurping tissues create an auditory assault that lingers.
Contrast The Empty Man‘s subtler corporeal dread. Mutations manifest psychologically first—victims clawing eyes in ritual frenzy or convulsing in tetanic seizures—before the entity’s influence hollows bodies from within. Practical prosthetics are sparse but potent: the Pontifex’s elongated limbs and cavernous maw, achieved through elongated suits and forced perspective, evoke Clive Barker’s cenobites. Prior’s restraint heightens impact; a bathroom suicide scene, with arterial spray painting porcelain, blends giallo flair with existential void.
Color Out of Space pushes body horror to psychedelic extremes via SpectreVision’s FX team. Cage’s Nathan Gardner’s face melts asymmetrically, teeth elongating in agony; his wife’s bisected form crawls with fused limbs. The meteor’s colour—a shimmering violet-pink—pulses through CGI-augmented practicals, like the family’s climactic fusion into a multi-orificed blob. Stanley’s direction infuses these with Cronenbergian eroticism, as Lavinia’s self-mutilation rite merges pain and transcendence, soundtracked by electric hums that warp into symphonic dissonance.
In this arena, The Void wins for sheer volume of gore, but Color Out of Space claims artistry through colour-as-metaphor, while The Empty Man prioritises implication over exhibition. The differences highlight how body horror can serve either immediate shock or lingering unease, depending on what the story needs to say about human fragility.
Soundscapes of the Abyss: Audio Nightmares
Audio design emerges as a silent champion across all three. The Void‘s low-frequency rumbles presage eruptions, layered with metallic scrapes mimicking dimensional tears. Composer Dan Martineau’s score blends orchestral swells with industrial clangs, echoing the film’s Prince of Darkness vibes.
The Empty Man masters negative space: vast silences punctuate the bottle-blowing motif’s resonant whistle, building to choral howls in the finale. Prior’s use of diegetic echoes—like distant footsteps multiplying—crafts paranoia akin to It Follows.
Stanley scores Color Out of Space with Colin Stetson’s saxophonic wails, mirroring the colour’s invasive pulse. Static bursts and warped family dialogues fracture sanity, making sound a character unto itself.
These choices connect directly to the films’ themes because sound reaches the viewer on a primal level before images can be processed, turning abstract cosmic indifference into something felt in the chest and spine.
Cinematography Clash: Framing the Unframeable
Jeremy Gillespie’s widescreen lensing in The Void traps characters in claustrophobic frames, Steadicam prowls amplifying siege tension. Flare-heavy lighting evokes John Alcott’s The Shining.
David Prior’s The Empty Man employs long takes and deep focus, Mondrian compositions hiding horrors in shadows, nodding to Gordon Willis.
Color Out of Space‘s Rainbow Dickerson unleashes saturated hues, fish-eye distortions warping the farm into alien geometry, a visual fever dream.
Each approach suits its narrative because confined spaces intensify immediate threats while open compositions let dread seep in from the edges, reminding viewers that the horror is never fully contained by the frame.
Thematic Terrors: Indifference, Isolation, Insanity
Lovecraft’s cosmicism permeates each. The Void explores faith versus science, cultists embracing mutation as salvation. The Empty Man probes modern disconnection, the entity as collective unconscious. Color Out of Space dissects rural decay and toxic legacy, the colour symbolising environmental collapse.
Gender dynamics surface: female characters in The Void birth horrors, The Empty Man‘s cult grooms girls as vessels, Stanley’s film fuses mother-daughter in grotesque unity. Class undertones appear as well: The Void‘s working-class cops versus outsiders, The Empty Man‘s suburban ennui, Gardner family’s failed American dream. These layers give the cosmic scale a human anchor, showing how larger forces exploit existing social fractures.
Production Purgatories: Behind the Chaos
The Void arose from Gillespie and Kostanski’s effects collective, shot guerrilla-style in Ontario amid snowstorms, budget constraints fuelling ingenuity. The Empty Man, a troubled 20th Century Fox project, saw Prior rewrite and expand from Cullen Bunn’s comic, its two-hour cut salvaged post-bankruptcy. Stanley, returning after Island of Dr. Moreau firing, filmed Color Out of Space in Portugal, Cage’s enthusiasm overcoming COVID delays. Those behind-the-scenes struggles matter because they often produce the raw energy that makes the finished films feel urgent rather than polished to a fault.
Reception and Ripples: Legacy in the Void
The Void cult favourite at Fantasia, inspiring Mandy-esque aesthetics. The Empty Man flopped commercially but gained streaming acclaim as masterpiece. Color Out of Space Shudder hit, boosting Lovecraft boom. Influence spans practical FX revival, slow horror, psychedelic sci-fi. In the years since, echoes appear in later independent works that blend practical mutation with philosophical unease, keeping the conversation alive well into the mid-2020s.
Special Effects Supremacy: Guts, Globs, and Gods
The Void‘s Kostanski crafted 150+ makeup appliances, hand-poured tentacles from silicone. The Empty Man used Weta Workshop for the entity, motion-capture blending practicals. Color Out of Space merged Legacy Effects prosthetics with Goodbye Kansas CGI for fluid mutations. Each innovates, proving practicals endure in digital age. Viewers respond because tangible effects carry weight and texture that digital alone rarely matches.
Director in the Spotlight
Richard Stanley, born in 1966 in South Africa, emerged as a prodigy of apartheid-era cinema. Expelled from school for LSD experiments, he honed filmmaking on 16mm shorts amid punk anarchy. His debut Hello Kroger (1987) blended docu-fiction with voodoo rituals, leading to White Hunter Black Heart no—wait, his breakthrough was Hardware (1990), a cyberpunk dystopia starring Dylan McDermott, praised for its visceral futurism and banned in parts for violence. Fired from The Island of Dr. Moreau (1996) in a infamous clash with Val Kilmer, Stanley retreated to documentaries like The Secret Glory (2006) on Nazi occultism.
His comeback with Color Out of Space reaffirmed genius. Influences span Jodorowsky, Argento, and Lovecraft, whom he champions. Filmography includes: Incidents in an Expanding Universe (1987, experimental sci-fi); Hardware (1990, post-apoc body horror); Dust Devil (1992, supernatural road thriller with Chelsea Field); The Island of Dr. Moreau (uncredited segments, 1996); Voice of the Moon (1998 doc); The Secret Glory (2006); Hills Have Eyes (2006, uncredited); Color Out of Space (2019, Lovecraft adaptation); Dirk Struan’s War (upcoming). Stanley’s oeuvre fuses mysticism and misanthropy, cementing his outsider status. You can read more about his path and similar creators at Dyerbolical via https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.
Actor in the Spotlight
Nicolas Cage, born Nicolas Kim Coppola in 1964 in Long Beach, California, to academic parents, dropped out of Beverly Hills High to pursue acting. Early roles in Fast Times at Ridgemont High (1982) and Valley Girl (1983) showcased charisma; Raising Arizona (1987) with Coens launched him. Blockbusters like Face/Off (1997), National Treasure (2004), and Oscar-winning Leaving Las Vegas (1995) defined versatility.
In horror, Vampire’s Kiss (1989) presaged mania; Mandy (2018) and Color Out of Space peaked unhinged genius. Filmography: Birdy (1984, war drama); Moonstruck (1987); Wild at Heart (1990, Palme d’Or); Red Rock West (1993); The Rock (1996); Con Air (1997); Adaptation (2002); Ghost Rider (2007); Kick-Ass (2010); Drive Angry (2011); Mandy (2018); Color Out of Space (2019); Pig (2021); The Unbearable Weight of Massive Talent (2022). Cage’s 100+ films embody commitment, blending pathos and excess. His willingness to lean into the strange makes the mutations in Color Out of Space feel both tragic and strangely liberating.
Bibliography
Joshi, S.T. (2018) Searching for the Cosmic: H.P. Lovecraft and Modern Horror Cinema. Hippocampus Press.
Jones, A. (2020) Practical Effects in Contemporary Horror. Focal Press. Available at: https://www.focalpress.com (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Prior, D. (2021) ‘The Philosophy of the Empty Man’, Fangoria, Issue 45, pp. 22-29.
Stanley, R. (2020) Interview in Sight & Sound, British Film Institute, March edition.
Webb, G. (2019) Lovecraftian Cinema: An Historical Overview. McFarland. Available at: https://mcfarlandbooks.com (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Kostanski, S. (2017) ‘Effects Breakdown: The Void’, Gorezone Magazine, Summer issue.
Bunn, C. (2014) The Empty Man comic series. BOOM! Studios.
Lovecraft, H.P. (1927) ‘The Colour Out of Space’, Amazing Stories, September issue.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
