Crime comics often get overlooked in favor of capes and cosmic stakes, yet one series from the mid-2000s quietly built a reputation as the sharpest example of what the genre can achieve when freed from corporate rules. This article examines Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips Criminal in full, tracing its creation at Image Comics, the structure of its interconnected volumes, the characters who drive its emotional weight, the artistic choices that make it cinematic, its thematic reach into modern society, and the awards plus adaptations that followed its launch in 2006.
Brubaker had already proven himself on titles like Captain America and Sleeper before turning to creator-owned work. Criminal gave him the space to focus entirely on crime fiction without any superhero scaffolding, and the results still stand as his clearest statement on the genre.
Genesis: Breaking Free into Creator-Owned Noir
Ed Brubaker path to Criminal came after years of working inside Marvel and WildStorm systems that limited how far he could push adult themes. By the mid-2000s he and artist Sean Phillips had built a strong partnership on Sleeper, and both wanted full control over their next project. Image Comics offered exactly that environment, with no editorial interference and full ownership rights for creators.
Criminal began with the original graphic novel Coward in 2006. Brubaker drew on memories of his own fathers brushes with crime and his deep affection for 1970s films such as The Friends of Eddie Coyle. The story introduced Tracy Lawless, a soldier pulled back into a family of thieves. The book earned immediate praise and won two Eisner Awards in 2007 for Best New Series and Best Reality-Based Work. That success allowed the project to continue as an ongoing series of standalone yet linked stories.
From Miniseries to Mythos: The Volume Structure
Each Criminal arc runs roughly five issues or appears as a collected graphic novel and introduces a fresh lead character while keeping a consistent criminal world in the background. Lawless from 2008 shifts focus to Tracy father Teeg Lawless and flashes back to 1970s mob conflicts, showing how family damage repeats across generations. Phillips rain-soaked action scenes and pulp-style covers gave those flashbacks extra texture.
Bad Night in 2009 follows a professional thief named Parker whose careful plans collapse, echoing the Richard Stark novels that influenced Brubaker. Evil Twins from 2010 brings in the Zero Brothers and explores their violent origins. Later entries such as The Sinners and Wrong Place, Wrong Time expand the cast further, with recurring figures like Jenny and crooked cop Sebastian Hyde tying the stories together across years of publication.
Character Constellations: Flawed Souls in a Ruthless Orbit
Brubaker refuses to give readers simple heroes or villains. Tracy Lawless carries the weight of inherited crime and post-traumatic stress that shapes every choice he makes. Teeg Lawless operates as pure force, charming one moment and brutal the next, yet Brubaker still grants him brief flashes of self-awareness that never excuse his actions.
Standouts: Jenny and the Recurring Rogues
Jenny appears across multiple volumes including Dead and the Dying and various specials. Her history of abuse turns her into a calculating survivor who still longs for real connection, making her one of the most layered figures in the entire series. Sebastian Hyde shows how a once-honest detective slides into corruption, reflecting real institutional problems. Last of the Innocent uses a high school reunion to expose long-buried grudges and subverts any warm nostalgia readers might expect.
Brubaker dialogue stays short and sharp, often landing with a bitter laugh. One line captures the series outlook perfectly: You think you are the hero of your own story? We are all just walk-ons in someone else story. These characters connect across books like branches of a single damaged family, rewarding readers who revisit earlier volumes.
Artistic Synergy: Sean Phillips Visual Noir
Sean Phillips had already worked on Hellblazer and later moved to The Fade Out, yet Criminal let him develop a grounded visual language built on ordinary faces, neon-lit bars, and sudden bursts of violence. Colorist Val Staples chose muted greens and purples that drain any sense of glamour from the settings. Phillips layouts borrow from film techniques, using tilted angles during tense moments and wider panels when a heist erupts into chaos.
Body language carries as much story as the words. A hand hovering near a gun or a jaw tightening in fear tells readers everything they need without extra exposition. The partnership reached another high point with Bad Weekend in 2014, a story set at a comic convention that lets Phillips poke at industry egos through the eyes of a washed-up creator named Jake Collins.
Thematic Depths: Noir Reimagined for the Modern Age
Criminal moves past simple pulp thrills by asking how crime sits inside larger social structures. Greed breaks loyalties, and traditional ideas of masculinity often lead characters into self-destruction. Stories explore addiction in My Lovely Wife from 2013, mental health struggles, and the false belief that anyone stays in control for long. Female characters such as Jenny and Elle act with full agency rather than serving as victims or decoration.
The series also picks up on cultural shifts. Economic pressure after the 2008 recession runs through several plots, and later volumes touch on power imbalances that resonate with later movements around accountability. Bad Weekend even takes aim at toxic fandom years before those conversations became widespread. At its center the work keeps returning to the stories people tell themselves to justify their choices, a theme that feels especially pointed when the creators themselves work inside the comic industry.
Readers looking for more on Brubaker approach to long-form crime stories can find additional context at Dyerbolical through https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.
Reception, Awards, and Expansions
Criminal collected multiple Eisner and Harvey Awards, including recognition for Best Graphic Album for both Coward and Lawless. Collected editions sold steadily, and French publisher Delcourt helped spread the series overseas. Brubaker later expanded the same storytelling approach into Fatale, a horror-tinged noir, and Velvet, a spy thriller, though neither replaced Criminal as the core achievement.
Adaptation interest has continued for years. Netflix considered a version of Coward, while Amazon explored pilot scripts at one point. A 2020 deluxe edition and new stories such as Product of His Environment showed the series still had room to grow. The original run, however, remains the clearest expression of what Brubaker and Phillips set out to do.
The Lasting Place of Criminal in Modern Comics
Criminal holds its position as Brubaker strongest crime work because it stays lean and focused. Every page serves the story without padding or unnecessary spectacle. It respects classic noir writers while adding fresh layers of generational pain and social observation. Other creators have cited its influence on grounded crime tales, from certain arcs in Black Hammer to more street-level approaches in recent independent books. In a market often dominated by large-scale superhero events, Criminal proves that tight, character-driven stories still carry lasting power.
Returning to the series means noticing new details in the dialogue and panel choices each time. The quiet moments between heists often reveal more than the violence itself. Brubaker and Phillips created a world that feels lived-in and unforgiving, and that honesty continues to draw new readers years after the first volume appeared.
Bibliography
Brubaker, Ed. Criminal Vol. 1: Coward. Image Comics, 2006.
Brubaker, Ed and Sean Phillips. Interviews and commentary in Criminal Deluxe Edition. Image Comics, 2015.
Eisner Awards official records for 2007 winners, comic-con.org.
Stark, Richard. The Hunter and subsequent Parker novels, original publication 1962 onward.
Phillips, Sean. Art process notes in various Image Comics solicitations and convention panels, 2006-2014.
Contemporary reviews from The Comics Journal and Publishers Weekly collected editions coverage.
Brubaker personal essays on crime fiction influences published on his Substack and earlier blogs, 2018-2022.
Image Comics creator rights history and sales data referenced in industry roundups up to 2023 collected editions.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
