In the crowded working-class neighborhoods of Copenhagen around 1910, unmarried mothers often faced impossible choices when they could no longer keep their newborns. One woman presented herself as a solution by offering to care for these children until better homes could be found. That woman was Dagmar Overbye, and her offer turned out to be a cover for systematic killings that lasted a decade.

This article examines the full scope of Overbye’s crimes, the social conditions that allowed them to continue, the investigation that finally exposed her, and the legal and social changes that followed. The case shows how gaps in welfare support and oversight created opportunities for someone willing to exploit desperate families.

Early Life and Descent into Darkness

Dagmar Johanne Overbye was born on April 23, 1887, in the small Jutland town of Adum. Her parents separated when she was young, leaving her mother to raise her in limited circumstances. Overbye left school at fourteen and took work as a domestic servant. In her early twenties she married and had a daughter, but the marriage ended amid money problems and personal disagreements.

She moved to Copenhagen around 1909 and began working in the city’s poorer districts. At the time Denmark was experiencing industrial growth, yet many residents still lived in poverty, especially after the disruptions of World War I. Unmarried mothers encountered strong social disapproval that could cost them jobs and family support. Overbye had picked up basic midwifery skills through informal training and saw a chance to earn money by taking in infants for a fee while mothers tried to stabilize their lives.

Social Context: The Plight of Unwed Mothers

Denmark’s public assistance at the time was limited and often came with moral judgments that discouraged women from seeking help. Overbye charged modest monthly fees, usually between twenty and fifty kroner, and promised she would arrange adoptions with respectable families. Many mothers, frequently young servants or factory workers, handed over their babies believing they would receive regular updates. Instead they received vague replies or nothing at all. These circumstances made it possible for Overbye to operate without immediate suspicion.

The Baby Farm: A Facade of Care

Between 1910 and 1920 Overbye ran her operation from several small apartments in Copenhagen’s Vesterbro area. She lived there with her own daughter and sometimes took in lodgers. At any given time she might have up to five infants in her care. Neighbors heard babies crying and noticed unusual odors, but such things were common in overcrowded buildings and did not raise alarms. Overbye kept up an appearance of normal life by attending church and speaking politely with people in the neighborhood.

Almost all the children placed with her were illegitimate and very young. Mothers paid in advance and then stepped back, expecting the promised adoptions to happen. When payments stopped or no adoptive families appeared, the infants became financial liabilities to Overbye. She later claimed to have arranged more than one hundred placements, but investigators found far fewer legitimate adoptions had actually taken place.

Modus Operandi: Luring and Isolating Victims

Overbye attracted clients through newspaper advertisements and word of mouth among working women. During first meetings she presented herself as a caring and experienced caregiver. Once the mothers left, the infants received little food and almost no attention. Their crying was ignored, and basic hygiene was neglected. This pattern of isolation let the crimes continue for years because no one outside the household regularly checked on the children’s welfare.

Methods of Murder: Cruel and Calculated

Overbye eventually confessed to killing at least twenty-five infants, though police suspected the total could have been higher. She chose methods that left few obvious traces. Strangulation with ropes, stockings, or her own hands was the most common approach. She later described the babies as going quietly. Some infants died from starvation after being given watered-down formula or no food at all. Others were drowned in tubs or buckets, after which she sometimes boiled the bodies to destroy evidence.

Disposal followed the same practical logic. Small remains were burned in her kitchen stove, and the ashes were scattered in gardens or thrown into canals. Larger bones went to a nearby dump or were buried in shallow holes. A laborer named Johannes Larsen, who had a personal relationship with Overbye, sometimes helped move bodies and later received a light sentence for his involvement.

During questioning Overbye offered a chilling justification, saying the children were better off dead than living in hardship. The statement revealed how she had framed her actions as a form of mercy, even though the evidence showed repeated, deliberate choices made over many years.

Discovery and Investigation: Cracks in the Facade

The case broke open in late 1920 when a mother named Karen Elise Jensen began asking questions about her son Georg, whom she had placed with Overbye the previous year. When she received no satisfactory answers and heard rumors from neighbors, she contacted the police on December 15. Officers raided Overbye’s apartment on December 29 and found two severely malnourished infants still alive. They also recovered bloodstained cloths, a small coffin, and stove ashes containing bone fragments. Overbye denied any wrongdoing at first but eventually began to talk under sustained questioning.

The Confession and Search

She initially admitted to sixteen murders and provided names and details. Further investigation raised the confirmed count to twenty-five. Police located hidden remains in several locations, and forensic examination showed marks consistent with strangulation on the recovered bones. Larsen and other associates provided additional information about how bodies had been moved. Inspector Martin Ditlevsen led the inquiry, which lasted several weeks. Public anger grew quickly once newspapers published the first reports, and more than forty mothers came forward to identify children they had lost.

The Trial: Justice in the Spotlight

The trial opened on March 21, 1921, at Copenhagen City Court before Judge Heinrich Hansen. Prosecutors Carl Bruun and Holger Bech presented confessions, forensic reports, and testimony from more than twenty mothers. Overbye pleaded guilty but tried to limit her responsibility by citing poverty. Her lawyers argued she was mentally unfit, yet court-appointed psychiatrists found her fully aware of her actions. Family members of the victims gave emotional statements that reminded the court of the individual lives involved.

Key Moments

Overbye’s own testimony stood out for its detached tone, which shocked observers in the courtroom. Physical evidence such as tiny bones and lengths of rope was displayed and produced strong reactions. On April 15 the court convicted her of twenty-five murders plus multiple counts of child neglect. She received a death sentence by hanging, the first such penalty given to a woman in Denmark since 1855. King Christian X later commuted the sentence to life imprisonment. Overbye served her term at Horsens State Prison and died of pneumonia on January 6, 1929, at the age of forty-one.

Psychological Profile: Unraveling the Killer

Contemporary observers noted Overbye’s lack of visible remorse and her ability to maintain a respectable front while committing repeated crimes. These traits align with patterns seen in other cases where financial gain combined with emotional detachment. Her background of instability and limited education may have contributed to the choices she made, yet many people in similar circumstances never turned to violence. The case also reflects the broader social attitudes of the period, in which illegitimate children from poor families were sometimes viewed as less valuable than others.

Similar patterns appear in other historical baby-farming cases across Europe. The methods and rationalizations Overbye used echo those documented in the Amelia Dyer investigation in Britain in 1896. Such parallels suggest that weak regulation of private child care created recurring opportunities for abuse wherever poverty and social stigma existed.

Legacy: Reforms and Lasting Echoes

Overbye’s exposure prompted Denmark to pass the Child Welfare Act of 1924. The new law required state licensing and regular inspections for anyone taking in children for payment. Midwifery practice also came under tighter control. Public discussion began to shift toward providing direct support for unmarried mothers rather than leaving them to private arrangements that could hide exploitation. These changes reduced the immediate risks that had allowed Overbye to operate for so long.

Today the case stands as an early example of how inadequate oversight of childcare can produce tragedy. Modern child-protection systems in many countries still rely on the principle that regular checks and transparent records are necessary to prevent similar harm. As explored further at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, historical cases like this one continue to inform current debates about safeguarding vulnerable children.

Bibliography

Dansk Kvindebiografisk Leksikon entry on Dagmar Overbye, published by the Danish National Archives.

Contemporary trial reports from Copenhagen City Court records, 1921.

Article on baby farming practices in early twentieth-century Scandinavia, Scandinavian Journal of History, 1998.

Comparison of European infanticide cases including Overbye and Amelia Dyer, Crime History Quarterly, 2005.

Official Danish government report on the 1924 Child Welfare Act reforms.

Medical examiner notes from the 1920 police investigation, preserved in the Copenhagen Police Museum archives.

Biographical study of Danish female offenders 1900-1930, University of Copenhagen Press, 2012.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289