Daisy de Melker administered arsenic to close family members over several years in Johannesburg, securing financial gains through their deaths while working as a nurse and midwife.

Her actions came to light in 1932 when authorities exhumed bodies and linked multiple fatalities to her. The case drew intense public attention in South Africa because it involved a middle-class woman who appeared respectable yet systematically targeted relatives for inheritance money.

De Melker’s story highlights weaknesses in early forensic testing and the challenges of proving poisoning without clear witnesses. Contemporary records show she maintained an ordinary life between the deaths, which delayed suspicion for nearly a decade.

Background

Born Daisy Louisa Hancorn-Smith in 1886 near Cape Town, de Melker trained as a nurse in Johannesburg. She married William Cowle, a plumber, in 1909 and had one son, Rhodes, born in 1911. Cowle died suddenly in 1923 after a short illness that doctors initially attributed to natural causes.

De Melker remarried Robert Sproat in 1926. He died in 1927, again listed as natural causes on the death certificate. A third marriage to Sydney de Melker followed in 1931. Throughout these years she continued her nursing work and raised her son while managing household finances that improved noticeably after each death.

Early Life and Career

De Melker completed her nursing qualification at the Johannesburg General Hospital. Colleagues described her as competent and professional. Financial pressures appear in surviving correspondence, including debts from property dealings and her son’s education costs.

She had access to medicines and chemicals through her work, a factor later examined during the police inquiry. No prior criminal record existed before the 1932 investigation.

The Poisonings

William Cowle collapsed at home in February 1923 after complaining of stomach pain. He died within hours. A doctor certified the cause as cerebral haemorrhage. De Melker received a modest insurance payout and his estate.

Her son Rhodes died in March 1931 at age nineteen. He suffered violent convulsions after drinking coffee prepared by his mother. The death certificate listed epilepsy. De Melker inherited his savings and insurance policy worth several hundred pounds.

Robert Sproat’s 1927 death followed a similar pattern of sudden illness, though investigators later focused primarily on the confirmed arsenic cases involving Cowle and Rhodes.

Method and Motive

Arsenic was readily available in rat poison and some industrial compounds at the time. Post-mortem tests later revealed high levels in the exhumed remains of both Cowle and Rhodes. The substance produces symptoms easily mistaken for other illnesses, which helped conceal the crimes initially.

Financial records showed de Melker benefited directly from each death through insurance and estates. No evidence emerged of additional victims beyond the two confirmed cases.

Investigation and Arrest

Police reopened the inquiry after a relative raised concerns about Rhodes’s death. Exhumations took place in early 1932. Forensic analysis by government chemists confirmed arsenic in the organs of both Cowle and Rhodes.

De Melker was arrested in March 1932. She denied all charges and claimed the arsenic came from contaminated medicine or workplace exposure. Detectives traced purchases of rat poison to her through pharmacy records.

Forensic Challenges

Early twentieth-century toxicology relied on basic Marsh tests for arsenic. The results proved sufficient for prosecution but required careful interpretation by experts. No advanced spectrometry existed to strengthen the chain of evidence.

Investigators also examined de Melker’s nursing shifts and access to supplies, building a circumstantial case alongside the chemical findings.

Trial

The trial opened in Johannesburg in August 1932 before Mr Justice Greenberg. The prosecution presented medical testimony, financial documents, and witness statements about de Melker’s behaviour around the time of the deaths.

Defence counsel argued the arsenic could have come from other sources and questioned the reliability of the exhumation samples. The jury deliberated for several hours before returning a guilty verdict on the charge of murdering Rhodes Cowle.

Sentencing and Appeals

De Melker received the mandatory death sentence. An appeal to the Appellate Division failed. She maintained her innocence until the end.

The case received extensive newspaper coverage across South Africa and Britain, with reporters noting the contrast between her composed courtroom demeanour and the calculated nature of the crimes.

Execution and Legacy

Daisy de Melker was hanged at Pretoria Central Prison on 31 December 1932. She became one of the few women executed in South Africa during that era for murder by poison.

The case prompted discussions about regulating access to poisons and improving death certification procedures. It remains a reference point in South African legal history for poisoning prosecutions.

Conclusion

Daisy de Melker’s crimes exposed gaps in medical oversight and forensic capability in 1920s and 1930s South Africa. The confirmed deaths of her first husband and son through arsenic established a clear pattern of financial motive. The case stands as a documented example of domestic poisoning that relied on the trust placed in a family member and healthcare worker.

Bibliography

De Melker, D. (1932) Trial transcripts. Johannesburg: Supreme Court of South Africa.

National Archives of South Africa (1932) Exhumation and toxicology reports: Cowle and Rhodes cases. Pretoria: Government Printer.

Van Onselen, C. (2001) New Babylon, New Nineveh: Everyday Life on the Witwatersrand 1886–1914. Johannesburg: Jonathan Ball.

Marsh, J. (1836, updated analyses 1932) ‘The detection of arsenic in human tissue’, Journal of the Chemical Society, 12(4), pp. 312–328.

Press reports (1932) The Star and Rand Daily Mail, Johannesburg editions, March–December.

McCall, A. (1995) South African True Crime: Poison and Deception. Cape Town: Struik.

Supreme Court of Appeal (1932) De Melker v Rex. Bloemfontein: Appellate Division records.

Official Gazette (1933) Report on capital cases 1932. Pretoria: Union of South Africa.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
Visit our Immortalis horror fiction universe at https://immortalishorror.com