Inside the Twisted Allure: Women Who Formed Parasocial Bonds with Ted Bundy, Charles Manson and Jeffrey Dahmer

On July 2, 1979, inside the crowded Dade County Courthouse in Miami, Ted Bundy stood convicted of multiple murders. The room fell silent as the verdict landed, yet dozens of young women reacted in ways no one expected. They blew kisses toward the man responsible for at least thirty deaths, some fainted in dramatic fashion, and others declared their love openly. This was not fiction. It was a clear display of parasocial relationships, one-sided emotional attachments that form when people project deep feelings onto figures they will never actually know.

This article examines how those attachments take root with serial killers and notorious murderers. It looks at the psychological drivers behind the bonds, the role of media in amplifying them, and the lasting harm they cause to victims and their families. Real cases from Bundy to Charles Manson, Richard Ramirez, Dennis Rader, Jeffrey Dahmer, and Israel Keyes show how admiration can cross into something far more troubling.

Understanding Parasocial Relationships

Psychologists Donald Horton and R. Richard Wohl first described parasocial relationships in 1956. They noticed that viewers often felt a sense of closeness to television personalities even though the connection only moved one way. The same pattern appears when the focus shifts to criminals. People absorb every detail from news reports, trial footage, and later documentaries, then fill in the rest with their own ideas about who the killer really is.

In true crime the effect grows stronger because the killer often comes across as intelligent or charismatic. Ted Bundy used his law background and clean-cut appearance to project normalcy. Dennis Rader presented himself as an ordinary family man who happened to hold a position in his church. Fans latch onto those surface traits and push aside the documented violence, building a version of events that feels more like a story than a record of real suffering.

The Role of Media in Fueling Obsession

When trials receive wall-to-wall coverage, defendants become public figures almost overnight. Bundy’s 1979 proceedings drew large daily crowds, many of them women who sketched his face or wore buttons claiming his innocence. Richard Ramirez collected hundreds of letters while awaiting trial, some written in blood and decorated with symbols. The attention turned courtrooms into stages.

Modern platforms push the same dynamic further. Podcasts and streaming series reach millions of viewers in a single week. After the 2022 Netflix dramatization of Jeffrey Dahmer’s crimes, users on short-video apps began recreating scenes or offering defenses based on the killer’s reported loneliness. The focus drifts away from the seventeen people he killed and toward the idea of the offender as a misunderstood figure. Families of the victims have spoken out about how this shift feels like a second violation.

Historical Cases of Criminal Fandom

Long before social media, certain killers already drew intense personal loyalty from strangers. The pattern repeats across decades and shows how charisma, media framing, and public curiosity can combine in damaging ways.

Ted Bundy: The Charismatic Killer

Bundy admitted to thirty murders carried out between 1974 and 1978. He typically approached young women under the pretense of needing help, then attacked them. His ability to appear articulate and even charming during interviews and court appearances created a split in public perception. Some viewers saw the polished exterior and decided the crimes must have been exaggerated or misunderstood.

Carol Ann Boone stood by him publicly, testifying in his favor and later marrying him inside the courtroom. She gave birth to his child while still convinced of his innocence. Only after DNA testing confirmed his guilt years after his execution did that certainty collapse. Thousands of letters arrived for Bundy, many containing explicit offers. The “mask of sanity” he maintained allowed admirers to imagine a version of him that existed only in their minds.

Charles Manson: Cult Leader Extraordinaire

Manson directed the 1969 killings at the Tate and LaBianca residences, resulting in seven deaths. He never struck the fatal blows himself, yet his instructions set the crimes in motion. After his conviction he continued to receive visits and letters from people who viewed him as a symbol of rebellion rather than a convicted murderer.

Lynette Fromme, one of his followers, attempted to assassinate President Gerald Ford in 1975. Decades later, visitors still travel to the old Spahn Ranch site hoping to connect with the myth. Sharon Tate was eight months pregnant when she was killed, yet some admirers continue to frame the entire episode as an act of counterculture defiance. The human cost remains fixed in the record, no matter how the story is retold.

Richard Ramirez and the Night Stalker Groupies

Ramirez committed thirteen murders and numerous sexual assaults across Los Angeles in 1984 and 1985. He left satanic markings at several scenes. In court, women fainted or openly expressed attraction. Doreen Lioy, an editor with a reported high IQ, began a correspondence that led to marriage in 1996. She wrote poems about him and described him as a rebel against society.

More than two thousand letters reached Ramirez during his time on death row. He died of cancer in 2013, yet references to his image still surface in certain music scenes. The pattern here mirrors earlier cases: surface traits such as appearance or defiance become the center of attention while the victims recede from view.

Modern Manifestations in the Digital Age

The internet has made these attachments easier to form and harder to escape. Dedicated forums and short-video platforms allow users to share edits, fan art, and theories that treat killers as characters rather than real offenders. After the Dahmer series aired, communities formed around imagined relationships involving the killer, often with little mention of victims such as Konerak Sinthasomphone, the fourteen-year-old boy police returned to Dahmer’s apartment.

BTK and the Secret Fan Club

Dennis Rader murdered ten people in Wichita between 1974 and 1991. He sent taunting letters to police that earned him the nickname BTK. Once caught in 2005, he revealed that admirers had sent him photographs and personal messages. His wife, Paula Dietz, initially remained supportive before the couple divorced. Online discussions sometimes focus on his self-described struggles while giving less attention to the fear he created in the community he targeted.

Emerging Cases: Israel Keyes and Beyond

Israel Keyes killed at least three people and may have been responsible for more between 2001 and 2012. He chose victims methodically and left few immediate clues. Podcasts that emphasize his planning have prompted fan drawings and speculation. Samantha Koenig, one of his victims, was held after death so a ransom could be collected. The emphasis on the offender’s methods can pull focus away from those individual losses.

Psychological Underpinnings

Researchers have identified hybristophilia, an attraction to people who commit crimes, as one factor. Dr. Katherine Ramsland has written about how trauma, low self-worth, or a desire for excitement can feed the impulse. Cognitive dissonance also plays a part. Fans sometimes rewrite events so the killer appears as a product of a difficult past rather than someone who chose to harm others. Social media reinforces the view by rewarding posts that fit the preferred narrative.

Many of the admirers are women who describe the offenders as misunderstood or exciting. Men may focus on the perceived power or cleverness. In both cases the killer’s own statements during interviews or confessions can trigger sympathy that overlooks the documented pain inflicted on victims and survivors.

Victim-Blaming and Desensitization

When attention centers on the offender, victims can be pushed into the background. Some Manson followers once suggested that Sharon Tate somehow invited her fate. Dahmer admirers have debated his isolation while the families of his victims continue to grieve. Research published in Psychology of Popular Media Culture in 2020 found that heavy consumption of glamorized true crime content can reduce empathy over time. The effect matters because it changes how society remembers the people who were harmed.

The Impact on Victims and Society

Survivors and relatives often describe renewed distress when they encounter fan content. Rhonda Stapley, who escaped Bundy, later faced harassment from his supporters. Debra Tate has worked for years to keep media portrayals centered on the victims rather than the perpetrators. On a larger scale, romanticized versions of killers have inspired copycat behavior, as seen in the 2014 Slender Man stabbing case that grew out of online myth-making. Prisons also report increased contact attempts that complicate daily operations and any chance of rehabilitation.

Responsible coverage requires deliberate choices. Highlighting victims by name, presenting context without sensationalism, and limiting graphic reenactments can reduce the space available for one-sided attachments. Platforms have begun adjusting algorithms after public backlash, but the underlying pull remains.

At Dyerbolical we have examined how these patterns persist across different eras and what they reveal about collective curiosity. The cases show that charisma and selective storytelling can turn convicted murderers into figures of fascination long after the courtroom doors close.

Bibliography

Rule, Ann. The Stranger Beside Me. W.W. Norton, 1980.

Ramsland, Katherine. The Human Predator. Berkley Books, 2005.

Psychology of Popular Media Culture. “True Crime Consumption and Empathy,” 2020 study.

Court transcripts from the 1979 Dade County Bundy trial.

Los Angeles Times coverage of the Richard Ramirez trial, 1980s.

Netflix viewership data for Dahmer – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story, 2022.

FBI case files on Dennis Rader, released after 2005.

Victim impact statements from the Tate family archives.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289