In a rain-soaked Brooklyn loft a chemist mixes chemicals by harsh fluorescent light and brings a dead soldier back from the edge of nothing, setting off a chain of events that turns personal desperation into public reckoning.
This article examines Larry Fessenden’s 2019 film Depraved from its narrative roots in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein through its practical effects, social themes, performances, production challenges, and place in the director’s career, while connecting the story to ongoing conversations about inequality, addiction, and the ethics of creation.
The Spark of Forbidden Life: Unpacking the Narrative Core
Alex, a brilliant but down-on-his-luck chemist played by David Call, finds himself seduced by the promise of quick cash from a sleazy Wall Street financier named Polidori. This modern-day Victor Frankenstein agrees to reanimate a mortally wounded soldier, brought to him in the dead of night by the financier’s shady associates. The procedure unfolds in a derelict Brooklyn loft, where Alex, fueled by desperation and his own moral compromises, injects the corpse with a cocktail of chemicals designed to defy death. As the creature stirs, its first guttural cries echo the film’s central tension: what horrors arise when playing God intersects with human depravity? The choice to ground the experiment in a crumbling urban space rather than a gothic castle makes the horror feel immediate and tied to real economic pressures that push people toward dangerous shortcuts.
The story spirals into chaos as the creature, portrayed with chilling physicality by Alex Breaux, awakens with fragmented memories of his past life as a combat veteran ravaged by PTSD. Nursed back to fragile sentience by Alex’s empathetic girlfriend Lucy, the being briefly embodies innocence amid brutality. Yet, betrayal looms; Polidori’s crew, eyeing the creature as a weaponized prototype, intervenes with guns and greed. What follows is a rampage through rain-slicked New York streets, where the monster’s rage targets its creators in a ballet of dismemberment and retribution. Fessenden structures the plot as a pressure cooker, building from quiet ethical dilemmas to explosive catharsis, mirroring the creature’s own volatile physiology. The decision to let the creature retain flashes of military trauma gives the violence a layer of consequence that lingers beyond simple revenge.
Key to the narrative’s power is its refusal to simplify motivations. Alex’s arc traces a descent from reluctant innovator to haunted destroyer, while Polidori embodies unchecked capitalism’s predatory instinct. Lucy serves as the moral compass, her tenderness clashing against the masculine aggression that dominates. Legends of golems and reanimated flesh infuse the tale, but Fessenden grounds them in specifics: the soldier’s backstory evokes real-world military casualties, transforming myth into indictment. These layers matter because they show how old stories of creation still speak to current fractures in American life, where ambition, trauma, and profit often collide in the same room.
Flesh and Fury: The Art of Practical Resurrection
Fessenden’s commitment to practical effects elevates Depraved beyond digital gimmicks, delivering gore that feels palpably real. Makeup artist Damien Leone, known for his work on Terrifier, crafts the creature’s transformation with layers of prosthetics: bulging veins, necrotic skin peeling in sheets, and eyes clouded by chemical rebirth. The reanimation sequence, lit by harsh fluorescents, showcases bubbling flesh and twitching limbs, evoking the tactile horror of early Cronenberg. Each effect serves the story, amplifying the creature’s pain rather than mere shock value. In an era when many horror films lean on CGI for speed and scale, this hands-on approach forces viewers to confront the physical cost of the experiment in ways that feel uncomfortably close.
During the climactic confrontations, effects reach a fever pitch. Limbs are torn asunder with hydraulic squibs and animatronics, blood spraying in arcs that stain concrete like urban stigmata. Fessenden favors close-ups on sinew and bone, the camera lingering on the wet snap of cartilage to immerse viewers in the carnage. This approach contrasts with glossy blockbusters, rooting the violence in indie pragmatism; budget constraints forced ingenuity, like using pig intestines for realistic viscera, turning limitation into visceral strength. The result is a sequence that lingers because the damage registers as something earned rather than manufactured.
The creature’s design evolves organically, from bandaged invalid to hulking abomination, symbolizing unchecked mutation. Influences from Rick Baker’s An American Werewolf in London transformations shine through, but Fessenden personalizes them with urban grime, rusty needles, flickering neon, making the effects a character in their own right. This attention to texture helps the film sit alongside other recent practical-heavy works that remind audiences why tangible horror still carries unique weight.
Hubris in the Concrete Labyrinth: Thematic Undercurrents
At its heart, Depraved dissects the Frankenstein myth through lenses of class antagonism and chemical dependency. Polidori’s elite funding exploits Alex’s working-class ingenuity, positioning the creature as a byproduct of inequality: born from the 1%’s whims, it devours them. Scenes of boardroom scheming juxtaposed with Alex’s squalid lab underscore this divide, critiquing how wealth warps innovation into monstrosity. The parallel feels especially sharp when viewed against ongoing debates about who controls new technologies and who bears their consequences.
The opioid crisis permeates the film, with characters numbed by pills and powders mirroring the creature’s drug-fueled revival. Alex’s hands shake from withdrawal during surgery, his creation a metaphor for addiction’s false resurrection. Fessenden draws parallels to national traumas, the soldier’s flashbacks invoking Iraq and Afghanistan, where broken bodies return home to fester. These connections give the horror a documentary edge that makes the fantasy harder to dismiss.
Gender dynamics add layers; Lucy’s nurturing role subverts damsel tropes, her agency clashing against male folly. Religion lurks implicitly, the golem-like creation defies divine order, while sexuality simmers in tense, unspoken bonds. These themes coalesce without preachiness, emerging through character actions and Fessenden’s economical dialogue. The restraint lets the ideas breathe and invites viewers to draw their own lines between the story and the world outside the theater.
Shadows and Screams: Sound and Visual Mastery
Cinematographer James Wolcott employs a desaturated palette, New York’s perpetual dusk amplifying dread. Handheld shots during chases evoke found-footage intimacy, while static wide frames in the loft capture isolation. Lighting plays with chiaroscuro: sodium lamps cast elongated shadows, symbolizing fractured psyches. The visual choices keep the city itself as an active participant rather than mere backdrop.
Sound design proves revelatory, with Graham Reznick’s mix layering ambient city thrum, sirens, distant arguments, with the creature’s labored breaths and fleshy rips. A throbbing synth score underscores mutations, its dissonance peaking in kill scenes. Subtle motifs, like echoing gunfire mimicking heartbeats, bind the auditory tapestry to thematic pulse. Together the sound and image create a sensory pressure that matches the story’s rising stakes.
Mise-en-scène brims with detail: medical detritus strewn like modern relics, Wall Street suits clashing against graffiti walls. Fessenden’s composition favors asymmetry, mirroring moral imbalance, drawing viewers into a world where beauty hides in decay. Every frame feels lived-in, which deepens the sense that these events could unfold just beyond the next block.
Human Monsters Unleashed: Performance Breakdowns
David Call’s Alex anchors the film, his portrayal a masterclass in quiet unraveling, from wide-eyed ambition to hollow-eyed regret. Owen Campbell imbues Lucy with fierce vulnerability, her pivotal confrontation with the creature crackling with raw emotion. Yet Alex Breaux steals scenes as the creature, his physicality conveying terror through spasmodic grace, guttural roars conveying lost humanity. The cast’s willingness to sit with discomfort gives the emotional beats the same weight as the physical ones.
Supporting turns enrich the ensemble: Josh Evans’ Polidori oozes predatory charm, a Victor Frankenstein for the hedge-fund era. Fessenden himself appears as a sleazy dentist, injecting dark humor. Performances prioritize authenticity, born from rehearsal improvisation, fostering chemistry that elevates genre tropes. When the actors feel this grounded, the larger ideas land with greater force.
From Shelley’s Storm to Brooklyn Basements: Literary and Genre Lineage
Fessenden nods to Shelley’s 1818 novel overtly, names like Polidori (Byron’s physician) and Lucy (after Stoker), while updating for modernity. Unlike Hammer’s romanticized beasts, this creature rages without eloquence, its silence indicting verbal society’s failures. Comparisons to Corman’s Frankenstein Conquers the World abound, but Fessenden infuses eco-horror hints from his prior work. The lineage matters because it shows how one story keeps finding new soil in each generation’s anxieties.
Within indie horror, Depraved extends Fessenden’s oeuvre, echoing Wendigo’s folk myths and Habit’s addiction themes. It slots into post-Recession horror like You’re Next, where economic woes birth killers, evolving the subgenre toward social realism. Viewers who know the earlier films can trace how Depraved refines long-standing concerns into a single, focused statement.
Against the Odds: The Battlefield of Production
Shot on a shoestring via Glass Eye Pictures, Depraved faced typical indie hurdles: securing NYC permits amid rainstorms, financing through crowdfunding. Fessenden’s guerrilla style, night shoots in abandoned buildings, infused authenticity, though cast endured hypothermia for realism. Censorship dodged via MPAA savvy, preserving unrated edge. These constraints shaped the film’s immediacy in ways a larger budget might have smoothed away.
Post-production stretched months, refining effects amid pandemic precursors. These trials honed the film’s urgency, its rawness a testament to perseverance in a streaming-dominated era. The finished work carries the texture of those difficulties, which in turn makes its warnings about unchecked ambition feel earned.
Ripples in the Blood: Influence and Enduring Echo
Though not a box-office smash, Depraved garnered festival acclaim, influencing micro-budget horrors prioritizing theme over spectacle. Its legacy lies in revitalizing literary adaptations, paving for works like The Substance. Fessenden’s film endures as a mirror to societal ills, its creature a harbinger of reckonings yet to come. As explored further at Dyerbolical https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, the director’s consistent focus on character-driven dread continues to shape conversations about what indie horror can achieve.
Director in the Spotlight
Larry Fessenden, born March 23, 1955, in the Bronx, New York, emerged from a culturally rich upbringing that fueled his lifelong passion for genre cinema. Raised amidst the grit of 1970s New York, he immersed himself in the works of Mario Bava, Hammer Films, and George A. Romero, influences that would define his career. After studying at New York University, Fessenden cut his teeth in experimental theater and Super 8 shorts, honing a DIY ethos that became his hallmark. That early hands-on experience explains why his later features retain such a personal, unpolished charge even when budgets tighten.
In 1985, he founded Glass Eye Pictures, a production company championing indie horror with a focus on character-driven narratives over jump scares. His directorial debut, No Telling (The Frankenstein Complex) (1991), a loose adaptation riffing on Shelley’s novel, introduced themes of scientific overreach amid rural isolation. It screened at festivals, earning cult status for its bold effects and satire. This led to Habit (1997), a vampire tale intertwined with AIDS allegory and addiction, starring Fessenden himself as the afflicted anti-hero. Shot for under $100,000, it premiered at Toronto International Film Festival, cementing his reputation. Each project built on the last, refining an approach that values atmosphere and moral ambiguity over easy shocks.
Wendigo (2001) marked a pivot to folk horror, blending Native American legend with family trauma in snowy upstate New York; its creature design and atmospheric dread drew comparisons to The Shining. Co-directing The Last Winter (2006) with Adam Guzkowski, Fessenden tackled eco-horror in the Arctic, critiquing oil industry hubris, Ron Perlman starred, and it won awards at Sitges. I Sell the Dead (2008), a macabre comedy with Dominic Monaghan and Ron Perlman, riffed on grave-robbing tales, blending humor with gothic whimsy. Segment work followed: “O is for Oxygen” in The ABCs of Death (2012), and producing/directing on Late Phases (2014), a werewolf saga lauded for Nick Damici’s lead. Fessenden’s return to Frankenstein with Depraved (2019) synthesized his obsessions, earning raves at Fantasia. Upcoming projects include Killers and producing duties on genre fare. The through-line across these films reveals a filmmaker who treats horror as a lens for examining how ordinary people confront extraordinary pressures.
Beyond directing, Fessenden acts prolifically: memorable in Sundance Kid, You’re Next (2011), Stranger Things, and In a Valley of Violence. As producer, he nurtured talents like Ti West (House of the Devil) and Jim Jarmusch (Dead Man). Awards include Career Achievement from New York City Horror Film Festival; his influence spans festivals, teaching at NYU, and advocacy for indie cinema. Fessenden remains horror’s philosopher-king, bringing intellectual depth into visceral scares. Comprehensive filmography highlights include No Telling (1991, dir./writer: Frankenstein satire); Habit (1997, dir./star: vampire addiction drama); Wendigo (2001, dir.: mythical creature family horror); The Last Winter (2006, co-dir.: environmental apocalypse); I Sell the Dead (2008, dir.: corpse-trading comedy); Hayride (2012, act.: slasher); Late Phases (2014, dir. segments/prod.: lycanthrope elderly tale); Depraved (2019, dir./act.: urban Frankenstein), plus dozens acting credits in Session 9 (2001), We Are What We Are (2013), Darkness (forthcoming).
Actor in the Spotlight
David Call, born circa 1983 in Massachusetts, carved a niche in indie cinema with his introspective intensity. Raised in a creative family, he trained at The Juilliard School, debuting on stage before transitioning to film. His breakthrough came in Peter and Vandy (2009), opposite Winona Ryder, earning praise for capturing millennial angst. That stage-honed precision carries into his screen work, where small gestures often reveal larger fractures.
Call’s horror turn in Depraved showcases his range, portraying Alex’s moral erosion with subtle tics and haunted stares. Earlier, he featured in Gossip Girl (TV, 2009-2010) as Marco, blending drama with edge. Films like Afterschool (2008, dir. Antonio Campos) highlighted his ability to embody troubled youth, while The James King Picture Show (shorts) displayed versatility. These varied roles prepared him to handle the quiet descent at the center of Fessenden’s story.
Notable roles include Wristcutters: A Love Story (2006), Fast Food Nation (2006), and The End of Love (2012). In theater, he starred in Off-Broadway productions like The Illusion. Recent work: Private Life (2018, Netflix), A Vigilante (2018, revenge thriller). No major awards yet, but critical acclaim abounds for authenticity. Comprehensive filmography includes The River Why (2010: angler drama); Love, Lots of It (2012: rom-com); 3rd Street Blackout (2014: ensemble comedy); The Squeeze (2015: thriller); Bad Country (2015: crime); The Big Short (2015, minor: financial crisis); Depraved (2019: lead chemist); Most Likely to Murder (2019: dark comedy). TV: Gossip Girl, Blue Bloods, Power. Call continues championing low-budget gems, embodying indie spirit.
Bibliography
Heller, B. (2019) Depraved movie review (2019). Roger Ebert. Available at: https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/depraved-movie-review-2019
Kaufman, D. (2020) Larry Fessenden on Depraved, Frankenstein, and the State of Indie Horror. Fangoria, 15 January. Available at: https://fangoria.com/larry-fessenden-depraved-interview/
Tallon, P. (2019) Depraved: Larry Fessenden Talks Revisiting FRANKENSTEIN. Bloody Disgusting, 6 September. Available at: https://bloody-disgusting.com/interviews/3584994/depraved-larry-fessenden-talks-revisiting-frankenstein-exclusive-interview/
Phillips, W. (2021) Indie Frankenstein: Larry Fessenden’s Dual Adaptations. Senses of Cinema, 98. Available at: https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2021/feature-articles/indie-frankenstein/
Bartlett, M. (2022) Interview with Larry Fessenden: Horror is the Ultimate Folk Art. Hammer to Nail, 10 March. Available at: https://www.hammertonail.com/interviews/larry-fessenden/
Shelley, M. (1818) Frankenstein; or, The modern Prometheus. London: Lackington, Hughes, Harding, Mavor & Jones.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
