In the spring of 1919, while Berlin was still picking up the pieces after the First World War, a small group of filmmakers decided to put something on screen that nobody had attempted before. They told the story of a man whose love for another man brought blackmail, ruin, and public shame. That film was Different from the Others, known in Germany as Anders als die Andern. This article looks at its story, the people who made it, the world it came from, and why its message still reaches us today.

The picture opens with Paul Körner, a celebrated violinist played by Conrad Veidt, teaching a talented young student named Kurt. Their connection grows into something tender and mutual, yet it immediately draws the attention of a blackmailer named Franz Bollek. Bollek knows that Paragraph 175, the German law that made male same-sex acts illegal, gives him power over Paul. What follows is not just a personal tragedy but a clear argument against that law. The film pauses the drama at key moments so that Magnus Hirschfeld himself can speak directly to the audience about the long history of same-sex love and the harm caused by criminalisation. These inserted lectures turn the movie into both a story and a lesson, something rare for its time.

Plot Summary

Paul’s life begins to unravel once the blackmail demands grow heavier. He loses concert bookings, faces stares from colleagues, and watches his family pull away. The film shows how quickly fear spreads when the law treats love as a crime. Kurt’s sister, played by Anita Berber, adds another layer of pressure as she tries to understand what is happening between her brother and Paul. In the end the weight becomes too much. Paul’s despair leads to a tragic conclusion that leaves no doubt about the human cost of Paragraph 175. Yet the final scenes do not stop at sorrow. They call on viewers to support reform, turning the ending into an open plea rather than simple defeat.

Those educational segments matter because they gave 1919 audiences facts instead of rumours. Hirschfeld listed famous figures from history who had loved people of the same sex and explained that such feelings were not new or foreign. By placing these moments inside a dramatic story, the film made the argument harder to dismiss. People came for the melodrama and left with information they could not easily forget.

Cast and Crew

Conrad Veidt brought quiet dignity to Paul, making the character’s pain feel real rather than theatrical. Reinhold Schünzel gave Kurt a mix of admiration and confusion that felt honest for a younger man discovering his feelings. Friedrich Berry’s blackmailer is all oily menace, the kind of villain audiences could recognise from real life. Anita Berber, already known for her daring stage work, appears as Kurt’s sister and adds a touch of Weimar-era boldness to the cast. Leo Connard plays Paul’s father, representing the older generation’s confusion and shame.

Richard Oswald directed and produced, working closely with Magnus Hirschfeld on the script. Hirschfeld also stepped in front of the camera to deliver the scientific segments himself. Cinematographer Max Fassbender captured the intimate spaces of concert halls and private rooms with the soft lighting common to late silent films. Every name on the credits took a risk simply by attaching themselves to the project.

Production and Context

Berlin in 1919 was a city caught between old rules and new freedoms. The war had ended, the Kaiser had gone, and for a few years the Weimar Republic allowed more open discussion of sexuality than Germany had ever seen before. Hirschfeld had already founded the Scientific-Humanitarian Committee, the first organisation in Europe to campaign for gay rights. When Oswald approached him about a film, Hirschfeld saw a chance to reach people who would never attend a lecture. The two men shaped the project together, mixing fiction with direct teaching.

The finished film ran about fifty minutes in the version that survives, though original prints were longer. Intertitles carried both story information and short arguments against the law. The premiere took place on 28 May 1919 at the Theater am Nollendorfplatz, a venue known for progressive programming. Audiences that night witnessed something that felt closer to a public meeting than a normal night at the pictures.

Paragraph 175 had been on the books since 1871, yet it was enforced unevenly until the Nazis later used it as a weapon. By attacking the law in 1919, the film stepped into a live political fight. Oswald and Hirschfeld were not asking for tolerance as a favour. They were insisting that the law itself created the blackmail and despair the story shows.

Reception and Legacy

Some viewers praised the film’s courage on the night it opened. Others, especially conservative politicians and church groups, called for it to be banned. Several German states quickly restricted or prohibited screenings. When the Nazis took power in 1933 they labelled the picture degenerate and destroyed nearly every print they could find. Only scattered reels survived in archives outside Germany.

A 1982 restoration stitched together the remaining footage from collections in East and West Germany as well as private holdings. Modern prints usually carry English intertitles so new audiences can follow the argument. The film now sits in film-history courses and queer-studies programmes as the earliest surviving feature to treat homosexuality as a central subject rather than a joke or a secret. Its mix of story and lecture influenced later advocacy films that blend drama with information.

What still strikes viewers is how directly the picture names the law and the damage it does. Many later movies hinted or coded their themes. Different from the Others refused to hide. That choice cost it most of its original audience, yet it preserved a record of early resistance that historians continue to study.

Where to Watch

Restored editions appear on YouTube and archive.org, often uploaded by film-preservation groups. Specialty streaming platforms that focus on silent cinema or LGBTQ+ history also carry versions with updated scores. The most complete prints include the surviving lecture scenes, which remain the clearest window into Hirschfeld’s thinking at the time. Watching one of these restorations today feels like stepping into a conversation that began more than a century ago and has not yet finished.

Bibliography

Magnus Hirschfeld, “The Sexual History of the World War” (1930 edition with references to the film project).

Richard Oswald production files held at the Deutsche Kinemathek, Berlin.

Robert Deam Tobin, “Peripheral Desires: The German Discovery of Sex” (University of Pennsylvania Press, 2015).

Restoration notes from the 1982 version compiled by the Stiftung Deutsche Kinemathek.

Laurie Marhoefer, “Sex and the Weimar Republic: German Homosexual Emancipation and the Rise of the Nazis” (University of Toronto Press, 2015).

Archive.org digitised print with original German intertitles and added English translation.

Conrad Veidt filmography entries in “The Weimar Cinema Reader” (BFI, 2009).

Scientific-Humanitarian Committee annual reports 1919–1920, reprinted in Hirschfeld Institute archives.

At Dyerbolical we keep returning to films like this one because they show how early creators used the screen to argue for fairness when few other platforms existed. The courage on display in 1919 still feels worth remembering.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289