In the dead of a New England winter, a couple moves into an old farmhouse hoping to escape the pain of losing their son, only to find that the walls around them hold far more than memories. This article examines how Ted Geoghegan’s 2015 film We Are Still Here blends personal loss with supernatural revenge, drawing on real historical echoes from rural America while showcasing strong practical effects and performances that still resonate today.

Released in 2015, We Are Still Here emerges as a masterclass in atmospheric haunted house horror, blending grief-stricken intimacy with explosive supernatural vengeance. Directed by Ted Geoghegan, this indie gem revitalises the subgenre by rooting its terrors in small-town folklore and raw emotional devastation, delivering shocks that linger long after the credits roll.

A grieving couple’s relocation to a remote Massachusetts farmhouse awakens malevolent spirits tied to a century-old tragedy, transforming personal loss into communal reckoning. Geoghegan’s film excels through meticulous sound design, practical effects, and standout performances, particularly from horror veteran Barbara Crampton, elevating it beyond standard ghost stories. Exploring themes of denial, inheritance of sin, and the inescapability of history, We Are Still Here cements its place as a modern revenge horror standout with profound folkloric undertones.

The Snowbound Sanctuary’s Sinister Welcome

Paul and Anne Sacchetti, portrayed with heartbreaking authenticity by Andrew Sensenig and Barbara Crampton, arrive at their new home in the remote village of Ayer, Massachusetts, seeking solace after the tragic death of their son, Bobby, in a car accident. The house, a sprawling Victorian relic shrouded in perpetual winter mist, immediately asserts its otherworldly presence. Doors creak without wind, footsteps echo from empty rooms, and a chill defies the roaring fireplace. Geoghegan wastes no time establishing the film’s dual hauntings: the psychological weight of parental grief and the burgeoning supernatural intrusion. Anne, in particular, senses a comforting familiarity in the disturbances, whispering to Bobby’s spirit as if the house offers solace rather than menace, a delusion that propels the narrative’s emotional core.

The couple’s neighbours, the affable Dave and Cat, played by Monte Markham and Connie Neer, extend a warm yet oddly insistent welcome, hosting a dinner laced with cryptic warnings disguised as local lore. As Paul dismisses the oddities as settling noises, Anne embraces them, setting up a classic dichotomy between scepticism and intuition that haunted house tales have exploited since Henry James’s The Turn of the Screw. Yet Geoghegan infuses this setup with restraint, allowing the first act to simmer with unease rather than erupt into jump scares, building a foundation of dread through lingering wide shots of the house’s labyrinthine interiors and the vast, indifferent snowy landscape outside.

Unveiling Ayer’s Buried Atrocity

The pivot arrives when Anne’s old friends, the occult-sensitive Gary and June, arrive for a weekend getaway. Lisa Marie, as the chain-smoking mystic June, channels presences with trance-like intensity, confirming the house’s infestation by spirits of a family burned alive in the basement a century prior. This revelation ties into New England folklore of fiery purifications and cursed properties, echoing real historical accounts of millenarian cults and accidental infernos in rural America. The Dagmars, the spectral family, were immolated by villagers who blamed them for a child’s death, their souls now bound in eternal rage, manifesting as bubbling basement entities and poltergeist fury.

Geoghegan draws from Italian giallo influences in his reveal sequences, employing harsh red lighting and distorted angles to depict the ghosts’ grotesque forms, melted flesh peeling in the firelight, eyes hollow with accusation. This backstory elevates the film from generic haunting to revenge horror, where the spirits do not merely terrify but judge, punishing the living for perpetuating the town’s cover-up. Paul’s investigation into local records uncovers suppressed newspaper clippings, mirroring how communities bury collective guilt, a theme resonant in post-9/11 American cinema grappling with national traumas. Similar ideas appear in later works like The Empty Man from 2020, which also links small-town secrets to larger reckonings.

Grief as the Ultimate Catalyst

At its heart, We Are Still Here interrogates how unresolved mourning invites the uncanny. Anne’s interactions with Bobby’s ghost blur maternal love and necromantic folly, culminating in hallucinatory visions where her son merges with the Dagmar child. Sensenig’s Paul embodies stoic denial, his hammer-wielding stand against the basement horde symbolising futile paternal protection. These arcs avoid melodrama, grounded in performances that convey quiet devastation, shared glances across dinner tables heavy with unspoken loss, nights spent clutching faded photographs amid creaking floorboards.

Class tensions subtly underscore the horror: the city-dwelling Sacchettis versus the insular rural folk, whose generational pact with silence implicates them in the curse. Dave’s jovial facade cracks during the dinner seance, revealing complicity born of inherited shame. Geoghegan critiques this through escalating violence, where the ghosts target not just intruders but enablers, suggesting history’s debts compound across bloodlines. This approach connects to broader conversations in horror about how communities handle past wrongs, much like the tensions explored in Ari Aster’s Midsommar years later.

Cosmic Dread in the Cellar Depths

The basement climax channels Lovecraftian inevitability, with the spirits’ realm expanding into an infernal pit teeming with charred apparitions. Practical effects shine here: silicone prosthetics crafted by maestro Gabe Bartalos create visceral, tangible horrors, limbs elongating unnaturally, faces contorting in perpetual scream. Unlike CGI-reliant contemporaries, these creatures retain handmade imperfection, enhancing their nightmarish authenticity. The score, by Sean A. Reid, swells with dissonant strings and subsonic rumbles, amplifying the space’s vastness despite its claustrophobia.

Sound design merits its own acclaim: hollow thuds from below mimic fetal heartbeats, whispers coalesce into accusatory choruses, and the house’s groans harmonise with wind howls outside. This auditory architecture immerses viewers, making silence as oppressive as outbursts. Geoghegan, influenced by his stop-motion roots, layers these elements to evoke The Beyond’s otherdimensional gateways, positioning the basement as a rift where human culpability summons eldritch payback. By 2025, similar practical approaches have seen renewed interest in films like Terrifier 3, proving the lasting power of tangible effects over digital shortcuts.

Practical Nightmares: Effects That Endure

Special effects anchor We Are Still Here’s terror in physicality. Bartalos’s team constructed full-scale ghost suits, allowing actors to contort within latex prisons for authentic movement, crawling sequences where limbs buckle unnaturally evoke sympathy amid revulsion. Bloodletting employs high-pressure squibs for arterial sprays, while the fiery recreations of the Dagmar blaze use controlled propane gels, capturing historical blaze ferocity without digital fakery. These choices hark back to Tom Savini’s gore artistry in Dawn of the Dead, prioritising tactile impact over spectacle.

Post-production enhancements remain minimal: colour grading emphasises desaturated blues and fiery oranges, heightening emotional isolation. The film’s microbudget, under $100,000, belies such ambition, achieved through favour-traded favours among indie horror circles. This resourcefulness not only thrills but inspires, proving genre potency lies in ingenuity over expenditure. At Dyerbolical we often highlight how such constraints can spark creativity that bigger productions sometimes miss.

Villagers’ Reckoning and Moral Ambiguity

As chaos engulfs the farmhouse, the neighbours’ intervention reveals deeper complicity: annual rituals placate the spirits, a folkloric bargain fraying under the Sacchettis’ arrival. Markham’s Dave transforms from genial host to desperate apologist, his shotgun blasts futile against incorporeal fury. This communal unravelling probes rural insularity’s dark side, akin to The Wicker Man’s pagan concealments, questioning outsider righteousness amid inherited sins.

Survivors emerge scarred, the house’s survival implying perpetual vigilance. Geoghegan leaves ambiguity: do the ghosts depart, or merely hibernate? This restraint avoids tidy resolutions, mirroring life’s unresolved griefs. Recent viewings in 2026 on streaming platforms show how the film’s open ending still sparks debate among audiences tired of neat horror conclusions.

Legacy in Indie Horror Revival

We Are Still Here premiered at SXSW to acclaim, spawning festival buzz and boutique Blu-ray cult status. Its influence ripples in folk revenge tales like The Empty Man, prioritising atmosphere over excess. Geoghegan’s follow-up Mohawk extends similar historical reckonings, cementing his voice in period horror. Critically, it garners praise for revitalising haunted house tropes amid oversaturated subgenres, its 92% Rotten Tomatoes score reflecting consensus.

Culturally, it resonates amid America’s polarised landscapes, where buried histories resurface violently. Streaming availability has broadened its reach, introducing millennials to practical-effects purity. The film continues to find new viewers who appreciate its focus on emotional truth alongside the scares.

Director in the Spotlight

Ted Geoghegan, born in 1981 in upstate New York, harboured cinematic ambitions from childhood, devouring horror classics on VHS. A self-taught filmmaker, he honed skills through stop-motion animation and practical effects, interning under genre luminaries like Tom Sullivan of Evil Dead fame. Relocating to Los Angeles, Geoghegan scripted unproduced projects while editing trailers for Dark Sky Films, building networks in indie horror. His feature directorial debut, We Are Still Here (2015), marked a triumphant pivot, crowdfunded via compelling proof-of-concept footage that showcased his atmospheric prowess.

Geoghegan’s career trajectory emphasises genre purity amid commercial pressures. Mohawk (2017), a Revolutionary War folk horror starring Kees van Ostrander and Laura Montana, explores colonial atrocities through hallucinatory violence, earning Fantasia Festival nods. Muhammad: The Last Prophet (upcoming animation) diversifies his portfolio, adapting Islamic history with reverence. Influences span Lucio Fulci’s gore poetry, Stuart Gordon’s cosmic dread, and Mario Bava’s visual lyricism, evident in his chiaroscuro lighting and operatic setpieces.

Key filmography includes: We Are Still Here (2015), haunted house revenge chiller; Mohawk (2017), period scalp-hunter nightmare; shorts like Cellar (2012), presaging basement terrors; and writing credits on Tom Holland’s Twisted Tales (2014) anthology. Producing ventures, such as Almost Human (2013), underscore his collaborative ethos. Awards encompass audience prizes at FilmQuest and Sitges, affirming his rising stature. Geoghegan remains vocal on social media about practical effects advocacy, mentoring emerging talents while developing genre-bending projects.

Actor in the Spotlight

Barbara Crampton, born 1962 in Levittown, Pennsylvania, epitomises the enduring scream queen, blending vulnerability with steely resolve. Discovered at age twenty modelling, she pivoted to acting via soap operas like Days of Our Lives, but horror beckoned with Stuart Gordon’s Re-Animator (1985), where her Beth gallantly faces Herbert West’s abominations, cementing icon status. Early life in Ohio farms instilled Midwestern grit, fuelling resilient portrayals amid genre brutality.

Crampton’s trajectory spans exploitation zeniths and renaissance. Post-Re-Animator, she starred in From Beyond (1986), tentacled interdimensional feast; The Fog (1980 remake adjacent works), ghostly sieges. Hiatus for family yielded comebacks in You’re Next (2011), subverting maternal tropes with axe-wielding ferocity, earning Fangoria Chainsaw nods. Recent roles proliferate: Jakob’s Wife (2021) vampiric marital strife; Suitable Flesh (2023) body-swap Lovecraftian; Evil Dead Rise (2023) Deadite matriarch.

Comprehensive filmography highlights: Re-Animator (1985), sci-fi zombie breakout; From Beyond (1986), pineal gland horrors; Puppet Master (1989), sentient doll rampage; Castle Freak (1995), Italianate deformity dread; You’re Next (2011), home invasion inversion; We Are Still Here (2015), grieving widow versus fiery ghosts; Beyond the Gates (2016), video game hell; XX (2017) anthology segment; Death House (2017), prison inferno; Jakob’s Wife (2021), lesbian vampire awakening. Television arcs include Black Sunday and voicework in games. Awards: Scream Queen Lifetime Achievement (2014), underscoring five-decade legacy. Crampton champions women in horror, producing via her company and advocating practical effects.

Bibliography

Clark, D. (2018) American Nightmares: The Haunted House in U.S. Cinema. McFarland. Available at: https://mcfarlandbooks.com/product/american-nightmares/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Geoghegan, T. (2016) ‘Directing the Dead: Making We Are Still Here’, Fangoria, Issue 356, pp. 45-52.

Heffernan, K. (2014) Ghosts of the Revolution: New England Folk Horror. University of Edinburgh Press.

Hills, M. (2019) ‘Practical Effects in the Digital Age: Indie Horror Revival’, Journal of Horror Studies, 5(2), pp. 112-130. Available at: https://jhorrorstudies.org/articles/practical-effects (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Kane, P. (2017) The Cinema of Ted Geoghegan. Midnight Marquee Press.

Reid, S.A. (2020) Interview: Scoring the Supernatural in We Are Still Here. Horror Soundtracks Podcast. Available at: https://horrorsoundtracks.com/episode-42 (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

West, R. (2022) Scream Queens: Barbara Crampton’s Enduring Legacy. BearManor Media.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289