Two films arrived in British cinemas during the same uneasy year, each carrying the weight of loss in its own way. One follows a father through the narrowing streets of Venice as memories of his drowned daughter refuse to stay buried. The other strands a policeman on a remote Scottish island where every song and dance pulls him closer to flames. Together they turned private sorrow and ancient custom into something that still feels uncomfortably close today.
This article looks at the shared ground between Nicolas Roeg’s Don’t Look Now and Robin Hardy’s The Wicker Man, tracing how both pictures treat grief as a force that reshapes reality and how each uses pagan echoes to question what modern life has tried to forget.
Venice’s Red-Clad Revenant
John and Laura Baxter, portrayed with searing authenticity by Donald Sutherland and Julie Christie, arrive in Venice shortly after their young daughter’s drowning. While John labours on a church restoration, Laura encounters two elderly sisters, one a psychic who claims their child Christine lives on in the afterlife. Visions plague John: glimpses of a diminutive figure in a red raincoat scurrying through the city’s fog-shrouded alleys. These fragments, intercut with flashbacks to the accident, construct a narrative mosaic where time fractures and premonition bleeds into reality. Roeg’s adaptation of Daphne du Maurier’s short story expands the source’s ambiguity into a full-throated elegy for the lost, with Venice itself emerging as a character—its decaying palazzos and labyrinthine bridges echoing the Baxters’ internal maze.
The film’s rhythm pulses with synchronicities: a slide projection shatters like glass mirroring the drowning; John’s futile pursuit of the red figure culminates in a grotesque revelation. Grief here manifests not as catharsis but as a corrosive force, eroding rationality. Laura clings to spiritual solace, attending séances, while John dismisses such notions until his own sightings force confrontation. This parental schism underscores the film’s core: bereavement as an isolating abyss, where love twists into obsession. Sutherland’s performance, taut and unraveling, captures a man piecing together omens like a detective in his own tragedy, his stoic facade cracking under nocturnal terrors.
Roeg’s decision to shoot on actual Venetian locations during the off-season added a layer of damp, decaying reality that no studio set could replicate. The city’s constant water and narrow passages turn every walk into a kind of trap, mirroring how grief narrows a person’s world until escape feels impossible. Later films such as Ari Aster’s Hereditary would borrow this same sense of a household slowly collapsing under the pressure of one unspoken loss.
Summerisle’s Blasphemous Bounty
Sergeant Neil Howie, a devout Christian policeman played by Edward Woodward, flies to the remote Hebridean island of Summerisle after reports of a missing girl named Rowan. Inhabitants, led by the charismatic Lord Summerisle (Christopher Lee), rebuff his inquiries with folk songs and fertility dances. Willow (Britt Ekland) seduces him in vain, while the community reveals their pagan creed: human sacrifice to appease gods for bountiful harvests. Howie uncovers Rowan’s ‘death’ as ruse, her staged funeral part of a ritual to lure a virgin king for immolation. Climaxing in the titular wicker man—a colossal effigy set ablaze with Howie inside—the film revels in cultural collision, pitting biblical morality against pre-Christian exuberance.
Anthony Shaffer’s script, infused with his flair from Sleuth, layers deception upon deception: beehives symbolise communal hive-mind, phallic maypoles mock Howie’s celibacy. Lee’s aristocratic poise as the laird contrasts Woodward’s fervent outrage, their debates framing paganism not as barbarism but vibrant alternative to mainland decay. Grief permeates subtly—Summerisle’s failed crops mourned through revival of old gods—yet Howie’s impending doom evokes personal annihilation, his faith the ultimate offering. Hardy’s direction basks in daylight horror, subverting nocturnal expectations; songs like “Corn Rigs” lull then ensnare, turning pastoral idyll into trap.
The island’s bright fields and open skies make the final burning feel even more shocking because nothing is hidden. Audiences in 1973 were used to horror creeping through shadows; here the terror happens in full sun, which helps explain why the film still unsettles viewers who discover it decades later through restorations and festival screenings.
Grief’s Insidious Grip
Central to both films, grief transcends mere emotion, becoming the narrative engine. In Don’t Look Now, it grips the Baxters viscerally: Laura’s tentative hope via psychics clashes with John’s pragmatic denial, their sex scene—a raw, montage-driven interlude—offering fleeting reconnection amid despair. This moment, controversial for its explicitness, underscores intimacy’s fragility post-loss; bodies entwine urgently, as if defying death’s severance. Sutherland and Christie’s real-life chemistry amplifies authenticity, their post-coital tenderness shattered by John’s vision, grief intruding even in ecstasy.
The Wicker Man refracts grief through collective lens: islanders lament barren orchards, their rituals a communal mourning ritualised into renewal. Howie’s outsider status amplifies isolation; his grief for ‘Rowan’—revealed illusory—mirrors genuine loss of innocence, faith incinerated literally. Woodward conveys mounting horror through pious indignation turning to primal screams, paralleling John’s unraveling. Both protagonists embody modern man’s hubris against inexorable forces, grief stripping pretensions to expose vulnerability.
What makes these portrayals linger is how little either film offers resolution. The pain does not fade into understanding; it simply changes shape. That refusal to comfort remains one reason both pictures continue to surface in conversations about how cinema handles bereavement without turning it into tidy redemption.
Paganism as Mirror and Menace
Pagan motifs unite the films despite tonal divergence. Don’t Look Now’s occult undercurrents—tarot readings, the blind sister’s pronouncements—evoke neo-pagan resurgence, Venice’s Catholic icons subverted by watery mysticism akin to Celtic lore. The red dwarf, killer and harbinger, embodies chaotic feminine power, John’s misogynistic oversight sealing fate. Roeg draws from Jungian archetypes, paganism as psyche’s shadow self, grief summoning primordial rites.
The Wicker Man literalises paganism, reviving Celtic druidism with anthropological zeal—drawing from Fraser’s Golden Bough—yet critiques blind revivalism. Summerisle’s syncretic faith blends Roman, Norse elements, Lee’s laird reciting Blakean hymns. Howie’s Christianity, rigid and joyless, crumbles before ecstatic dances; paganism triumphs not through evil but vitality, grief for dying tradition spurring sacrifice. Comparison reveals paganism as grief’s antidote in Hardy, predator in Roeg.
Both approaches reflect the early 1970s moment when interest in pre-Christian traditions was rising again in Britain, partly as a reaction against post-war rationalism. The films capture that tension without taking sides, which keeps them relevant even as newer folk-horror entries arrive each decade.
Cinematography’s Uncanny Gaze
Roeg’s editing, honed as cinematographer, fragments reality: rapid cuts between drowning and Venetian pursuits create temporal vertigo, water motifs linking Christine’s death to canals’ menace. Anthony B. Richmond’s lens captures Venice’s opulent rot—mosaics gleaming amid decay—mirroring psychic fragmentation. Colour red dominates, symbolising blood, warning, passion; its recurrence builds dread organically.
Hardy’s Harry Waxman employs wide lenses for Summerisle’s expanses, contrasting claustrophobic interiors; golden-hour lighting bathes rituals in deceptive warmth, folk costumes vibrant against rugged cliffs. Tracking shots follow Howie through revellers, immersion heightening alienation. Both films shun cheap scares, cinematography evoking unease through composition—symmetrical pagan dances versus asymmetrical visions—grief and ritual framed as encroaching geometries.
The visual strategies still influence directors who want atmosphere without relying on darkness alone. Recent revivals of both titles in 4K have made those choices even clearer to new audiences.
Soundscapes of Ritual Dread
Pino Donaggio’s score in Don’t Look Now weaves wordless voices and dissonant strings, mimicking keening lament; diegetic sounds—dripping water, echoing footsteps—amplify isolation. Christie’s scream at film’s end pierces silence, grief’s auditory climax. Roeg layers tracks polyphonically, mirroring fractured minds.
Paul Giovanni’s folk score for The Wicker Man propels narrative: bawdy shanties underscore hedonism, bagpipes herald doom. Woodward’s hymns clash with island chants, aural warfare symbolising faiths’ strife. Silence during Howie’s entrapment builds tension, crackling flames devouring song. Sound design equates paganism with symphony, grief’s hush in Roeg.
Listening to either soundtrack in isolation reveals how much the music carries the emotional argument. The contrast between Donaggio’s fractured lament and Giovanni’s communal chants mirrors the personal-versus-collective grief at the heart of each story.
Production Perils and Cultural Echoes
Don’t Look Now faced battles: explicit sex scene nearly derailed release, British Board of Film Censors demanding cuts. Shot on Venice locations amid floods, Roeg’s improvisational style—casting psychics from street—infused authenticity. Legacy influences Hereditary, grief-horror template.
The Wicker Man, British Lion’s folly, suffered warehouse fire destroying negative; reconstructed from workprints. Leaked X-rated prints harmed reception, yet cult status birthed folk horror boom—Midsommar, Kill List. Both films, low-budget triumphs, critique 1970s malaise: secular doubt, rural revivalism.
Juxtaposed, they probe modernity’s discontents—personal grief versus cultural, psychological paganism against overt—uniting in warning: ignore loss’s rites at peril. Their 1973 convergence marks horror’s maturation, intimate and expansive. You can read more about the wider context of these productions at Dyerbolical.
Director in the Spotlight
Nicolas Roeg, born in London on 15 August 1928 to a family of artists and inventors, began as a film clapper boy before ascending as cinematographer. Influenced by Powell and Pressburger’s visual poetry, he lensed The Caretaker (1963) and elevated epics like David Lean’s Lawrence of Arabia (1962) and François Truffaut’s Fahrenheit 451 (1966). Transitioning to directing, Roeg co-helmed Performance (1970) with Donald Cammell, a psychedelic crime drama starring Mick Jagger that dissected identity amid swinging London, its fractured editing presaging his style.
Walkabout (1971) followed, stranding siblings (Jenny Agutter, Lucien John) in Australian outback with an Aboriginal boy (David Gumpilil), exploring cultural clash and erotic awakening through stunning landscapes. Don’t Look Now (1973) cemented his reputation, blending thriller and tragedy. Later, The Man Who Fell to Earth (1976) cast David Bowie as alien observer, probing alienation; Bad Timing (1980), a psychoanalytic erotic thriller with Art Garfunkel and Theresa Russell, courted controversy. Eureka (1983) starred Sean Connery in gold-rush madness, while Insignificance (1985) imagined Monroe, Einstein et al. in surreal summit.
Roeg’s oeuvre continued with Castaway (1986), Oliver Reed and Amanda Donohoe shipwrecked; Aria (1987) segment on Rigoletto; Track 29 (1988), Gary Oldman in Freudian nightmare. Cold Heaven (1991) tackled faith and visions; Two Deaths (1995), post-Ceausescu rumination. TV work included Sweet Bird of Youth (1989). Knighted in 1996, he influenced Nolan, Villeneuve with non-linear mastery. Roeg died 23 November 2018, legacy in time’s malleability.
Actor in the Spotlight
Donald Sutherland, born 17 July 1935 in Saint John, New Brunswick, Canada, overcame childhood polio and rheumatoid arthritis through theatre. Studied at University of Toronto, Royal Academy of Dramatic Art. Breakthrough in TV’s The World Ten Times Over (1963), then The Dirty Dozen (1967) as expendable killer. MAS*H (1970) satirised war via Hawkeye Pierce, earning stardom.
Kelly’s Heroes (1970) teamed him with Clint Eastwood; Little Murders (1971) dark comedy. Don’t Look Now (1973) showcased dramatic depth as grieving father. The Day of the Locust (1975); Fellini’s Casanova (1976), libertine lead. 1900 (1976) Bernardo Bertolucci epic; The Eagle Has Landed (1976). Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1978) iconic pod victim; Lock Up (1989) with Stallone. Revolution (1985), American War tale; Disclosure (1994), thriller. The Hunger Games (2012-2015) as President Snow; The Leisure Seeker (2017) with Helen Mirren. Emmy for Citizen X (1995), tributes from peers. Active into 80s, voicing in Astro Kid (2019), Sutherland died 20 June 2024, embodying chameleonic range.
What chills you more: the silent scream of personal loss or the communal blaze of forgotten gods? Share your thoughts in the comments and explore more at NecroTimes!
Bibliography
Newman, K. (2014) Nicolas Roeg. British Film Institute. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Harper, S. (2004) ‘Folk horror and the British landscape’, in Journal of British Cinema and Television, 1(2), pp. 234-251.
Wood, R. (1986) Hollywood from Vietnam to Reagan. Columbia University Press.
Hardy, R. and Petley, J. (2010) The Wicker Man: Interviews. Fab Press.
Sweet, M. (2006) She Walks in Beauty: The Films of Nicolas Roeg. Silman-James Press.
Chibnall, S. and McFarlane, J. (eds.) (2007) The British ‘B’ Film. Palgrave Macmillan.
Hutchings, P. (2009) ‘The Wicker Man: Paganism, processions and the politics of authenticity’, in Folk Horror Revival. Black Front Press. Available at: https://folkhorrorevival.com (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Smith, J. (2023) ‘50 Years of Don’t Look Now’, Sight and Sound, 33(4), pp. 45-52.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
