Queer Theory and Masculinity in The Blue Caftan: How Maryam Touzani Challenges Gender Norms in Moroccan Cinema

The quiet rhythm of needles piercing cloth in a small Casablanca workshop hides more than just careful craftsmanship. Maryam Touzani’s 2023 film The Blue Caftan uses that setting to examine love, identity, and the pressures of tradition in a society that rarely speaks openly about desire. Nominated for the Academy Award for Best International Feature, the story follows master tailor Halim, his wife Mina, and their new apprentice Youssef. For anyone studying film, the movie provides a clear window into queer theory and the ways masculinity can shift under close observation.

By the end of this discussion you will recognise core ideas from queer theory, see how they apply to the performances of masculinity on screen, and understand the film’s place in recent Arab cinema. These tools help when you analyse character choices or broader patterns in media representation. The focus stays on gender as something performed rather than fixed, and on how small gestures can question long-standing expectations.

We start with the basics of queer theory, move through changing ideas of masculinity in film, and then look closely at Touzani’s story. Every detail of fabric and glance builds toward larger questions about identity and belonging.

Foundations of Queer Theory

Queer theory took shape in the late 1980s and 1990s as scholars questioned the idea that gender and sexuality are simple, unchanging categories. It drew on post-structuralist thought, feminist writing, and earlier work in gay and lesbian studies. The central claim is that labels such as heterosexual or masculine gain their meaning through repeated social practices and institutional power rather than through any inner essence. Judith Butler’s 1990 book Gender Trouble made this point concrete with the idea of gender performativity: what we call gender is a series of repeated acts shaped by cultural rules, not a natural core that simply shows itself.

Three main lines of thought matter here. First, the theory breaks down binary oppositions. It shows that the line between heterosexuality and homosexuality or between normative and queer behaviour stays unstable and often gets enforced by family structures, religious teachings, and legal systems. Second, it looks at how exaggerated or excessive performances can expose the artificial quality of so-called normal ideals, a line of thinking developed by Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick in Epistemology of the Closet from 1990. Third, it insists on intersectionality, the recognition that queer experience always meets other factors such as race, class, and national context, which can increase marginalisation outside Western settings.

In film studies these ideas help explain how certain movies redirect the male gaze that Laura Mulvey identified in classical Hollywood. Instead of treating women as objects, the camera can linger on male bodies or on moments of fluid desire. Directors such as Pedro Almodóvar and Apichatpong Weerasethakul have used visual style to question fixed identities. Touzani continues that approach by turning the everyday work of tailoring into a space where rigid expectations about men begin to loosen.

Masculinity on Screen: From Hegemony to Fluidity

For decades mainstream cinema presented a narrow version of manhood: the stoic hero who leads, protects, and rarely shows doubt. Raewyn Connell’s 1987 account of hegemonic masculinity described this ideal as the form most rewarded by culture while other expressions of manhood were pushed aside. Westerns starring John Wayne offered clear examples, with their emphasis on self-reliance and emotional control. Narrative conventions kept reinforcing the same pattern through stories of the strong provider or the unyielding father figure.

More recent films have opened space for different portrayals. Queer cinema often shows men dealing with vulnerability, physical limits, or same-sex attraction. Gus Van Sant’s Milk from 2008 presents Harvey Milk’s public and private life without reducing him to a single heroic trait. Luca Guadagnino’s Call Me by Your Name from 2017 lets youthful desire unfold gradually and without apology. Both films treat masculinity as something shaped through relationships and repeated choices, which matches Butler’s emphasis on performativity rather than fixed traits.

Challenges in Non-Western Contexts

Arab and North African films face additional layers. Colonial histories, conservative religious norms, and national identity projects after independence have all shaped how masculinity appears on screen. Nabil Ayouch’s Much Loved from 2015 examined patriarchal control and its costs. Openly queer stories remain rare because of censorship and social risk. Touzani works within those limits by placing moments of tension inside ordinary routines such as sewing or bathing, letting viewers notice what remains unspoken.

The Blue Caftan: Synopsis and Cultural Backdrop

The action stays inside the narrow streets of Casablanca’s old medina. Halim, played by Saleh Bakri, runs a workshop making custom caftans. His wife Mina, played by Lubna Azabal, lives with a serious illness, and the couple has no children. They hire Youssef, played by Ayoub Missioui, a young married man, to help with the work. As the days pass, Halim and Youssef develop a quiet attraction that Mina notices and quietly accepts. The story never shows explicit scenes; instead it relies on shared cigarettes, careful measurements, and long silences.

Touzani’s earlier film Adam from 2019 also dealt with unspoken desires. In Morocco, Article 489 of the penal code still criminalises homosexuality, so public discussion stays limited. The film premiered at Venice in 2022 and drew attention for its measured tone. That restraint echoes Sedgwick’s idea of the closet, where knowledge of desire circulates through hints rather than declarations.

Queer Performativity in Halim’s World

Halim performs masculinity through his skill at the sewing table and his role as teacher to Youssef. Yet those same actions open room for other feelings. In many cultures tailoring carries associations with women’s work, so Halim’s command of the craft already sits at an angle to stricter models of manhood. Close shots of his hands adjusting fabric on Youssef’s body turn the measuring tape into a point of contact that carries more than professional meaning.

Several sequences make this visible. During the measurement scene Halim’s hands rest on Youssef’s chest while the tape stretches across his back; the master-apprentice relation supplies cover for a growing physical awareness. Later, in the hammam, both men appear without clothes. The steam and shared nudity remove everyday barriers and let Halim’s older body stand beside Youssef’s youth, exposing vulnerability instead of strength. The finished blue caftan itself becomes a symbol of ideals that remain out of reach; its careful construction runs parallel to Halim’s gradual recognition of feelings he has kept hidden.

Mina’s role adds another dimension. She understands her husband’s orientation and brings Youssef into the household anyway. The resulting three-way bond steps outside conventional family triangles and suggests forms of attachment that do not fit standard scripts.

Deconstructing Masculinity: Halim and Youssef

Halim begins as the steady head of the workshop, yet his composure cracks when Mina’s health declines. Tears and honest conversations with Youssef show the cost of maintaining an unyielding front. Saleh Bakri’s performance keeps the emotions contained rather than theatrical, which fits Connell’s description of protest masculinities that resist dominance through openness instead of force.

Youssef presents a different picture. He arrives already married and expecting a child, yet his eagerness around Halim reveals uncertainty about his own desires. Ayoub Missioui’s acting captures both physical confidence and quiet confusion, offering one of the few recent Arab film portraits of a man whose identity refuses easy labels.

Visual and Auditory Cues

Cinematographer Víctor Iriarte uses soft light and shallow focus to keep attention on bodies surrounded by bolts of cloth. The effect isolates small gestures and makes them feel intimate. A spare musical score built around oud melodies supports the mood without forcing resolution. Together these choices invite viewers to read the film through a queer lens even when dialogue stays minimal.

At Dyerbolical we have looked at similar techniques in other slow-paced films where atmosphere carries theoretical weight. The same approach appears here, turning everyday spaces into sites where identity can be reconsidered.

Cultural and Global Implications

The Blue Caftan belongs to a wave of Moroccan films that test social limits. Directors such as Faouzi Bensaïdi and Hicham Lasri have also taken on difficult subjects. The Oscar nomination brought wider attention, allowing conversations about desire and belonging to reach audiences outside the region. Queer theory helps explain why such films matter: they humanise characters who might otherwise remain stereotypes and show cinema’s capacity to shift public feeling.

Students of media will notice the film’s use of extended takes and minimal action, hallmarks of slow cinema that encourage reflection. Comparisons with Hong Sang-soo’s understated character studies or Claire Denis’s attention to touch offer useful cross-cultural parallels. Each approach shows how queerness can surface through style rather than plot alone.

Conclusion

The Blue Caftan demonstrates how queer theory can illuminate a single narrative while respecting its cultural setting. The main points are straightforward. Gender appears as repeated performance rather than inner truth, following Butler. Vulnerability undercuts hegemonic models of manhood, following Connell. Cinema can give voice to marginalised experiences even when direct speech carries risk. Touzani’s decision to work through glances and fabric rather than declarations shows that restraint itself can carry political weight.

When you watch again, pay attention to the way cloth, eye contact, and pauses shape identity. Further reading can start with Butler’s Gender Trouble, Connell’s Masculinities, and films such as Abdellatif Kechiche’s Blue Is the Warmest Colour from 2013. Each offers additional angles on how masculinity and desire intersect on screen.

Bibliography

Butler, Judith. Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. Routledge, 1990.

Connell, Raewyn. Masculinities. University of California Press, 1995.

Sedgwick, Eve Kosofsky. Epistemology of the Closet. University of California Press, 1990.

Mulvey, Laura. “Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema.” Screen, vol. 16, no. 3, 1975.

Touzani, Maryam, director. The Blue Caftan. Barney Production, 2022.

Van Sant, Gus, director. Milk. Focus Features, 2008.

Guadagnino, Luca, director. Call Me by Your Name. Sony Pictures Classics, 2017.

Ayouch, Nabil, director. Much Loved. Strand Releasing, 2015.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289