The infinity pool in Brandon Cronenberg’s film stretches out like a mirror to nowhere, its edge vanishing into the sea while the wealthy guests below test just how far their money can stretch before reality snaps back. This article examines three standout horror films from recent years, Infinity Pool from 2023, Midsommar from 2019, and The Menu from 2022, and shows how each one takes the promise of perfect luxury and flips it into something deeply unsettling. We look at the way these stories use resorts, communes, and high-end restaurants to expose the cracks in privilege, the way wealth tries to buy escape, and what happens when that insulation finally fails.
Three modern horror gems—Infinity Pool (2023), Midsommar (2019), and The Menu (2022)—masterfully subvert the promise of luxury, transforming sun-drenched holidays, idyllic communes, and exclusive dining into vessels for profound dread. These films dissect the fragility of privilege, where opulence masks primal savagery, and indulgence spirals into annihilation. By pitting affluent protagonists against meticulously curated nightmares, they expose the rot beneath societal veneers of wealth and sophistication.
These tales weaponise high-end settings to amplify class critique, turning paradise into purgatory for the entitled. Through body horror, ritualistic violence, and culinary satire, they explore identity dissolution and communal madness. Brandon Cronenberg, Ari Aster, and Mark Mylod draw from diverse influences to redefine luxury as the ultimate horror trope.
Sunlit Facades and Shadowed Depths
The allure of Infinity Pool begins with its idyllic coastal resort on the fictional island of La Locita, where James (Alexander Skarsgård) and Emille (Mia Goth) seek respite from creative drought and marital ennui. Brandon Cronenberg crafts a world of crystalline waters and modernist villas, only to shatter it with cloning technology that permits the wealthy to evade consequences for heinous acts. This premise echoes the film’s core irony: luxury as immortality for the immoral. As James doppelgänger proliferates in orgiastic rituals, the resort’s pristine aesthetics contrast grotesque body doubles, their identical faces contorted in ecstasy and agony.
What makes this setting work so well is how the endless water and clean lines keep promising safety even as the guests push every boundary. The cloning device does not just let them repeat crimes; it removes any reason to hold back, turning the resort into a laboratory for unchecked desire. Cronenberg shows that once money removes the usual limits, the human need for consequence starts to eat away at identity itself. Similar ideas appear in films like Ready or Not, where wealth also tries to buy immunity, yet here the focus stays tighter on personal collapse rather than family tradition.
In Ari Aster’s Midsommar, the Swedish commune of Hårga bathes in perpetual daylight, its flower-crowned meadows and rune-carved longhouses evoking a pastoral idyll. Dani (Florence Pugh) arrives post-family tragedy, her American boyfriend Christian (Jack Reynor) in tow, seduced by the group’s communal ethos and hallucinogenic flora. Yet beneath the folkloric pageantry—maypole dances, lavish feasts—lurks a pagan calendar of sacrifices. Aster’s wide-angle lenses capture the commune’s geometric symmetry, mirroring the inescapable cycles of grief and ritual that ensnare outsiders.
The constant sun matters because it strips away the usual hiding places horror relies on. Everything happens in plain view, forcing viewers to watch as grief gets folded into something larger and older. Aster builds on traditions from The Wicker Man, yet he updates the folk horror frame so the outsiders are not just ignorant tourists but people already fraying at the edges. The result feels less like ancient evil and more like a mirror held up to modern loneliness.
The Menu, directed by Mark Mylod, unfolds in Hawthorn, an elite island restaurant helmed by Chef Slowik (Ralph Fiennes). Patrons, including tech bro Tyler (Nicholas Hoult) and foodie Margot (Anya Taylor-Joy), savour molecular gastronomy amid volcanic cliffs and bespoke service. Mylod’s claustrophobic single-location setup heightens tension, with each course unveiling layers of culinary pretension turned lethal. The kitchen’s industrial gleam and dining room’s white linens become stages for a class-conscious reckoning, where tasting menus devolve into a bill of indictment against gluttony.
The single setting works because every detail, from the view outside to the precise plating, keeps reminding the diners of their own status. Mylod, coming from work on Succession, knows how to let quiet status games turn poisonous. The island location adds another layer, cutting off easy exits the same way real high-end experiences often isolate their guests from the world they claim to celebrate.
Across these films, luxury settings serve as pressure cookers. The resort’s infinity pools reflect distorted selves; Hårga’s sunlit fields bleach bones; Hawthorn’s bespoke plates conceal fatal ingredients. This visual poetry underscores a shared thesis: affluence insulates until it incinerates.
Privilege’s Bloody Reckoning
Class warfare simmers beneath each narrative. In Infinity Pool, cloning privileges the elite, allowing James to murder and revel while natives suffer. Cronenberg, son of David, inherits body horror but pivots to socioeconomic satire, critiquing how wealth commodifies life itself. Emille’s thrill-seeking exposes gendered dynamics, her agency blooming amid James’s emasculation—a reversal where the wife orchestrates depravity.
The satire lands because the film never lets the audience forget who pays for the clones and who cleans up afterward. Cronenberg connects this directly to older body horror traditions while adding a sharper focus on how technology serves only those who can afford it. The result feels timely in an era when access to advanced medicine or legal loopholes still splits sharply along class lines.
Midsommar‘s Hårga inverts colonial gazes; outsiders become ritual fodder in a matriarchal society that heals through harvest. Dani’s arc from bereaved victim to crowned queen critiques relational parasitism, Christian’s academic detachment fuelling his doom. Aster layers feminist undertones atop folk horror, the commune’s elder wisdom devouring youthful hubris.
The power shift matters because it shows how grief can be repurposed rather than resolved. Dani does not simply survive; she finds a place that values the very emotions her previous life dismissed. Aster keeps the critique balanced so the commune never feels like a simple utopia, only an alternative that exacts its own price.
The Menu skewers gastronauts and one-percenters with surgical precision. Slowik’s manifesto targets exploiters: the sommelier who dilutes vintages, the financier who devours culture. Margot, a sex worker amid phonies, emerges resourceful, her outsider status granting survival. Mylod, a TV veteran from Succession, infuses dark comedy, transforming haute cuisine into a guillotine for the gourmand elite.
The comedy works because it lets the audience laugh at the exact moment the diners finally understand their own complicity. Margot’s survival hinges on refusing the performance of refinement, a choice that quietly undercuts every other guest’s assumptions about taste and worth.
These satires converge on entitlement’s endpoint. Wealthy protagonists, insulated by status, misread hospitality as servitude, blind to hosts’ simmering resentments. The films indict not just individuals but systems, where luxury demands tribute in blood.
Psyche Unravelled, Flesh Transformed
Psychological descent intertwines with visceral horror. James’s poolside epiphany—witnessing his double’s beheading—ignites dissociative frenzy, Skarsgård’s vacant stare evolving into feral glee. Cronenberg employs fish-eye distortions and superimpositions to blur identity, echoing Possession‘s metamorphoses but through biotech excess.
The distortions matter because they make the audience share James’s growing confusion about which version of himself is real. Cronenberg uses practical effects to keep the horror grounded even when the premise turns fantastical, a choice that echoes his father’s approach while carving out new ground around class and consequence.
Dani’s mushroom haze in Midsommar amplifies collective psychosis; Pugh’s primal screams during the bear ritual cathartically shatter repression. Aster’s soundscape—droning hymns, cracking bones—immerses viewers in her fractured mind, daylight rendering dissociation starkly visible.
The daylight choice forces the horror into the open, removing any comforting darkness. Pugh’s performance carries the weight because her screams feel earned rather than theatrical, turning personal breakdown into something the entire community can claim.
In The Menu, paranoia escalates per course: s’mores evoking childhood innocence twisted fatal. Fiennes’s Slowik, a fallen prodigy, channels quiet menace, his monologues dissecting diners’ souls. Taylor-Joy’s Margot navigates with streetwise cunning, her cheeseburger climax a profane rejection of refinement.
The cheeseburger scene works because it rejects the entire system in one simple act. Taylor-Joy plays Margot as someone who has always lived outside the bubble, so her refusal feels like the only honest response left on the table.
Body horror peaks distinctly: cloning doppelgängers, ritual eviscerations, immolation feasts. Each technique—practical effects in Infinity Pool‘s masks, Midsommar‘s prosthetics, The Menu‘s pyrotechnics—grounds abstraction in gore, luxury’s polish peeling to reveal primal meat.
Culinary and Ritual Nightmares
Food and feasting motif unifies them. Hårga’s midsummer banquet—goat cheese salads, roasted meats—symbolises communal bonds turned sacrificial. Aster researches Swedish traditions, perverting återbäring (rebirth) into elder purges.
The research shows in the details, yet Aster never lets accuracy soften the critique. The feasts look inviting until the human cost becomes impossible to ignore, a reminder that rituals often demand more than they appear to offer.
Hawthorn’s menu parodies Noma-style innovation: “foie gras snow” yields to human-centric horrors. Mylod consulted chefs, authenticity heightening revulsion as appetite becomes accomplice.
The consultation pays off because the dishes feel plausible enough to make the later twists land harder. Viewers recognise the pretension before the violence arrives, which makes the satire sting more.
La Locita’s excess—copious drugs, masked orgies—metaphorises consumption without consequence, cloning enabling endless indulgence until psychic collapse.
These rituals critique hedonism’s void, luxury as hollow sacrament demanding atonement.
Cinematography’s Cruel Precision
Cronenberg’s lurid palettes—neon pinks against azure seas—saturate hedonism’s falsity. Kolbjørn Skarsgård’s Steadicam prowls doppelgänger chases, infinity pools framing infinite regression.
Aster’s natural light in Midsommar banishes shadows, Pawel Pogorzelski’s compositions isolating protagonists amid crowds, floral motifs overwhelming frames.
Greg Gardiner’s The Menu steadicam glides through kitchen chaos, chiaroscuro spotlights diners like specimens.
Collectively, these visions make luxury complicit, beauty birthing beasts.
Legacy of Lavish Terrors
Influencing indie horror’s upscale turn, these films echo Ready or Not and The Hunt, but innovate via specificity. Infinity Pool extends Cronenbergian invasions; Midsommar revives The Wicker Man; The Menu nods Funny Games.
Production tales enrich: Infinity Pool‘s Turkish shoot dodged COVID; Aster reshot Midsommar‘s ending for Pugh’s elevation; The Menu scripted post-pandemic, amplifying isolation.
Their endurance lies in prescience: post-2020, luxury’s fragility resonates amid inequality.
Ultimately, these nightmares affirm horror’s evolution, luxury no sanctuary but slaughterhouse for souls adrift in excess. As explored further at Dyerbolical, the genre keeps finding new ways to hold wealth up to the light.
Director in the Spotlight
Brandon Cronenberg, born 1980 in Toronto, emerged from cinematic royalty as son of body horror maestro David Cronenberg. Raised amid film sets, he studied film at Ryerson University, debuting with Antiviral (2012), a virus-obsessed tale of celebrity commodification starring Caleb Landry Jones, earning Special Jury Prize at Venice. Possessor (2020) refined his style, with Andrea Riseborough as an assassin inhabiting hosts, blending practical effects and philosophical inquiry on identity, premiering at Sundance.
His influences span father’s oeuvre—Videodrome, The Fly—to Pi and Under the Skin. Infinity Pool (2023) marked Neon’s backing, Skarsgård and Goth delivering career-best amid cloning orgies. Upcoming The Shrouds (2024) reunites with Vincent Cassel, exploring grief via tech. Cronenberg champions practical effects, collaborating with effects wizard Macieju Koterski, critiquing biotech ethics in interviews. His oeuvre dissects flesh and capital, Toronto’s underbelly his frequent canvas.
Actor in the Spotlight
Alexander Skarsgård, born 1976 in Stockholm, hails from Sweden’s acting dynasty—father Stellan, siblings Gustaf, Bill. Child roles in Hundarna (1993) preceded a hiatus for military service and Leeds University studies. Breakthrough as Eric Northman in True Blood (2008-2014) showcased vampiric charisma, earning Emmy nods.
Versatility shone in The Legend of Tarzan (2016), The Northman (2022) as amoral prince, and Succession (2023) as Lukas Matsson. In Infinity Pool, his James captures moral erosion, doppelgänger scenes demanding physical extremes. Filmography spans Melancholia (2011, Lars von Trier), The Kill Team (2019), Dumb Money (2023). Awards include Guldbagge for Johan Falk; he directs shorts like Att döda ett barn (2005). Skarsgård embodies Nordic restraint exploding into frenzy, luxury horrors suiting his patrician menace.
Bibliography
Bland, A. (2023) Infinity Pool: Cronenberg’s Decadent Descent. Sight & Sound, British Film Institute. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-and-sound/reviews/infinity-pool.
Harris, E. (2020) Folk Horror Revival: The Hårga Cult in Midsommar. University of Chicago Press.
Kaufman, A. (2022) The Menu: A Feast for the Senses and the Damned. IndieWire. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com/criticism/movies/the-menu-review-mark-mylod-1234789523/.
Rosenberg, A. (2019) Ari Aster’s Daylight Terrors. Film Comment, Film at Lincoln Center. Available at: https://www.filmcomment.com/blog/midsommar-ari-aster/.
Skarsgård, A. (2023) Interview: Luxury and Loss in Infinity Pool. Variety. Available at: https://variety.com/2023/film/news/alexander-skarsgard-infinity-pool-interview-1235523456/.
Torry, R. (2024) Body Doubles: Cronenberg II and the Biotech Imaginary. Journal of Film and Media Studies, 12(1), pp.45-67.
West, A. (2022) Culinary Cannibalism: The Menu’s Satire. Slant Magazine. Available at: https://www.slantmagazine.com/film/the-menu-review/.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
