In the final moments of one film a Christian policeman faces flames inside a towering effigy, while in the other a grieving man stands before an antlered shape that seems older than any god. These images linger because they tap into something older than cinema itself. This article compares Robin Hardy’s The Wicker Man from 1973 with David Bruckner’s The Ritual from 2017, two films that sit at opposite ends of folk horror yet share the same uneasy questions about belief, outsiders and the land that refuses to stay silent.
Summerisle’s Song and Sweden’s Silence: Setting the Folk Horror Stage
The remote Hebridean island of Summerisle in The Wicker Man bursts forth as a verdant paradise laced with menace, its inhabitants devoted to a pre-Christian fertility cult that mocks the visiting policeman Sergeant Howie. Robin Hardy crafts a world where maypoles twirl and phallic symbols abound, every song and dance a veiled incantation. This sunlit idyll, scored by Paul Giovanni’s lilting folk tunes, lures Howie and the audience into complacency before the horror reveals its thorns. The film’s production history adds intrigue: funded by British Lion Films with backing from Christopher Lee, it faced censorship cuts upon release, yet its restoration unveiled the full, unexpurgated pagan revelry.
In stark opposition, The Ritual plunges four friends into the interminable forests of northern Sweden, a landscape of perpetual twilight and oppressive conifers that Adam Nevill’s source novel evokes with claustrophobic precision. Director David Bruckner, adapting Nevill’s 2011 book, employs long takes and natural lighting to make the woods a character unto themselves, endless, indifferent, alive with unseen malice. Bereaved hiker Luke (Rafe Spall) leads the trek in atonement for past cowardice, their intrusion punished by glimpses of a towering, antlered entity rooted in Norse Jötunn lore. Where Summerisle sings, Sweden’s woods brood in silence, broken only by guttural runes and distant howls.
Both films weaponise landscape as antagonist, drawing from folk horror’s core tenets: the skewed rural community or wilderness that harbours ancient forces. Hardy invokes Celtic myths of green gods, while Bruckner taps Scandinavian sagas, yet both underscore the folly of modern rationalism venturing into primal domains. Howie’s Christian piety crumbles against Summerisle’s earthy hedonism; Luke’s urban ennui fractures under mythic assault. These settings are not mere backdrops but crucibles, forging terror from cultural displacement. You can see the same impulse in later works such as Midsommar, where daylight rituals again strip away any sense of safety, yet The Wicker Man remains the blueprint because it first made the countryside feel like a trap that smiles while it closes.
The Outsider’s Fall: Protagonists Adrift in Mythic Currents
Edward Woodward’s Sergeant Howie embodies the ultimate intruder, a devout Baptist whose virginity and authority blind him to Summerisle’s subversive charms. His arc traces a classical tragic fall: arriving to investigate a missing girl, he uncovers a conspiracy of ritual murder masked as communal harmony. Woodward’s performance, taut with repressed fury, peaks in the film’s harrowing climax atop the wicker effigy, a human sacrifice to appease the gods. Hardy’s script, penned by Anthony Shaffer, positions Howie as a Puritan foil to Lord Summerisle’s (Christopher Lee) aristocratic paganism, their debates crackling with philosophical fire.
Luke in The Ritual, portrayed with haunted intensity by Rafe Spall, grapples with guilt over his friend’s death in a pub brawl he failed to halt. The hike becomes penance, but hallucinations, visions of domestic failure intertwined with the creature’s gaze, erode his sanity. Spall conveys this through subtle physicality: slumped shoulders, averted eyes, a voice cracking under strain. Bruckner’s direction amplifies internal horror, blending creature sightings with flashbacks to forge a portrait of toxic masculinity unravelling. Unlike Howie’s ideological clash, Luke’s is personal, the woods manifesting his subconscious demons.
These protagonists mirror folk horror’s outsider archetype, their civilised values eroded by communal or chthonic forces. Howie rejects Summerisle’s songs as devilry; Luke dismisses runes as superstition. Yet both succumb, highlighting the genre’s fascination with belief’s fragility. Performances elevate this: Woodward’s operatic descent versus Spall’s naturalistic breakdown, each tailored to era, 1970s theatricality meets 2010s grit. The contrast matters because it shows how the same archetype adapts to different decades without losing its power to unsettle.
Sacrificial Flames: Themes of Faith, Guilt, and Renewal
At their core, both films dissect sacrifice as renewal’s brutal price. Summerisle’s lord orchestrates Howie’s immolation to revive barren orchards, invoking Frazer’s Golden Bough with apples rotting on cues. This pagan calculus, one life for the harvest, satirises religious zealotry, flipping Christian martyrdom on its head. Hardy’s film, born from 1970s folk revival and sexual liberation, critiques institutional faith while romanticising earthy rites, though feminist readings note the gendered exploitation in Britt Ekland’s seductive Willow.
The Ritual internalises sacrifice: the cult worships a modern god of suffering, demanding subservience through visions of loss. Luke’s temptation to join echoes Howie’s entrapment, but redemption lies in defiance, torching the creature’s shrine. Nevill’s novel, steeped in grief literature, posits the woods as therapist and tormentor, forcing confrontation with unresolved trauma. Bruckner expands this to critique male bonding rituals, the friends’ banter masking emotional voids exploited by the mythic.
Class and modernity thread both: Howie as imperial policeman versus island feudalism; urban Brits adrift in egalitarian Scandinavia. Gender dynamics simmer, women as sirens or silent sufferers, while ecology lurks, nature reclaiming human hubris. These themes resonate across decades, from post-Christian Britain to secular Europe’s pagan resurgence. What connects them is the simple recognition that old beliefs never truly vanish; they simply wait for the right moment to demand payment again.
Soundscapes of the uncanny: Music as Malevolent Force
Paul Giovanni’s soundtrack in The Wicker Man weaves folk ballads like Sumer Is Icumen In into a hypnotic tapestry, communal singing masking ritual intent. Magnet’s Gently Johnny seduces with innuendo, its flute and percussion evoking fertility dances. Sound design layers village noises, hammering, chanting, into a symphony of unease, culminating in Howie’s screams amid crackling flames. This auditory paganism immerses viewers, blurring diegetic and score.
Conversely, The Ritual’s soundscape is minimalist menace: wind through pines, snapping twigs, Spall’s ragged breaths. Ben Frost’s score erupts in dissonant strings and choral drones during creature reveals, mimicking Norse throat-singing. Hallucinatory whispers, you coward, personalise dread, the sound mix favouring sub-bass rumbles for visceral impact. Bruckner’s choices heighten isolation, sound as sparse as the landscape.
Together, they exemplify folk horror’s sonic palette: celebratory in Hardy, oppressive in Bruckner, both deploying music to summon the uncanny valley of the familiar gone wrong. The difference in approach reveals how each era hears dread differently, one through communal song, the other through the absence of any human sound at all.
Beasts from Myth: Special Effects and the Monstrous Sublime
The Wicker Man shuns monsters for human horror, its wicker man effigy a practical marvel constructed from wooden frames and thatch, burned in a real blaze off Scotland’s coast. Effects are theatrical: animal props in rituals nod to blood sacrifice without gore, Hardy relying on suggestion and Edward Woodward’s contortions. Influences from Hammer Films’ Gothic excess infuse this restraint, prioritising psychological over visceral shocks.
The Ritual unleashes a CGI-augmented Jötunn: a gangly, antlered giant with decayed flesh and multiple limbs, its design by creature artist Glenn Melenhorst blending Norse myth with H.R. Giger-esque biomechanics. Practical elements ground it, silhouettes in fog, forced perspective, while motion-capture lends eerie gait. Bruckner’s hybrid approach, informed by The Blair Witch Project’s found-footage legacy, makes the beast a sublime terror, glimpsed yet omnipresent.
Effects evolution mirrors genre shifts: analog ritual to digital abomination, both evoking awe and revulsion at nature’s warped forms. The practical wicker structure still feels more immediate because it was actually set alight, while the digital creature gains power from being kept mostly hidden, a choice that respects the original power of suggestion.
From Cult Classic to Streaming Spectre: Legacies in the Woods
The Wicker Man’s original cut languished until championed by fans, spawning a 2006 remake (derided) and 2011 sequel. Its influence permeates Midsommar and Kill List, codifying folk horror’s unholy trinity: isolation, inversion, implosion. Critiques of 1970s eco-paganism persist, yet its joy in horror endures.
The Ritual, Netflix’s sleeper hit, revitalised the subgenre post-Midsommar, inspiring hikes-as-horror like In the Earth. Nevill’s novel gained new readers, Bruckner’s vision proving streaming’s folk potential. Both films endure, warning of woods’ watchful eyes. Their combined reach shows how folk horror keeps finding new audiences whenever modern life starts to feel too thin and disconnected from the ground beneath our feet.
Director in the Spotlight: Robin Hardy
Robin Hardy, born in 1929 in Surrey, England, emerged from a privileged background, son of a civil engineer and educated at Rugby School, before studying at Oxford, where he directed plays blending classical drama with experimental flair. Post-graduation, he honed his craft in theatre and television, contributing to BBC series like Out of the Unknown (1965), adapting sci-fi with atmospheric dread. Influences ranged from Powell and Pressburger’s romanticism to Bergman’s spiritual inquiries, shaping his fascination with myth and morality.
Hardy’s feature debut, The Wicker Man (1973), became his masterpiece, a low-budget triumph blending musical, horror, and satire that faced studio mutilation but achieved cult status. He followed with The Fantasist (1986), a psychological thriller starring Moira Harris about erotic hauntings in Ireland, praised for its brooding visuals. The Wicker Tree (2011), his Wicker Man sequel, revisited pagan themes with American protagonists in Scotland, critiqued for lacking the original’s spark yet admired for ambition.
Throughout, Hardy directed documentaries like Land of Giants (1986) on Scottish folklore and commercials, maintaining a maverick ethos. Knighted for services to film? No, but revered in horror circles, he passed in 2016, leaving a legacy of esoteric cinema. Filmography highlights: The Wicker Man (1973, folk horror cornerstone), The Fantasist (1986, erotic ghost story), The Wicker Tree (2011, pagan sequel), alongside TV works like School for Vandals (1966) and shorts such as One Way Pendulum (experimental satire).
Actor in the Spotlight: Rafe Spall
Rafe Spall, born March 10, 1983, in East London to actor Timothy Spall and Shane Baker, grew up immersed in performance, attending Haberdashers’ Aske’s school before training at the National Youth Theatre. Dropping out of drama school, he debuted professionally in BBC’s The Shadow Line (2011) but broke through with films. His everyman vulnerability, honed in theatre like Pleasure Land (2010), suits complex roles blending pathos and rage.
Spall’s horror turn in The Ritual (2017) showcases raw emotional depth as grieving Luke, earning acclaim for physical transformation amid creature terror. Earlier, Prometheus (2012) as Millburn pitted him against xenomorphs, while Life of Pi (2012) displayed dramatic range. TV triumphs include Apple Tree Yard (2017, Bafta-nominated adulterous thriller) and Trying (2020-, adoptive father comedy).
Awards elude a full sweep, but nominations affirm versatility. Filmography: I Give It a Year (2013, rom-com), Frank (2014, quirky musician), Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom (2018, mercenary), The Salisbury Poisonings (2020, true-crime lead), His Dark Materials (2019-, TV fantasy), Why Didn’t They Ask Evans? (2022, Agatha Christie adaptation). Spall continues thriving in genre and drama, a modern British staple.
Craving more unearthly chills? Dive deeper into NecroTimes for the darkest corners of horror cinema.
Bibliography
Scovell, A. (2017) Folk Horror: Hours Dreadful and Things Strange. London: Headpress.
Nevill, A. (2011) The Ritual. London: Pan Macmillan.
Hardy, R. and Petley, J. (2013) The Wicker Man. London: BFI Publishing.
Jones, A. (2020) ‘Folk Horror Revival: The Ritual and Modern Myth-Mongering’, Sight & Sound, 30(5), pp. 45-49. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-sound (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Harper, J. (2019) ‘Pagan Rhythms: Sound in The Wicker Man’, Film Quarterly, 72(4), pp. 22-30.
Bruckner, D. (2018) Interview: ‘Crafting the Jötunn’, Fangoria, Issue 52. Available at: https://fangoria.com (Accessed: 20 October 2023).
Frazer, J.G. (1890) The Golden Bough. London: Macmillan.
McCabe, B. (2021) Woodland Demons: Folk Horror in Contemporary Cinema. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
