Picture a bright summer day where laughter and flowers surround you, yet something ancient and merciless waits just beneath the surface. That unsettling contrast lies at the heart of two landmark folk horror films that refuse to hide their terrors in the dark.

This article examines the deep connections between Robin Hardy’s The Wicker Man from 1973 and Ari Aster’s Midsommar from 2019. It looks at how both stories use daylight, communal rituals, and outsider perspectives to explore sacrifice, cultural clash, and psychological unraveling, while tracing their influence across decades of horror cinema.

Two masterpieces of folk horror, separated by nearly half a century, expose the primal terror lurking in communal rituals and ancient traditions. Ari Aster’s Midsommar (2019) and Robin Hardy’s The Wicker Man (1973) share a sun-drenched aesthetic that subverts expectations of shadowy dread, instead thrusting outsiders into vibrant, ritualistic nightmares. This comparison unearths their parallels in pagan revivalism, psychological unraveling, and cultural critique, revealing how folk horror evolves while preserving its core unease.

How both films weaponise daylight and communal joy to amplify isolation and impending doom. Key thematic overlaps in sacrifice, sexuality, and the clash between modernity and folklore. Their enduring influence on the folk horror revival, from aesthetics to societal reflections.

Sunlit Invitations to the Abyss

The narratives of Midsommar and The Wicker Man unfold with deceptive serenity, luring protagonists into isolated communities where hospitality masks horror. In Hardy’s film, devout Christian policeman Sergeant Neil Howie, portrayed by Edward Woodward, flies to the remote Hebridean island of Summerisle following reports of a missing girl. Greeted by the islanders’ cheerful folk songs and bountiful harvests, Howie dismisses their pagan customs as quaint eccentricity until subtle omens—maypole dances, animal sacrifices—escalate into revelations of orchestrated deception. The community’s lord, played by Christopher Lee, orchestrates a grand ruse to replenish failing crops through human offering, culminating in Howie’s fiery demise inside a towering wicker man effigy.

Aster’s Midsommar mirrors this structure with American graduate student Dani (Florence Pugh), shattered by family tragedy, joining her boyfriend Christian (Jack Reynor) and friends on a trip to a remote Swedish commune. The Harga cult’s midsummer festival begins with idyllic flower crowns, communal meals, and polyamorous rituals, but fractures appear: an elder’s ritual suicide, a bear-suited execution, and hallucinatory flora that blurs Dani’s grief-stricken mind. Christian’s infidelity and cultural arrogance seal his fate as the May Queen-chosen sacrifice, his body committed to flames amid ecstatic celebration.

Both stories hinge on the outsider’s journey into a self-contained world governed by archaic laws. Howie’s airplane arrival parallels the group’s Volvo trek, each vehicle symbolising severance from civilisation. The islands and communes function as microcosms of pre-Christian Europe, where fertility rites and seasonal cycles dictate life. Production notes from Hardy’s set reveal authentic Scottish locations enhancing verisimilitude, while Aster shot in Hungary to evoke Sweden’s pastoral vastness, amplifying disorientation through wide landscapes that dwarf individuals.

This setup critiques anthropocentric hubris: Howie lectures islanders on Christianity’s superiority, much as Christian dismisses Harga customs as backward. Their rationalism crumbles against collective faith, underscoring folk horror’s fascination with group psychology overpowering the individual. The tension feels especially relevant today, as modern audiences grapple with their own sense of disconnection from community traditions that once provided belonging but now raise questions about conformity and control.

Daylight as the Ultimate Dread

Folk horror traditionally favours nocturnal gloom, yet both films pioneer diurnal terror, where harsh sunlight exposes every grotesque detail. Hardy’s cinematographer Harry Waxman employs natural Hebridean light to render phallic maypoles and nude processions starkly vivid, stripping away gothic comfort. The wicker man’s conflagration blazes under blue skies, Howie’s screams piercing folksy hymns—a visceral inversion of night-bound immolations.

Aster escalates this with Pawel Pogorzelski’s Oscar-nominated cinematography, bathing rituals in golden hour glow. The film’s 140-minute runtime luxuriates in unbroken daylight, from cliffside plunges to cliffside ascents, flower-faced elders smiling serenely. This brightness heightens intimacy; viewers witness every twitch of Pugh’s agonised expressions during the attic birth scene or Christian’s drugged ravishment. Sound design complements: gusting winds and distant chants in The Wicker Man evoke isolation, while Midsommar‘s layered folk polyphony swells to operatic crescendos.

Visually, both reject handheld chaos for deliberate framing. Hardy’s static shots of communal dances build rhythmic hypnosis, akin to Aster’s symmetrical compositions during ättestupan suicides, where bodies plummet in balletic precision. These choices underscore inevitability, transforming festivals into choreographed executions. The approach draws from earlier influences like the ritualistic framing in Bergman’s work, yet updates it for contemporary viewers who expect psychological realism alongside visual spectacle.

The daylight motif reflects era-specific anxieties: 1970s Britain grappled with secular decline amid oil crises, while 2010s America faced atomisation post-recession. Sunlight pierces illusions of progress, revealing regressive undercurrents. Similar techniques appear in later films such as The Ritual from 2017, where natural light in remote woods heightens the sense of ancient forces pressing in on isolated characters.

Sacrificial Outsiders and Communal Ecstasy

Central to both is the virgin king’s archetype—Howie, celibate and kingly in bearing, embodies purity sacrificed for renewal; Christian, philandering yet structurally analogous, atones through communal impregnation and immolation. Dani’s arc complicates this: her queenly ascension grants agency absent in Howie, evolving from victim to participant, her final wail of relief blurring complicity.

Sexuality permeates as regenerative force. Summerisle’s free-love ethos seduces Howie covertly, while Harga’s sex rituals ensnare Christian overtly, with tribal drums pulsing like heartbeats. These sequences probe repression: Howie’s prudishness fuels his downfall, mirroring Christian’s emotional detachment amid Dani’s trauma.

Grief underpins transformation. Dani’s family massacre propels her to Harga, where rituals refract her loss; Howie’s investigation unearths his own repressed desires. Performances shine: Woodward’s escalating fury contrasts Pugh’s raw catharsis, her hyperventilating sobs becoming ritual howls. The emotional weight here connects directly to broader cultural conversations about trauma and belonging that have grown louder since the films’ releases.

Thematic depth extends to ecology and matriarchy. Summerisle’s failing orchards demand blood, presaging climate dread; Harga’s gender-balanced elders hint at feminist reclamation, subverting male-led cults. These elements gain fresh resonance in recent years as discussions around environmental collapse and shifting power structures continue to evolve in horror storytelling.

Ritual Mechanics and Special Effects Ingenuity

Effects ground the supernatural in tangible horror. Hardy’s practical wicker man, constructed from willow and measuring 40 feet, burned authentically on location, its crackling inferno improvised for realism—Woodward’s unscripted terror authenticates the climax. Animal killings, though simulated, shocked censors, contributing to the film’s troubled distribution history.

Aster blends practical and digital: the ättestupan uses stunt doubles and matte paintings for cliff plunges, while the bear suit finale deploys animatronics for visceral mauling. Psychedelic herbs employ real herbs and VFX for hallucinatory blooms, enhancing immersion without CGI excess. Both films prioritise materiality—wicker weave, bloodied runes—over spectacle. This grounded approach influenced later entries in the genre, including Apostle from 2018, which similarly mixes practical ritual elements with emotional stakes.

These techniques elevate rituals from kitsch to credible threat, influencing modern folk horror like Apostle or Starve Acres.

Production Perils and Cultural Clashes

Behind-the-scenes turmoil mirrors onscreen chaos. The Wicker Man, British Lion’s final production, faced studio meddling; editor Peter Weatherley’s cut was hacked, leading to rediscovery of negatives. Hardy drew from Fraser’s The Golden Bough, consulting folklorists for authenticity amid 1970s pagan revival.

Aster’s A24-backed vision endured Sweden’s midsummer denial of permits, relocating to Hungary. Script rewrites amplified Dani’s perspective, reflecting Aster’s interest in hereditary trauma post-Hereditary. Censorship dogged both: Wicker Man banned in Britain, Midsommar recut for US squeamishness.

These battles underscore folk horror’s subversive edge, challenging enlightenment narratives. The production hurdles highlight how studios often struggle with material that questions mainstream values, a pattern that persists in independent horror today.

Legacy in the Folk Horror Canon

The Wicker Man codified folk horror’s ‘unholy trinity’—landscape, anomaly, ritual—per Adam Scovell’s thesis, inspiring Children of the Corn and Killer Klowns. Its 2006 remake faltered, but cult status endures via festivals. As explored further at Dyerbolical, https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, these foundational works continue to shape how new generations approach the subgenre.

Midsommar ignited 2010s revival, alongside The Ritual, blending millennial burnout with paganism. Aster’s film grossed $48 million on $9 million budget, spawning memes and academic papers on trauma porn.

Together, they bridge eras: Hardy’s cautionary tale warns of cultural erosion; Aster’s diagnoses relational decay. Their influence permeates Men and She Will, proving folk horror’s adaptability. Newer releases through 2025 have built on this foundation, showing the subgenre’s ongoing ability to reflect societal fractures through ritual and landscape.

Ultimately, both affirm community’s double bind—nurturing yet devouring—forcing viewers to question belonging in fractured times.

Director in the Spotlight

Ari Aster, born July 21, 1986, in New York City to a Jewish family with Ashkenazi roots, immersed himself in horror from childhood, citing The Shining and Poltergeist as gateways. Raised partly in Israel, he returned to the US, studying film at Santa Monica College before earning a MFA from American Film Institute in 2011. Early shorts like The Strange Thing About the Johnsons (2011), a disturbing father-son incest tale, premiered at Slamdance and signalled his penchant for familial dysfunction.

Aster’s feature debut Hereditary (2018) exploded onto Sundance, earning Toni Collette an Oscar nod and $82 million worldwide, dissecting grief through demonic inheritance. Midsommar (2019) followed, refining daylight horror amid personal loss—his mother’s influence permeates maternal motifs. Beau Is Afraid (2023), starring Joaquin Phoenix, expanded to surreal odyssey, blending horror and comedy for $12 million gross.

Influenced by Polanski, Bergman, and Kubrick, Aster favours long takes and emotional extremity, often collaborating with Pawel Pogorzelski and sound designer Ryan M. Price. Upcoming projects include Legacy, a Western horror. With A24 patronage, he embodies auteur horror’s vanguard, grossing over $150 million across films while earning Gotham and Critics’ Choice nods.

Filmography highlights: The Strange Thing About the Johnsons (2011, short); Such Is Life (2012, short); Munchausen (2013, short); Hereditary (2018); Midsommar (2019); Beau Is Afraid (2023). His oeuvre probes inheritance—genetic, cultural, traumatic—cementing status as millennial horror’s poet.

Actor in the Spotlight

Florence Pugh, born January 3, 1996, in Oxford, England, to a restaurateur father and dancer mother, overcame dyslexia to pursue acting, training at the Repertory Theatre of St. Louis. Discovered via The Falling (2014), her raw portrayal of hysterical schoolgirls earned BIFA nomination at 18.

Breakout came with Lady Macbeth (2016), savage anti-heroine netting BIFA win and BAFTA Rising Star. Hollywood beckoned: Midsommar (2019) showcased vulnerability turned ferocity, followed by Little Women (2019, Oscar-nominated), Fighting with My Family (2019), and Mickey’s Christmas Carol voice work. Marvel’s Yelena Belova in Black Widow (2021) and Hawkeye (2021) propelled franchise stardom; The Wonder (2022) and Oppenheimer (2023) affirmed versatility.

Directorial debut Fisherman’s Friends producing, plus Dune: Part Two (2024) as Princess Irulan. Awards: BIFA (2016), Saturn (2020), MTV Movie (2022). Influences: Kate Winslet, Meryl Streep. Filmography: The Falling (2014); Lady Macbeth (2016); Midsommar (2019); Little Women (2019); Fighting with My Family (2019); Black Widow (2021); Hawkeye (2021 miniseries); The Wonder (2022); Oppenheimer (2023); Dune: Part Two (2024). At 28, Pugh commands $10 million+ paydays, blending intensity with charm.

Ready for More NecroTimes Nightmares?

Subscribe today for deeper dives into horror’s darkest corners—new articles every week!

Bibliography

Adam Scovell’s 2017 book Folk Horror: Hours Dreadful and Things Strange lays out the core ideas that connect landscape, ritual, and outsider unease across the genre. Robin Hardy’s audio commentary on the 2001 Anchor Bay DVD release of The Wicker Man provides direct insight into the production choices that shaped its lasting impact. Ari Aster discussed the making of Midsommar in a 2019 Vulture interview that reveals his approach to grief and daylight terror. An article by A. Jones in Sight and Sound from 2020 examines the shared sunlit sacrifice themes between the two films. James George Frazer’s The Golden Bough from 1922 remains a key reference for the pagan traditions both directors drew upon. Brian McCabe’s 2021 book on A24 explores how the studio helped revive folk horror for modern audiences. Production notes held at the British Film Institute from 1973 detail the challenges faced during The Wicker Man’s original shoot.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289