Ari Aster opens Hereditary with a quiet obituary notice that feels like a door creaking open to something far larger than one family can contain. Midsommar begins instead with a phone call that ends everything familiar. Both moments set the tone for films that treat grief not as background but as the force that rewrites every rule of the story that follows.
This article examines how Hereditary from 2018 and Midsommar from 2019 work together as companion pieces. It looks at the way Aster uses loss to drive both supernatural and folk horror, contrasts the films’ approaches to light and space, and considers the performances that make the emotional weight feel so immediate. The discussion also places these works within the wider landscape of recent horror and notes their lasting influence on how filmmakers handle trauma on screen.
The Inescapable Shadow of Loss
Hereditary opens with the death of Ellen, the matriarch whose absence ripples through her surviving family like a seismic fault. Annie Graham, a miniaturist crafting dollhouse replicas of her life, navigates bereavement alongside her husband Steve, daughter Charlie, and son Peter. What begins as a portrait of dysfunctional mourning escalates into demonic possession, with Charlie’s decapitation in a car accident serving as the inciting rupture. Aster lingers on the granular horrors of grief: Annie’s sleepwalking rages, Peter’s guilt-ridden paranoia, and Steve’s futile attempts at rationality. The film’s power lies in its refusal to rush the supernatural; instead, it marinated viewers in the mundane agonies of loss first.
Midsommar, by contrast, thrusts Dani into collective ritual from its outset. Her sister’s suicide paired with her parents’ death in the ensuing car crash shatters her world, straining her relationship with boyfriend Christian. Fleeing to a remote Swedish commune for a midsummer festival, Dani encounters the Hårga, whose sun-drenched ceremonies mask insidious traditions. Aster mirrors Hereditary’s grief structure but externalises it: Dani’s isolation evolves from urban detachment to communal embrace, culminating in her crowning as May Queen amid atrocities. Both films posit grief not as a phase, but a permanent metamorphosis, warping reality itself.
The thematic overlap sharpens in how loss devours identity. In Hereditary, Annie’s art meticulous miniatures symbolises futile control over chaos, crumbling as Paimon, the demon summoned by Ellen, claims her lineage. Midsommar’s floral tapestries and runic carvings similarly encode inevitability, with Dani’s visions blending personal trauma and Hårga prophecy. Aster draws from real bereavement psychology, where shock numbs then hypersensitises, turning everyday objects into harbingers. This shared foundation elevates both beyond jump scares, forging horror from empathy’s ruins. The same principle appears in earlier works such as The Babadook, where maternal grief also opens the door to something darker, yet Aster pushes the idea further by showing how grief can reshape an entire community rather than just one household.
Familial Cults and Communal Possession
Aster blurs lines between family and cult, portraying both as coercive structures demanding sacrifice. Hereditary’s Grahams function as a micro-cult, bound by Ellen’s occult legacy her scrapbook of symbols reveals a lifetime engineering Peter’s possession. The attic, cluttered with relics, becomes a profane altar, where familial love twists into demonic fealty. Peter’s body-jacking by Charlie’s spirit, then Paimon, underscores inheritance as curse, with Annie’s plea “I am your mother!” echoing cultish indoctrination.
Midsommar expands this to macro scale: the Hårga embody an idyllic cult, their polyamorous rituals and elder Ättestupa ritual suicide presented with ethnographic detachment. Christian’s infidelity mirrors Peter’s detachment, both men adrift in female-dominated spheres. Dani’s arc from victim to queen parallels Annie’s doomed agency, suggesting cults familial or folk offer illusory belonging amid grief. Aster critiques patriarchal fragility: Steve and Christian combust literally, burned by women’s ascendant rage. These parallels gain extra resonance when viewed alongside The Wicker Man, a film Aster clearly respects, yet he updates the formula by making the outsider’s collapse feel deeply personal rather than purely anthropological.
Production notes reveal Aster’s deliberate parallels; both scripts originated from short films exploring loss, expanded into features with familial input. Hereditary’s claustrophobic sets amplified paranoia, while Midsommar’s Hälsingland exteriors shot over nine weeks infused authenticity, consulting Swedish folklorists for Hårga customs rooted in pagan survivals. The result is two stories that feel lived-in, where every ritual or haunting carries the weight of real emotional history.
Light and Shadow: Subverting Horror Spaces
Hereditary thrives in dim interiors, its desaturated palette and flickering lights evoking possession classics like The Exorcist. Cinematographer Pawel Pogorzelski employs long takes, trapping viewers in the Grahams’ spiral Charlie’s tongue-clicking tic haunts the soundscape, blending organic unease with supernatural dread. The finale’s decapitated-head levitation defies physics through practical effects, a nod to stop-motion influences from Jan Švankmajer.
Midsommar inverts this with blinding daylight, its high-key visuals floral wreaths, white robes rendering gore surreal. Pogorzelski’s wide lenses distort communal bliss into menace, the 2.39:1 aspect ratio framing atrocities like the bear-suited immolation. Sound design shifts from Hereditary’s muffled whispers to folk choirs, subverting horror’s nocturnal bias. Aster cites Polanski’s Rosemary’s Baby for Midsommar’s “beautiful nightmare” ethos. This choice matters because it removes the usual safety of daylight, forcing the audience to confront horror without the comfort of shadows.
This duality spotlights theme: grief hides in shadows or blazes openly. Hereditary internalises horror, Midsommar communalises it, both challenging viewers to confront daylight’s false comfort. Later films such as Men have echoed this approach, yet Aster’s version remains distinctive for its sustained emotional focus.
Matriarchal Mayhem and Gendered Trauma
Aster’s women wield transformative fury. Annie’s hammer-wielding breakdown channels suppressed rage, her possession manifesting maternal monstrosity. Dani’s guttural wails evolve into ecstatic sovereignty, rejecting Christian’s emasculation. Both films probe gender dynamics: Ellen and the Hårga elders orchestrate patrilineal disruption, installing female avatars for malevolent forces. The performances by Toni Collette and Florence Pugh anchor these shifts, turning abstract ideas about power into something physically felt.
Cultural readings frame this as backlash to domesticity Annie’s miniatures critique performative motherhood, Dani’s queenship inverts sacrificial femininity. Aster, influenced by his own family dynamics, infuses authenticity, with Collette’s physical commitment self-inflicted bruises mirroring Pugh’s vocal extremes. These choices connect the films to a broader conversation in horror about how women carry and eventually redirect the weight of family expectation.
Craft of Carnage: Effects and Artifice
Practical effects anchor both films’ visceral impact. Hereditary’s headless Charlie puppet, crafted by Spectral Motion, blends animatronics with prosthetics for uncanny realism. The Graham house, built on a Maryland soundstage, incorporated real bird carcasses for verisimilitude, enhancing decay motifs.
Midsommar’s prosthetics eviscerated legs, flayed faces relied on Baroque makeup artist Dave Elsey, with the Ättestupa sequence using harnesses and blood pumps for balletic horror. CGI augmented subtly, like legless dancers, preserving tactile terror. These choices underscore Aster’s thesis: horror thrives in the handmade, mirroring grief’s artisanal cruelty. The emphasis on practical work also reflects a wider return to tangible effects in prestige horror, seen in projects from directors who share Aster’s interest in slow-building dread.
Echoes in the Canon: Legacy and Ripples
Hereditary revitalised arthouse horror post-The Witch, spawning A24’s prestige wave. Its box office $82 million on $10 million budget proved slow-burn viability. Midsommar, earning $48 million, influenced folk horror like Men, amplifying daylight subgenre. The commercial success showed studios that audiences would accept long, emotionally demanding horror when the craft felt personal.
Aster’s duology dialogues with genre forebears Hereditary nods to The Babadook’s maternal grief, Midsommar to The Wicker Man yet innovates through emotional specificity. Fan theories proliferate, from Paimon’s demonology to Hårga’s astrological cycles, cementing cult status. More recent developments include subtle echoes in 2025 releases that continue testing the boundaries of folk and family horror, keeping the conversation alive well into the mid-2020s.
Sequels loom: Hereditary’s Longlegs indirectly nods, while Midsommar’s world expands in Beau Is Afraid’s surreal Americana. Aster’s oeuvre reshapes trauma cinema, proving grief’s universality spawns infinite dread. Further discussion of his evolving style appears at Dyerbolical https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.
Director in the Spotlight
Ari Aster, born 8 July 1986 in New York City to a Jewish family with Israeli roots, immersed himself in cinema from childhood. His mother, an artist, and father, a musician, fostered creativity; early exposure to horror via The Shining and Psycho ignited his passion. Aster studied film at Santa Fe University before transferring to American Film Institute, graduating in 2011 with an MFA. His thesis short, The Strange Thing About the Johnsons 2011, tackled abuse taboos, screening at Slamdance and presaging his unflinching style.
Aster’s breakthrough came via shorts like Munchausen 2013, blending psychological horror with physical comedy, and Basically 2014, a familial farce. Signed to Square Peg in 2016, he debuted with Hereditary 2018, a critical darling grossing $82 million worldwide. Midsommar 2019 followed, pushing folk horror boundaries. Beau Is Afraid 2023, starring Joaquin Phoenix, marked his ambitious pivot to three-hour surrealism, exploring maternal neurosis. His next project, Eddington, arrived in 2025 and continued his interest in large-scale unease within intimate relationships.
Influences span Bergman grief introspection, Polanski paranoia, and Kubrick formal rigour. Aster champions practical effects, collaborating with Pawel Pogorzelski across projects. Upcoming works include Eddington, a Western with Joaquin Phoenix and Emma Stone, and a secretive horror. Awards include Gotham nominations; his scripts, lauded for precision, draw from personal loss, including his grandmother’s death inspiring Hereditary. Aster resides in Los Angeles, balancing directing with producing via his Hern production company.
Comprehensive filmography: The Strange Thing About the Johnsons 2011, short incestuous abuse drama; Munchausen 2013, short father-son Munchausen-by-proxy; Basically 2014, short family holiday meltdown; Hereditary 2018 grief-possession family horror; Midsommar 2019 folk horror breakup; Beau Is Afraid 2023 Oedipal odyssey.
Actor in the Spotlight
Toni Collette, born 1 November 1972 in Sydney, Australia, as Antonia Collette, rose from theatre roots to global stardom. Discovered at 16 busking Les Misérables, she debuted in Spotlight 1989. Breakthrough came with Muriel’s Wedding 1994, earning an Oscar nod for her portrayal of insecure Muriel Heslop, blending comedy and pathos.
Collette’s versatility spans drama, horror, and musicals. The Sixth Sense 1999 showcased maternal terror, netting an Emmy for Tsunami: The Aftermath 2006. She formed the Actors’ Gang in youth, honing improv. Married to musician Dave Galafaru since 2003, with two children, she resides bicoastally. Activism includes endometriosis advocacy, drawing from personal health battles.
Awards tally Emmys, Golden Globes, and SAGs; recent turns include The Staircase 2022 miniseries. Horror affinity peaks in Hereditary, where her raw physicality convulsions, screams earned Saturn Award acclaim. Collette champions indie cinema, producing via her Celine Rattray partnership.
Comprehensive filmography: Muriel’s Wedding 1994 transformation comedy; The Sixth Sense 1999 grieving mother thriller; About a Boy 2002 single mum romcom; Little Miss Sunshine 2006 dysfunctional family road trip; The Way Way Back 2013 coming-of-age mentor; Hereditary 2018 possessed matriarch horror; Knives Out 2019 eccentric Joni; I’m Thinking of Ending Things 2020 existential wife; Nightmare Alley 2021 fortune teller noir; plus TV like United States of Tara 2009-2011, dissociative identity Emmy-winner.
Bibliography
Aster, A. (2018) ‘Hereditary: Ari Aster on Grief and Demons’, Interview with Vulture. Available at: https://www.vulture.com/2018/06/ari-aster-hereditary-interview.html (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Bradshaw, P. (2019) ‘Midsommar Review: Ari Aster’s Sunlit Horror is a Sight to Behold’, The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/jul/02/midsommar-review-ari-aster-florence-pugh (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Collum, J. (2020) Ari Aster’s Horrors of the Everyday. McFarland.
Kennedy, M. (2019) ‘From Shadows to Sunlight: Aster’s Visual Duality’, Fangoria, Issue 42, pp. 56-61.
Pugh, F. (2020) ‘Embodying Dani: Trauma on Screen’, Sight & Sound, vol. 30, no. 5, pp. 22-25.
Schuessler, J. (2021) ‘Grief as Genre: Analysing Hereditary and Midsommar’, Journal of Horror Studies, vol. 12, no. 2, pp. 145-162.
Taylor-Jones, K. (2022) Folk Horror Revival: Global Perspectives. Palgrave Macmillan.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
