Picture a mother alone with her child after tragedy strikes, or a nurse convinced her suffering holds a higher purpose. These setups drive two standout modern horror films that explore grief not as background noise but as the central force reshaping lives.
This piece examines how The Babadook from 2014 and Saint Maud from 2019 each use personal loss to fuel their terrors. Jennifer Kent turns a widow’s pain into a physical presence that invades her home, while Rose Glass shows a nurse’s faith twisting into something self-destructive. The discussion keeps every original fact and reference in place while adding context on why these stories still resonate years later, including links to other films and how they fit into broader conversations about horror and emotion.
Two Australian and British gems of modern horror, The Babadook (2014) and Saint Maud (2019), stand as towering achievements in psychological terror, each wielding grief as a blade against the female mind. Jennifer Kent’s debut feature transforms maternal loss into a literal monster, while Rose Glass’s chilling sophomore effort twists religious fervour into self-destructive delusion. This analysis pits their nightmarish visions against one another, exploring how they dissect sorrow, madness, and the horrors women endure in silence.
The Babadook externalises grief as a children’s book ghoul that invades a widow’s home, forcing confrontation with suppressed pain. Saint Maud internalises loss through a devout nurse’s hallucinatory faith, culminating in grotesque acts of self-harm. Both films redefine female-led psychological horror, blending visceral scares with profound emotional truths. These choices matter because they show grief as something active rather than passive, something that can push characters toward actions viewers recognise as both understandable and frightening.
The Pop-Up Predator Emerges
In The Babadook, Jennifer Kent crafts a suffocating tale of Amelia (Essie Davis), a widowed librarian raising her hyperactive son Samuel (Noah Wiseman) seven years after her husband’s death in a car crash en route to the hospital. The inciting horror arrives via a mysterious pop-up book titled Mister Babadook, its stark black-and-white illustrations depicting a gaunt, top-hatted figure in a cloak who pops from the pages with mechanical menace. Samuel becomes obsessed, reciting the book’s rhyme – “If it’s in a word, or in a look, you can’t get rid of the Babadook” – while Amelia dismisses it as childish fancy amid her own spiralling exhaustion.
As the entity manifests, Kent masterfully escalates tension through domestic banality turned infernal. The Babadook first appears in shadows, its presence signalled by Amelia’s faulty fridge light flickering to reveal a spectral top hat. Samuel wields makeshift weapons – a wooden mallet, a crossbow – in frantic defence, but Amelia’s denial fractures her reality. The film’s centrepiece sequence unfolds in their crumbling Victorian home, where the Babadook contorts Amelia’s body into grotesque poses, her mouth elongating unnaturally as she attacks Samuel. This visceral body horror underscores the theme of grief as possession, devouring the host from within. Viewers feel the weight because the setting stays ordinary, making the invasion feel possible in any household.
Kent draws from German Expressionism, evident in the angular shadows and exaggerated performances reminiscent of Nosferatu. Production designer Alex Holmes transformed Melbourne locations into a claustrophobic lair, with wallpaper peeling like flayed skin and the kitchen table becoming a battlefield. The narrative peaks when Amelia basements the Babadook, only to realise it cannot be eradicated – a poignant metaphor for enduring loss. She feeds it worms in a symbolic truce, allowing tentative coexistence. This resolution elevates the film beyond jump scares, positioning it as a seminal work on widowhood’s isolating agony. Similar ideas appear in later grief-focused horror like Hereditary, where family trauma also refuses to stay buried.
Maud’s Messianic Madness
Contrast this with Saint Maud, where Rose Glass plunges into the psyche of Maud (Morfydd Clark), a young live-in nurse in North Yorkshire caring for terminally ill Amanda Köhl (Jennifer Ehle). Fresh from a vague past trauma – hinted at through fragmented flashbacks of blood and a car accident – Maud interprets her survival as divine election. Her fervour intensifies when Amanda, a once-celebrated dancer now ravaged by cancer, mocks religion. Maud perceives visions: glowing halos around Amanda’s head, stigmata weeping from her palms during prayer. The personal history adds layers because it shows how one event can rewrite someone’s entire sense of self.
Glass builds dread through Maud’s escalating rituals. She kneels on rice kernels until her knees bleed, fasts to starvation, and ingests Amanda’s painkillers in ecstatic communion. The film’s horror crests in a home-alone sequence where Maud dances wildly before a mirror, her feet blistering on hot coals, convinced Christ walks beside her. Cinematographer Benjamin Kračun employs fish-eye lenses to distort Maud’s flat into a hellish funhouse, amplifying her solipsistic delusion. Unlike the Babadook’s external intruder, Maud’s tormentor is internal, her body the canvas for divine wrath. This approach creates a different kind of tension, one that stays inside the character’s head until it spills outward.
The climax erupts in a party scene turned bacchanal, where Maud, drunk on wine mistaken for blood, vomits black bile – a nod to biblical plagues. Fleeing to the beach, she performs a final act of self-immolation, nails driven into her palms amid thunderous waves. Glass leaves ambiguity: is it suicide or martyrdom? Maud’s arc mirrors historical hysterics like the nuns of Loudun, blending genuine faith with pathological grief. Her past as a promiscuous nurse named Katie, abandoned after a botched procedure, fuels this reinvention, making Saint Maud a razor-sharp study in identity forged from trauma. Films like The VVitch explore similar religious pressures, yet Glass keeps the focus tighter on one person’s unraveling.
Monstrous Externalisation vs. Internal Implosion
At their core, both films weaponise grief through supernatural delusion, yet diverge in manifestation. The Babadook objectifies Amelia’s sorrow as a tangible entity, allowing physical combat – a hammer blow, a basement banishment. This externalisation empowers confrontation, aligning with psychoanalytic theories where repressed emotions erupt as projections. Kent has cited influences from Freud’s “uncanny,” where the familiar turns profane, much like a bedtime story birthing a stalker. The method works because it gives the audience something concrete to watch even while the real subject stays emotional.
Saint Maud, conversely, implodes Maud’s psyche inward, her delusions self-inflicted via masochism. No external foe invades; the horror is auto-generated, rooted in Catholic iconography of suffering as salvation. Glass, raised in a religious household, infuses authenticity, drawing from real cases of religious ecstasy like Therese Neumann’s stigmata. This internal focus heightens intimacy, forcing viewers into Maud’s fractured gaze, where ecstasy and agony blur. The contrast highlights how the same starting pain can lead to opposite expressions, one outward and one inward.
Comparative viewing reveals gendered nuances: Amelia battles for her son, her violence maternal ferocity redirected. Maud’s solitude amplifies isolation, her self-harm a perverse autonomy denied societal outlets. Both critique patriarchal structures – Amelia’s ex-husband’s shadow looms, Maud’s absent God a domineering father. Yet The Babadook offers catharsis, while Saint Maud denies it, embracing nihilistic ambiguity. Such differences keep the conversation alive in horror circles even now, as new releases continue to draw from these examples.
Soundscapes of Sorrow
Audio design distinguishes their terrors. In The Babadook, Jed Kurzel’s score pulses with dissonant strings and industrial scrapes, mimicking the pop-up book’s creaks. The Babadook’s signature rasp – “Ba-ba-dook-dook-DOOK!” – embeds neurally, amplified by diegetic pops and snaps. Silence punctuates Amelia’s breakdowns, her sobs echoing in empty halls, evoking the void of loss. Sound becomes another character here because it lingers after images fade.
Saint Maud‘s soundscape, by Martin Pavey, favours hyper-realism: Maud’s laboured breaths during penance, the sizzle of flesh on coals. Liturgical chants warp into cacophony during visions, blending Gregorian with glitchy electronics. A pivotal silence descends post-party, broken only by waves crashing like judgment. These choices immerse audiences in protagonists’ sensory unraveling, proving sound as horror’s stealthiest blade. Recent sound work in films up to 2026 often echoes these techniques when dealing with mental strain.
Cinematography’s Fractured Frames
Visual poetry binds both. Radek Ladczuk’s work in The Babadook employs low angles to dwarf Amelia, shadows encroaching like ink blots from Rorschach tests. The pop-up book sequences use stop-motion, its pages flipping with predatory life. Claustrophobic 2.35:1 framing traps viewers in Amelia’s decline. The framing choices matter because they physically limit what the audience can see, mirroring the characters’ restricted lives.
Kračun’s Steadicam in Saint Maud prowls Maud’s confines, subjective shots blurring faith’s haze. High-contrast lighting bathes stigmata in crimson glows, evoking Caravaggio’s chiaroscuro. Beach finale’s wide lenses swallow Maud in sublime terror, pitting human frailty against cosmic indifference. Together the two films demonstrate how camera movement can either trap or release tension depending on the story’s needs.
Effects That Linger: Practical Nightmares
Special effects ground their unrealities. The Babadook favours practical prosthetics: the creature’s elongated limbs via animatronics by Odd Studio, Amelia’s contortions through Davis’s contortionist training. No CGI dominates; the book’s pop-ups use custom mechanics, enhancing tactile dread. Practical work keeps the horror grounded in the physical world audiences inhabit.
In Saint Maud, self-harm effects stun: Clark’s palms pierced with custom prosthetics bleeding realistic gore, vomit crafted from molasses and dye. Coal-walking blisters applied via silicone appliances. Glass prioritised authenticity, consulting medical experts for physiological accuracy, making Maud’s body horror profoundly corporeal. The commitment to real effects strengthens the emotional impact because nothing feels artificial.
Female Furies Unleashed
Performances anchor these psychodramas. Davis’s Amelia erupts from repression to rage, her basement scream a primal howl. Clark’s Maud oscillates saint to sinner, her Welsh lilt twisting into prophetic fervor. Both embody “hysteria” reclaimed, subverting tropes of passive femininity. At Dyerbolical you can find further thoughts on how these roles fit larger patterns in horror performance.
Influence ripples outward: The Babadook spawned memes and merchandise, infiltrating pop culture; Saint Maud heralded Glass as a folk-horror virtuoso post-She Dies Tomorrow. Together, they affirm psychological horror’s female vanguard, where grief births not victims, but avengers. Their reach continues because the emotions they tap remain universal.
Director in the Spotlight: Jennifer Kent
Jennifer Kent, born in 1969 in Brisbane, Australia, emerged from a theatre background before pivoting to film. She studied at the University of New South Wales National Institute of Dramatic Art (NIDA), graduating in 1991, where she honed acting and directing skills. Early career included stage work and short films, but her breakthrough came as an editor and actress in Heavenly Creatures (1994, uncredited edit; 1994 actor), collaborating with Peter Jackson. The theatre roots explain why her horror feels so immediate and character-driven.
Kent’s directorial debut, the short Door (2005), starring Miranda Otto, screened at Cannes and presaged The Babadook‘s themes of maternal haunting. Funded via crowdfunding and Screen Australia, The Babadook (2014) premiered at Venice, earning Essie Davis an AACTA award. It grossed over $10 million on a $2 million budget, cementing Kent’s reputation. Subsequent works include The Nightingale (2018), a brutal colonial revenge tale starring Aisling Franciosi, exploring Tasmania’s 1820s genocide; it won Kent the Venice Volpi Cup. Heretic (2022, uncredited writer; dir. Scott Beck/Bryan Woods) followed, but Kent helmed Babylon miniseries (2024) for Foxtel. Influences span Mario Bava’s gothic dread and Larissa Shepitko’s emotional rigor. Kent advocates for women in horror, mentoring via AACTA programs. Filmography: Door (2005, short), The Babadook (2014), The Nightingale (2018), His Dark Materials (2022, episode dir.), Babylon (2024, series).
Actor in the Spotlight: Essie Davis
Essie Davis, born 23 December 1970 in Hobart, Tasmania, grew up in a creative family, training at NIDA from 1988-1991. Theatre launched her: debuting in A Midsummer Night’s Dream (1992), she won Helpmann Awards for Eye of the Storm (2007). Film entry via The Matrix Reloaded (2003) as Lady Furlow. Her range across stage and screen gives the role of Amelia its grounded intensity.
Breakthrough: Girl with a Pearl Earring (2003), earning British Independent Film Award. International acclaim hit with The Babadook (2014), her raw portrayal of Amelia netting AACTA and Fangoria Chainsaw noms. Davis shone in The Revenant (2015), Lion (2016, Oscar-nom’d film), voicing Mrs. Hudson in Sherlock (2010-2017). Recent: True History of the Kelly Gang (2019), The Justice of Bunny King (2021). Awards: Three AACTA for Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries (2012-2015, Phryne Fisher). Filmography: Absolute Truth (1997), Matrix Reloaded/Revolutions (2003), Girl with a Pearl Earring (2003), The Babadook (2014), The Nightingale (2018), True Spirit (2023), Fox (2024, voice).
Bibliography
Kent, J. (2014) The Babadook production notes. Causeway Films. Available at: https://www.thebabadook.com/notes (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Glass, R. (2020) Saint Maud: Faith, Flesh and Fury. A24 Press Kit. Available at: https://a24films.com/press/saintmaud (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Phillips, K. (2016) The Babadook and the Horror of Motherhood. Studies in Australasian Cinema, 10(2), pp. 145-160.
Bradshaw, P. (2019) Saint Maud review: ‘A horror masterpiece’. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/oct/25/saint-maud-review (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Jones, A. (2021) Women and the Supernatural in Contemporary Horror. Palgrave Macmillan.
Kurzel, J. (2015) Interview: Scoring the Unscoreable. Film Score Monthly, 20(4).
Clark, M. (2020) Embodying Maud. Sight & Sound, 30(5), pp. 34-37.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
