The notorious hotel built by Herman Webster Mudgett on Chicago’s South Side became the setting for one of the most calculated criminal enterprises of the 1890s.

Mudgett arrived in the city in 1886 under the alias H.H. Holmes. He quickly established a pharmacy business and then acquired land at the intersection of 63rd and Wallace Streets. Construction of a large mixed-use building began soon afterwards. The structure combined retail space, apartments and a hotel intended to serve visitors to the upcoming World’s Columbian Exposition. Contemporary records show that Holmes obtained multiple mortgages and frequently changed contractors, practices that later complicated efforts to determine the building’s true layout.

The completed building featured ground-floor shops, upper-level living quarters and a hotel section advertised during the fair. City directories and insurance documents from the period list the address as 601–603 West 63rd Street. Holmes retained personal control over access to certain areas, a detail confirmed in later police statements.

Background

Mudgett was born in New Hampshire in 1861. He trained briefly as a doctor before moving westward. By the time he reached Chicago he had already adopted several aliases and faced minor legal complaints in other states. Local newspapers described him as well-spoken and neatly dressed, traits that helped him secure credit and business partnerships.

The decision to build on the South Side aligned with preparations for the 1893 exposition. Property values in the area rose sharply in anticipation of increased visitor numbers. Holmes financed the project through a combination of pharmacy profits, loans from acquaintances and insurance policies taken out on business associates. Several of those associates later disappeared, although contemporary investigators could not always link the absences directly to Holmes at the time.

The Building and Its Features

Construction and Layout

Building permits and surviving architectural sketches indicate a three-storey brick structure with a basement. The ground floor contained a pharmacy, a restaurant and several small shops. The second and third floors were divided into hotel rooms and apartments. Holmes personally oversaw many alterations after the initial construction, including the installation of additional partitions and locked doors. Former employees later testified that certain corridors ended abruptly and that some rooms lacked windows.

Daily Operations

During the exposition Holmes advertised rooms at competitive rates. Staff turnover was high, and several workers reported being dismissed without explanation. Neighbours recalled frequent deliveries of large quantities of building materials even after the main structure was finished. These deliveries included lengths of piping and quantities of quicklime, items later cited in court proceedings.

Crimes

Court records and contemporary newspaper accounts document that Holmes was linked to the deaths of at least nine individuals whose remains were recovered from the building or from locations associated with him. Victims included former employees, romantic partners and visitors who had stayed at the hotel. In several cases Holmes collected life insurance or assumed control of personal property shortly after the disappearances.

One well-documented case involved the death of Julia Conner and her daughter Pearl in 1891. Neighbours reported seeing the child with Holmes on the day she vanished. Remains later identified as belonging to both victims were found during the 1895 police search. Additional human remains discovered in the basement and in a nearby kiln supported the prosecution’s claim of multiple homicides.

Holmes maintained that some deaths resulted from accidents or from the actions of third parties. The jury rejected these explanations after reviewing physical evidence and witness testimony.

Investigation

The case gained momentum in 1894 when police in Philadelphia arrested Holmes on an unrelated fraud charge. Information supplied by a former associate prompted Chicago authorities to examine the 63rd Street building. A systematic search began in July 1895. Officers removed floors, walls and sections of the basement. They recovered bone fragments, hair, and items of clothing identified by relatives of missing persons.

The investigation extended to properties Holmes had owned in other states. In each location authorities found evidence of further financial irregularities and, in some instances, additional human remains. The scale of the inquiry required cooperation between several municipal police departments and the Pinkerton detective agency.

Trial and Aftermath

Holmes was tried in Chicago in 1895 on charges relating to the death of Benjamin Pitezel, a former business partner. The prosecution presented evidence that Holmes had killed Pitezel to collect insurance money and had subsequently murdered three of Pitezel’s children. The jury returned a guilty verdict after brief deliberation. Holmes was sentenced to death and executed by hanging at Moyamensing Prison in Philadelphia on 7 May 1896.

Following the trial the Chicago building was partially dismantled. Remaining portions served various commercial uses until a fire in 1895 caused further damage. Today the site is occupied by a post office.

Conclusion

The Holmes case illustrated how rapid urban growth and the promise of large public events could create opportunities for sustained criminal activity. Court documents and contemporary reporting established that Holmes exploited trust, financial arrangements and physical isolation within his own property to commit multiple murders. The confirmed victim count remains lower than the sensational claims that circulated after his arrest, yet the evidence presented at trial demonstrated a deliberate pattern of homicide sustained over several years.