Harley Quinn has always thrived on the razor edge between a punchline and a scream, but few stories have pushed that balance further than the 2020 Black Label one-shot that forced her onto the comedy stage with lethal consequences.
This article examines DC Black Label’s Harley Quinn: Make ’em Laugh #1, its place in the imprint’s mature lineup, the creative choices behind its horror-comedy tone, the full plot and visual techniques, the thematic exploration of trauma and fame, and its reception and lasting influence on how Harley is portrayed in comics.
In the chaotic pantheon of Gotham’s rogues, few characters embody reinvention quite like Harley Quinn. From her breakout in Batman: The Animated Series to her blockbuster solo films, Harley has danced across the spectrum of madness, mischief, and empowerment. Yet, DC Black Label’s Harley Quinn: Make ’em Laugh #1 (2020) plunges her into uncharted depths, blending razor-sharp comedy with visceral horror. This one-shot, released amid the publisher’s mature imprint push, strips away the candy-coloured chaos for a blood-soaked satire on fame, laughter, and the Joker’s lingering shadow.
Black Label, DC’s prestige line for creator-driven stories unbound by continuity, arrived in 2018 as a response to Vertigo’s legacy and the demand for adult-oriented comics. Titles like Frank Miller’s Dark Knight Returns sequels and Scott Snyder’s Batman: Last Knight on Earth set the tone: no holds barred, with themes of violence, psychology, and moral ambiguity. Into this arena steps Harley, not as the mallet-swinging anti-heroine of recent years, but as a would-be stand-up comic haunted by her past. Writer Stephanie Phillips and artist Riley Rossmo craft a tale that interrogates the very essence of Harley’s humour. Is it born from pain, or does pain fuel it?
What elevates this issue beyond a gimmick is its unflinching exploration of performance. Harley’s quest for laughs becomes a metaphor for her fractured psyche, echoing real-world comedian tragedies while amplifying them through Gotham’s gothic lens. Clocking in at 64 pages, it is a dense, rewarding read that rewards multiple revisits, revealing layers in its script and visuals.
DC Black Label Context: Harley’s Mature Makeover
DC Black Label emerged from the ashes of imprints like Vertigo, aiming to deliver standalone prestige miniseries and one-shots for mature audiences. Free from the constraints of mainline continuity, it allows creators to reimagine icons without canon repercussions. By 2020, the line boasted hits like The Batman Who Laughs and Joker War tie-ins, but Harley’s entry marked a bold pivot. Previous Black Label Harley appearances, such as in Harley Quinn and Power Girl, leaned comedic; here, the tone skews towards horror, aligning with the imprint’s penchant for psychological dread.
Harley Quinn herself has evolved dramatically since her 1992 debut in The Batman Adventures #15. Co-created by Paul Dini and Bruce Timm, she started as the Joker’s abused sidekick, her Brooklyn accent and acrobatics masking deep trauma. The New 52 and Rebirth eras empowered her, breaking free in Harley Quinn #25 (2014), leading her own gang, even starring in Birds of Prey and The Suicide Squad. Yet, traces of the Joker’s influence persist, as seen in Harley Quinn #1 (2016)’s meta adventures. Make ’em Laugh revisits this tension, positing a post-Joker Harley seeking normalcy through comedy, only to find her punchlines laced with lethality.
Positioning in Harley’s Solo Canon
This one-shot slots neatly into Harley’s expansive solo bibliography. Amid runs by Amanda Conner and Jimmy Palmiotti’s whimsical volumes, or Tom King’s introspective Heroes in Crisis, Phillips’ story stands out for its brevity and bite. It echoes the dark humour of Garth Ennis’ Hitman or Grant Morrison’s Joker tales, where laughter conceals atrocity. At a time when Harley dominated screens via Margot Robbie’s portrayals, this comic reminded fans of her roots in psychological horror. At Dyerbolical we have long tracked how these prestige experiments reshape fan expectations for legacy characters.
The Creative Powerhouse Behind the Madness
Stephanie Phillips, then an emerging talent known for Grim at Image Comics, brings a fresh voice to Harley. Her script masterfully balances rapid-fire jokes with escalating dread, drawing from stand-up routines that feel authentic. Think Sarah Silverman’s edge meets Joan Rivers’ bite. Phillips avoids caricature, granting Harley vulnerability: her therapy sessions and stage fright humanise the clown princess.
Riley Rossmo’s artwork is the issue’s true star. Fresh off The Ferryman and Razorblades: The Horror Magazine, Rossmo employs a style blending European ligne claire with American expressionism. Panels warp like funhouse mirrors, faces elongating in laughter or agony. Colourist Ivan Plascencia amplifies this with sickly greens and arterial reds, evoking Mike Mignola’s shadows but infused with neon punchlines.
Letterer Tom Napolitano deserves mention; his sound effects, “HA HA HA” balloons morphing into screams, integrate seamlessly, turning typography into a character. Together, the team crafts a symphony of unease, where every gag lands with a thud.
Plot Dissection: Spoilers Ahead
Warning: Full plot summary follows. Proceed if you have read it or do not mind twists spoiled.
The story opens with Harley, post-Joker breakup, attempting a civilian life as Harleen Quinzel. Therapy helps, but boredom drives her to Gotham’s comedy clubs. Her first open-mic bombs, until a heckler’s interruption unleashes something primal: she bashes him, eliciting uproarious laughs. Enter the demon, a literal manifestation of Joker’s ghost, or perhaps Harley’s id, who brokers a deal. Kills equal laughs; the more gruesome, the bigger the crowds.
Harley’s ascent is meteoric. From dingy basements to sold-out arenas, her act evolves: props become weapons, jokes double as confessions. Flashbacks interweave her Arkham origins, the Joker’s abuse, and her suicide attempts, framing comedy as catharsis turned curse. Climaxing at a massive show, Harley confronts the demon in a hallucinatory duel, her mallet clashing with ethereal grins. The resolution offers bittersweet ambiguity. Freedom won, but at what cost to her soul?
Phillips paces it like a killer set: short, punchy scenes building to a frenzy. Rossmo’s double-page spreads of blood-drenched stages are unforgettable, the crowd’s ecstasy mirroring Harley’s despair.
Visual Storytelling: Rossmo’s Nightmare Carnival
Rossmo’s art defies convention. Figures contort with elastic fluidity, reminiscent of his 4 Kids Walk Into a Bank work, but here infused with body horror. Harley’s pigtails whip like tentacles; audiences dissolve into toothy maws. Page layouts mimic stand-up timing, wide establishing shots for setups, jagged insets for punchlines.
Plascencia’s palette shifts masterfully: club scenes glow in vomit-yellows, kills explode in crimson. Shadows swallow panels, symbolising Harley’s encroaching darkness. Compared to Guillem March’s pin-up style in mainline Harley books, this is raw, unpolished brilliance. Ink splatters evoke laughter’s messiness.
Influences and Innovations
Echoes abound: Jack Kirby’s bombast in the action, Daniel Clowes’ suburban unease in Harley’s therapy bits. Yet Rossmo innovates with “laugh tracks”, visual motifs of grinning skulls overlaying panels, a nod to sitcom hell.
Thematic Depths: Laughter as the Ultimate Punchline
At its core, Make ’em Laugh dissects comedy’s dark underbelly. Harley embodies the trope of the wounded funnyman, akin to Andy Kaufman’s provocations or Richard Pryor’s fire scars. The demon-Joker pact critiques toxic relationships: laughter as abuse’s currency.
It also skewers fame’s machinery. Harley’s viral rise parodies social media stardom, crowds craving spectacle over substance. Gender dynamics simmer too. Female comedians mining trauma for applause, a la Hannah Gadsby’s Nanette.
Broadly, it probes Harley’s duality: clown or killer? Black Label affords this nuance, unburdened by heroic mandates. In comic history, it joins Arkham Asylum: A Serious House on Serious Earth in psychologising Gotham’s freaks.
Reception, Sales, and Lasting Echoes
Critics hailed it: IGN awarded 9/10 for “hilariously horrifying” execution; Comics Beat praised Phillips’ debut. Sales topped 50,000 copies, strong for Black Label one-shots, buoyed by Harley’s popularity post-Birds of Prey film.
Fan discourse fixated on the ending’s ambiguity. Redemption or relapse? It influenced subsequent Harley tales, like Harley Quinn #1 (2021)’s horror arcs. Rossmo’s style inspired imitators, cementing its artisanal cred.
Culturally, it arrived during pandemic isolation, when comedy’s role in coping resonated deeply. A trade paperback inclusion in Black Label collections ensures longevity.
Conclusion
Harley Quinn: Make ’em Laugh #1 stands as a pinnacle of DC Black Label’s ambition: a compact masterpiece that weaponises wit against woe. Phillips and Rossmo do not just entertain; they vivisect Harley’s soul, proving her enduring appeal lies in chaos’s core. In a medium often criticised for superficiality, this issue reaffirms comics’ power to provoke, perturb, and ultimately, make us laugh through the tears.
For Harley fans craving more than slapstick, it is essential. It challenges us: what price humour? As Gotham’s queen of quips navigates ever-darker stages, expect her Black Label shadow to loom large.
Bibliography
DC Comics, Harley Quinn: Make ’em Laugh #1, 2020.
IGN review archive, coverage of Black Label releases 2018-2021.
Comics Beat, Stephanie Phillips interview and debut coverage, 2020.
Paul Dini and Bruce Timm, Batman: The Animated Series production notes, 1992.
Image Comics, Grim series by Stephanie Phillips, collected editions.
Vertigo and DC Black Label imprint history overview, official DC records.
Hannah Gadsby, Nanette, Netflix special transcript analysis, 2018.
Mike Mignola Hellboy artistic influence studies in modern horror comics, 2015-2022.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
