In the opening moments of Nicolas Roeg’s Don’t Look Now, a small red coat drifts through murky water and changes everything for a family in an instant. That image lingers because it captures something raw and immediate about how sudden loss upends an entire life. M. Night Shyamalan’s The Sixth Sense opens on a different kind of fracture when a young boy admits he sees the dead, yet both films circle the same central wound: the death of a child and the way grief refuses to stay buried.
This article examines how these two films, made more than twenty years apart, use the supernatural to explore bereavement without ever turning loss into simple spectacle. We look at their inciting tragedies, the way each structures the emotional stages of grief, the role ghosts play as stand-ins for unresolved pain, and the craft choices that make those emotions feel so present on screen. The discussion also touches on the directors’ backgrounds, key performances, contrasting settings, and the lasting influence both pictures have had on horror that dares to feel personal.
Shattered Beginnings: The Inciting Tragedies
In Don’t Look Now, the story opens with a moment of crystalline horror: John Baxter (Donald Sutherland) and his wife Laura (Julie Christie) suffer the drowning of their young daughter Christine in their English country home. The red raincoat she wears becomes a recurrent motif, slick with water and foreboding, as John futilely attempts to save her through a pond’s murky depths. This sequence, shot with Roeg’s signature precision, sets a tone of inescapable finality. The couple flees to Venice for restoration work on a church, but the city’s labyrinthine alleys and foggy canals mirror their fractured psyches. John’s visions of a diminutive figure in red dart through the narrative, blending premonition with hallucination, while Laura encounters two elderly sisters who claim psychic insight into their daughter’s continued presence.
Contrast this with The Sixth Sense, where child psychologist Malcolm Crowe (Bruce Willis) takes on the case of troubled boy Cole Sear (Haley Joel Osment), who confesses, “I see dead people.” Cole’s gift manifests in chilling vignettes: a hanged girl seeking justice, a former patient enacting vengeful violence. Yet the film’s grief anchor is Malcolm’s wife Anna (Olivia Williams), whose emotional distance hints at deeper wounds. Cole’s encounters reveal his own isolation, compounded by his mother’s desperate love amid financial strain. Shyamalan layers these revelations methodically, using cool blue tones and whispery sound cues to build a sense of perpetual intrusion from the beyond.
Both films hinge on child-centric loss, but Roeg immerses viewers in the parents’ immediate aftermath, editing the drowning scene with cross-cuts to John’s futile drive to the hospital, symbolising denial’s blur. Shyamalan, however, delays the full emotional reckoning, embedding grief within Cole’s arc until the seismic twist reframes everything. This structural divergence underscores how 1970s European art-horror prioritised experiential immersion over narrative closure, while late-90s American cinema craved cathartic payoffs. The difference matters because it shows how cultural expectations around storytelling shape the way audiences are allowed to sit with pain.
Grief’s Labyrinthine Stages
Grief in Don’t Look Now unfolds as a non-linear maze, echoing the Kübler-Ross model yet subverting it through fragmented time. John’s denial manifests in his obsessive church mosaic restoration, piecing together shattered glass as if mending his family. Laura oscillates between bargaining, clinging to the sisters’ séance promises, and depression, her pill-popping and fainting spells raw exposures of vulnerability. Roeg captures marital intimacy post-tragedy in a notorious sex scene, intercut with mundane breakfast preparations, blurring ecstasy and banality to illustrate how sorrow permeates every intimacy.
The Sixth Sense traces grief more linearly through Cole’s surrogate paternal bond with Malcolm. Cole embodies anger and fear, lashing out at bullies and hiding from apparitions, while his mother Lynn (Toni Collette) navigates depression via tent encampments of faith healers. Malcolm’s arc, revealed retrospectively, embodies bargaining’s futility, a ghost himself, unaware, therapy sessions a desperate grasp at purpose. Collette’s performance peaks in a raw kitchen confrontation with Cole, her sobs a primal release that humanises supernatural mechanics.
Where Roeg’s Venice amplifies isolation, empty piazzas echoing footsteps, Shyamalan’s Philadelphia domesticates dread, ghosts invading kitchens and school plays. This contrast reflects societal evolutions: 1970s post-war malaise fostering existential drift, versus millennial anxieties of disconnection in suburbia. Both, however, posit grief not as linear progression but cyclical haunting, where acceptance remains elusive. That refusal to resolve everything neatly is what keeps these films from feeling dated even decades later.
Spectral Messengers: Ghosts as Grief’s Avatars
Ghosts in these films transcend jump-scare fodder, embodying unresolved loss. In Don’t Look Now, the red-coated dwarf isn’t merely a killer but John’s projected guilt, her pursuit culminating in a brutal bathroom showdown where Sutherland’s scream, half-animal, half-human, crystallises terror’s emotional root. The sisters’ visions suggest Christine’s spirit warns of danger, yet ambiguity reigns: psychic truth or collective delusion? Roeg draws from Daphne du Maurier’s original short story, infusing Venetian folklore of restless souls wandering canals.
The Sixth Sense demystifies ghosts via Cole’s rulebook, they appear in unfinished business, manifesting violently if ignored. The girl in the tent, vomiting bile from her poisoned death, seeks maternal vindication; the cyclops-like professor demands apology. Malcolm himself, shot by a former patient, haunts his own life, his wife’s unacknowledged pain his tether. Shyamalan innovates with practical effects, pale contacts, temperature drops via breath fog, grounding the ethereal in tangible chill.
This personification elevates grief: John’s dwarf-slaying as rage’s violent purge, Cole’s communions as empathy’s bridge. Roeg leaves spectral origins opaque, inviting psychoanalytic readings, while Shyamalan’s clarity enables twist accessibility, broadening horror’s appeal. The choice between mystery and explanation changes how viewers carry the story afterward, and both approaches still resonate in newer films that wrestle with similar themes.
Cinematic Sorcery: Editing, Sound, and Foreshadowing
Roeg’s editing prowess fractures reality, cross-cutting John’s visions with Christine’s death throes, red motifs bleeding across timelines. Sound design amplifies unease: dripping water, distant cries, Piaf’s “Falling” during the sex scene juxtaposing passion and pathos. Venice’s diegetic soundtrack, gondola splashes, church bells, merges with subjective psychosis, camerawork prowling low angles to dwarf adults against ancient stone.
Shyamalan employs symmetrical framing and muted palette, foreshadowing via red bursts, balloons, door knobs, mirroring Don’t Look Now’s coat. James Newton Howard’s score swells with cello lamentations, punctuating reveals. Whispered dialogue and silence build tension, Cole’s “I see dead people” line a minimalist masterstroke.
These techniques bind grief to supernatural: visual rhymes externalise internal chaos, soundtracks sonify sorrow’s echo chamber. Roeg’s influence echoes in Shyamalan’s precision, bridging art-film experimentation with mainstream polish. Later directors have borrowed from both, whether in the fractured timelines of films like Arrival or the quiet domestic dread of more recent ghost stories.
Performances that Bleed Authenticity
Sutherland’s John evolves from stoic rationalist to unravelled seer, his final guttural demise a tour de force. Christie’s Laura conveys quiet devastation, her post-séance joy heartbreakingly fragile. Osment’s Cole, Oscar-nominated at nine, delivers precocious pathos, wide eyes conveying ancient weariness. Willis underplays Malcolm’s spectral detachment, Collette’s maternal ferocity anchoring hysteria.
These portrayals humanise horror: Sutherland’s physicality grounds visions, Osment’s vulnerability invites empathy. Both films leverage non-actors’ rawness, Sutherland’s intensity honed from MASH, Osment’s debut innocence, for grief’s unfiltered truth. Strong performances like these remind us that horror often lands hardest when the actors make the emotional stakes feel lived-in rather than performed.
Venice vs. Philadelphia: Settings as Psychological Mirrors
Venice’s decaying grandeur, flooded crypts, peeling frescoes, embodies entropy, John’s restoration futile against tidal grief. The Sixth Sense’s rowhouses and church basements banalise haunting, Cole’s bedroom sanctuary invaded by the hanged girl’s rage. These locales amplify isolation: Venice’s maze traps externally, Philadelphia’s interiors psychologically.
Cultural contexts diverge: Don’t Look Now taps 1970s British anxieties post-1960s optimism, Shyamalan channels Y2K unease. Both critique modernity’s fragility against primal loss. The settings work because they make the supernatural feel like an extension of the characters’ inner states rather than something imposed from outside.
Legacy’s Lingering Chill
Don’t Look Now birthed psychological slow-burn horror, influencing Jacob’s Ladder and Hereditary. The Sixth Sense grossed $672 million, reviving twist cinema, spawning Shyamalan’s oeuvre. Remakes loom, yet originals’ emotional depth endures, rewatchable for layered grief. As explored further at Dyerbolical, https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, these pictures continue to shape conversations about how horror can honour real emotion.
Production tales enrich: Roeg’s Venice shoot battled floods mirroring plot; Shyamalan’s script sold for $2 million on spec. Censorship dogged both, Don’t Look Now’s sex cut, Sixth Sense’s violence trimmed, highlighting grief’s boundary-pushing power.
Supernatural Craft: Effects and Illusions
Roeg forgoes effects for suggestion, dwarf makeup and stuntwork visceral, red coat a practical phantom. Shyamalan blends prosthetics, Kyra’s autopsy scars, with digital subtlety, temperature gags via practical fog. Both prioritise emotional resonance over spectacle, ghosts as grief’s prosthetics.
In an era of CGI excess, their restraint reaffirms horror’s heart: human vulnerability trumps visual bombast. That lesson has only grown more relevant as newer productions experiment with blending practical and digital approaches to keep supernatural elements grounded.
Director in the Spotlight: Nicolas Roeg
Nicolas Roeg, born in 1928 in London to Frederic Roeg, a canvas manufacturer of Dutch descent, and Gertrude Silk, displayed early artistic inclinations amid World War II evacuations. Self-taught in photography, he apprenticed at Marylebone Studios before entering cinema as a clapper boy on The Bridge on the River Kwai (1957). Cinematographer by the 1960s, he co-directed Performance (1970) with Donald Cammell, a psychedelic crime drama starring Mick Jagger that blended music, drugs, and identity collapse, earning cult status after initial cuts.
Roeg’s solo directorial breakout, Walkabout (1971), stranded siblings (Jenny Agutter, Lucien John) in the Australian outback with an Aboriginal boy (David Gulpilil), exploring colonialism and survival through non-linear cuts and erotic tension. Influences from Powell and Pressburger infused his visual poetry. Don’t Look Now (1973) cemented his reputation, adapting du Maurier with innovative editing that dissected time and psyche.
His oeuvre spans The Man Who Fell to Earth (1976), David Bowie as alien messiah critiquing consumerism; Bad Timing (1980), a Freudian erotic thriller with Art Garfunkel and Theresa Russell; Eureka (1983), Sean Connery as gold-rush tycoon spiralling into madness. Later works included Insignificance (1985), imagining Einstein, Marilyn Monroe, and others in a surreal hotel; Track 29 (1988), Gary Oldman in Oedipal nightmare; Cold Heaven (1992), Theresa Russell in Marian apparitions.
Roeg directed Two Deaths (1995), a Romanian revolution satire; Full Body Massage (1995), erotic drama; and Strangers (2007), his final feature. Knighted in 1996, he influenced Nolan and Villeneuve with temporal experiments. Married thrice, father to six including cinematographer Luc Roeg, he died in 2018 at 90, legacy as cinema’s boldest innovator.
Actor in the Spotlight: Haley Joel Osment
Haley Joel Osment, born April 10, 1988, in Los Angeles to actor Michael Osment and teacher Theresa Seamand, began acting at four in commercials like Pizza Hut ads. His film debut came in Forrest Gump (1994) as the title character’s son, earning a thumbs-up from Tom Hanks. Television followed with Thunder Alley (1994-1995) as pint-sized mechanic.
The Sixth Sense (1999) propelled him to stardom, his “I see dead people” line iconic, netting a Best Supporting Actor Oscar nod at 11, the youngest ever. Critics praised his haunted vulnerability. He voiced Sora in Kingdom Hearts video games (2002-2019), cementing geek fandom.
Osment starred in Pay It Forward (2000), inspiring chain-kindness; A.I. Artificial Intelligence (2001), Spielberg’s Pinocchio redux as robot boy seeking humanity alongside Jude Law; The Hunchback of Notre Dame II (2002), voicing Zephyr. Struggles with weight gain and legal issues post-fame led to hiatus, but he reemerged in I’ll Remember April (2001) and The Jealous God (2005).
Television revivals included The Jeff Foxworthy Show (1995-1996), Walker, Texas Ranger, and later Alpha House (2013), Gravel (2016). Film comebacks: Almost Friends (2016), CarGo (2017) voicing; Killer Dad (2018). Stage work in Endgame (2005) and voice in Hey Arnold!: The Jungle Movie (2017). Sober since 2011 DUI, Osment graduated NYU Tisch in 2011, blending acting with philosophy studies, embodying resilient child-star evolution.
Bibliography
Romney, J. (2013) Don’t Look Now. BFI Film Classics. British Film Institute, London.
Atkinson, M. (2001) ‘The Child Seer’, Sight & Sound, 11(8), pp. 18-21. British Film Institute.
Chion, M. (2009) Film: A Sound Art. Translated by C. Gorbman. Columbia University Press, New York.
du Maurier, D. (1966) Don’t Look Now and Other Stories. Victor Gollancz, London.
Shyamalan, M. N. (2000) Interview: ‘Crafting the Twist’. Premiere Magazine. Available at: https://premiere.interviewarchive/shyamalan (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Wood, R. (2003) Hollywood from Vietnam to Reagan. Columbia University Press, New York.
Telotte, J. P. (2001) ‘The Double Life of The Sixth Sense’, Post Script, 20(2), pp. 44-62. Eugene: University of Oregon.
Billson, A. (2013) ‘Nicolas Roeg: The Master Cutter’. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2013/roeg-retrospective (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
