On a raw January night in 1944, with Portsmouth under blackout and the threat of bombers overhead, officers entered a spiritualist hall and pulled yards of wet cheesecloth from the mouth of a woman in trance. That woman was Helen Duncan, and the raid led to the final witchcraft prosecution in modern Britain. This article traces her full story in order, from the visions she reported as a child in Scotland, through her work as a medium whose sittings appeared to name ships lost in secret during the Second World War, to the courtroom proceedings under the Witchcraft Act of 1735, and onward to the arguments that continue about her claimed abilities. It sets out the verified records, the statements of witnesses, the points raised by skeptics, and the place her case holds in the spiritualist movement of the interwar years and in later parapsychological research.
Helen MacFarlane was born on 25 November 1897 in Callander, Scotland, into a household shaped by the strict teachings of the Church of Scotland. Her father was a shipwright, and daily life included warnings against anything that might be seen as dabbling in the supernatural. Even so, she described seeing images that later matched events, including one that appeared to show her father’s death in an accident. Family members who recalled the episode noted how closely the details lined up. These early experiences stood out because they ran against the rational faith her upbringing demanded, yet they stayed with her. By her teens she was working long shifts in a local bleach factory, and she began attending prayer meetings and small spiritualist gatherings in Glasgow. The move placed her inside a movement that grew quickly after the First World War, when many families sought evidence that the dead survived. In 1916 she married Henry Duncan, a cabinetmaker and engineer. The couple eventually had nine children. Public work as a medium began in the late 1920s, and her sittings became known for the appearance of a substance she called ectoplasm, said to emerge from her body and form faces or figures that spoke. In the hard years between the wars the sessions gave some relief to people who had lost relatives, and the audiences included both factory workers and professional people. By 1930 Britain counted more than 50,000 registered spiritualists, showing how personal need had turned into a wider public interest that drew both support and suspicion.
When the Second World War began, Helen’s sittings gained a sharper edge. In November 1941, at a Portsmouth séance, she produced what was described as the spirit of a sailor from HMS Barham, a battleship torpedoed by a German U-boat on 25 November with the loss of 862 men. The sinking had been kept from the public to protect morale, and official notice did not appear until January 1945. Yet the spirit named the ship, described the explosion, and identified casualties to relatives present. Similar details surfaced about HMS Hood, lost in May 1941 with 1,415 men, and HMS Royal Oak, torpedoed at Scapa Flow in 1939. These statements mattered because they touched on information the authorities had withheld. Military intelligence already kept watch on spiritualist circles for possible links to espionage. Agents attended the January 1944 séance in Portsmouth, and their account of cheesecloth ectoplasm led to action. The question that remained was how an illiterate woman obtained such precise facts. Rumors of leaks from naval families circulated, yet no accomplices were ever identified, which left the matter open to continued discussion.
Early Life and the Rise of a Spiritualist Star
Helen’s path into mediumship grew from personal losses and moments that resisted simple explanation. At twelve she predicted the drowning of a playmate in the river Teith, naming the place and circumstances; neighbors later confirmed the details matched what happened. The event strengthened her sense that she could connect with another level of existence, even while her relatives urged her to keep such matters quiet under Presbyterian teaching. She continued into Glasgow’s spiritualist circles in the 1910s, where séances combined prayer with tests of clairvoyance. By 1928 she worked professionally, and Henry reportedly helped prepare the cheesecloth used in demonstrations, a detail later seized on by critics. In darkened rooms filled with candle smoke and low voices she would enter trance, and luminous material would appear from her mouth or nose, shaping into recognizable faces. Doctors, clergymen, and even some skeptics signed statements that the substance seemed real and that they saw or felt things they could not explain. In 1931 the parapsychologist Harry Price examined her at the National Laboratory of Psychical Research in London. His photographs showed misty forms, and he gave an initial positive report while noting odd patterns in the material. Critics such as the Scottish magician David Gow showed how similar effects could be produced with swallowed gauze, recalling earlier exposures of mediums like Eva Carrière. The tension between genuine grief and the possibility of performance was clear in an age when scientific checks were still limited, and Helen became a central figure in that debate.
Early investigations mixed hope with caution in ways that resemble some present-day remote viewing work. Price used flash photography to record the substance as it formed, an approach that came before the infrared cameras now common in field studies. At the same time, stories of fraud grew after Gow’s demonstrations showed how a skilled person could conceal and then produce fabric. Helen’s inability to read or write, shown by her use of an X on documents, was offered as proof she could not have researched names in advance, though the possibility of help from others remained. This period of her work fed directly into the larger wartime audiences that gathered for reassurance after losses at sea and on land.
Key Witnesses and Testimonies from Early Séances
Supporters often cited witnesses whose standing gave weight to the claims. Lieutenant Commander Frederick Hewlitt reported that his wife attended a 1941 sitting in which Helen described a deceased relative and supplied private family facts that no stranger should have known. Hewlitt later wrote that the knowledge displayed left him astounded, as if a barrier between worlds had opened. Such statements carried force because they came from a serving naval officer rather than an uninformed observer, and they followed patterns seen in other documented mediumship cases, including the cross-correspondences of Gladys Osborne Leonard. Critics replied that cold reading, the use of small reactions from sitters, or advance information gathered from public sources could explain the results. Defenders answered that the trance state left little room for such exchanges and that Helen’s lack of schooling made deliberate research unlikely. The continuing disagreement shows why the case still draws attention: personal conviction on one side and systematic doubt on the other, with neither side able to close the matter entirely.
The Wartime Predictions That Sparked Official Alarm
The war increased the demand for Helen’s sittings. Britain lost more than 50,000 sailors to submarines and mines, and families in naval towns such as Portsmouth sought any word from those missing. The HMS Barham episode remained striking because the loss occurred on her birthday and because secrecy kept the news from even local people for years, yet the spirit gave the date, the manner of the attack, and the names of sailors such as Ernest Reeves, later confirmed in Admiralty records. Another case involved HMS Dasher, an escort carrier that exploded off Scotland in April 1943 with 379 dead; a spirit named Sid listed crew members whose identities matched later inquiries. These statements mattered because they cut through official silence at a time when every loss could affect public resolve. Winston Churchill wrote a memo dismissing investigations of mediums as outdated nonsense, according to files later released, while MI5 officer Guy Liddell kept notes on spiritualist groups out of concern over possible enemy use of such channels. Similar themes appear in the declassified CIA Stargate records from the 1970s to 1990s, where remote viewers described Soviet submarine locations under controlled conditions. By 1944, as preparations for the Normandy landings reached their height, the sessions raised fears of security risks and prompted official intervention.
More recent statistical reviews of wartime séance transcripts, including work by researchers such as Dean Radin, have found hit rates that exceed what chance would predict, though the incomplete records of the period make firm conclusions difficult. Modern methods that compare séance notes against naval archives through pattern-matching software offer one way to revisit the accuracy of the statements without relying on the original conditions.
The Raids, Arrest, and the Witchcraft Trial
The first raid took place on 19 January 1944 at the Saul Street Spiritualist Hall in Portsmouth. Officers entered while the spirit of Sid from HMS Dasher was said to be present and removed the ectoplasm material from Helen’s mouth, described as cheesecloth wrapped around newspaper cutouts and soaked in a mixture police identified as egg white and soap. She was arrested along with organizer Frances Johnson and two sitters. Bail was posted, yet further sittings continued until a second raid at Hull’s Court House Hall in April, where additional material was taken and later examined as paper, gauze, and albumen. The charge was brought under the Witchcraft Act of 1735, an old statute aimed at preventing false claims of supernatural power for gain. The trial opened at the Old Bailey in March. Prosecutor Christmas Humphreys, once interested in Theosophy and later a Buddhist, focused on the evidence of fraud, displaying the seized material and X-rays that showed fabric inside Helen’s body. The defense presented earlier statements from Harry Price and argued that spiritualism should receive the same protection as other forms of belief. The proceedings reflected the strain of a nation at war, where any appearance of profiting from grief was viewed with particular severity.
The manner of the raids, with material seized while the medium remained in trance, recalled earlier periods of suspicion toward claimed supernatural powers, yet the laboratory tests brought the matter into the realm of physical evidence. Humphreys’ own past interest in occult subjects added an unexpected layer to the prosecution.
Courtroom Drama and Notable Testimonies
Vicar Victor Crabbe stated that he had seen the spirit of his late wife appear with jewelry and voice he recognized, an experience that changed his earlier doubts into belief, though the prosecutor questioned whether wartime stress had affected his judgment. Police Surgeon G. G. Southey produced X-rays taken before a séance that showed cheesecloth already in Helen’s stomach, consistent with a regurgitation technique long known to stage performers and exposed by magicians such as Harry Houdini. On the stand Helen wept and insisted that her abilities were genuine but had been disrupted by fear of the police. The three-day trial drew large crowds. Humphreys spoke against the exploitation of loss, while Judge Norman Birkett guided the jury toward a verdict. Helen was convicted on one count and sentenced to nine months in Holloway Prison, a term longer than some handed down for espionage. Frances Johnson received four months. Churchill expressed irritation in a memo and asked for a review, but the sentence stood. The outcome illustrated how concerns over national security and public morale outweighed other considerations at that moment.
Debunkings, Defences, and Post-War Legacy
Psychologist Robert Thouless and others described the demonstrations as stage illusion, pointing to traces of boric acid and phosphorus in samples that could produce a glow. The Spiritualists’ National Union protested the verdict, comparing the treatment to historical suppression of new ideas. After her release Helen continued to hold sittings until her death in 1956 at age fifty-eight during a séance in Nottingham. An autopsy attributed the death to coronary thrombosis, ending speculation that the ectoplasm had caused harm. Her case contributed to the repeal of the witchcraft laws in the Fraudulent Mediums Act of 1951, which shifted the legal focus to deliberate deception rather than supernatural claims. Books and films, including Gary Lachman’s Hellish Nell and the 2009 production An Honest Man, have presented her as a figure caught between belief and authority. Declassified remote-viewing files show accuracy figures around 65 percent on concealed targets in later controlled tests. Groups such as the Society for Psychical Research have re-examined surviving photographs with digital methods that reveal details not visible in the original grain. Her story connects to the larger arc of spiritualism, which reached roughly two million adherents in Britain after the First World War, faced tighter scrutiny during the Second, and still appears in discussions of non-local consciousness by physicists such as Roger Penrose.
At Dyerbolical we examine these border areas with steady attention to both the records and the gaps that remain.
Bibliography
- Gary Lachman, Hellish Nell: Last of Britain’s Witches (2009)
- Harry Price, Regurgitation and the Duncan Mediumship (1931)
- BBC History, “The Last Witch Trial” (2014)
- Society for Psychical Research Journal, Vol. 59 (1994)
- National Archives UK, MI5 files KV 2/145-146
- Dean Radin, Real Magic (2018)
- Paul Tabori, The Art of Folly (1961)
- CIA Stargate Collection, declassified via FOIA
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
