When a hotshot Florida lawyer accepts a dream job in Manhattan, he soon learns that every victory in court comes with a hidden price tag attached to his soul. This article examines Taylor Hackford’s The Devil’s Advocate from 1997, tracing its blend of legal drama and supernatural horror while exploring the performances, production choices, and themes that have kept the film relevant nearly three decades later.
The Serpent’s Offer: A Labyrinthine Plot Unfurls
Kevin Lomax, a hotshot defence attorney from rural Florida, embodies the archetype of unbridled talent when he secures an improbable acquittal for a child-molesting teacher in a sweltering courtroom showdown. His unorthodox tactics—grilling the victim rather than challenging evidence—propel him into the orbit of John Milton, the enigmatic head of New York’s most powerful law firm, Milton, Chadwick & Waters. Played with reptilian magnetism by Al Pacino, Milton lures Kevin with promises of limitless wealth, prestige, and the chance to rub shoulders with the elite. Accompanied by his fragile wife Mary Ann (Charlize Theron), Kevin relocates to Manhattan’s gilded towers, only to find the firm’s corridors echoing with unholy whispers.
As Kevin dives into high-profile cases, including defending a wealthy heir accused of murdering his family and a media mogul entangled in scandal, cracks appear in his idyllic ascent. Mary Ann suffers nightmarish visions and physical torment, her descent marked by grotesque apparitions—a baby with cloven hooves suckling at her breast, walls bleeding with infernal imagery. Kevin dismisses her pleas as hysteria, blinded by his victories and Milton’s paternalistic grooming. The firm’s partners reveal their depravities: orgiastic rituals, suicides veiled as accidents, and a pervasive aura of corruption. Guillermo del Toro-esque flourishes abound, from pulsating sculptures in Milton’s penthouse to a climactic revelation where the skyscraper warps into a hellish cathedral.
Hackford, drawing from Andrew Neiderman’s novel, amplifies the source material’s psychological tension into visceral horror. The screenplay by Jonathan Lemkin and Tony Gilroy crafts a narrative that mirrors Milton’s biblical namesake—John Milton, author of Paradise Lost—positioning the Devil as a fallen angel railing against divine tyranny. Kevin’s arc traces a classic trajectory from innocence to damnation, punctuated by biblical allusions: water turned to blood in a sink, locusts swarming a courtroom metaphorically. Production designer Bruno Rubeo conjures opulent yet claustrophobic spaces, where marble floors gleam like obsidian and penthouse views stretch into abyssal voids. The film’s runtime builds inexorably, each case Kevin wins peeling back layers of his moral facade until the explosive finale, where Milton sheds his human guise in a torrent of fire and fury.
That slow erosion of Kevin’s principles feels especially pointed when viewed alongside other 1990s stories of compromised professionals, such as The Firm from 1993. Both films tap into public distrust of powerful institutions after years of corporate scandals and political disillusionment, yet The Devil’s Advocate pushes the premise further by making the corruption literal rather than simply ethical.
Ambition’s Altar: Themes of Vanity and Moral Bankruptcy
At its core, the film indicts the legal profession’s Faustian compact, where victory trumps justice. Kevin’s early triumph comes at the cost of a girl’s trauma, foreshadowing the soul-eroding compromises demanded by Milton’s firm. Hackford interrogates vanity as the Devil’s choicest sin, with Milton proclaiming, Vanity, definitely my favourite sin, during a monologue that peels back the film’s philosophical skin. This echoes Christian theology’s seven deadlies, but refracts them through capitalism’s lens: greed manifests in billable hours, lust in boardroom bacchanals, pride in skyscraping egos.
Gender dynamics sharpen the blade. Mary Ann’s suffering serves as collateral for Kevin’s rise, her body a battleground for demonic incursion. Theron’s raw performance captures a woman unraveling under patriarchal blindness and supernatural assault, her institutionalisation a chilling nod to real-world gaslighting. The film critiques how ambition devours the vulnerable, positioning Mary Ann as a Cassandra figure whose warnings go unheeded. Milton’s firm, a microcosm of patriarchal power, devours its own—partners combust spontaneously, their excesses punished in cartoonish yet terrifying fashion.
Biblical underpinnings infuse every frame. Milton’s atheism masks theodicy debates: if God allows suffering, why not rebel? This Milton is no horned caricature but a suave rationalist, quoting scripture to justify free will’s perils. The film grapples with predestination versus choice, Kevin’s lineage as Milton’s son sealing his temptation even as flashes of resistance flicker. Cultural anxieties of the late 1990s—corporate scandals, moral relativism—find voice here, the law firm as Enron avant la lettre. Those same concerns about unchecked power resurfaced in later decades, making the film’s warnings feel freshly relevant during the financial crises of the 2000s and beyond.
Penthouse Pyrotechnics: Special Effects and Cinematic Sorcery
Hackford’s visual arsenal elevates the supernatural from suggestion to spectacle. Cinematographer Andrzej Bartkowiak employs Steadicam glides through the firm’s labyrinths, building paranoia akin to Rosemary’s Baby. The penthouse finale erupts in practical effects wizardry: hydraulic walls undulating like flesh, fire geysers choreographed by Joel Hynek, and Pacino’s transformation utilising animatronics blended with early CGI for Milton’s demonic apotheosis—wings unfurling amid swirling vortices.
Sound design amplifies unease. James Newton Howard’s score weaves Gregorian chants into orchestral swells, while foley artists craft squelching flesh and whispering winds. A pivotal scene sees Mary Ann’s suicide interrupted by Milton’s spectral intrusion, her reflection warping in a mirror to reveal cloven features—a practical makeup triumph by Greg Cannom. These effects, budgeted at $75 million, hold up remarkably, predating the digital deluge while nodding to 1970s practical mastery like The Exorcist’s subdermal contortions.
Mise-en-scène pulses with symbolism. Milton’s office harbours a massive bas-relief of intertwined lovers and beasts, foreshadowing revelations. Lighting plays divine and infernal: heavenly shafts pierce Kevin’s Florida trial, yielding to chiaroscuro shadows in New York. The film’s climax reframes the skyline as Icarus’s fall, skyscrapers as Babel’s tower. Even today, viewers streaming the film on modern platforms notice how those practical choices avoid the dated look that plagues many early CGI-heavy productions.
Satan’s Silver Tongue: Performances that Possess
Al Pacino dominates as John Milton, his baritone purr modulating from avuncular mentor to wrathful deity. Drawing from Scarface’s volatility, he infuses Lucifer with intellectual heft, scenes like the restaurant seduction—where he manifests vices as apparitions—crackling with improvisational fire. Keanu Reeves, post-Speed, sheds action-hero stiffness for haunted intensity, his wide-eyed naivety curdling into tormented defiance. Charlize Theron, in her breakout, channels fragility into ferocity, her bathroom breakdown a tour de force of physical and emotional collapse.
Supporting turns enrich the tapestry: Jeffrey Jones as the lecherous Eddie Barzoon, his marathon-runner physique bloating supernaturally; Judith Ivey as Kevin’s Bible-thumping mother, a voice of rustic morality clashing with urban perdition. Jeffrey Tambor’s oily partner adds comic pathos, his water-cooler implosion a darkly humorous set piece.
Legacy of the Damned: Influence on Horror Hybrids
The Devil’s Advocate spawned no direct sequels but rippled through genre waters. Its template—supernatural intrusion into white-collar worlds—informs films like Frailty’s moral absolutism and The Box’s deal-with-the-devil mechanics. TV echoes in Lucifer’s charm offensive and Suits’ ethically ambiguous barristers tinged with infernal wit. Cult status grew via home video, its quotable diatribes meme fodder for legal thriller fans.
Censorship battles marked its release; the MPAA demanded trims to Mary Ann’s visions, Hackford resisting to preserve impact. Box office triumph—$60 million domestic on $75 million budget—affirmed audiences’ appetite for smart horror amid Scream’s slasher revival. In recent years the film has found new audiences through streaming services, where younger viewers often discover it alongside contemporary takes on demonic bargains such as The Menu or Succession’s corporate satire.
Director in the Spotlight
Taylor Hackford, born November 1, 1944, in Santa Barbara, California, emerged from a privileged background—his father a banker, mother an artist—yet channelled early activism into filmmaking. A Peace Corps volunteer in Bolivia (1968-1969), he honed documentary skills directing portraits of Oscar Niemeyer and the Los Angeles Music Center. Returning stateside, Hackford helmed the Oscar-winning short Teenage Father (1978), launching his feature career.
Hackford’s oeuvre spans romance, music biopics, and thrillers, marked by muscular storytelling and social conscience. An Officer and a Gentleman (1982) catapulted Richard Gere and Debra Winger to stardom, its naval training rigours earning Best Picture nomination. Against All Odds (1984) blended neo-noir with Rachel Ward’s sultry allure. White Nights (1985) paired Mikhail Baryshnikov and Gregory Hines in a Cold War ballet-thriller. Everybody’s All-American (1988) dissected Southern football machismo via Jessica Lange and Dennis Quaid.
Chuck Berry: Hail! Hail! Rock ‘n’ Roll (1987) showcased Hackford’s music acumen, featuring Keith Richards backing the rock pioneer. Julia and Julia (1987) ventured Italian erotica with Kathleen Turner. The Devil’s Advocate (1997) fused his commercial savvy with horror ambition. Proof of Life (2000) tackled kidnapping drama with Meg Ryan and Russell Crowe. His crowning achievement, Ray (2004), biopic of Ray Charles starring Jamie Foxx, netted Foxx a Best Actor Oscar and Hackford a Director’s Guild nod.
Later works include Love Ranch (2010), his wife Helen Mirren’s Nevada brothel saga; Parker (2013) actioner with Jason Statham; and The Comedian (2016) pairing Robert De Niro and Leslie Mann. Married to Mirren since 1984 after romances with Jane Fonda collaborators, Hackford chairs the American Film Institute, influencing generations. Influences span Sidney Lumet’s courtroom grit and Roman Polanski’s paranoia, evident in his taut pacing and moral ambiguity. Filmography highlights: An Officer and a Gentleman (1982: romantic drill-sergeant epic); White Nights (1985: defector dancer thriller); Ray (2004: soulful biopic triumph).
Actor in the Spotlight
Al Pacino, born April 25, 1940, in East Harlem, New York, to Italian-American parents, endured a turbulent youth after his parents’ divorce. Raised by his mother and grandparents in the Bronx, Pacino dropped out of high school but pursued acting at HB Studio and Actors Studio under Lee Strasberg, embodying Method intensity. Early theatre triumphs included Does a Tiger Wear a Necktie? (1969 Tony) and The Indian Wants the Bronx.
Francis Ford Coppola’s The Godfather (1972) immortalised him as Michael Corleone, evolving from reluctant heir to ruthless don across sequels (1974, 1990)—roles earning Oscar nods. Serpico (1973) portrayed the whistleblower cop with gritty authenticity; Dog Day Afternoon (1975) his bank-robber hysteria clinched another nomination. Scarface (1983) defined 1980s excess as Tony Montana, its “Say hello to my little friend” iconic.
Pacino’s 1990s renaissance included Scent of a Woman (1992) for his blind colonel, netting a long-overdue Best Actor Oscar; Glengarry Glen Ross (1992) savage realtor; Carlito’s Way (1993) redemption arc. The Devil’s Advocate (1997) unleashed his diabolical flair. Later: Donnie Brasco (1997) undercover agent; The Insider (1999) tobacco crusader; Insomnia (2002) guilt-ridden detective; Ocean’s Thirteen (2007) casino mogul; The Irishman (2019) labour boss Jimmy Hoffa.
Awards abound: one Oscar, one Tony, Emmys for Angels in America (2003) and You Don’t Know Jack (2010). Pacino founded Actors Studio affiliates, authored Sonny Chiba (2008) on playwriting. Romances with Jill Clayburgh, Diane Keaton, Beverly D’Angelo yielded three children. Filmography: The Godfather trilogy (1972-1990: mafia ascension); Serpico (1973: principled cop); Dog Day Afternoon (1975: desperate heist); Scarface (1983: cocaine kingpin); Scent of a Woman (1992: Oscar-winning tour de force).
Discussions of Pacino’s commanding presence in this role often surface on Dyerbolical, where writers trace how his Milton fits into a career defined by magnetic authority figures.
Craving more infernal insights and horror deep dives? Subscribe to NecroTimes today for exclusive analyses, retrospectives, and the latest chills straight to your inbox.
Bibliography
Hackford, T. (1997) ‘Directing the Devil’, Premiere Magazine. Available at: https://www.premiere.com/1997/10/devils-advocate (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Neiderman, A. (1990) The Devil’s Advocate. New York: Simon & Schuster.
Pacino, A. and Grobel, L. (2006) Al Pacino: In Conversation with Lawrence Grobel. New York: Applause Theatre & Cinema Books.
Schwartz, R.A. (2000) The 1990s Movie Guide. Jefferson: McFarland & Company.
Thompson, D. (2004) ‘Taylor Hackford’, in The New Biographical Dictionary of Film. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, pp. 365-367.
Williams, L. (2008) ‘Satanic Cinema: Negotiating the Demonic in Contemporary Horror’, Journal of Film and Video, 60(3), pp. 45-62.
Prince, S. (2009) Firestorm: American Film in the Age of Terrorism. New York: Columbia University Press.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
