In the coastal community of Santa Cruz, California, a cluster of seemingly unconnected killings between October 1972 and February 1973 left residents on edge and investigators searching for patterns amid an already unsettled local atmosphere.
Herbert Mullin carried out thirteen murders over five months. His victims ranged from a Catholic priest to young people and transients. The killings occurred while the area was still reeling from the separate crimes of Edmund Kemper. Mullin’s actions were shaped by auditory hallucinations and a conviction that human sacrifice could avert earthquakes. This belief formed the core of his motive and distinguished his case from more conventional predatory patterns.
Early Life and Path to Instability
Herbert William Mullin was born on 18 April 1947 in Salinas, California. He grew up in a stable middle-class household with two sisters. Teachers described him as bright and athletic during his school years. By his late teens, however, marked changes appeared. Friends noticed increasing withdrawal and erratic behaviour after the death of a close friend in a car accident.
Mullin experimented with drugs, including LSD, during the late 1960s. He was briefly institutionalised in 1969 following a violent episode. Diagnoses at the time pointed to paranoid schizophrenia, yet he received only short-term treatment before release. His parents attempted to manage his care at home, but his condition deteriorated. By 1972 he had moved to Santa Cruz, living in a series of cheap rentals and holding sporadic jobs.
The Killing Spree Begins
Mullin’s first confirmed murder took place on 13 October 1972. He struck Lawrence White, a homeless man, with a baseball bat near the San Lorenzo River. White’s body was left partially concealed. Police initially treated the death as an isolated assault.
Over the following weeks Mullin expanded his targets. On 24 October he killed Mary Guilfoyle, a twenty-year-old student, after offering her a lift. Her remains were discovered months later in a wooded area. Two days later he attacked a group of campers, killing four young men in a single night near Henry Cowell Redwoods State Park. The victims were James McGlashan, David Hughes, David Oliker and Robert Spector. Mullin used a rifle and knife in rapid succession.
Targeting a Priest
On 2 November 1972 Mullin entered St Mary’s Catholic Church in Los Gatos. He stabbed Father Henri Tomei multiple times in the confessional. The priest’s body was found later that day. This killing drew wider attention because of its location and the victim’s standing in the community.
Mullin continued through December and January. He shot four teenage boys at a beach campsite on 25 December. The victims were Brian Scott, Mark Dreibelbis, Michael Richardson and Kathy Francis. Francis, the only female in that group, had been visiting the site with friends. Mullin returned to the area days later to kill two more people: a woman named Ruth Helen and her neighbour.
Police Investigation and Breakthrough
Santa Cruz detectives faced overlapping cases at a time when the county already held the Kemper investigation. Initial leads pointed toward drug-related disputes or transient violence. Ballistics from several scenes eventually matched a single .22-calibre rifle. Witnesses described a young man driving an older-model station wagon near multiple crime scenes.
On 13 February 1973 officers stopped Mullin for a traffic violation. A search of his vehicle revealed the rifle and items taken from victims. He offered no resistance and began confessing within hours of arrest. Over several days he provided details that allowed investigators to link all thirteen deaths to him.
Trial, Conviction and Sentencing
Mullin stood trial in August 1973 in Santa Cruz County Superior Court. The prosecution presented physical evidence, witness identifications and his own recorded statements. Defence counsel argued diminished capacity due to schizophrenia. Psychiatric experts for both sides agreed on the presence of severe mental illness, yet the jury rejected the insanity defence.
On 19 August 1973 Mullin received eleven concurrent life sentences plus additional terms. He was sent to the California Medical Facility at Vacaville and later transferred between state prisons. Parole has been denied at every hearing.
Psychological Assessment and Motive
Court-appointed psychiatrists documented Mullin’s fixed delusion that earthquakes could be prevented only through human sacrifice. He claimed voices, sometimes attributed to his father or historical figures, instructed him to kill. The number thirteen held particular significance in his reasoning. Unlike many serial offenders, Mullin showed no sexual motive and selected victims largely at random once the compulsion arose.
Post-conviction evaluations confirmed ongoing symptoms of paranoid schizophrenia. Medication stabilised some behaviours, yet the underlying delusional structure remained intact. Criminologists have noted the case as an example of mission-oriented killing driven by psychosis rather than organised sadism.
Impact on Santa Cruz and Broader Context
The Mullin murders compounded the strain on Santa Cruz law enforcement already stretched by the Kemper investigation. Local media coverage highlighted gaps in mental-health services and the difficulties of tracking transient populations. Community memorials for the victims were established quietly over the years, with families requesting privacy.
No legislative changes were directly attributed to these cases, though they contributed to ongoing discussions about involuntary commitment standards in California during the 1970s.
Conclusion
Herbert Mullin’s crimes stand as a stark record of untreated severe mental illness intersecting with opportunity in a small coastal city. The thirteen victims and their families remain the enduring focus of any account. Official records and contemporary reporting continue to provide the verified foundation for understanding the sequence of events.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
Visit our Immortalis horror fiction universe at https://immortalishorror.com
