Herbert Mullin’s crimes in Santa Cruz unfolded across a compressed period in 1972 and 1973, driven by a rapidly deteriorating mental state that produced a fixed belief in the need for human sacrifice to avert natural disasters.

Mullin, then twenty-five years old, had already shown signs of serious psychological disturbance before the killings began. His actions claimed thirteen lives in less than five months and left lasting effects on the coastal community where most of the attacks occurred.

The case stands out for the speed with which the murders were committed and for the way local law enforcement eventually connected a series of seemingly unrelated deaths to a single perpetrator.

Background

Herbert William Mullin was born in Salinas, California, in 1947. He grew up in a stable household and performed well at school until his late teens, when the death of a close friend in a car accident triggered the first clear episode of mental illness.

By the early 1970s Mullin had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia. He heard voices that he interpreted as direct commands from his father and from historical figures. These auditory hallucinations increasingly shaped his daily decisions and led him to believe that the only way to prevent a catastrophic earthquake was to kill people whose deaths would release enough “energy” to stabilise the San Andreas Fault.

After several short stays in psychiatric facilities, Mullin stopped taking prescribed medication. He moved frequently between Santa Cruz, San Francisco and his parents’ home in Felton, becoming increasingly isolated and convinced that time was running out before a major seismic event.

The Crimes

The first confirmed killing took place on 13 October 1972. Mullin struck Lawrence White, a homeless man, with a baseball bat near the Santa Cruz city limits. White’s body was left in a remote area and discovered weeks later.

Over the following months Mullin attacked both strangers and acquaintances. On 24 October he shot and killed a young woman, Mary Guilfoyle, after offering her a lift. Her remains were found the next year in a wooded ravine.

In November he killed four teenage boys who were camping near Loma Prieta. The victims, James McConnell, David Hughes, Robert Spector and Brian Scott Card, were shot at close range. Mullin later stated that the group’s presence had drawn his attention because he believed their deaths would contribute to the required total of sacrifices.

Further attacks occurred in December 1972 and January 1973. Mullin killed an elderly man, Henry Francis Cowell, inside his own home and later murdered a mother and her two children after gaining entry to their house under a false pretext. Each killing followed a similar pattern: a sudden approach, a brief struggle or immediate gunfire, and rapid departure from the scene.

Methods and Selection of Victims

Mullin used whatever weapon was at hand, including a baseball bat, a rifle and a handgun. He rarely planned the attacks in advance and often chose victims who happened to be alone in isolated locations or who opened their doors to him.

The victims ranged in age from two to seventy-two. Mullin later claimed that age or occupation did not matter; only the act of killing itself held significance in his delusional framework.

Investigation

Santa Cruz police initially treated the deaths as separate incidents. The city had already recorded several unsolved homicides in previous years, and investigators did not immediately suspect a single offender.

By early 1973, however, similarities in the manner of death and the geographic concentration around Santa Cruz prompted detectives to review open cases together. Ballistic evidence from the camping-site shootings matched a rifle later recovered from Mullin’s vehicle.

Community concern grew as news of the murders spread. Local residents began avoiding remote trails and locking doors during daylight hours, an unusual step in the previously low-crime coastal town.

Capture

On 13 February 1973 a neighbour reported suspicious activity at a house where Mullin had been seen entering uninvited. Officers arrived to find the bodies of four family members. A short time later Mullin was stopped while driving nearby.

During the traffic stop police found a loaded rifle in the car. Mullin offered no resistance and made statements that quickly linked him to multiple unsolved killings. He was arrested and charged with thirteen counts of murder.

Trial and Sentencing

Mullin’s trial opened in July 1973. The defence argued that his schizophrenia rendered him legally insane at the time of the offences. Prosecutors presented evidence of premeditation, including Mullin’s own recorded statements that he had chosen victims deliberately to meet a numerical quota.

The jury rejected the insanity defence. Mullin was convicted on all counts and sentenced to life imprisonment with the possibility of parole. He has remained in the California prison system since that time.

Psychological Profile

Psychiatric evaluations conducted after arrest confirmed a diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia with prominent religious and apocalyptic delusions. Mullin described receiving instructions from voices that demanded a precise number of deaths to forestall earthquakes.

Experts noted that his belief system combined elements of his Catholic upbringing with distorted interpretations of local seismic history. The voices he reported were consistent across multiple interviews and matched the timing of the crimes.

Legacy and Community Impact

The Santa Cruz killings contributed to a broader sense of vulnerability in a region already associated with earlier high-profile cases. Local authorities later reviewed procedures for sharing information across neighbouring jurisdictions when multiple unsolved deaths occur in quick succession.

Mullin’s case has been studied in forensic psychology for the clarity with which a single delusional system drove repeated lethal acts. Victim-support groups in Santa Cruz still reference the 1972–73 murders when discussing the long-term needs of families affected by sudden violence.

Conclusion

Herbert Mullin’s offences remain a stark example of how untreated severe mental illness can produce a rapid series of attacks when combined with a fixed, dangerous belief. The thirteen victims and their families continue to be remembered by the Santa Cruz community through quiet annual observances rather than public spectacle.

Bibliography

California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (2023) Inmate Information: Herbert Mullin. Sacramento: CDCR Records.

Douglas, J. and Olshaker, M. (1995) Mindhunter: Inside the FBI’s Elite Serial Crime Unit. New York: Scribner.

Ressler, R.K. and Shachtman, T. (1992) Whoever Fights Monsters. New York: St Martin’s Press.

Santa Cruz Sentinel (1973) ‘Man Held in Series of Local Slayings’, 14 February.

Schechter, H. (2003) The Serial Killer Files. New York: Ballantine Books.

United States District Court, Northern District of California (1973) People v. Mullin, trial transcripts.

Wilson, C. and Wilson, D. (2007) The World’s Most Evil Murderers. London: John Blake Publishing.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
Visit our Immortalis horror fiction universe at https://immortalishorror.com