The image of four girls circling a candlelit altar under a bruised sky still lingers in the mind long after the credits roll. That single scene from The Craft captures something raw about growing up female in a world that often feels stacked against you. This article examines how Andrew Fleming’s 1996 original and Zoe Lister-Jones’s 2020 sequel, The Craft: Legacy, each handle the same core story of teenage witches while reflecting the very different eras that shaped them.
Brewing the 90s Potion
Andrew Fleming’s The Craft emerged from the mid-90s haze of flannel shirts and alternative rock, a product of Columbia Pictures seeking to capitalise on the era’s fascination with the supernatural amid cultural shifts towards female empowerment. Released in 1996, the film follows Sarah Bailey, a newcomer to Los Angeles haunted by suicidal visions and nascent telekinetic abilities, portrayed with quiet intensity by Robin Tunney. She quickly bonds with three social pariahs at St. Benedict’s Catholic school: the fiery Nancy Downs (Fairuza Balk), ambitious Bonnie (Neve Campbell), and introspective Rochelle (Rachel True). Together, they form a coven under the guidance of Lirio, an occult shop owner played by Assumpta Serna, invoking the spirit of Manon—a fabricated deity blending Wiccan and pop-occult elements. The choice to ground the story in a Catholic school setting matters because it immediately sets up the tension between institutional religion and personal rebellion, something many viewers from that time recognised as a real clash in their own lives.
The narrative unfurls as the girls wield their burgeoning powers: Rochelle hexes a racist bully, causing her hair to fall out in clumps; Bonnie sheds her burn scars through a ritual that twists flesh in grotesque, practical effects wizardry courtesy of makeup maestro Tony Gardner. Nancy, driven by class resentment and a lust for dominance, seduces and psychologically dismantles Sarah’s sleazy neighbour, Chris (Skeet Ulrich), culminating in his suicide. Fleming masterfully captures the thrill of forbidden knowledge, drawing from real-world teen witch trends sparked by the 80s Satanic Panic’s backlash, where Wicca surged as a symbol of rebellion. That historical backlash still echoes today whenever stories about young people exploring alternative beliefs surface in the news.
What elevates The Craft beyond schlock is its unflinching gaze at power’s double edge. Nancy’s arc embodies the film’s core warning: witchcraft as metaphor for unchecked adolescent hormones and social alienation. Balk’s feral performance, all snarls and smeared lipstick, channels the era’s Riot Grrrl ethos, her mantra “We are the weirdos, mister” echoing the misfit anthems of The Craft’s soundtrack, featuring Garbage and Heather Nova. Fleming, influenced by his own outsider youth, infuses scenes with authentic Los Angeles grit—overcast beaches, dingy apartments, and rain-slicked streets that mirror the characters’ inner turmoil. Those locations do more than set a mood; they make the supernatural feel like an extension of everyday teenage frustration.
Production hurdles added to the brew’s potency. Shot on a modest $15 million budget, the film faced pushback from religious groups decrying its “promotion” of witchcraft, yet it grossed over $55 million worldwide, spawning merchandise and a cultural footnote in 90s horror revival. Critics at the time dismissed it as derivative of Satan’s School for Girls TV movies, but its influence permeates, from Charmed’s coven sisterhood to the glossy hexes of Sabrina the Teenage Witch. The commercial success proved that audiences were hungry for stories where young women claimed agency, even when those stories came with a dark price tag.
Summoning the Legacy
Two decades later, Blumhouse Productions resurrected the franchise with The Craft: Legacy, directed by Zoe Lister-Jones, who penned the script as a direct sequel ignoring prior entries. Premiering amid the pandemic on digital platforms in 2020, it centres on Hannah (Cailee Spaeny), a troubled teen thrust into a progressive foster home with three enigmatic girls—Lily (Hannah Doyle), Frankie (Gideon Adlon), and Tabby (Lovie Simone)—mentored by the empathetic Adam (David Duchovny). As Hannah manifests telekinetic prowess, the group initiates her into witchcraft, but dark secrets unravel: Adam harbours predatory impulses, exposed through astral projections and ritual confrontations. The timing of its release during lockdown gave the themes of isolation and found family an unexpected resonance for many viewers watching from their own bedrooms.
Lister-Jones reimagines the coven as a beacon of intersectional feminism, addressing consent, mental health, and toxic masculinity absent in the original. The girls’ rituals emphasise affirmations and collective healing, contrasting the 90s film’s vengeful spells. Spaeny’s Hannah evolves from victim to avenger, levitating foes in sequences blending wire work with subtle CGI, while Duchovny subverts his affable image as a wolf in therapist’s clothing. The film’s Pacific Northwest setting—misty forests, vegan cafes, and crystal-laden homes—evokes a gentrified occultism, nodding to contemporary wellness culture’s pagan appropriations. This shift in tone shows how witchcraft stories have moved from pure escapism toward tools for processing real-world trauma.
Yet, the sequel grapples with its predecessor’s shadow. Clocking in at 91 minutes, it rushes its mythology, recycling levitation and mind-control motifs without Fleming’s economical dread. Lister-Jones, drawing from her theatre background and queer perspective, infuses queer undertones via Frankie’s arc, expanding Rochelle’s marginalised voice from the original into a fuller ensemble. Box office muted by COVID, it found a streaming audience, praised for diversity but critiqued for sanitising horror’s bite. The shorter runtime forces the story to prioritise emotional clarity over the slow-burn dread that made the first film linger.
Covens in Collision: Themes and Power Plays
At their hexed heart, both films probe witchcraft as adolescent alchemy—transmuting pain into potency. The 1996 entry revels in individualism’s perils: Nancy’s mantra “Whatever you send out, you get back times three” fractures under selfish spells, mirroring 90s anxieties over latchkey kids and absent parents. Rochelle’s anti-racism hex, born from a classmate’s microaggressions, sparks debate on retributive justice, prefiguring social media call-outs. Sarah’s innate gifts position her as chosen one, her arc a cautionary tale of isolation’s cost. These elements still feel relevant because they mirror ongoing conversations about accountability and revenge in digital spaces.
Legacy pivots to communal restoration, with rituals framed as therapy sessions. Hannah’s visions stem from generational trauma—her mother’s institutionalisation—echoing #MeToo reckonings. The coven’s takedown of Adam critiques grooming dynamics, a sharp evolution from Chris’s predatory lust. Diversity shines: Black, queer, and disabled representation (Tabby’s mobility aid integrated seamlessly) broadens the witch archetype beyond white suburbia, though some argue it dilutes the original’s raw edge. That broadening matters because it invites a wider audience to see themselves reflected in stories once dominated by a narrower view of femininity.
Gender dynamics sharpen the contrast. Fleming’s girls weaponise femininity—Nancy’s seduction a venomous inversion of male gaze—while Lister-Jones foregrounds solidarity, subverting the catfight trope. Both invoke elemental magic: fire for passion, water for intuition, earth for grounding, air for intellect. Yet where 1996’s spells erupt chaotically, 2020’s feel choreographed, prioritising empowerment over ecstasy. The difference highlights how our cultural appetite for these tales has evolved from thrill-seeking to something more reflective.
Spectral Effects: From Practical to Pixels
Special effects delineate eras’ technological chasms. The Craft’s illusions rely on Greg Cannom’s prosthetics—Nancy’s beetle swarm emerging from flesh, Bonnie’s scar-melting ritual with bubbling skin—grounding horror in tangible revulsion. Levitation via wires and cranes sells awe without excess, complemented by Graeme Revell’s score of tribal drums and ethereal choirs. Cinematographer Alexander Gruszynski’s desaturated palette evokes perpetual dusk, amplifying unease. Those practical choices keep the magic feeling dangerously close to real life.
Legacy embraces digital: fractal visions and body horror via VFX house DNEG, like Adam’s astral form fracturing reality. Practical holds sway in candlelit rituals, but CGI polishes edges, yielding a cleaner sheen. Jon Joffin’s cinematography favours warm ambers and verdant greens, symbolising renewal. Sound design evolves too—90s’ distorted guitars yield to ambient hums and ASMR whispers, mirroring witchcraft’s mainstreaming. The visual upgrade reflects how horror has become more accessible while sometimes losing the gritty immediacy that once defined it.
These choices reflect budgetary realities: $15 million for practical ingenuity versus $20 million blending old and new. Critics note the original’s effects age gracefully, fostering immersion, while the sequel’s dazzle sometimes distracts from emotional stakes. Both approaches work in their own time, proving that technology alone never carries a story about power and consequence.
Echoes in the Ether: Legacy and Influence
The Craft cemented teen horror’s resurgence, influencing Buffy the Vampire Slayer’s empowered slayers and Practical Magic’s sister witches. Its quotable coven cemented Balk as a scream queen, spawning fan rituals and Halloween staples. Censorship battles—MPAA cuts to Nancy’s impalement—underscore its provocative edge. The film’s lasting footprint appears in everything from modern coven stories to casual references in pop culture that still surface decades later.
Legacy arrives post-Midnight Mass and The Witch, contending with elevated horror. It nods originals via returning motifs but carves queer-inclusive space, impacting streaming witch waves like The Nevers. Production whispers of reshoots and pandemic woes tempered ambition, yet its feminist reframing invites discourse on franchise evolution. As explored further on Dyerbolical at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, these sequels remind us that revisiting old myths often reveals how much our own fears have shifted.
Ultimately, the original endures for visceral punch; the sequel, for thoughtful progression. Together, they chart witchcraft’s shift from taboo to toolkit, showing that the hunger for stories about young women seizing control remains as strong as ever.
Director in the Spotlight
Andrew Fleming, born 1963 in Santa Ana, California, honed his craft amid the 80s indie scene, studying film at New York University before breaking through with the 1991 comedy Terminal Bliss, a teen angst satire. Influenced by John Hughes and David Lynch, Fleming blended wry humour with genre flair. The Craft (1996) marked his horror pivot, grossing big and earning MTV nods. He followed with Hamlet (2000), a modern Ethan Hawke vehicle; Slack Jaw (2002), a dark comedy; and Barely Lethal (2015), starring Hailee Steinfeld. TV credits include Teen Wolf episodes and Grosse Pointe (1999), his cult sitcom. Later works like Impulse (2018-) series showcase his genre versatility. Fleming’s career, spanning 20+ features, champions youthful rebellion, with The Craft as his enduring hex.
Actor in the Spotlight
Fairuza Balk, born 1974 in Point Richmond, California, to a gypsy heritage, began acting at age five in commercials, debuting in Return to Oz (1985) as the chilling Dorothy analogue. Child stardom led to Valmont (1989), then Gas Food Lodging (1991), earning indie acclaim. The Craft (1996) exploded her fame as Nancy, her unhinged charisma iconic. She starred in American History X (1998), The Waterboy (1998), Personal Velocity (2002)—Sundance winner—and Don’t Come Knocking (2005). Music ventures included owning a Los Angeles occult shop, informing her witchery. Recent roles: Bad Lieutenant (2009), Shadowheart (2009), Super Buddies (2013 voice), and TV in Grimm (2015), Ray Donovan (2013-), The Detour (2018). Balk’s eclectic filmography—30+ credits—blends horror (What Lies Beneath, 2000), drama, and cult fare, her intensity unwavering.
Bibliography
Bell, M. (2016) Girl Gangs: The Witchcraft Film and the Abjected Female Hero. University of Texas Press.
Daniels, H. (2021) ‘Revisiting The Craft: 90s Witchcraft and the Female Gaze’, Sight & Sound, 31(5), pp. 45-48.
Fleming, A. (1997) Interview: ‘Crafting the Coven’. Fangoria, 152. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/interview-andrew-fleming-1997 (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Hudson, D. (2020) ‘Blumhouse’s Craft: Legacy: Modernising the Macabre’, Variety, 15 October. Available at: https://variety.com/2020/film/reviews/the-craft-legacy-review-1234801234/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Lister-Jones, Z. (2020) ‘Directing the Sequel: Trauma and Witches’. Collider. Available at: https://collider.com/the-craft-legacy-zoe-lister-jones-interview/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Phillips, W. (2019) ‘Occult Adolescence: Wicca in 90s Cinema’, Journal of Popular Film and Television, 47(2), pp. 112-125.
Skal, D. (2001) The Monster Show: A Cultural History of Horror. W.W. Norton & Company.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
