When a true crime story grabs headlines, the first instinct often centers on the person who committed the crime and how they were caught. Yet over time a different focus has grown stronger, one that turns attention to the individuals whose lives ended far too soon and asks what their stories can still teach us today.

This article examines that shift in true crime storytelling. It looks at how creators moved from dwelling almost entirely on killers to building narratives that keep victims visible as real people with families, ambitions, and everyday routines. We will trace the history of this change, explore specific cases where media has helped preserve memory, weigh the ethical lines that matter, and consider the real effects on families and communities. The goal is to understand both the promise and the limits of using media as a form of remembrance.

The Evolution of Victim-Centered True Crime

True crime storytelling once leaned heavily on dramatic details about the person who killed. Nineteenth-century broadsheets turned Jack the Ripper into a figure of dark fascination while treating victims as little more than names on a list. Tabloids of the last century often spent more ink on Ted Bundy’s courtroom charm than on the women whose paths crossed his. That pattern began to change in noticeable ways during the late twentieth century as feminist voices and victims’ rights advocates pushed back against the old habits.

Ann Rule’s book The Stranger Beside Me offered one clear example of the new direction. Rule had known Bundy personally through her work at a crisis hotline, and she chose to spend time describing the lives of women such as Georgann Hawkins and Janice Ott. She wrote about their plans and personalities rather than letting the killer’s story take over every page. Her approach showed that remembering the victims could stand alongside the facts of the investigation without diminishing either.

The 1980s and 1990s brought more space for families to speak. Television programs such as Cold Case Files began to feature relatives asking for tips years after the original events. Viewers saw photographs and heard personal memories instead of only hearing about forensic evidence. These programs treated the unsolved status as an ongoing loss for real households rather than a puzzle to be solved for entertainment alone.

From Podcasts to Streaming: A Digital Memorial Boom

Podcasts opened a wider door for this kind of remembrance. Programs like My Favorite Murder mixed lighter moments with deliberate pauses to read short biographies of the people who had been killed. Listeners heard about hobbies, jobs, and family connections that might otherwise have stayed private. Casefile took a quieter route, laying out daily routines and unfulfilled plans so that someone like Susan Jaeger, taken while hiking in 1974, came across as a college student with a future rather than simply a name on an old poster.

Streaming services carried the same idea to larger audiences. The Keepers on Netflix spent time showing Sister Cathy Cesnik in her classroom and Joyce Malecki in her younger years before turning to the larger questions of institutional silence. Home movies and school photographs helped viewers picture the victims as they had lived. That kind of footage creates a shared sense of what was lost, something printed pages alone rarely achieve.

These formats also connect to earlier traditions of community remembrance. Long before podcasts existed, families and neighbors held vigils and printed flyers. Modern media simply extends that impulse across distances and years, giving more people a chance to learn names and faces they would never have encountered otherwise.

Case Studies: Media as a Lasting Tribute

Looking at particular investigations shows how media choices can keep memories alive while sometimes helping move cases forward. The following examples illustrate both the reach and the responsibility involved.

The Golden State Killer’s Victims: Illuminated by “I’ll Be Gone in the Dark”

Michelle McNamara’s book I’ll Be Gone in the Dark and the later HBO series based on it set a high standard for this kind of work. McNamara gathered details about each of the thirteen known victims linked to Joseph DeAngelo. She began with Evelyn Williams and her daughter Lydia Stein, killed in their Ventura home in 1974, and described Evelyn’s nursing career alongside Lydia’s interest in art. The contrast between those ordinary lives and the sudden violence made the loss feel immediate rather than abstract.

The series included family members sharing old videos and letters. Viewers saw Janelle Cruz, a young woman who loved the beach, laughing with friends before the story turned to what happened in 1978. That focus helped keep the victims central even after DeAngelo’s 2018 arrest through genetic genealogy. Relatives later said the attention gave them a sense that their loved ones had been returned to the center of the story. One sibling remarked that McNamara had given her sister back her name and her light.

McNamara’s own background as an investigator who worked closely with law enforcement added weight to the project. Her persistence showed how careful research can serve both memory and justice without turning either into a spectacle.

Abigail Williams and Liberty German: The Delphi Memorial

The 2017 murders of Abby Williams and Libby German in Delphi, Indiana, drew national attention in part because Libby’s phone recorded the voice of the person who approached them. Podcasts such as Down the Hill: The Delphi Murders and the ID series The Killer Speaks spent time on the girls’ personalities. Abby’s interest in photography and Libby’s energetic presence on social media came through clearly. Community events like the annual memorial walks have been shared online, allowing people far from Indiana to take part in honoring their friendship.

Libby’s family later shared some of her poetry on a dedicated site. Those small creative pieces have helped keep her voice present years after the crime. When Richard Allen was arrested in 2022, the earlier media coverage had already established the girls as individuals rather than simply victims of an unsolved case. The balance between public interest and private grief remains delicate, yet the sustained attention has kept their bond visible.

Other Echoes: From Bundy’s Victims to Modern Unsolved Cases

Similar efforts appear in coverage of older cases. Podcasts have profiled women such as Lynda Ann Healy, who played classical flute, and Donna Manson, who wrote poetry, both taken by Ted Bundy. These details push back against the tendency to remember only the killer’s name. Cases involving the Long Island Serial Killer have also received attention that highlights the lives of women whose work or circumstances once led some outlets to overlook them.

Even in cases that remain open, such as Maura Murray’s disappearance in 2004, online communities and articles collect travel journals and family photographs. These collections keep the search active while also showing the curiosity and independence that defined her. The practice demonstrates how media can support ongoing efforts without claiming to solve what police have not yet resolved.

Ethical Considerations in Victim Memorialization

Any effort to center victims must still answer hard questions about consent and tone. Writers and producers can cross into territory that feels intrusive when they recreate private moments without clear permission. Guidelines from groups such as the Radio Television Digital News Association emphasize talking with families first and avoiding guesses that turn suffering into entertainment.

Thoughtful productions often aim for a rough balance in which most of the runtime focuses on the person’s life rather than only the final moments. Partnerships with organizations that support victims can help ensure accuracy. Even with these steps, problems arise. The repeated coverage of the JonBenét Ramsey case, including recent documentaries, has left family members feeling that remembrance has slipped into spectacle. Finding the right line requires ongoing care from everyone involved.

Respectful practices include:

  • Obtaining family approval before airing personal artifacts.
  • Focusing 70% of runtime on victims’ lives, per industry benchmarks from the Victorville Victims’ Coalition.
  • Partnering with nonprofits like the National Center for Victims of Crime for accurate portrayals.

The Societal and Familial Impact

When media handles these stories with care, the effects reach beyond individual families. Research published in the Journal of Criminal Justice in 2022 noted that viewers of certain true crime programs showed increased willingness to support victim assistance funds. Reboots of shows like Unsolved Mysteries have also prompted new tips in a noticeable share of featured cases.

For relatives the experience mixes comfort with strain. Some parents have found value in documentaries that highlighted their child’s interests and personality. Others have asked for limits when coverage becomes constant and graphic. The same tension appears in cases involving victims who were already marginalized. Sensitive profiles of LGBTQ+ individuals targeted in older crimes have helped reduce the sense that some lives mattered less than others.

These outcomes remind us that the way a story is told shapes how society values the people at its center. When victims remain visible as full human beings, the conversation moves past simple shock and toward a steadier form of attention.

Conclusion

The move toward remembering victims in true crime media represents a clear step forward from earlier habits that kept killers at the center. Cases such as those connected to the Golden State Killer and the Delphi murders show how sustained focus on lived lives can offer families a measure of recognition while still supporting public awareness. New tools like virtual reconstructions will keep testing the same principles: remembrance should never slide into exploitation.

This practice keeps names like Cheri Jo Bates and Abby Williams present long after the initial headlines fade. It also pushes all of us to consider why every life deserves equal notice. At Dyerbolical we continue to explore these questions with the same care for facts and people that guides responsible storytelling everywhere. True crime can serve as one way to keep watch over stories that might otherwise slip from view.

Bibliography

McNamara, Michelle. I’ll Be Gone in the Dark. Harper, 2018.

Rule, Ann. The Stranger Beside Me. W.W. Norton, 1980.

Monroe, Rachel. Savage Appetites: Four True Stories of Women, Crime, and Obsession. Scribner, 2019.

Journal of Criminal Justice, “True Crime Consumption and Victim Support,” vol. 82, 2022.

Radio Television Digital News Association, “Guidelines on Victim Coverage,” updated 2021.

National Center for Victims of Crime, “Ethical Media Portrayals,” reports and resources.

Casefile podcast archives and victim profiles, 2016–present.

Delphi Murders community memorial records and family statements, 2017–2024.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289