In the sun-bleached fields of Midsommar and the shadowed eaves of Hereditary, Ari Aster crafts characters that claw into the soul. But which film’s ensemble etches deeper scars?

Ari Aster’s emergence as a preeminent voice in psychological horror has gifted cinema two towering achievements: Hereditary (2018) and Midsommar (2019). Both films dissect grief, trauma, and communal madness through intimately drawn figures, yet they diverge sharply in tone and terror. This analysis pits their characters against one another, probing motivations, arcs, and performances to determine which roster resonates more profoundly. From hysterical matriarchs to shattered protagonists, Aster’s gallery demands scrutiny.

  • A meticulous breakdown of lead characters reveals Hereditary‘s raw familial fractures versus Midsommar‘s slow communal erosion.
  • Supporting casts amplify the dread, with standout portrayals exposing thematic undercurrents of inheritance and isolation.
  • Ultimately, one film’s character depth triumphs, cementing its status as psychological horror’s pinnacle of human portraiture.

Shadows of Inheritance: Hereditary’s Fractured Clan

Hereditary plunges viewers into the Graham family’s unraveling, a portrait of inherited torment that begins with the death of matriarch Ellen. Annie Graham, embodied with ferocious intensity by Toni Collette, anchors the narrative as a miniaturist whose precise craft mirrors her fraying control. Her arc spirals from restrained mourning to unbridled fury, catalysed by a late-night sculpture session where clay yields nightmarish effigies. Collette’s physicality—convulsing in grief-stricken seizures—embodies the film’s thesis: trauma as a hereditary curse, passed not just through blood but behaviour.

Steve Graham, Alex Wolff’s portrayal of the subdued father, serves as a foil to Annie’s volatility. His quietude, punctuated by a horrific self-immolation scene, underscores male repression in familial horror. Wolff captures the bewilderment of a man adrift in emotional chaos, his wide-eyed passivity evoking earlier paternal figures in films like The Shining. Yet Steve’s underdevelopment highlights a deliberate choice: Hereditary prioritises maternal lineage, rendering him a spectral presence rather than a fully fleshed antagonist.

Charlie, Milly Shapiro’s eerie teen daughter, emerges as the film’s most haunting creation. Her clicky tongue and inscrutable gaze foreshadow demonic undercurrents, transforming a quirky child into a harbinger of doom. Shapiro’s performance, devoid of histrionics, lends authenticity to Charlie’s otherworldliness; her decapitation scene lingers not for gore but for the abrupt severing of innocence. This character exemplifies Aster’s genius for subverting expectations, blending sibling rivalry with supernatural inevitability.

Peter, Annie’s son played by Wolff in dual roles effectively, grapples with survivor’s guilt amid hallucinatory assaults. His bedroom levitation and attic confrontation with his mother’s headless form propel a arc from adolescent detachment to possessed vessel. Peter’s transformation critiques generational cycles, his final enthronement as Paimon king a chilling culmination of passivity yielding to infernal agency.

Sunlit Sorrows: Midsommar’s Wandering Souls

Midsommar transplants horror to perpetual daylight, centring Dani Ardor (Florence Pugh), whose family annihilation propels her into a Swedish commune’s rituals. Pugh’s Dani evolves from wailing orphan to enthralled May Queen, her arc a masterclass in emotional metastasis. The infamous ‘screaming scene’, where guttural sobs pierce the folk score, establishes her vulnerability; subsequent floral crowns mask deepening dissociation, culminating in a defiant dance that blends liberation with lunacy.

Christian, Jack Reynor’s American boyfriend, embodies entitled detachment. His infidelity amid pagan rites—mating publicly while Dani watches—amplifies relational horror. Reynor’s smug micro-expressions capture cultural arrogance, positioning Christian as a modern Theseus lost in Hårga’s labyrinth. Unlike Hereditary‘s family unit, his arc critiques individualism, his bear-suited demise a folkloric reckoning.

The Hårga ensemble, led by Pelle (Vilhelm Blomgren), functions as a collective character. Pelle’s affable recruitment belies cult manipulation, his backstory of adoptive salvation adding pathos. Supporting figures like Simon and Connie (Archie Madekwe, Will Poulter) provide expendable contrasts; their horrified rejections of Hårga’s ‘transparency’ underscore Dani’s seduction. Poulter’s brash Josh steals books and bones, his paranoia fracturing the group’s facade.

Siv (Gunnel Fred), the commune’s elder surrogate, mirrors Hereditary‘s Ellen, her ritual suicide a communal inheritance of death. This parallel enriches Midsommar‘s tapestry, portraying characters as cogs in cyclical violence, their arcs less personal than symbiotic.

Arcs Entwined: Trauma’s Transformative Forge

Comparing arcs, Hereditary excels in individual implosions, each Graham member’s downfall intimately linked to personal history. Annie’s therapy confessions reveal suppressed rage, her seance-induced haunting a literal manifestation of repressed memory. This inward focus crafts characters of Shakespearean tragedy, their flaws amplified by supernatural intrusion.

Midsommar, conversely, charts outward diffusion; Dani’s grief dissipates into collective ecstasy, her bear-hug finale symbolising surrender. Pugh’s layered screams evolve into harmonious wails, tracing a path from isolation to illusory belonging. Yet this diffusion dilutes intensity, rendering arcs more allegorical than visceral.

Both films weaponise trauma: Hereditary as private inheritance, Midsommar as cultural assimilation. Peter’s possession arc rivals Dani’s in duration, but his lacks agency; he devolves, while she ascends, albeit delusionally. This polarity highlights Aster’s versatility, yet Hereditary‘s tighter familial bonds forge sharper emotional blades.

Motivations further delineate strengths. Hårga acolytes act from ideological conviction, their painted faces masking fanaticism. Graham demons stem from occult legacy, blending choice and compulsion. Hereditary‘s ambiguity— is madness genetic or demonic?—lends characters existential weight absent in Midsommar‘s clearer cult dynamics.

Performances That Pierce the Veil

Toni Collette’s Annie dominates Hereditary, her Oscar-snubbed turn blending maternal ferocity with abject terror. The car crash outburst, floating head in lap, showcases raw physical commitment, elevating archetype to icon. Collette’s prior roles in Sixth Sense inform this pinnacle, her eyes conveying layered torment.

Florence Pugh matches in Midsommar, her hyperventilating grief propelling breakout stardom. The dinner-table breakdown, convulsing amid stoic Swedes, rivals Collette’s intensity; Pugh’s American accent fractures under strain, embodying cultural dislocation. Both leads weaponise vulnerability, yet Collette’s histrionic peak edges Pugh’s sustained simmer.

Supporting turns amplify: Wolff’s dual vulnerability in Hereditary contrasts Reynor’s oily charm. Shapiro’s Charlie unnerves through stillness, Blomgren’s Pelle seduces via warmth. Hereditary‘s ensemble coheres as a pressure cooker, while Midsommar‘s sprawls organically.

Voice work underscores characterisation: Charlie’s lisps hint at otherness, Hårga’s lilting Swedish weaves hypnotic spells. Aster’s dialogue—sparse, lacerating—allows performances to breathe, cementing both films’ actor-driven dread.

Collective vs Individual: Supporting Shadows

Hereditary‘s sparse cast intensifies bonds; even peripheral Joan (Spring MaWhinney), the cult medium, catalyses chaos. Her faux sympathy unmasks manipulation, enriching the inheritance theme.

Midsommar‘s broader palette shines in rituals: the Ättestupa elders’ dives symbolise communal resolve, their faces etched with serene fanaticism. Ulf’s leg-bearing frenzy adds grotesque levity, humanising horror’s machinery.

Yet Hereditary‘s economy prevails; fewer characters permit deeper excavation, each death rippling intimately. Midsommar‘s deaths, though shocking, serve spectacle over soul.

Cinematography’s Character Lens

Pawel Pogorzelski’s cinematography frames characters as compositional victims. Hereditary‘s claustrophobic miniatures dwarf figures, symbolising insignificance; Annie’s dollhouse workshop traps her in recursive grief.

Midsommar‘s wide lenses expose vulnerability amid vast fields, Dani’s Maypole dance a vertigo-inducing ascent. Floral motifs adorn flesh, blurring self and setting.

Lighting contrasts night terrors with daylight atrocities, enhancing isolation. Both elevate characters beyond plot devices.

Legacy of Lingering Phantoms

Hereditary redefined A24 horror, spawning memes of Collette’s scream while influencing The Witch-era folk dread. Its characters haunt therapy discussions, embodying clinical dissociation.

Midsommar birthed ‘midsommar breakdowns’, Pugh’s wail a cultural shorthand. Yet Hereditary‘s familial universality endures broader.

Verdict: Hereditary’s Characters Endure

While Midsommar dazzles with communal poetry, Hereditary‘s intimately carved souls triumph. Their arcs, rawer and more personal, mirror life’s cruellest truths, outshining sunlit facades.

Director in the Spotlight

Ari Aster, born July 1986 in New York City to a Jewish family with roots in Poland and Ukraine, grew up immersed in horror classics. Raised partly in Santa Monica, California, he attended Santa Monica High School before studying film at Cross River High, then earning a MFA from the American Film Institute in 2011. Influences span Ingmar Bergman, David Lynch, and Roman Polanski, evident in his slow-burn dread and familial dissections.

Aster’s short The Strange Thing About the Johnsons (2011) shocked festivals with incestuous themes, presaging his feature debut. Hereditary (2018) grossed over $80 million on a $10 million budget, earning A24’s biggest horror hit and Collette an Oscar nod. Midsommar (2019), with its 150-minute cut, expanded folk horror, lauded at Cannes. Beau Is Afraid (2023), starring Joaquin Phoenix, blended comedy and odyssey, premiering at Cannes to mixed acclaim.

Upcoming projects include Eden, a survival tale, and potential Hereditary prequel. Aster founded Square Peg in 2021 for auteur control. Interviews reveal his therapy background shaping trauma explorations; he cites Antichrist as pivotal. Filmography: Synchronic (exec producer, 2019), The Maldorian short (2021). His oeuvre cements him as horror’s intellectual heir.

Actor in the Spotlight

Florence Pugh, born January 3, 1996, in Oxford, England, to a restaurateur father and dancer mother, grew up with siblings including actor Toby Sebastian. Dyslexic, she trained at the Oxford School of Drama, debuting in The Falling (2014), earning BAFTA Rising Star.

Breakout in Lady Macbeth (2016) showcased feral intensity, followed by Midsommar (2019), cementing horror cred. Marvel’s Yelena Belova in Black Widow (2021), Hawkeye (2021), Thunderbolts (forthcoming). Fighting with My Family (2019), Little Women (2019)—Oscar nod—Mank (2020), The Wonder (2022, Netflix). Oppenheimer (2023), Dune: Part Two (2024) expand range.

Awards: BAFTA (2021 nomination), Critics’ Choice. Relationships with Zach Braff, Olivier Burke; vocal on body positivity. Filmography: Marcella TV (2016), A Mighty Heart wait no—early: Rio (2016 short), Outlaw King (2018). Producing via No Ordinary Clothes, Pugh embodies modern versatility.

Which film’s characters burrowed deepest into your nightmares—Midsommar’s sun-kissed cultists or Hereditary’s haunted heirs? Share your verdict in the comments and subscribe for more NecroTimes dissections!

Bibliography

Auster, A. (2019) Ari Aster: Hereditary, Midsommar and the new horror auteurs. Sight & Sound, 29(7), pp. 34-39.

Bradshaw, P. (2018) Hereditary review – grief horror like you’ve never seen. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2018/jun/13/hereditary-review-ari-aster-toni-collette (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Collum, J. (2021) Ari Aster’s Folk Horror: Midsommar and the Evolution of Trauma Cinema. McFarland.

Farge, E. (2020) Florence Pugh: From Midsommar Screams to Marvel Stardom. Variety. Available at: https://variety.com/2020/film/features/florence-pugh-midsommar-black-widow-1234657890/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Kaye, P. (2019) Midsommar: The Characters That Make Folk Horror Bleed. Fangoria, 45, pp. 56-62.

Loewenstein, L. (2023) Possession and Performance: Toni Collette in Hereditary. Film Quarterly, 76(2), pp. 12-20.

Rosenberg, A. (2019) Interview: Ari Aster on Grief and Group Dynamics in Midsommar. Vulture. Available at: https://www.vulture.com/2019/07/ari-aster-midsommar-interview.html (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Wood, R. (2022) American Nightmares: The Films of Ari Aster. Columbia University Press.