Picture a mother staring into the dark after loss has already taken everything she held close, only to find that darkness staring back with a voice of its own. That image sits at the heart of two standout modern horror films that turn private pain into something far larger and more unsettling.

This piece compares Jennifer Kent’s The Babadook from 2014 with Ari Aster’s Hereditary from 2018. Both stories use supernatural elements to explore how grief can reshape a family, how motherhood carries its own quiet terrors, and how trauma can echo across generations. The goal is to weigh their approaches side by side while keeping every original detail and reference in place.

Emergence from Darkness: Origins and Foundations

The genesis of these films mirrors their thematic intensity. The Babadook sprang from Jennifer Kent’s feature directorial debut, born from her short film Monster from 2005, which explored a single mother’s anguish. Kent crafted a low-budget Australian production, shot in Adelaide, where the titular pop-up book becomes a vessel for suppressed sorrow. Amelia, played by Essie Davis, widowed by a car crash, and her son Samuel, played by Noah Wiseman, encounter the Babadook, a top-hatted ghoul symbolising her unprocessed grief. The narrative unfolds in their claustrophobic home, amplifying isolation’s horrors.

In contrast, Hereditary marked Ari Aster’s first feature after shorts like The Strange Thing About the Johnsons from 2011. Produced by A24 with a higher budget, it delves into the Graham family’s unraveling post-teen daughter Charlie’s decapitation in a car accident, a chilling echo of The Babadook’s inciting tragedy. Annie, played by Toni Collette, her husband Steve, played by Gabriel Byrne, son Peter, played by Alex Wolff, and mother Ellen, played by Kathleen Chalfant and uncredited initially, grapple with escalating madness. Aster weaves Paimon worship, a demon from occult lore, into generational curses, expanding grief into cosmic inevitability.

Production hurdles shaped both. Kent battled funding woes, relying on practical effects and shadowy cinematography by Radek Ladczuk to evoke dread without gore. Aster faced A24’s trust in his vision, employing elaborate miniatures for Charlie’s decapitation scene and Pawel Pogorzelski’s Steadicam work to mimic familial entrapment. These origins ground the themes: The Babadook as personal exorcism, Hereditary as inescapable lineage.

Legends underpin each. The Babadook draws from silent-era German expressionism like Der Golem from 1920, while Hereditary nods to Rosemary’s Baby from 1968 and possession films. Yet both innovate, rooting folklore in therapy-speak realism. As explored further on Dyerbolical at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, these choices show how directors can turn familiar fears into something freshly personal.

Grief Incarnate: The Monster Within

Central to both is grief’s personification. In The Babadook, the creature manifests literally from a children’s book, its jerky movements and gravelly voice, “If it’s in a word, or in a look, you can’t get rid of the Babadook,” embodying depression’s persistence. Amelia’s denial evolves into acceptance; she feeds the monster basement scraps, a poignant metaphor for managing mental illness. Kent draws from real psychology, where grief stages such as denial, anger, and bargaining mirror the film’s acts.

Hereditary elevates this to collective torment. Grief fractures the Grahams individually. Annie’s sleepwalking sews her mouth shut, Peter’s guilt induces seizures, and Steve combusts from shock. Paimon, summoned via Ellen’s cult, amplifies loss into predestined horror. Aster references Freudian mourning and melancholia, where unresolved grief turns pathological, but adds hereditary doom through family miniatures that foreshadow sculpted fates.

Comparison reveals The Babadook’s intimacy. One mother’s battle yields resolution, offering hope. Hereditary denies closure; Peter’s possession crowns endless cycles. The former heals, the latter consumes. Hereditary’s bleakness hits harder thematically. Sound design reinforces this difference. The Babadook’s scraping claws and whispers build paranoia, while Hereditary’s clacks from Charlie’s tongue and orchestral swells by Colin Stetson evoke inevitability.

Mothers at the Abyss: Maternal Torment

Motherhood forms the thematic core. Amelia’s exhaustion with Samuel’s hyperactivity stems from widowhood’s toll, her screams of “I am tired!” raw pleas amid societal expectations. Davis’s performance, all tremors and hollow eyes, captures postpartum despair blended with grief. Kent critiques isolation, where single mothers bear unseen burdens.

Annie’s arc plunges deeper. Crafting dolls as proxies, she attends grief groups yet snaps, clapping Peter’s head in a car door unknowingly, a Freudian slip of rage. Collette’s Oscar-snubbed turn mixes hysteria and pathos, her attic confrontation with her mother exposing inherited madness. Aster probes generational trauma, questioning nature versus nurture in maternal failure.

The Babadook empowers Amelia through confrontation; she reclaims agency. Hereditary indicts her passivity, participating unwittingly in Paimon’s ritual. Hereditary’s theme pierces motherhood’s myth of protection, revealing complicity in doom. Gender dynamics shine here as both films challenge the strong mother trope, but Hereditary indicts patriarchal cults exploiting female vessels.

Inheritance of Madness: Family Curses

The Babadook confines trauma to the nuclear family, resolvable individually. Samuel aids Amelia, forging bonds through horror. Themes stress communication’s role in healing. Hereditary expands to lineage. Ellen’s letters reveal cult machinations, Peter’s visions link to Charlie’s seizures. Aster explores epigenetic trauma and mental illness passed down. The finale’s head-clasping pose echoes Charlie’s death, cyclical horror unmatched.

This breadth gives Hereditary the edge. Themes encompass fate, free will, and absent fathers as Byrne’s Steve dies early. The Babadook feels like personal therapy while Hereditary delivers existential dread.

Cinematography’s Grip: Visual Dread

Ladczuk’s frames in The Babadook use shadows and Dutch angles. The house becomes a character as pop-up book pages invade reality via overlays. Tight close-ups on Amelia’s cracking facade heighten claustrophobia. Pogorzelski’s Hereditary employs long takes, like the post-party drive, building unease. Light flares symbolise possession while miniatures dwarf humans, underscoring insignificance. Hereditary’s formalism through symmetrical compositions fracturing mirrors thematic collapse, surpassing The Babadook’s expressionism.

Effects and Artifice: Crafting the Uncanny

Practical effects dominate. The Babadook’s suit actor Robert Sheehan contorts unnaturally while book animations remain handmade. No CGI ensures tactile terror. Hereditary innovates with an animatronic Charlie head that decapitates convincingly, flame effects and levitations that blend prosthetics with subtle digital work. Aster’s miniatures, burned live, evoke fragility. Both shun jump scares for unease, but Hereditary’s scale with Paimon’s temple amplifies thematic grandeur.

Performances that Haunt: Human Core

Davis anchors The Babadook. Her transformation from brittle to feral feels visceral. Wiseman’s unhinged energy grounds the supernaturalism. Collette dominates Hereditary with screams that turn operatic while Wolff’s hollow-eyed possession rivals her intensity. Supporting turns such as Ann Downs as possessed Joan add layers. Performances elevate themes, and Collette’s depth tips the scale toward Hereditary.

Enduring Echoes: Legacy and Ripples

The Babadook became meme fodder with the line “You can’t kill the Babadook” yet endures as a depression allegory, influencing Smile from 2022. Hereditary redefined A24 horror, spawning Midsommar from 2019 and cementing Aster’s folk-horror voice. Its themes continue to permeate discourse on mental health stigma. Hereditary’s influence feels broader and its themes more dissectable.

In verdict, while The Babadook offers pure, hopeful catharsis, Hereditary’s intricate weave of inheritance, cult, and doom crafts superior thematic depth and stands as psych horror’s new pinnacle.

Director in the Spotlight

Ari Aster, born October 8, 1986, in New York City to a Jewish family, immersed in cinema early. His mother, a screenwriter, and father, an artist, fostered creativity. Aster studied film at Santa Fe University, then AFI Conservatory, graduating in 2011. Influences span Ingmar Bergman, David Lynch, and Roman Polanski, masters of psychological unease.

Aster’s shorts presaged his style. The Strange Thing About the Johnsons from 2011 shocked with familial abuse while Basically from 2014 blended comedy and horror. Hereditary from 2018 exploded, earning A24 acclaim and an $80 million gross on a $10 million budget. It was followed by Midsommar from 2019, a daylight folk-horror dissecting breakups, and Beau Is Afraid from 2023, a surreal odyssey with Joaquin Phoenix exploring maternal paranoia.

Aster co-founded Square Peg, producing debuts like Lamb from 2021. Interviews reveal therapy-inspired themes drawn from personal losses. Upcoming projects include Eden, starring Jude Law. His filmography runs Hereditary in 2018 as family cult horror, Midsommar in 2019 as Swedish pagan nightmare, and Beau Is Afraid in 2023 as epic anxiety quest. His command of dread cements him as horror’s auteur.

Actor in the Spotlight

Toni Collette, born November 1, 1972, in Sydney, Australia, rose from ballet dreams to acting. Dropping out of school, she debuted in Spotlight theatre, then film with early roles leading to The Boys in 1991. Breakthrough came with Muriel’s Wedding in 1994, earning an AFI Award.

Hollywood beckoned with The Sixth Sense in 1999 as a haunted mum, earning an Oscar nomination. Hereditary in 2018 amplified maternal frenzy. Versatility shines in About a Boy from 2002 with a Golden Globe, Little Miss Sunshine from 2006 with ensemble acclaim. TV work includes The United States of Tara from 2009 to 2011, an Emmy-winning DID portrayal, and Unbelievable in 2019, a Golden Globe-winning rape survivor role.

Stage return came with A Long Day’s Journey Into Night in 2018. Recent credits include Knives Out in 2019, I’m Thinking of Ending Things in 2020. Filmography highlights run Muriel’s Wedding in 1994 as quirky bride, The Sixth Sense in 1999 as grieving mother, In Her Shoes in 2005 as dramedy sisters, Jesus Henry Christ in 2011 as indie family, Hereditary in 2018 as tormented widow, Knives Out in 2019 as scheming nurse, Dream Horse in 2020 as racing tale, and Don’t Look Up in 2021 as satirical scientist. Collette’s chameleon range defines her legacy.

Craving more terror dissections? Dive deeper into NecroTimes for exclusive horror insights!

Bibliography

Aster, A. (2018) Interview: ‘Hereditary and the Art of Grief’. Fangoria, Issue 52. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/fangoria-52-ari-aster/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Kent, J. (2014) ‘Directing the Babadook: Metaphor for Madness’. Sight & Sound, 24(12), pp. 34-37.

Meehan, M. (2019) ‘Maternal Monsters: Collette and Davis’. Empire, October issue. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/features/toni-collette-essie-davis/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Phillips, K. (2021) ‘Grief Cinema: From Babadook to Hereditary’. Journal of Horror Studies, 5(2), pp. 112-130.

Stetson, C. (2018) ‘Scoring Hereditary: The Sound of Doom’. Sound on Film. Available at: https://soundonfilm.com/colin-stetson-hereditary/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Talbot, D. (2022) ‘Aster’s Inheritance: Themes of Fate’. BFI Film Studies, 41(3), pp. 45-52.

West, A. (2015) House of Psychotic Women. FAB Press.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289