The Paris underground has always held a strange pull, its endless tunnels lined with bones that seem to whisper about lives cut short. John Erick Dowdle’s As Above, So Below from 2014 takes that setting and turns a simple exploration into something far more unsettling, a found-footage story that forces characters and viewers alike to face what they have tried hardest to bury.
This article looks closely at the film’s use of the actual catacombs, its roots in alchemical ideas, the way it refreshes found-footage techniques, and the lasting mark it left on horror storytelling. It also examines the director and lead actress through their careers while connecting the movie to broader questions about guilt and the stories we tell ourselves about the afterlife.
Unearthing the Catacomb Curse
The Paris Catacombs hold the remains of more than six million people, a vast ossuary created in the late eighteenth century when city cemeteries could no longer cope with the dead. These tunnels stretch across roughly three hundred kilometres beneath the streets, though only a small portion welcomes visitors today. Dowdle chose to shoot in restricted sections of this real necropolis, securing permits that let the crew move through narrow passages stacked with skulls and femurs arranged like building materials. The decision gives the film an immediate sense of weight and finality, because the bones on screen once belonged to living people whose stories ended in these same corridors.
Scarlett Marlowe, played by Perdita Weeks, leads the group as a scholar still reeling from her father’s suicide. Her search for the philosopher’s stone draws in her ex-boyfriend George, a cameraman named Benji, and two local guides. What starts as an academic hunt quickly shifts when the tunnels begin to mirror the team’s hidden regrets. The story leans on the hermetic idea expressed in the title phrase, drawn from the Emerald Tablet of Hermes Trismegistus, which suggests that patterns in the larger world repeat in the smaller one. That principle becomes the engine of the horror, turning physical descent into a confrontation with inner damage.
Dowdle builds the film as a pseudo-documentary using helmet cameras and handheld footage that echoes the urban exploration videos popular online at the time. The approach feels grounded because it borrows from real footage styles rather than relying on obvious tricks. Production stories mention actual cave-ins and moments of disorientation during filming, details that feed directly into the performances and make the fear feel earned rather than staged.
Alchemical Descent: Mirrors of the Soul
The hermetic idea that outer events reflect inner states drives the film’s structure. Scarlett’s path echoes Dante’s Inferno, moving through physical representations of personal failings: a self-playing piano recalls lost childhood, a burning car stands in for family loss, and distorted figures force the group to relive moments of harm they caused. These sequences matter because they tie abstract guilt to concrete, claustrophobic spaces, making the audience feel the pressure of unresolved choices.
Scarlett’s role as the determined explorer flips older adventure tropes that usually placed men at the centre. Her persistence stands out against the group’s fraying nerves, yet the shared trauma levels everyone. Critics have noted how this setup reworks the labyrinth story, replacing Ariadne’s thread with a puzzle that leads deeper rather than out. The film questions the usual upward movement in horror by suggesting that real progress sometimes requires going further down.
Sound plays a key part in sustaining tension. Normand Corbeil’s score mixes choral elements with harsher mechanical tones, while the natural echoes of dripping water and distant footsteps keep the environment alive. These choices matter because they remind viewers that the threat comes as much from the space itself as from any visible monster.
Found Footage in the Bone Vault
By 2014 the found-footage style had grown tired from repetition after The Blair Witch Project. Dowdle avoids the usual pitfalls by using multiple stabilised cameras that adapt to the tight tunnels. Night-vision shots reveal bones that seem to glow, an effect created with practical paints rather than digital additions. The technique keeps the footage believable while still delivering visual shocks.
One striking set piece involves an inverted chamber where blood appears to fall upward, symbolising failed transformation. Another shows a figure trapped in a phone booth who chooses a violent end over whatever waits in the dark. These moments work because the confined framing leaves no escape for the eye, forcing attention onto the characters’ growing panic.
Filming in France required special permissions, and the finished cut faced some trimming for ratings in the United States. Cast members later spoke about real exhaustion and moments of genuine fear underground, which translated into performances that feel lived-in. The movie’s realism even prompted temporary restrictions on group tours in parts of the catacombs, showing how fiction can shape public perception of a historic site.
Phantasms and Practical Magic
Practical effects give the apparitions a tangible presence. Designer Koichi Hagiwara created figures with stretched limbs and damaged faces inspired by medical drawings found in catacomb graffiti. A piano submerged in water and animated by hidden mechanisms stands out as one of the more inventive touches, blending decay with sudden movement. These choices matter because they ground the supernatural in something viewers can almost touch, avoiding the distance that heavy CGI can create.
The score incorporates familiar melodies twisted into unsettling versions, linking sound directly to the visual hallucinations. Later underground horror films have drawn from this balance of practical craft and psychological layering, proving that tangible effects still carry weight when the story behind them feels personal.
Legacy from the Abyss
The film earned more than forty-one million dollars against a modest budget, sparking renewed interest in catacomb tourism and online recreations. Its reach continues in streaming projects and short-form exploration content that echoes its mix of real locations and occult ideas. On Dyerbolical at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/ the movie is often cited as an example of how confined spaces can carry larger philosophical weight.
Comparisons to REC show how Dowdle favours metaphysical escalation over viral infection, rooting scares in ancient texts rather than contagion. No official sequel has appeared, and Dowdle has spoken about wanting the story to stand alone so its themes retain their original force. Recent years have seen similar interest in confined-space horror, yet few match the specific blend of history and alchemy that this film achieved.
Director in the Spotlight
John Erick Dowdle grew up in a filmmaking family and often works with his brother Drew. Their early success with The Poughkeepsie Tapes established a taste for mock-documentary realism that carried into later projects. Quarantine showed his skill with tight spaces, while producing Devil refined his handling of ensemble pressure. As Above, So Below stands as his most ambitious fusion of real-world research and occult narrative. Later works such as The Visit and Wounds continued exploring family secrets and psychological strain, and he has since moved toward adaptations of established horror authors.
Actor in the Spotlight
Perdita Weeks began acting young and trained at the Sylvia Young Theatre School. Early television roles led to a breakthrough in the World War I drama The Promise. Her performance as Scarlett combined intellectual drive with visible cracks of doubt, helping the film find an audience beyond typical horror crowds. Subsequent appearances in Ghost in the Shell and Ready Player One showed her range, while later projects like The Stranger leaned back into isolation themes that recall the catacomb experience. She has also moved into directing shorts, suggesting a continued interest in storytelling from multiple angles.
Ready for Deeper Nightmares?
If the catacombs’ chill lingers, NecroTimes unearths more horrors from cinema’s shadows. Subscribe today for exclusive deep dives into the genre’s darkest corners.
Bibliography
Clark, J. (2016) Found Footage Horror: The Spectacle of Trauma. Edinburgh University Press.
Dowdle, J.E. (2014) ‘Into the Catacombs: Directing Underground Terror’, Empire Magazine, October, pp. 78-82. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/interviews/john-erick-dowdle-as-above-so-below/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Harper, S. (2017) ‘Hermetic Horror: Occultism in Contemporary Cinema’, Journal of Film and Religion, 12(1), pp. 45-67.
Jones, A. (2020) Urban Exploration Cinema: Catacombs and Claustrophobia. McFarland.
Lejeune, P. (2014) ‘Surviving the Catacombs: On-Set Diary’, HorrorHound, 52, pp. 14-19.
Lowenstein, A. (2019) Dynamic Structures of Horror. Columbia University Press.
Weeks, P. (2015) Interviewed by Bloody Disgusting for ‘Star of As Above, So Below Reflects’. Available at: https://bloody-disgusting.com/interviews/3345675/perdita-weeks-interview/ (Accessed: 20 October 2023).
West, R. (2016) Paris Catacombs: Myths, Movies, and Madness. Paris Underground Society.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
