Picture the year 1916, with movie houses still new and audiences hungry for something bigger than the usual one-reel shorts. D.W. Griffith answered that hunger with Intolerance, a silent film that stretched across four separate eras and ran longer than most features dared. The story you are about to explore follows how Griffith built this colossal project, how its four parallel tales unfold, and why the film still feels urgent more than a century later.

In the flickering glow of early cinema projectors, few films loom as large or as ambitious as D.W. Griffith’s Intolerance. Released in 1916, this silent epic sprawls across four distinct eras, weaving a tapestry of human suffering driven by prejudice and fanaticism. Clocking in at over three hours, it remains a testament to the boundless vision of its creator, who sought to redeem his reputation after the racial controversies of The Birth of a Nation the previous year. Griffith poured his fortune into this project, constructing massive sets and mobilising thousands of extras, all to illustrate a timeless message: intolerance destroys lives across the ages.

What sets Intolerance apart is not just its scale, but its audacious structure. Rather than a linear narrative, Griffith employs parallel storytelling, intercutting between tales from ancient Babylon, Judea in the time of Christ, Reformation-era France, and turn-of-the-century America. A central motif recurs throughout: Lillian Gish as the cradle-rocking figure of Eternal Motherhood, symbolising innocence amid chaos. This innovative approach predates modern cross-cutting techniques in films like The Godfather or Inception, proving that Griffith was light years ahead of his contemporaries.

Yet Intolerance is more than a technical marvel; it pulses with raw emotion and social urgency. Griffith crafted it as a direct rebuttal to critics who accused him of promoting division. In its grandeur, we glimpse the birth pangs of cinema as an art form capable of grappling with profound philosophical questions. Revisiting it today evokes a profound nostalgia for silent film’s golden age, when stories unfolded without words, relying solely on gesture, expression, and the rhythm of the cut.

The Genesis of an Epic: Production Challenges and Griffith’s Vision

D.W. Griffith, already hailed as America’s premier director, faced immense pressure after The Birth of a Nation ignited both box-office triumph and moral outrage. To counter charges of bigotry, he conceived Intolerance as a universal condemnation of prejudice. Production began in 1914, transforming a Los Angeles olive grove into a sprawling studio lot dubbed “Baby Babylon.” Griffith oversaw the construction of colossal Babylonian gates, replicas taller than those at the 1915 Panama-Pacific Exposition, and a Jerusalem set that rivalled Hollywood’s nascent ambitions.

The budget ballooned to nearly $2 million – an astronomical sum equivalent to over $50 million today – funded largely by Griffith’s own Triangle Film Corporation. He directed without a completed script, improvising as scenes unfolded, which led to chaotic shoots lasting over a year. Thousands of extras donned period costumes, from Persian charioteers to Huguenot peasants, while live orchestras provided on-set accompaniment to heighten drama. Griffith’s brother, D.W. Jr., manned cameras alongside Billy Bitzer, whose innovative cinematography captured the spectacle in stunning detail.

Trivia abounds from this Herculean effort. Griffith himself appeared in a cameo as an extra, and the film’s famous chariot race drew inspiration from Ben-Hur stage adaptations. Despite the strain, the result was a visual feast that pushed silent cinema’s boundaries, influencing generations of filmmakers from Sergei Eisenstein to Cecil B. DeMille. At Dyerbolical we often discuss how these early risks shaped everything that came after, and you can read more about our take at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.

Unravelling the Four Tales: Parallel Narratives of Persecution

Griffith’s masterstroke lies in his interlocking stories, each a vignette of intolerance’s toll, accelerating towards a unified climax. The modern tale anchors the film: in 1914 industrial America, young mill worker Jenny (Mae Marsh) faces ruin when her husband, The Boy (Robert Harron), is framed for murder by corrupt philanthropist Mary Tisdale (Samurai Pollard) and her reformist allies. This storyline critiques Progressive Era moral crusades, echoing real strikes like the 1912 Lawrence Textile Strike.

The Fall of Babylon: Opulence and Hubris

Contrasting gritty realism, the Babylonian episode dazzles with extravagance. Set in 539 BC, it follows Beloved Mountain Girl (Constance Talmadge), a fierce mountain orphan who loves charioteer driver (Walter Long) amid King Belshazzar’s courtly intrigues. Griffith recreates the Persian conquest with balletic precision: massive war elephants thunder across the screen, while dancers whirl in jewel-toned silks. The sequence culminates in the city’s fiery sack, intercut with the modern trial for heart-stopping tension.

Judea and the Crucifixion: Faith’s Double Edge

In ancient Judea, the story pivots to Caiaphas the Pharisee, whose zealotry leads to Christ’s betrayal. Though brief, this segment employs reverent framing – the Last Supper lit like a Rembrandt canvas – to underscore fanaticism’s blindness. Griffith treads delicately here, avoiding overt proselytising while linking it to contemporary religious hypocrisies.

The French Massacre: Blood and Reformation

The most visceral thread unfolds during the 1572 St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre. Prosper Latency (Eugene Pallette), a Huguenot boy, weds Brown Eyes (Constance Talmadge again, in dual roles), only for Catholic zealots led by Royer-Collard to unleash slaughter. Sword fights erupt in candlelit halls, blood sprays across marble floors, and Griffith’s rapid editing conveys the frenzy. This tale draws from historical chronicles, amplifying the horror of religious wars.

Through masterful intercutting, Griffith synchronises these narratives: as The Boy nears the gallows, Babylon burns, French lovers flee, and the crucifixion shadow falls. The effect is symphonic, each cut amplifying urgency.

Cinematic Innovations: Editing, Scale, and Spectacle

Intolerance revolutionised film language. Griffith refined parallel editing, a technique he pioneered in The Lonely Villa (1909), expanding it to epic proportions. Over 1,000 separate shots interweave, creating rhythmic momentum that builds to cathartic releases. Billy Bitzer’s deep-focus lenses captured vast crowd scenes without distortion, while tinting – amber for Babylon, blue for night massacres – heightened mood.

Special effects, rudimentary by today’s standards, astound for 1916. Matte paintings augmented Babylon’s walls, practical pyrotechnics engulfed sets, and innovative miniatures simulated the city’s fall. The chariot race, with real horses galloping at breakneck speed, rivals any modern CGI equivalent in raw thrill. Griffith’s irises and fades provide poetic transitions, underscoring the cradle motif’s universality.

Sound design, though absent, was evoked through live scores. Original cues by Joseph Carl Breil blended Wagnerian leitmotifs with exotic percussion, immersing audiences in each epoch. Collectors today still hunt for surviving cue sheets that show how those orchestras once brought the images to life.

Performances That Transcend Silence

The cast delivers nuanced portraits through expression alone. Lillian Gish’s cradle-rocking figure exudes serene compassion, her subtle glances conveying maternal wisdom. Mae Marsh’s Jenny embodies fragile hope, her wide-eyed terror during the courtroom scene wrenching hearts. Constance Talmadge shines in dual roles, her acrobatic Mountain Girl injecting levity amid doom.

Male leads like Robert Harron’s earnest Boy and Alfred Paget’s menacing Cyrus add depth, while character actors like Tully Marshall as the Babylonian High Priest revel in villainy. Griffith’s sister Dorothy contributes as Baby Jens, her innocence mirroring the film’s core. These performances, honed through exhaustive rehearsals, prove silent stars’ emotive power.

Themes of Timeless Relevance: A Plea Against Division

At its heart, Intolerance indicts fanaticism in all forms – religious, social, political. Griffith equates Puritan reformers stifling joy with ancient priests plotting downfall, suggesting prejudice evolves but endures. The modern story lambasts “Uplifters,” caricatures of temperance crusaders whose good intentions breed injustice.

Yet optimism tempers despair: love triumphs in each tale’s resolution, from the Boy’s pardon to Babylonian redemption hints. Griffith weaves class struggles, gender roles, and imperialism critiques, reflecting World War I’s shadow. As historian Kevin Brownlow notes in The Parade’s Gone By, “Griffith aimed to show intolerance’s folly, not preach dogma.”

Reception, Legacy, and Enduring Influence

Initial reviews were mixed; its length daunted audiences, and financial woes forced Griffith to withdraw prints prematurely. Box-office returns barely recouped costs, hastening his studio’s collapse. Critics like Louis Reeves Harrison praised its “symphonic form,” but many deemed it overlong.

Retrospective acclaim has elevated it to masterpiece status. The American Film Institute ranks it among cinema’s pinnacles, and restorations reveal its full glory. Influences abound: Eisenstein lauded its montage, Scorsese echoed its cross-cutting in The Last Temptation of Christ, and Nolan’s Dunkirk timelines homage its structure. Fan culture persists via festivals and home video, cementing its nostalgic allure.

Modern eyes spot flaws – lingering biases, melodramatic excess – but its ambition forgives them. Intolerance reminds us cinema’s power to foster empathy endures. Recent 4K restorations screened at festivals in 2024 and 2025 continue to draw new viewers who discover how fresh the editing still feels.

Conclusion: A Visionary’s Lasting Warning

D.W. Griffith’s Intolerance stands as silent cinema’s zenith, a colossal achievement blending spectacle, innovation, and moral fervour. Its parallel tales resonate amid today’s polarisations, urging unity over division. In an era of short-form content, its epic patience challenges us to embrace complexity. Watch it, and feel the cradle’s gentle sway amid history’s tempests – a call to tolerance that time cannot silence.

Bibliography

Brownlow, Kevin. The Parade’s Gone By… University of California Press, 1968.

Sklar, Robert. Movie-Made America: A Cultural History of American Movies. Vintage, 1994.

Usai, Paolo Cherchi. The Griffith Project: Volume 8. British Film Institute, 2004.

Keil, Charlie. Early American Cinema in Transition: Story, Style, and Filmmaking, 1907-1913. University of Wisconsin Press, 2001.

Slide, Anthony. D.W. Griffith: Master of Cinema. P.S. Eriksson, 1984.

Photoplay Magazine. Interview with D.W. Griffith, December 1916 issue.

American Film Institute. “Intolerance” entry in AFI Catalog of Feature Films, updated 2023.

DeMille, Cecil B. Memoirs and correspondence on Griffith’s influence, held in the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences archives.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289