Picture yourself in a packed New York theater back in 1916, the air thick with anticipation as massive sets depicting ancient Babylon fill the screen in ways no one had seen before. That kind of ambition defines D.W. Griffith’s Intolerance, a film that stretches across thousands of years to examine how prejudice keeps repeating itself. This article looks at how the movie came together after the uproar over Griffith’s earlier work, breaks down its groundbreaking storytelling across four eras, highlights the performances and technical leaps that still impress today, and considers why restored versions continue to speak to modern viewers who love classic cinema.
In the flickering glow of early cinema projectors, few films loom as large or as ambitious as D.W. Griffith’s Intolerance. Released in 1916, this silent spectacle unfolds across millennia, weaving four distinct tales of human suffering under the weight of prejudice and fanaticism. Clocking in at over three hours, it was Griffith’s audacious response to the backlash against his previous work, The Birth of a Nation, transforming personal controversy into a universal cry for understanding. For modern audiences rediscovering this colossus through restored prints, Intolerance remains a breathtaking testament to cinema’s power to bridge epochs and evoke empathy.
What sets Intolerance apart is not merely its scale—thousands of extras, lavish sets, and innovative techniques—but its unflinching humanism. Griffith, ever the pioneer, employs parallel storytelling to hammer home his message: intolerance is timeless, a poison recurring from ancient Babylon to the industrial age. As we revisit this landmark in the comfort of high-definition restorations, its relevance surges anew amid today’s divided world. This epic does not preach; it immerses, pulling viewers into a tapestry of joy shattered by judgment. The choice to intercut stories from different centuries lets audiences feel how the same patterns of judgment keep surfacing, whether in royal courts or factory towns, and that connection makes the film’s plea feel immediate rather than distant.
Griffith’s vision demanded unprecedented resources. With a budget swelling to nearly $2 million—equivalent to tens of millions today—he constructed Babylon’s towering walls and the opulent halls of Versailles. Yet beyond the grandeur lies a director wrestling with his legacy, using film as atonement and prophecy. Intolerance invites us to ponder: in an era of rapid cuts and CGI spectacles, can silent intertitles and rhythmic editing still stir the soul? Those practical builds, raised on the California landscape, forced crews to solve problems on the spot, and the resulting footage carries a weight that digital effects often struggle to match even now.
The Genesis of an Epic
Intolerance emerged from Griffith’s tumultuous year following The Birth of a Nation. Critics lambasted that film’s racial portrayals, prompting protests and calls for censorship. Rather than retreat, Griffith doubled down, declaring in interviews that he aimed to illustrate “man’s inhumanity to man” across history. Production began in 1915 under the banner of the Triangle Film Corporation, with Griffith micromanaging every detail from script to score. The pressure of that moment pushed him to expand a single idea into something far larger, turning defense into a broader statement about how societies turn on their own.
The film’s structure revolves around a modern framing device: a benevolent figure, the Mother of the Gospels (Lillian Gish), rocking a cradle in a tableau evoking compassion. This image bookends the narrative, linking the four stories through motifs of cradles and rocking chairs, symbolising innocence disrupted by zealotry. Griffith’s choice reflects his belief in film’s symphonic potential, where visuals compose a grand fugue on tolerance. Watching that cradle return between eras gives the whole picture a steady heartbeat, reminding viewers that every generation starts with the same fragile hope before outside forces interfere.
Parallel Narratives: A Revolutionary Montage
Griffith’s masterstroke lies in cross-cutting between eras, a technique he refined here to dizzying effect. The modern tale follows “The Boy” (Robert Harron), a mill worker ensnared by industrial strife and judicial intolerance. His wife, the Dear One (Mae Marsh), embodies fragile hope amid poverty and reformist overreach. This story, drawn from contemporary headlines like the upsweep of social purity movements, pulses with urgency, its frantic courtroom climax intercut with ancient atrocities. Those real-world echoes of labor strikes and moral campaigns gave the 1916 audience something familiar to latch onto, making the older stories land with extra force.
In ancient Babylon, circa 539 BCE, the Mountain Girl (Constance Talmadge) races on horseback to warn Prince Belshazzar (Alfred Paget) of Cyrus the Persian’s siege. Griffith recreated the city with 5,000 extras in a spectacle rivaling DeMille’s later extravaganzas. The infamous feast scene, with its parade of dancers and sumptuous excess, cascades into betrayal by the priest of Bel-Marduk, whose religious intolerance invites doom. The sheer number of people moving across those sets still astonishes, and the practical scale meant every charging chariot carried real momentum that no later recreation has quite duplicated.
The Judean segment, set during Christ’s ministry, offers poignant vignettes: the Pharisees’ scorn for the adulteress, the wedding at Cana. Though brief, it underscores Griffith’s reverence for biblical mercy, contrasting Pharisee rigidity with Christ’s grace. Finally, the French Huguenot story amid the St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre depicts Catholic-Valois intolerance devouring Protestant lovers, their tragedy mirroring the modern couple’s plight. Each thread tightens the same knot, showing how personal lives get crushed when fear of difference takes hold.
Performances That Transcend Silence
The ensemble cast delivers nuanced portrayals through gesture and expression, hallmarks of silent-era artistry. Lillian Gish, as the cradle-rocking figure, conveys ethereal serenity with minimal movement, her presence a quiet anchor. Mae Marsh’s Dear One flits from wide-eyed innocence to desperate resolve, her prison visit scene a masterclass in emotional escalation via close-ups. Those close-ups let small shifts in expression carry entire scenes, a skill that feels especially alive when you watch on a good restoration where every flicker registers.
Constance Talmadge steals the Babylonian reel as the fierce Mountain Girl, her athleticism and impish grin injecting levity into the epic. Robert Harron’s Boy, often critiqued as passive, embodies the everyman crushed by systems, his subtle shifts from naivety to defiance resonant today. Supporting turns, like Howard Gaye’s dignified Jesus or Eugene Pallette’s bombastic Cyrus, add layers, proving Griffith’s eye for talent. Talmadge’s energy in particular keeps the Babylonian section from feeling purely tragic, giving viewers someone to root for amid the pageantry.
Griffith’s Directorial Innovations
Technically, Intolerance pushed boundaries. Griffith’s irising and masking effects guide the eye, while his rhythmic editing—pioneered in The Birth of a Nation—creates unbearable tension. The Babylonian battle sequences, with chariots thundering and walls crumbling via practical effects, rival modern blockbusters. Composer Joseph Carl Breil’s original score, later enhanced in restorations, syncs perfectly with the visuals, amplifying emotional crescendos. Those editing rhythms taught later directors how to make silence feel loud, and you can trace the same pulse through action sequences in films made decades afterward.
Production trivia abounds: Griffith shot in Los Angeles, importing Babylonian costumes from museums and training horses for authenticity. Challenges mounted—budget overruns, actor injuries, a devastating set fire—but Griffith’s relentlessness prevailed. He even premiered the film in a marathon New York run with a 40-piece orchestra, turning viewing into an event. The fire incident alone forced quick thinking on set, and surviving footage from that day shows how the crew turned disaster into dramatic opportunity.
Core Themes: Intolerance’s Timeless Warning
At its heart, Intolerance indicts fanaticism in all guises: religious, social, political. The modern reformers, led by the sanctimonious Uplifters, echo temperance crusaders, their “mercy” birthing miscarriages of justice. Griffith draws parallels explicitly, intercutting the Boy’s trial with Babylonian priests plotting and Huguenots fleeing daggers. Those juxtapositions make the point without words, letting the audience feel the pattern repeat across time.
Social commentary permeates. The film’s critique of capital punishment, via the Boy’s death-row vigil, stirred debates; Griffith consulted real convicts for authenticity. Gender dynamics emerge too—the Friendless One (Miriam Cooper) as a fallen woman redeemed too late, highlighting era mores. Yet Griffith tempers judgment, portraying vice as circumstance’s child. That grounded view of how ordinary people get swept into larger cruelties keeps the stories from turning into simple morality plays.
Cultural and Historical Context
Released amid World War I’s prelude and America’s Progressive Era, Intolerance mirrored anxieties over immigration, labour unrest, and moral panics. Griffith, influenced by Herodotus and the Bible, synthesised history into prophecy. Critics like those in Variety noted its plea against “the Pharisees of today,” linking it to suffrage battles and anti-vice leagues. The timing meant audiences carried fresh memories of European conflict into the theater, so the film’s warnings about division landed with extra weight.
In cinema history, it marks the birth of the epic form, paving for Ben-Hur and Gone with the Wind. Though accused of historical liberties—Belshazzar predates Cyrus slightly—its emotional truth endures. Collectors today often seek out the various restored editions because each one reveals new details in the crowd scenes or set textures that reward repeat viewings.
Reception, Legacy, and Rediscovery
Initial reviews split: audiences marvelled at the spectacle, but many decried its length and complexity. Box-office woes nearly bankrupted Griffith, yet luminaries like Sergei Eisenstein hailed it as “the model of montage.” Over decades, restorations by Kevin Brownlow and David Gill revived its lustre, with the 1989 MoMA print earning acclaim at Cannes. Those efforts brought the film back to new generations who might otherwise have only read about its reputation.
Its influence ripples: cross-cutting inspired Hitchcock and Kurosawa; the Babylonian sets informed Intolerance’s parodies in Singin’ in the Rain. Fan culture thrives via festivals and home video, where Talmadge’s antics delight anew. Controversies linger—Griffith’s racial views taint some readings—but the film’s anti-bigotry core shines brighter. Modern collectors and film historians, including those at Dyerbolical who explore these classics further at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, keep finding fresh angles in how the parallel stories still mirror current debates.
Overlooked gems abound: the cradle motif’s philosophical depth, or the tender mother-child bonds defying epochs. Griffith himself reflected, “I tried to show that intolerance is the cause of all war,” a sentiment echoing in his memoirs. Sitting with the film now, those small human moments stand out more than the spectacle, reminding us why people keep returning to it.
Bibliography
Herman G. Weinberg, Stardust and Shadows: The Life of D.W. Griffith (1928).
Sergei Eisenstein, Film Form (1949).
D.W. Griffith, The Rise and Fall of Free Speech in America (1916).
Richard Schickel, D.W. Griffith: An American Life (1984).
Kevin Brownlow, The Parade’s Gone By (1968).
David A. Cook, A History of Narrative Film (various editions through 2020).
Scott Simmon, The Films of D.W. Griffith (1993).
Paolo Cherchi Usai, Silent Cinema: A Guide to Study, Research and Exhibition (updated editions to 2023).
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
