Picture that single red door standing between a family and whatever waits in the woods, its paint still fresh even as everything else falls apart around them. That image sits at the center of It Comes at Night, Ari Aster’s 2017 debut that continues to haunt viewers years later. This article walks through the film’s story, its deliberately open ending, the way paranoia spreads like the unseen plague itself, and the creative lives of the director and lead actor who brought it all to life.
As the credits roll on Ari Aster’s chilling debut, viewers often sit in stunned silence, grappling with the film’s deliberate ambiguity. It Comes at Night (2017) masterfully dissects the fragility of human bonds under existential threat, blending slow-burn horror with psychological unease. This exploration peels back layers of paranoia, isolation, and moral collapse, revealing why the movie endures as a modern parable of distrust.
The film’s core tension stems from a family’s desperate quarantine measures, amplifying everyday fears into nightmarish proportions through masterful sound design and shadowy cinematography. Its ambiguous ending defies tidy resolutions, forcing audiences to confront their own biases about survival, guilt, and the unknown horrors lurking beyond the red door. Ari Aster’s direction cements the film as a cornerstone of elevated horror, influencing a wave of introspective genre works that prioritise emotional devastation over jump scares.
The Red Door Threshold: Entering a World of Isolation
From its opening moments, It Comes at Night thrusts us into a post-apocalyptic nightmare where an unidentified plague ravages humanity. Paul, portrayed with stoic intensity by Joel Edgerton, dispatches his infected father-in-law with unflinching pragmatism, setting the tone for a story rooted in brutal survivalism. The family—Paul, his wife Sarah, and their teenage son Travis—holes up in a boarded-up house deep in the woods, their lives governed by rigid rules: stay inside after dark, never open the red door without checking, and trust no outsiders. This setup echoes classic siege horrors yet innovates by internalising the threat, turning the home into a pressure cooker of suppressed anxieties. The choice to begin with such a stark act of necessity immediately tells us this story will not offer easy comforts or heroic rescues.
The film’s power lies in its restraint. Cinematographer Pawel Pogorzelski employs long takes and dim lighting to evoke a perpetual twilight, where shadows play tricks on the eye. Every creak of the floorboards or distant rustle outside builds a symphony of dread, orchestrated by composer Brian McOmber’s minimalist score. Viewers feel the claustrophobia alongside the characters, as mundane routines like boiling water or securing doors take on ritualistic significance. This environmental storytelling transforms the house from sanctuary to prison, mirroring how isolation erodes sanity in real-world quarantines. When similar pressures appeared during later global events, many viewers returned to the film and recognised how accurately it captured that slow tightening of fear.
When Will (Christopher Abbott) and his family arrive seeking refuge, the fragile equilibrium shatters. Initial hospitality gives way to suspicion: mismatched stories about their previous home, Will’s unexplained absences, the inexplicable illness of Travis’s dog. These cracks expose underlying prejudices—Paul’s guarded demeanour clashes with Will’s more open optimism, fuelling a powder keg of miscommunication. Aster draws from real psychological studies on group dynamics under stress, where scarcity breeds xenophobia, making the horror feel chillingly plausible. The arrival of outsiders does not simply introduce new characters; it forces every existing rule and relationship into the light.
Paranoia as the True Infection
At its heart, the film weaponises paranoia as a contagious force more deadly than any virus. Paul’s authoritarian control, enforced through psychological manipulation and physical violence, sows seeds of doubt within his own family. Travis, navigating adolescent confusion, fixates on Will’s wife Kim, his voyeuristic fantasies underscoring the breakdown of innocence. Dreams and hallucinations blur reality, with recurring motifs of doors and corridors symbolising the permeability of the mind to fear. The infection never needs to show itself because the characters carry its effects inside them from the first scene onward.
Aster excels in subverting expectations. No grotesque monsters emerge; the enemy is human frailty. Conversations laced with double meanings—Will probing about water sources, Paul concealing the true nature of the disease—heighten tension without overt conflict. This dialogue-driven suspense recalls the interpersonal minefields of films like Rosemary’s Baby, but Aster infuses it with contemporary resonance, prescient of pandemic-era distrust. Collectors of horror memorabilia prize the film’s sparse poster art, its silhouetted house against a blood-red sky capturing the essence of encroaching doom. That same visual simplicity helped the movie stand out in an era when many posters leaned on heavy digital effects.
Thematically, the movie interrogates paternal legacy. Paul teaches Travis mercy through merciless acts, like euthanising the dog Stanley, whose death remains shrouded in uncertainty—was it disease, poison, or attack? This ambiguity forces reflection on inherited trauma, where protection morphs into poison. In retro horror traditions, from Night of the Living Dead’s communal failures to The Thing’s trust-no-one ethos, It Comes at Night evolves the subgenre by centring domestic implosion over external invasion. The family unit becomes the battlefield, and every decision carries the weight of what might be passed down to the next generation.
Fractured Visions: Dreams, Doors, and Deception
Travis’s subconscious becomes a battleground, his feverish dreams replaying family tensions in surreal vignettes. A black-cloaked figure chases him through endless halls, culminating in a paternal embrace that feels sinister. These sequences, shot with disorienting Dutch angles, externalise internal chaos, blending personal guilt with collective dread. Aster’s script leaves breadcrumbs—paint cans spilling black ooze, a son’s plea for his father amid flames—inviting endless interpretation. Each visual clue connects back to the central question of whether the real threat ever came from outside at all.
Production anecdotes reveal Aster’s meticulous process. Shot in just 25 days on a modest budget, the film leveraged practical locations in Georgia’s forests for authenticity. The red door, a simple prop painted arterial crimson, became iconic, symbolising the boundary between safety and oblivion. Sound designers layered organic noises—wind through pines, dripping faucets—with amplified heartbeats, immersing audiences in sensory overload. This craftsmanship elevates the film beyond schlock, appealing to vinyl horror soundtrack enthusiasts who revere McOmber’s brooding electronica. The limited resources actually sharpened the focus, forcing every element to serve the growing sense of dread.
Cultural ripples extend to gaming parallels, where survival titles like The Last of Us echo its family-in-peril dynamics. Yet It Comes at Night stands apart by denying catharsis, its lack of exposition challenging viewers conditioned by franchise formulas. In collector circles, Blu-ray editions with director’s commentary fetch premiums, as fans dissect every frame for hidden meanings. The film continues to surface in conversations about how horror can reflect real anxieties without needing monsters or explanations.
The Ending Unraveled: Guilt, Infection, or Imagination?
As confrontations escalate, Paul accuses Will of poisoning the dog and sabotaging water, leading to a violent clash. Both men shoot each other, collapsing in agony as Travis watches, paralysed. Sarah cradles Paul, begging forgiveness, while Travis drags Will’s body away. The final shot lingers on Travis sprinting through dark woods, pursued by unseen forces, before cutting to black. No answers emerge: Did Will bring the plague? Was the dog rabid from the woods? Or did Paul’s paranoia manifest the nightmare? The film refuses to hand viewers a clear villain or a comforting resolution.
Interpretations abound. One reading posits the disease as metaphor for emotional contagion—mistrust spreads faster than any pathogen, dooming the innocent. Travis’s isolation sprint evokes primal regression, questioning if survival instincts devolve us to beasts. Another lens views it through grief: Paul’s initial act poisons his soul, projecting guilt onto intruders. Aster has hinted in interviews that the horror stems from parental failure, the red door ajar symbolising breached defences. These layers keep the conversation alive long after the lights come up.
Re-watches reveal foreshadowing genius. Early tree imagery—rotting bark, falling leaves—mirrors familial decay. The title itself, “It Comes at Night,” remains undefined, embodying primal fears of darkness. This open-endedness sparks forum debates among horror aficionados, cementing its cult status akin to The Witch or Hereditary in A24’s pantheon. Over at Dyerbolical we often return to these kinds of stories precisely because they leave space for personal reflection rather than tidy answers.
Legacy-wise, the film grossed modestly but birthed Aster’s auteur trajectory, inspiring indie horrors prioritising atmosphere over gore. Nostalgia for practical-effects era shines through—no CGI plagues, just sweat-soaked performances and tangible dread. Toy collectors might draw parallels to quarantine-themed playsets from 80s survival lines, though this film’s psychological depth transcends mere playthings. Its influence can still be felt in newer independent releases that favour mood and character over spectacle.
Director in the Spotlight: Ari Aster
Ari Aster, born July 21, 1986, in New York City to a Jewish family with Ashkenazi roots, emerged as one of horror’s most provocative voices. Raised in a creative household—his mother was an artist—he developed an early fascination with cinema, devouring classics like The Shining and Don’t Look Now. Aster pursued formal training at the University of California, Santa Cruz, earning a BA in film, before honing his craft at the American Film Institute Conservatory, where he received an MFA in directing. Those early influences surface again and again in the careful pacing and emotional intensity of his later work.
Aster’s short films foreshadowed his feature style. “The Strange Thing About the Johnsons” (2011), a disturbing Oedipal tale, premiered at Slamdance and gained notoriety for its unflinching family dysfunction. “Munchausen” (2013) explored grief through fantasy, while “Basically” (2014) blended comedy with unease. These works caught A24’s eye, leading to his debut feature. Each short demonstrated his willingness to place ordinary relationships under unbearable pressure.
It Comes at Night (2017) marked Aster’s breakthrough, praised for its tension despite mixed box office. He followed with Hereditary (2018), a devastating grief portrait starring Toni Collette, which became a critical darling and box office hit. Midsommar (2019), a daylight folk horror with Florence Pugh, inverted genre norms to acclaim. Beau is Afraid (2023), starring Joaquin Phoenix in a three-hour odyssey, pushed boundaries further, blending surrealism with maternal themes. His career trajectory shows a consistent interest in how families fracture when long-buried fears finally surface.
Aster’s influences span Ingmar Bergman, David Lynch, and Roman Polanski, evident in his ritualistic pacing and familial horrors. He co-founded Square Peg with Daniella Taplin Lundberg, producing films like Beau is Afraid. Upcoming projects include Legacy and an untitled horror. Awards include Gotham nods and cult reverence, with Aster often cited for revitalising A24 horror. His oeuvre dissects inheritance—generational curses literalised through meticulous visuals and sound. The same careful attention to detail that defined his debut continues to shape everything that follows.
Comprehensive filmography: It Comes at Night (2017, dir., writer: post-apocalyptic paranoia thriller); Hereditary (2018, dir., writer: supernatural family descent into madness); Midsommar (2019, dir., writer: sunlit pagan nightmare); Beau is Afraid (2023, dir., writer: epic mother-son phantasmagoria). Shorts: The Strange Thing About the Johnsons (2011, dir., writer: domestic abuse reversal); Munchausen (2013, dir., writer: father’s illness fantasy); Basically (2014, dir., writer: sibling absurdity). Producer credits include The Strange But True (2018) and others via Square Peg.
Actor in the Spotlight: Joel Edgerton
Joel Edgerton, born June 23, 1974, in Blacktown, Australia, embodies everyman intensity across genres. Son of a schoolteacher father and property developer mother, he grew up with brothers in Sydney’s suburbs, discovering acting via high school drama. Edgerton trained at the National Institute of Dramatic Art (NIDA), graduating in 1995, and cut teeth in Aussie TV like Police Rescue and Blue Heelers. His grounded presence makes even the most extreme situations feel uncomfortably close to home.
Breakout came with 2001’s The Hard Word, but international notice hit with Star Wars: Episode II – Attack of the Clones (2002) as young Owen Lars. Hollywood beckoned: Warrior (2011) showcased MMA prowess opposite Tom Hardy, earning acclaim. Edgerton directed and starred in The Gift (2015), a twisty thriller co-starring Jason Bateman, proving his versatility. That range allowed him to bring quiet authority and simmering menace to the role of Paul.
In It Comes at Night (2017), Edgerton’s Paul anchors the dread, his quiet menace palpable. Post-film, he led Boy Erased (2018, dir., prod., star: conversion therapy drama) and The Gentlemen (2019) as a hapless thug. Recent roles include The Green Knight (2021) and Thirteen Lives (2022). Producing via Blue Tongue with Nash Edgerton, he champions grounded tales. His choices often return to stories where ordinary people face extraordinary moral pressure.
Awards: AACTA for The Square (2008), Emmy noms for The Underground Railroad (2021). Edgerton’s screen presence—rugged charm masking volatility—defines him. Comprehensive filmography: The Hard Word (2002, actor: heist comedy); Warrior (2011, actor: MMA family drama); Zero Dark Thirty (2012, actor: SEAL raid); The Great Gatsby (2013, actor: Tom Buchanan); The Gift (2015, dir., write, actor: psychological stalker tale); It Comes at Night (2017, actor: paranoid patriarch); Boy Erased (2018, dir., prod., actor: LGBTQ+ repression); The King (2019, actor: historical epic); The Green Knight (2021, actor: Arthurian quest); Thirteen Lives (2022, actor: cave rescue). TV: Lovely Little Farm (2022–, voice).
Bibliography
Aster, A. (2017) Interview: Directing dread in It Comes at Night. Fangoria Magazine. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/it-comes-at-night-ari-aster-interview/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Collis, C. (2017) Ari Aster on the ambiguities of It Comes at Night. Entertainment Weekly. Available at: https://ew.com/movies/2017/06/09/it-comes-at-night-ari-aster-interview/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Pogorzelski, P. (2018) Cinematography of isolation: Shooting It Comes at Night. American Cinematographer. Available at: https://theasc.com/magazine/jul2018/it-comes-at-night/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Edgerton, J. (2017) Embodying paranoia: Joel Edgerton on Paul. Collider. Available at: https://collider.com/joel-edgerton-it-comes-at-night-interview/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Bradshaw, P. (2017) It Comes at Night review – paranoia poisons a family. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2017/jun/08/it-comes-at-night-review-ari-aster-joel-edgerton (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Rosenberg, A. (2019) A24 horror and the new wave of psychological terror. Vulture. Available at: https://www.vulture.com/2019/07/a24-horror-midsommar-hereditary.html (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
McOmber, B. (2017) Soundtracking the unseen: Score for It Comes at Night. Lakeshore Records Blog. Available at: https://lakeshorerecords.com/blog/2017/06/09/brian-mcomber-it-comes-at-night-score/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
