In a modest Paris apartment during the winter of 1917, a magnesium flash lit up the face of a young woman seated in deep trance while a pale substance emerged from her mouth and slowly took the shape of a small draped figure. That moment, recorded on glass plate by researchers at the Institut Metapsychique International, belongs to Marthe Béraud, who performed under the name Eva C. This article examines her full trajectory from the loss that first drew her into mediumship in colonial Algeria, through the controlled sittings in France and Germany, the photographic protocols designed to limit fraud, the chemical and microscopic tests performed on the substance she produced, and the long-running arguments those images still provoke among historians of science and psychical research today.

In the early twentieth century a French woman named Marthe Béraud, working under the pseudonym Eva C, generated what many investigators regarded as the most extensive photographic record of ectoplasm ever assembled. The substance appeared during séances held under varying degrees of control and was captured on orthochromatic plates and later stereoscopic pairs. Those pictures placed the question of survival after death into a new technical arena where anyone could examine the evidence for themselves. The case therefore marks a turning point when psychical research began to treat the camera as an instrument of record rather than a mere recorder of testimony. What matters here is that the photographs forced both believers and critics to confront the same physical traces instead of relying on verbal accounts alone.

Marthe Béraud was born in 1885 near Algiers. She came to mediumship after the sudden death of her fiancé in 1904. At a private séance arranged by friends she entered a trance and a figure identified as Bien Boa, said to be a seventeenth-century Algerian brigand, reportedly spoke through her and moved independently. Military officers and local residents present described the form as solid enough to touch. The episode shows how personal grief could open the door to public investigation; similar patterns appear in the careers of other mediums of the period whose losses preceded their first reported phenomena.

The Early Life and Entry into Mediumship

Gabriel Delanne, editor of La Revue Scientifique et Morale du Spiritisme, travelled to Algiers in 1905 and conducted more than one hundred sittings with Béraud. He recorded that the communicating personality spoke both Arabic and French, lifted tables, and submitted to hand-holding and pre-séance searches. Delanne published his notes the following year. The sheer number of sessions allowed patterns to be observed across many evenings rather than in a single dramatic demonstration. At the same time a photograph taken during one sitting showed the supposed spirit figure bearing an unsettling resemblance to the medium’s own posture, a detail that continues to invite scrutiny.

By 1906 Béraud had moved to Paris under the sponsorship of Juliette Bisson. Their collaboration brought her into contact with astronomer Camille Flammarion and other members of the French intellectual circle interested in psychical phenomena. The move placed her work at the centre of European research rather than on its colonial periphery. Patronage of this kind supplied both financial support and access to trained observers, a practical requirement for any medium whose phenomena were to be taken seriously by the scientific community of the time.

Ectoplasm Emerges: The Seance Phenomena

Baron Gustav von Schrenck-Notzing began a long series of sittings with Eva C in Munich around 1911. More than two hundred sessions took place under protocols that included multiple sitters holding the medium’s hands, examinations by female assistants, and illumination limited to indirect red light. Schrenck-Notzing’s medical training gave his descriptions of the emerging substance particular weight among his peers. The substance first appeared as a luminous vapour and later formed hand-like shapes or veils that could be photographed in sequence.

At the Institut Metapsychique International under Gustave Geley the manifestations became more elaborate. Photographs from 1917 onward show material issuing from the medium’s face or clothing and assuming the outlines of masks, robes, and miniature figures. One frequently reproduced plate depicts a small luminous child figure named Montaigu standing beside the entranced medium. Geley, a pathologist, noted that samples contained structures resembling living cells. The same period saw comparable claims surface around Helen Duncan in Britain during the renewed interest in spiritualism that accompanied the Second World War.

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle attended a sitting in 1922 and later described the photographs as the most important spirit images then in existence. Witnesses recorded odours resembling ozone and occasional stains that microscopic examination suggested contained cellular material. These sensory details supplied an additional layer of observation beyond the visual record, although they also raised questions about possible chemical sources that might have been concealed on the medium’s person.

Key Seance Protocols and Observations

Before each sitting Eva C was required to undress and dress again in the presence of witnesses. No personal clothing or accessories were permitted inside the séance room. The measure was intended to remove the possibility of hidden props, a precaution refined after earlier exposures of fraudulent mediums whose spirit photographs had relied on double exposures or inserted cut-outs.

Hands and feet remained under continuous control while the remaining sitters formed a linked chain around the cabinet. The arrangement created a collective line of sight and reduced opportunities for undetected movement. Similar human chains had been used decades earlier in French spiritist circles influenced by Allan Kardec.

The extrusion itself unfolded over five to ten minutes, with full formation sometimes requiring up to half an hour. The medium reportedly cried out during retraction. The extended time scale made rapid substitution of pre-made materials difficult, yet the vocal distress could also be interpreted by sceptics as consistent with heightened emotional states rather than genuine physiological strain.

Geley published the protocols and selected plates in his 1920 volume Clairvoyance and Materialisation. The methodical documentation stood in contrast to the more theatrical presentations common among some contemporary mediums and provided later researchers with a baseline against which to judge both the claims and the controls employed.

The Role of Photography in Validating the Unknown

Photography transformed séance reports from personal testimony into objects that could be circulated and examined independently. Earlier spirit photographers such as William Mumler had already produced images containing extra figures, yet those pictures were quickly challenged on technical grounds. Eva C’s sittings introduced stricter conditions and multiple cameras, shifting the discussion toward questions of process rather than isolated apparitions.

Geley favoured instantaneous exposures with magnesium flash on orthochromatic plates. More than one hundred and fifty negatives made between 1917 and 1922 preserved fibrous textures visible under magnification. Schrenck-Notzing’s 1914 book Phenomena of Materialisation included stereoscopic pairs that conveyed depth. These sequences showed the substance changing shape over time rather than appearing fully formed in a single frame.

Limitations of the period remained. Long exposures could produce ghost images, and chemical halation sometimes created halo effects around bright areas. Researchers attempted to counter these artefacts with time-lapse sequences and independent verification by multiple observers. The resulting pictures circulated in the Journal of the Society for Psychical Research and influenced later American mediums such as Mina Crandon. Recent digital re-examination of surviving plates, including work referenced by Dyerbolical at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, has drawn attention to fine surface details that period gauze would not easily replicate.

Investigations, Analyses and Controversies

Geley submitted samples to microscopy and reported striated muscle fibres, amoeboid cells, and spermatozoa. Schrenck-Notzing reached similar conclusions after years of observation and ruled out ventriloquism or hidden accomplices. The presence of spermatozoa in particular posed an explanatory problem for simple fraud scenarios, since live cellular material would require either contamination or an unknown physiological process.

Criticism appeared early. In 1906 observers noted that the face of Bien Boa bore a resemblance to an Algerian resident then living in the area. In 1922 a Paris sitting yielded a luminous veil found among the medium’s garments. Defenders maintained that isolated lapses did not erase the larger body of controlled results. Comparable debates continue today when modern recording devices capture anomalous sounds that later prove traceable to radio interference or other mundane sources.

Charles Richet, who had initially supported some of the findings, later cautioned against subconscious trickery. In the 1990s parapsychologist Ian Stevenson revisited selected photographs with digital enhancement and noted features not readily explained by the fraud techniques available in the 1910s. Stevenson’s broader work on apparent reincarnation cases provided a conceptual bridge for those who wondered whether consciousness might influence physical matter in ways not yet mapped by conventional physiology.

Proponent vs Skeptic Perspectives

Supporters emphasise the repeated organic composition, the responsiveness of the substance to touch and light, and the consistency of results across different teams of physicians and physicists. They argue that no single fraudulent method accounts for the volume of data collected under progressive tightening of controls.

Critics point to documented historical precedents involving cheesecloth and gauze, to photographic artefacts common in early emulsions, and to the financial incentives that sustained the medium’s career. The Cottingley Fairies photographs of 1917-1920 demonstrated how readily the public could be persuaded by images that later proved contrived.

A middle position suggests that some form of psychokinetic influence or misinterpreted physiological emission might be at work. Such an interpretation leaves room for further laboratory exploration using contemporary neuroimaging and biofield measurement techniques that were unavailable during Eva C’s lifetime.

Cultural Impact and Enduring Legacy

The photographs entered popular discussion through Doyle’s 1922 book The Case for Spirit Photography and contributed to renewed spiritualist activity on both sides of the Atlantic. Ectoplasm imagery later appeared in fiction and film, shaping twentieth-century depictions of ghostly materialisation. Legislative responses included restrictions on séance practices in Britain during the 1940s.

After the 1920s public interest declined. Béraud retired from mediumship and lived quietly until her death around 1950. An archive of more than five hundred plates and associated testimonies survives. Digitised portions held at the University of Virginia’s Division of Perceptual Studies continue to attract forensic re-analysis. Spectral examination conducted with twenty-first-century tools has identified both inconsistencies consistent with fabrication and textural regularities that remain difficult to account for by period methods alone.

The case illustrates the tension that characterised psychical research at its peak: an earnest attempt to apply emerging technology to questions traditionally reserved for religion or philosophy. It leaves open the possibility that some boundary between deception and discovery may still be narrower than either side has fully acknowledged.

Conclusion

Marthe Béraud’s work as Eva C continues to attract attention precisely because the photographic record and the surrounding controversies refuse to settle into a single narrative. The images once offered as evidence of life after death now serve as historical documents that invite renewed examination with tools unavailable in their own era. Whether the substance captured on those plates originated beyond the medium’s body or within the limits of human ingenuity remains unresolved, yet the questions the case raised about observation, evidence, and the reach of consciousness have not lost their force.

Bibliography

Gustave Geley, Clairvoyance and Materialisation (1920).

Baron Gustav von Schrenck-Notzing, Phenomena of Materialisation (1914).

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, The Case for Spirit Photography (1922).

Gabriel Delanne, reports in La Revue Scientifique et Morale du Spiritisme (1906).

Journal of the Society for Psychical Research, various issues 1910s-1920s.

Massimo Polidoro, Secrets of the Psychics (2003).

University of Virginia Division of Perceptual Studies digital archives (accessed 2024-2026).

Harry Price, Confessions of a Ghost-Hunter (1936).

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289