When a Black family arrives in a sunlit 1950s Compton neighborhood hoping for a fresh start, the welcome they receive mixes everyday hatred with forces that refuse to stay buried. This article examines the Amazon Prime anthology series Them, its two seasons, the real history it draws upon, the debates it sparked, and the craft that makes its terrors linger long after the credits roll.
In the heart of suburbia, where the American Dream curdles into nightmare, ‘Them’ drags horror’s sharpest blade across the wounds of racial history.
Since its debut in 2021, the Amazon Prime anthology series Them has ignited fierce debates within the horror community and beyond. Created by Little Marvin, this unflinching exploration of Black and Latino families besieged by both supernatural forces and entrenched bigotry challenges viewers to stare into the abyss of America’s racial psyche. Far from mere scares, Them weaves ghostly apparitions with historical atrocities, prompting questions about representation, exploitation, and the ethics of evoking trauma on screen.
- How Them blends real-world racism with otherworldly terror to create a new breed of racial horror.
- The firestorm of controversy surrounding its graphic depictions and what they reveal about audience expectations.
- The creative forces behind the series, from visionary direction to powerhouse performances, that elevate it to must-watch status.
Monsters from the Margins: ‘Them’ and the Rise of Racial Horror
In the opening moments of Them: Covenant, the first season set in 1950s Los Angeles, we meet the Emory family: Lucky (Deborah Ayorinde), a nurse haunted by her past; her husband Henry (Luke James), a stoic World War II veteran chasing the postwar promise of prosperity; their young daughter Gracie (Melody Garrett), innocent and wide-eyed; and adolescent son Edmund (Archie Madekwe), teetering on the edge of rebellion. Fleeing the Jim Crow South, they purchase a home in an all-white Compton neighbourhood, embodying the era’s Great Migration northward. But their dream sours swiftly. Neighbours spit slurs, stones shatter windows, and a malevolent force infiltrates their lives. Betty Wendell (Alison Pill), a prim housewife with a venomous smile, leads the human assaults, while spectral entities claw from the shadows. Crosses burn on their lawn, children vanish into night terrors, and the house itself seems to pulse with malice. As tensions escalate, the supernatural mirrors the societal horrors: possessions mimic lynchings, ghostly figures echo slave catchers. The narrative crescendos in revelations that bind personal guilt to collective sins, forcing the family to confront not just external demons but the inherited curses of trauma.
The choice to root the story in the Great Migration years matters because those families carried both hope and unhealed wounds northward. When the Emorys step off the train in Los Angeles they carry stories from the South that no new house can erase. The series shows how those memories surface in the most ordinary moments, turning a child’s bedroom or a kitchen table into places where the past refuses to stay quiet.
Season two, Them: The Scare, shifts to 1991 South Central Los Angeles amid the riots’ aftermath. Jasmine Bishop (again Ayorinde), a single mother and LAPD detective, moves into a rundown house with her daughter Iris (Madison Thompson). Plagued by visions and a vengeful spirit, they grapple with Jasmine’s buried secrets involving a serial killer case and interracial tensions. The ghostly antagonist, a detective from her past (Pam Grier in a chilling cameo), embodies institutional betrayal. Hooded figures, poltergeist fury, and hallucinatory assaults amplify the era’s crack epidemic, police brutality, and gang violence. Once more, the home becomes a battleground where past injustices summon literal monsters, culminating in a desperate bid for maternal salvation. Across both instalments, creator Little Marvin crafts a tapestry where poltergeists serve as metaphors for unresolved generational pain, and hauntings literalise the psychological scars of marginalisation.
The 1991 setting lets the series place its characters inside a city already on edge. News footage of burning streets and National Guard presence does more than set the scene; it reminds viewers that the characters are living through events that shaped how many families still view the police and their own safety today.
Unveiling the Ghosts of History
Them roots its terrors in meticulously researched historical specificity, transforming real events into spectral allegory. The 1950s Compton setting evokes the restrictive covenants that barred non-whites from white neighbourhoods until the 1948 Shelley v. Kraemer Supreme Court decision, yet vigilante resistance persisted. Neighbours’ barbecues turn into witch hunts, echoing actual sundown towns where Black travellers risked death after dark. Marvin draws from oral histories and redlining maps, ensuring the Emorys’ plight resonates with authenticity. This grounding elevates the supernatural: when Gracie encounters a barefoot apparition reciting slave spirituals, it evokes the Middle Passage’s drowned souls, a motif echoed in Jordan Peele’s Get Out (2017) but here amplified through family fragmentation.
In The Scare, the 1991 riots provide a volatile backdrop, with Jasmine navigating a city fractured by the Rodney King beating. The series intercuts news footage of burning palms and National Guard patrols, blurring fiction with footage that scorches the screen. This contextual layering critiques how horror has historically sidelined racial narratives, from the blaxploitation era’s vampires in Blacula (1972) to modern fare like Candyman (2021). Them insists that true fright lies not in jump scares but in the banality of exclusion, where a child’s birthday party devolves into arson.
That same approach to history appears in other recent horror as well. Series like Lovecraft Country and films such as His House also treat past injustice as an active force rather than distant backdrop. What sets Them apart is how tightly it ties each haunting to the specific street and decade its characters inhabit, making the supernatural feel like an extension of the neighborhood itself.
The Firestorm of Controversy
Upon release, Them polarised critics and audiences. Detractors labelled it ‘trauma porn’, accusing it of wallowing in Black suffering for white liberal catharsis. A graphic scene in Covenant depicting Edmund’s assault drew walkouts and online fury, with some arguing it sensationalised real violence without empowerment. Outlets like The Root questioned if the series prioritised gore over nuance, comparing it unfavourably to Lovecraft Country (2020), which balanced spectacle with solidarity. Defenders, including Marvin himself, countered that sanitising history dishonours survivors, positioning Them in a lineage of unflinching works like Roots (1977) or 12 Years a Slave (2013).
The backlash highlighted broader tensions in racial horror: who gets to tell these stories? As a queer Black creator, Marvin faced scrutiny over ‘selling out’ to Amazon, yet his vision subverts expectations by centring matriarchal resilience. Latino representation in The Scare sparked similar dialogues, with praise for authenticity amid debates over colourism and stereotypes. Ultimately, the controversy underscores horror’s evolution from escapist thrills to cultural mirror, forcing conversations on complicity.
These arguments still surface whenever horror tackles real pain. Some viewers want stories that offer clear heroes and healing; others argue that honest discomfort is the point. Them lands in the middle, refusing easy comfort while giving its central families moments of fierce determination that keep the narrative from feeling hopeless.
Supernatural Mechanics and Symbolism
The hauntings in Them operate on dual planes: psychological manifestations of guilt and autonomous entities enforcing cosmic retribution. In Covenant, the Black Hat Man – a towering figure with elongated limbs – personifies paternal failure, stalking Henry as he unravels. Practical effects by Legacy Effects (known for The Mandalorian) blend prosthetics with puppetry, creating grotesque realism. Shadows elongate unnaturally, walls bleed molasses-thick ichor, and levitations defy gravity with wirework so seamless it chills. Symbolically, the Hat Man evokes Ku Klux Klan hoods, merging folklore with lynching iconography.
Jasmine’s tormentor in season two channels vengeful spirits from Latin American brujería traditions, her form shifting from alluring seductress to decayed revenant. Compositional genius places families in wide, empty frames, dwarfed by Victorian homes that loom like mausoleums. Cinematographer Bobby Bukowski employs Dutch angles to induce vertigo, while Steadicam prowls hallways, mimicking intruders’ gaze. These choices transform domestic spaces into liminal hells, where the picket fence becomes a prison wall.
Sound Design as Silent Scream
Audio craftsmanship amplifies unease, with composer Marcus Norris layering droning synths over archival field recordings of lynch mobs and riot sirens. Whispers in Southern drawls precede apparitions, subliminally invoking minstrelsy tropes. The Emory house creaks with amplified floorboards, each groan a racial epithet unspoken. In pivotal sequences, diegetic silence punctuates violence – Gracie’s muteness during hauntings contrasts with explosive shrieks, heightening dread. This sonic palette influences contemporaries like Midnight Mass (2021), proving sound as horror’s unsung antagonist.
Performances that Pierce the Soul
Ayorinde’s dual portrayals anchor the series. As Lucky, she conveys quiet ferocity, her eyes wells of unspoken grief; as Jasmine, weary pragmatism cracks into hysteria. Madekwe’s Edmund captures adolescent rage morphing into monstrosity, while Pill’s Betty is a masterclass in passive-aggressive villainy, her saccharine tones masking abyss. Supporting turns, like Jeremy Bobb’s unhinged sheriff, add layers of institutional rot. These performances ground the fantastical, making empathy inevitable.
Special Effects: Crafting the Uncanny
Them‘s effects eschew CGI excess for tactile horror. In Covenant, the Hat Man’s design by Adrien Morot features hydraulic limbs extending two feet, filmed in practical extensions for verisimilitude. Demonic transformations use silicone appliances melting under heat lamps, paired with practical blood squibs. Season two’s poltergeist rampages employ pneumatic debris launchers, hurling furniture with kinetic force. Compositing minimalises digital artefacts, preserving intimacy. Legacy Effects’ work earned Emmy nods, influencing From‘s creature designs. This commitment to ’60s practical ethos amid modern tools revitalises horror’s visceral core.
Legacy in a Fractured Genre
Them extends Horror Noire‘s canon, bridging Tales from the Hood (1995) to Peele’s oeuvre. Its anthology format invites expansion, rumoured third season exploring Asian American traumas. Culturally, it permeates memes and TikTok recreations, while sparking panels at Black Horror Con. By humanising victims without redemption arcs, it challenges horror’s punitive gaze, paving for works like V/H/S/99‘s racial vignettes. In an era of reckonings, Them endures as provocation incarnate. You can find further reflections on this evolution at Dyerbolical https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.
Director in the Spotlight
Craig Brewer, the powerhouse director helming four episodes of Them: Covenant, embodies Southern Gothic grit fused with Hollywood polish. Born December 15, 1971, in Palo Alto, California, but raised in Memphis, Tennessee, Brewer immersed in blues culture and grindhouse cinema from youth. After studying film at Wesleyan University, he debuted with The Poor & Hungry (2000), a raw indie about urban despair. Breakthrough came with Hustle & Flow (2005), starring Terrence Howard as a pimp-turned-rapper; its Oscar-winning song ‘It’s Hard Out Here for a Pimp’ catapulted him. Influences like David Lynch and Rainer Werner Fassbinder infuse his work with feverish lyricism.
Brewer’s filmography brims with provocative tales: Black Snake Moan (2006), a blues-soaked redemption saga with Samuel L. Jackson chaining Christina Ricci’s nymphomaniac; the 2011 Footloose remake, injecting kinetic energy into the classic; The Liberty Land (2013), a zombie musical critiquing Memphis decay. Television expands his reach: Empire episodes (2015-2016) showcasing musical flair; Atlanta (2018); Looking for Alaska (2019); and The Idol (2023) with The Weeknd. Recent: directing Bernie Mac biopic and Red One (2024) action-fantasy. Brewer’s auteur stamp – humid visuals, rhythmic editing, outsider empathy – shines in Them, where he marshals ensemble chaos into symphonic dread. Awards include Independent Spirit nods; he’s mentored by Tarantino, cementing his genre vanguard status.
Actor in the Spotlight
Deborah Ayorinde commands screens with magnetic intensity, her roles in Them cementing her as horror’s new scream queen. Born 1990 in London to Nigerian parents, she relocated often, fostering resilience. Educated at Lagos’ Corona Secondary, then LAMDA (London Academy of Music and Dramatic Art), graduating 2013 with honours. Early theatre in Amsterdam honed her craft before screen transition.
Breakout: 2016’s Supergirl as Project Cadmus scientist; I May Destroy You (2020) as Alaga. Them (2021-) showcases range: Lucky’s unraveling maternal steel, Jasmine’s haunted cop. Filmography: Lightning (2017, short); The 24th (2020), historical drama on Houston riot; Diary of a Mad Black Woman stage revival; Our Girl (BBC); Harlots (2018) as Adeline Quigley. Upcoming: Birth/Rebirth (2023) horror, Macbeth adaptation. Awards: NAACP Image nominee, BAFTA buzz. Ayorinde champions diverse stories, producing via D&A Productions, blending poise with primal fury.
Craving more chills and insights? Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly deep dives into horror’s darkest corners. Share your thoughts on Them in the comments below!
Bibliography
Billson, A. (2021) Them review – one of the scariest series in years. The Guardian, 26 April.
Coleman, R. M. (2011) Horror Noire: A History of Black Horror. Routledge.
Fears, D. (2021) ‘“Them” Creator Little Marvin on Conjuring Racial Horror’, Variety, 9 April.
Marsh, C. (2022) ‘Trauma Porn or Necessary Reckoning? Racial Horror in Streaming Era’, Journal of Popular Film and Television, 50(2).
McFarland, M. (2021) ‘Amazon’s “Them” isn’t horror. It’s hate porn.’ Washington Post, 12 April.
Young, L. (2022) ‘From “Candyman” to “Them”: Evolution of Racial Metaphors in Horror’, Film Quarterly, 75(3).
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
