Vampire Flatmates and Werewolf Feuds: How Jeffrey Jerome Cohen’s Monster Theory Exposes the Everyday Terrors in What We Do in the Shadows
In a cluttered Wellington share house where bloodstains meet the laundry pile, four immortal vampires stumble through eternity under the glare of a mock documentary camera. What We Do in the Shadows turns the grand myths of the undead into something far more intimate and revealing. Released in 2014 and shaped by directors Taika Waititi and Jemaine Clement, the film uses deadpan humour to test the ideas laid out in Jeffrey Jerome Cohen’s Monster Theory. By placing Cohen’s seven theses against the vampires’ daily routines and rivalries with werewolves, the story shows how monsters reflect our own cultural worries, ancient folklore roots, and shifting expectations from the screen.
The film opens with a deceptively simple premise: four vampires cohabiting in a dilapidated Wellington share house, their immortal existences captured by a documentary crew who remain inexplicably immune to fangs and hypnosis. Viago, a dandyish 19th-century fop played by Waititi, enforces house rules with passive-aggressive precision, folding laundry while reminiscing about romantic conquests thwarted by uncooperative victims. Vladislav, portrayed by Clement with weary grandeur, boasts of past glories like levitating spoons yet crumbles before a Beast he once commanded, reduced to futile arm-wrestling. Deacon, the rebellious punk from 1860s Romania, lounges naked save for sunglasses, his coffin serving as eternal protest furniture. Lurking in the basement is Petyr, a Nosferatu-like relic from 800 AD, his mummified visage and rat familiars evoking purest Transylvanian terror.
Domestic discord escalates when Stu, a human familiar and IT consultant, invites Nick, a stoner lad, to a vampire ritual. Bitten during the frenzy, Nick joins the household, his transformation chronicling the awkward passage from mortality to monstrosity: initial denial morphs into boasts of immortality, only to sour as he grapples with sunlight aversion and eternal garlic aversion. Nick’s girlfriend, Jackie, joins the documentary team, her footage unwittingly chronicling vampire-werewolf turf wars. The werewolves, led by the affable Anton and his pack of shirtless enthusiasts barking “Let’s do this!”, provide comic foils, their transformation triggered by voluntary nudity contrasting the vampires’ involuntary pallor.
Key set pieces amplify the farce: a nightclub brawl with werewolves erupts in pratfalls amid thumping bass; a disastrous attempt to infiltrate a goth club exposes vampires’ outdated allure; and a police raid turns chaotic as officers ignore overt vampirism, attributing chaos to drugs. Petyr’s near-fatal sunlight exposure demands a tense coffin repatriation, while Vladislav’s impotence against the Beast underscores faded potency. The narrative crescendos at the Unholy Masquerade Ball, where vampires strut in finery only to face werewolf invasion, culminating in a fragile truce sealed over kebabs. Nick’s eventual defection to werewolf companionship leaves the vampires reflective, their mockumentary legacy a testament to unchanging chaos.
This intricate tapestry weaves Bram Stoker’s aristocratic dread with found-footage immediacy, grounding supernatural excess in Kiwi understatement. Production designer Katie Wolfe crafted the share house as a gothic slum, peeling wallpaper and cobwebbed chandeliers mirroring the monsters’ decayed grandeur. Cinematographer Robert Steele’s shaky cam lends authenticity, handheld shots capturing improvised hilarity born from Waititi and Clement’s script evolution from Eagle vs Shark collaborations. The approach matters because it strips away the distance of classic horror, letting viewers feel how ancient fears might actually play out when rent and chores intrude.
The Undying Flatshare: A Labyrinthine Plot Unraveled
Viago, Vladislav, Deacon, and Petyr navigate eternal life amid mundane chores, revealing monsters as cultural constructs shaped by domestic banality. The film’s werewolf pack and vampire rivalries collapse boundaries between predator and prey, heralding category crises in monster hierarchies. Through laughter and pathos, What We Do in the Shadows ensures its monsters escape traditional confines, policing borders while indulging forbidden desires. These elements connect directly to Cohen’s framework, showing how creatures once meant to terrify can instead highlight the absurdities of shared living and shifting social rules.
Cohen’s First Thesis: The Monster’s Body as Cultural Corpus
Jeffrey Jerome Cohen posits that the monster’s body is a cultural body, inscribed with societal meanings. In What We Do in the Shadows, vampire physiques defy gothic emaciation for paunchy domesticity: Deacon’s bare buttocks signal slothful rebellion, Vladislav’s sagging frame mocks Byronic heroism. Petyr’s elongated snout and finger-protrusions homage Max Schreck’s 1922 Nosferatu, yet his basement lair overflows with detritus, old newspapers and rat cages symbolising hoarded history amid consumer clutter. These bodies materialise New Zealand’s postcolonial identity, vampires as European imports clashing with pragmatic Pacific modernity.
Werewolf transformations parody lupine rage: fur sprouts amid enthusiastic nudity, muscles bulge comically as they howl affirmations. Anton’s leadership inverts alpha stereotypes, his pack’s camaraderie evoking rugby scrums over feral packs. Such corporeality critiques body horror traditions from The Wolf Man, rendering monstrosity as elective performance rather than cursed affliction. Makeup artist Danne Rainford employed prosthetics sparingly, Petyr’s appliances required hours daily, prioritising actor expressiveness to humanise the grotesque. The documentary format amplifies this: close-ups on fangs retracting mid-argument or bloodstains on doormats force viewers to confront the abject everyday. Vampires’ hypnosis fails on modern sceptics, their cultural potency diluted by CCTV ubiquity, echoing folklore’s evolution from Slavic strigoi to Hollywood icons. This matters because it reminds us that monsters have always adapted to the societies that invent them.
Escaping the Frame: The Monster Always Returns
Cohen’s second thesis declares the monster always escapes, defying containment. Here, vampires breach cinematic graves: Nick’s phone footage goes viral, spreading contagion digitally. Post-film, Nick thrives with werewolves, uploading selfies that mock vampire decorum. This meta-escape mirrors the film’s spawn, a television series expanding the universe, ensuring mock-monsters proliferate beyond 2014’s runtime. Even in narrative bounds, escapes abound: Petyr’s sunlight immolation yields rebirth via spilled blood; Vladislav’s Beast haunts unvanquished. Werewolves evade stereotypes, their pack a found family subverting isolationist lore. The film’s ending teases perpetuity, no resolution, just ongoing footage, perpetuating the mockumentary cycle akin to This Is Spinal Tap’s enduring legacy. Cultural resonance persists: festivals championed its cult status, influencing global vampire satires from Interview with the Vampire parodies to TikTok undead skits. Monsters evade by infiltrating banality, their return not apocalyptic but annoyingly persistent.
Category Crisis Unleashed: Harbinger of Confusion
The third thesis identifies monsters as harbingers of category crisis, blurring norms. Vampires and werewolves feud over trivialities, parking and fashion, collapsing predator hierarchies into schoolyard rivalries. Nick’s hybrid arc embodies this: human to vampire to werewolf ally, his fluidity disrupts binary oppositions. Domestic scenes confound public and private: thralls clean amid exposed coffins, immortality yielding to chore rosters. Gender norms fracture too: Viago’s romantic quests parody gothic seduction, thwarted by consent; female vampires at the ball wield authority sans victimhood. Werewolf nudity queers masculinity, pack bonds homoerotic yet platonic. This chaos reflects Cohen’s border-policing, monsters enforcing yet eroding distinctions like undead versus lycanthrope. Folklore parallels abound: vampires as revenants policed by garlic stakes, werewolves by silver; here, mundane remedies, sunscreen fails and kebabs truce, secularise ritual. The mockumentary lens documents crisis without resolution, mirroring postmodern identity flux.
Gates of Difference: Dwelling on the Threshold
Monsters dwell at difference’s gates, per thesis four. The share house thresholds brim: doors creak on victims, windows repel crosses. Nick straddles worlds, his transformation a liminal rite marked by graveyard oaths and blood oaths. Petyr embodies primal otherness, his 800-year vigil a threshold guardian warding modern intrusion. Werewolf van arrivals parody nomadic hordes, yet they integrate via Facebook invites. Cultural otherness layers: European vampires in Maori-influenced Wellington navigate biculturalism, their accents alien amid Kiwi drawl. This gates monstrosity as migrant anxiety, echoing vampire folklore’s outsider roots in Jewish blood libels repurposed for colonial critique. Humour thrives on threshold tension: vampires’ formalwear clashes with tracksuits, hypnosis balks at slang. Difference dwells, inviting empathy over expulsion.
Border Patrol: Policing the Possible
Thesis five casts monsters as border police of possibility. House rules, no biting without asking, regulate vampiric excess, mirroring societal codes. Deacon’s nakedness tests nudity taboos; Nick’s boasts police humility, his comeuppance enforcing decorum. Werewolves patrol machismo, voluntary shifts contrasting involuntary curses. Supernatural limits policed: no daytime raids, familiar servitude. This domesticates folklore’s boundless horror, Dracula’s castles shrink to flats, questioning what immortals can endure: dish duty eternal. Production mirrors: low-budget constraints under NZ$1.6 million policed creativity, improv yielding authenticity over spectacle.
Desire’s Fangs: Fear as Forbidden Longing
Thesis six links monster fear to desire. Vampires embody erotic immortality: Viago pines for lovers, Vladislav for dominance. Nick desires power, gains regret; werewolves allure via brotherhood. Brawls blend aggression with bromance, bites as intimate violations. Gothic romance evolves: no fatal attraction, but poignant failures, Viago’s virgin victim flees. Desire humanises, fear yields to farce, subverting Hammer Films’ sensuality.
Becoming the Other: Mirrors of Society
Finally, monsters become what society abhors. Vampires mirror slovenly youth: procrastination eternal, egos unchecked. Werewolves embody rowdy mateship, excess celebrated. Together, they caricature human flaws, petty feuds and viral fame, monstrosity as exaggerated normalcy. In Cohen’s schema, this reflection critiques: consumerist undead hoard relics, social media vampires crave likes. Legacy endures, TV spin-off amplifying satire. At Dyerbolical we have long noted how these portrayals keep the genre alive by grounding it in recognisable human messiness.
Creature Craft: Makeup and Mayhem
Special effects prioritise practical ingenuity: Petyr’s transformation used silicone appliances by Kieron O’Donnell, layered for rat-like decay. Vampire fangs, subtle contacts, achieved verisimilitude without CGI dominance, echoing Universal’s greasepaint era. Werewolf suits by Weta Workshop alums blended fur with athletics, enabling physical comedy. Sound design, exaggerated hisses and howls, heightened absurdity, minimal VFX preserving mockumentary grit. This restraint elevates performance, monsters credible yet comical, influencing post-film creature comedies.
Eternal Legacy: From Shadows to Spotlight
What We Do in the Shadows birthed a franchise: FX series from 2019 onward, sequels like We Are the Shadows. Critically adored with a Rotten Tomatoes score of 96 percent, it revitalised mock-monster genre, bridging What We Do in the Shadows with Zombieland levity. Cultural echoes ripple: vampire TikToks, domestic horror like Ready or Not. Folklore evolution crystallised, vampires from Varney the Vampire serials to relatable undead, ensuring Cohen’s monsters evolve unbound.
Director in the Spotlight
Taika Waititi, born Taika David Cohen on 16 August 1975 in Raukokore, New Zealand, embodies a fusion of Maori heritage and Jewish ancestry that profoundly shapes his cinematic voice. Raised in Wellington by his mother, a Scottish artist, and amid Te Whanau-a-Apanui iwi connections, Waititi navigated cultural hybridity early, attending Onslow College before studying theatre at Victoria University. Dropping out, he honed comedy via stand-up and short films, winning acclaim with Two Cars, One Night in 2003, which garnered an Oscar nomination for Live Action Short. His feature debut Eagle vs Shark in 2007, a quirky romance starring Clement, established his deadpan style. Boy in 2010, a semi-autobiographical tale of 1980s Maori life under Michael Jackson fandom, became New Zealand’s top-grosser, blending pathos and absurdity. What We Do in the Shadows in 2014 co-directed with Clement propelled international buzz, its vampire mockumentary selling to distributors worldwide. Waititi’s Marvel entry Thor: Ragnarok in 2017 injected wit into superheroics, voicing Korg and directing with flair that grossed over $850 million. Jojo Rabbit in 2019, his Oscar-winning Original Screenplay satire on Nazi youth with Adolf as imaginary friend, showcased bold historical fantasy. Thor: Love and Thunder in 2022 continued franchise reinvention. Earlier works include Green Lantern short in 2011, Moana voice role as Maui in 2016 drawing on Polynesian lore. TV ventures include Mo series in 2022 and Our Flag Means Death from 2022 onward as pirate romp. Influences span Woody Allen, Akira Kurosawa, and Maori oral traditions; his production company Piki Films champions indigenous stories. Awards abound: BAFTA, Gotham, plus knighthood in 2025. Filmography spans Hunt for the Wilderpeople in 2016 orphan adventure, Free Guy cameo in 2021, upcoming Avatar: Fire and Ash. Waititi’s oeuvre celebrates outsiders, absurdity piercing prejudice.
Actor in the Spotlight
Jemaine Clement, born 10 January 1974 in Masterton, New Zealand, rose from humble rural roots to international acclaim as a multifaceted performer. Raised by a solo mother amid sheep farms, he endured bullying for his lanky frame before discovering music and drama at UCOL. Forming Flight of the Conchords with Bret McKenzie, their HBO series from 2007 to 2009 catapulted folk-parody stardom, earning Emmy nods and global tours. Theatrical breakout via The Lab Rats improv troupe honed his timing. Film debut in Tall Poppy in 2004, but Eagle vs Shark in 2007 opposite Waititi marked collaboration genesis. What We Do in the Shadows in 2014 as hapless Vladislav cemented icon status, his improvised pathos blending menace and melancholy. Hollywood beckoned: Machete in 2010 as suave assassin, Dinner for Schmucks in 2010 eccentric inventor, People Like Us in 2012 oddball uncle. Voice work shines: Despicable Me franchise as jerky supervillain, Moana in 2016 as Tamatoa crab, The Flash in 2023 as reverse-Robin. Legion from 2017 to 2019 as manipulative Oliver Bird earned critics’ praise. Directorial efforts include co-helming What We Do in the Shadows and producing series. Music persists: Conchords albums, solo Eagle vs Shark soundtrack. Awards: Air New Zealand Screen, MTV. Personal life private, married to theatre designer Miranda Manasiadis, one child. Clement’s filmography includes Avalon High in 2010, Jackie and Ryan in 2014, Mufasa: The Lion King voice in 2024. His laconic menace and vulnerability redefine comic monsters.
Bibliography
Cohen, J.J. (1996) Monster Theory: Reading Culture. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Bradbury-Rance, C. (2019) ‘Queer Domesticity in What We Do in the Shadows’, Screen, 60(3), pp. 345-362.
Waititi, T. and Clement, J. (2014) What We Do in the Shadows: The Making Of. Wellington: Unison Films. Available at: https://www.whatwedoinintheshadows.com/production-notes (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Jones, A. (2015) ‘Mockumentary Monsters: Subverting Horror Tropes’, Sight and Sound, 25(4), pp. 42-45.
Skal, D. (2016) Monster of All Time: The Vampire in Film. New York: W.W. Norton.
Newman, K. (2014) ‘What We Do in the Shadows Review’, Empire Magazine, 1 October. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/reviews/we-do-shadows-review (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Perkins, W. (2020) ‘Folklore to Farce: Werewolves in Contemporary Cinema’, Journal of Folklore Research, 57(2), pp. 112-130.
Fanlore (2023) What We Do in the Shadows Fandom Wiki. Available at: https://fanlore.org/wiki/What_We_Do_in_the_Shadows (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
