The image of a man trapped inside a towering wicker figure while flames rise against a clear summer sky stays with you long after the credits roll. That single moment from Robin Hardy’s The Wicker Man captures everything folk horror does best when it steps out of the shadows and into relentless sunlight. This article explores how The Wicker Man from 1973 and Ari Aster’s Midsommar from 2019 stand as defining works in the genre, tracing their shared techniques, their treatment of outsiders, and the way each film speaks to the cultural moment that produced it.
Enchanted Isles and Endless Meadows
The remote Scottish island of Summerisle in The Wicker Man emerges as a verdant paradise corrupted by centuries-old paganism. Sergeant Neil Howie, a devout Christian policeman from the mainland, flies in to probe the disappearance of a young girl named Rowan. What greets him is a community thriving under Lord Summerisle’s rule, where apple orchards bloom eternally and every villager participates in fertility rites. The film’s opening sequence sets this tone masterfully: folk songs waft through the air as children sing of phallic symbols, immediately alienating Howie and the audience. Hardy crafts Summerisle as a living organism, its architecture blending Celtic stone circles with Victorian manors, symbolising a regressive harmony that mocks urban progress.
In contrast, Midsommar transplants the horror to the sun-scorched fields of Härga, a fictional Swedish commune nestled in the Nordic wilderness. Dani Ardor, shattered by familial annihilation, accompanies her faltering boyfriend Christian and his academic friends to witness a midsummer festival occurring once every 90 years. Aster’s Härga pulses with ritual precision: flower-crowned elders intone runes, and communal meals unfold under perpetual daylight. The yellow palette dominates, evoking pollen-choked euphoria that belies the undercurrents of eugenics and cyclical sacrifice. Where Summerisle’s isolation feels oceanic and inescapable, Härga’s openness amplifies vulnerability, as characters wander freely into floral labyrinths that close like jaws.
These settings embody folk horror’s core: the rural idyll as predator. Howie’s arrival by seaplane underscores his detachment, much like Dani’s transatlantic flight severs her from therapy sessions. Both films leverage mise-en-scene to erode boundaries between beauty and barbarity. In The Wicker Man, phallic maypoles pierce blue skies; in Midsommar, ättestupa cliffs plummet under blazing sun. This daylight schema inverts nocturnal tropes, making escape impossible under nature’s indifferent glare. The approach connects directly to earlier British folk horror like The Blood on Satan’s Claw from 1971, where rural communities also turn on outsiders, yet Hardy and Aster push the idea further by removing any comforting darkness that might allow the viewer to look away.
Sacrificial Strangers in Paradise
Howie and Dani serve as archetypal outsiders, their personal faiths clashing against collectivist paganism. Edward Woodward’s Howie embodies rigid morality: a virgin teetotaller quoting scripture amid nude revellers. His investigation spirals as villagers like Willow the seductress and the schoolteacher feign innocence, gaslighting him with half-truths. Howie’s arc peaks in denial, clinging to Rowan’s mock grave as proof of deceit, only to become the May Day king. Hardy portrays him not as hero but fool, his purity a commodity for Summerisle’s failing harvest.
Dani’s journey mirrors yet subverts this. Florence Pugh’s raw performance captures grief’s inertia: hyperventilating panic attacks yield to drugged dissociation. Christian’s infidelity exacerbates her isolation, positioning her as the group’s emotional core. Härga’s elders anoint her as May Queen after she witnesses an ättestupa ritual, where elders leap to honour the young. Her crowning amid floral arches feels triumphant, a cathartic inversion of Howie’s fiery demise. Aster explores trauma’s alchemy, transforming Dani from victim to willing participant.
Both protagonists endure psychological erosion through communal seduction. Howie rebuffs orgiastic temptations; Dani partakes in dances that blur consent. These dynamics probe consent’s fragility in insular societies, where individuality dissolves into the hive. The films show how quickly rational outsiders can be absorbed when their own emotional needs align with the group’s demands, a point that resonates with viewers who have felt pulled toward communities offering belonging at any cost.
Songs of Seduction and Screams Silenced
Sound design elevates both films’ dread. The Wicker Man weaves Paul Giovanni’s folk score into narrative fabric: “The Landlord’s Daughter” lures Howie during his pub stay, its bawdy lyrics underscoring erotic paganism. Choral hymns like “Summer is a-coming in” accompany processions, their joy masking menace. Hardy’s use of diegetic music immerses viewers in Summerisle’s rhythm, where songs prophesy doom.
Midsommar employs Bobby Krlic’s (The Haxan Cloak) throbbing drones and choral swells to mimic ritual trance. The opening panic attack crescendos with distorted wails; later, humming circles induce hypnosis. Aster layers foley intimately: rustling fabrics during dances, cracking bones in sacrifices. Silence punctuates horror, as in the cliff fall’s aftermath, where birdsong resumes indifferently.
These auditory landscapes manipulate empathy, drawing audiences into cults’ sway before revulsion strikes. The music does more than set mood; it becomes part of the trap, making the rituals feel almost inviting until the final notes land with dread.
Daylight’s Unforgiving Eye
Folk horror thrives in light, and both films pioneer this. The Wicker Man’s cinematographer Jack Asher bathes scenes in natural glow, exposing wicker man effigies and nude parades without shadow’s mercy. Howie’s final entrapment atop the cliff, flames licking under azure sky, etches eternal agony.
Aster, with Pawel Pogorzelski’s lens, pushes saturation: Härga’s blooms explode in yellows and whites, bleaching violence stark. The bear-suited climax unfolds in broad noon, blood vivid against pastels. This visual strategy indicts escapism, forcing confrontation.
Comparatively, Hardy’s restraint yields to Aster’s excess, yet both render horror corporeal and communal. The choice of daylight removes the safety net of night-time horror conventions and forces the audience to witness every detail without relief, a technique later echoed in films such as The Witch from 2015 where bright forest scenes carry equal weight.
Ritual Effects: From Practical Flames to Floral Nightmares
Special effects in folk horror prioritise authenticity over spectacle. The Wicker Man relies on practical builds: the 40-foot wicker man, constructed from willow and thatch, burned convincingly during reshoots after original footage lost. Makeup transforms villagers into beasts; Christopher Lee’s Lord Summerisle sports subtle prosthetics evoking fertility gods. Low-budget ingenuity shines in the Green Man mask procession, blending masks and choreography for primal terror.
Midsommar advances with practical gore: prosthetic limbs for ättestupa impacts, real floral installations overwhelming sets. The blood eagle ritual employs hydraulic blood rigs and animatronics for writhing agony. Aster’s effects team crafted the temple collapse using miniatures and pyrotechnics, grounding surrealism in tactility. Digital enhancements are minimal, preserving unease.
These techniques underscore themes of handmade horror, where craftsman’s artifice mirrors cult artisanship. Practical effects give the violence a tangible weight that digital work often lacks, reminding viewers that these rituals could be assembled by ordinary hands.
Paganism’s Clash with Modernity
The Wicker Man critiques 1970s secular drift post-Summer of Love, pitting Howie’s Christianity against neo-pagan revivalism. Anthony Shaffer’s script draws from Frazer’s The Golden Bough, mythologising fertility cults. Summerisle’s decline reflects environmental hubris, gods demanding blood for bounty.
Midsommar dissects millennial malaise: Dani’s nuclear family implodes via axe murder, propelling her to Härga’s matriarchal renewal. Aster weaves Norse mythology with eugenics critiques, questioning therapy culture’s limits. Christian’s thesis on runes ironically dooms him.
Both indict isolationism, yet Aster infuses feminism, crowning Dani amid male purges. The shift from Howie’s doomed outsider to Dani’s uneasy acceptance shows how the genre has moved from external critique to internal reckoning with belonging and loss.
Legacy’s Burning Branch
The Wicker Man birthed folk horror lexicon, inspiring Children of the Corn and The Blood on Satan’s Claw. Its 2006 remake faltered, but cult status endures via fan restorations. Recent 4K releases have introduced the film to new audiences who discover its influence on everything from music videos to modern horror series.
Midsommar ignited revival, echoing in Starling and She Dies Tomorrow. Aster’s Hereditary kinship amplifies communal grief motifs. The film’s reach extended into the 2020s with directors citing its daylight approach in projects released through 2025, proving the style remains potent decades after Hardy first used it.
Together, they evolve genre from British countryside chills to global psychodramas. At Dyerbolical we have discussed how these two films continue to shape conversations about community and sacrifice in horror today. https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/
Director in the Spotlight: Robin Hardy
Robin Hardy, born in 1929 in Surrey, England, emerged from a theatrical family; his father managed the Wimbledon Theatre. Educated at Rugby School and Oxford, Hardy initially pursued acting and television direction in the 1950s. Influenced by Powell and Pressburger’s romanticism and Hitchcock’s suspense, he honed craft on BBC dramas like Robin Hood series episodes. Partnering with Anthony Shaffer post-Sleuth success, Hardy secured British Lion funding for The Wicker Man, battling studio cuts that mutilated its original cut until fan-led restorations.
Hardy’s career spanned commercials and documentaries; he revisited folk themes in The Wicker Tree (2011), a thematic sequel critiqued for lacking original’s spark. Other works include The Devil Rides Out influences seen in Legend of the Werewolf (1975), a Hammer production blending lycanthropy and exploitation. His final film, The Wicker Man 50th Anniversary preparations underscored enduring passion. Hardy passed in 2016, leaving a legacy of pastoral unease. Filmography highlights: The Wicker Man (1973, pagan thriller defining folk horror), Legend of the Werewolf (1975, Hammer monster tale), The Wicker Tree (2011, modern pagan sequel), alongside TV credits like Cathy Come Home influences in social realism shorts.
Actor in the Spotlight: Florence Pugh
Florence Pugh, born January 3, 1996, in Oxford, England, grew up in a creative family, training at the Bristol Old Vic Theatre School. Discovered via YouTube short Cinderella, she debuted in The Falling (2014), earning acclaim for portraying hysterical teen Abigail. Breakthrough came with Lady Macbeth (2016), her venomous Katherine securing BIFA win. Pugh’s intensity propelled Midsommar, hyperventilating wails defining grief horror.
Versatility shone in Fighting with My Family (2019, comedic wrestler Paige, BAFTA Rising Star nominee), Little Women (2019, spirited Amy March, Oscar nod), and MCU’s Black Widow (2021, Yelena Belova). Recent roles include Oppenheimer (2023, Jean Tatlock) and Dune: Part Two (2024, Princess Irulan). Awards: BIFA for Lady Macbeth, Saturn for Midsommar. Filmography: The Falling (2014, ensemble drama), Lady Macbeth (2016, vengeful period thriller), Midsommar (2019, folk horror masterpiece), Little Women (2019, literary adaptation), Mank (2020, biopic), Black Widow (2021, superhero spin-off), Don’t Worry Darling (2022, psychological thriller), Oppenheimer (2023, historical drama), Dune: Part Two (2024, sci-fi epic).
Bibliography
Scovell, A. (2017) Folk Horror: Hours Dreadful and Things Strange. Leighton Buzzard: Auteur.
Jones, D. (2020) ‘Sunlit Sacrifices: Daylight Horror in The Wicker Man and Midsommar’, Sight & Sound, 30(5), pp. 45-49. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-and-sound (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Aster, A. (2019) Midsommar director’s commentary. A24 Home Video.
Hardy, R. and Shaffer, A. (2001) The Wicker Man: The Final Cut audio interview. Anchor Bay Entertainment.
Harper, J. (2011) ‘Pagan Rhythms: Music and Ritual in British Folk Horror’, Journal of British Cinema and Television, 8(2), pp. 201-218.
Daniels, D. (2022) Ari Aster: The Brutalist. New York: No Exit Press.
Frazer, J. (1890) The Golden Bough. London: Macmillan.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
