What if the greatest act of creation also became the deepest violation of self? Yorgos Lanthimos turns that question into a visceral cinematic experience in Poor Things, a 2023 film that reworks Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein for a modern audience while staying true to its Victorian roots.
This article examines the film’s narrative structure, its striking visual approach to body horror, the performances that anchor its emotional core, and the production details that brought its grotesque world to life. It also explores the director’s career path, the lead actress’s remarkable transformation, and the lasting questions the story raises about autonomy and invention.
Laboratory Genesis: The Spark of Forbidden Life
In the fog-shrouded towers of Godwin Baxter’s Victorian mansion, Poor Things ignites its narrative with a scene of profound violation. A pregnant woman, felled by suicide, plummets from a bridge into the Thames. Her body, recovered and repurposed, receives an infant’s brain harvested from the unborn child within. Godwin Baxter, portrayed with leering intensity by Willem Dafoe, orchestrates this reanimation, his scarred visage a testament to his own experimental past. Bella Baxter stirs to life, her first steps wobbly, her vocabulary limited to monosyllables, embodying the ultimate tabula rasa forged in the crucible of surgical precision.
The plot unfurls as a picaresque journey. Duncan Wednesday, a roguish lawyer played by Mark Ruffalo, lures Bella from her cloistered existence with promises of adventure. Their escapades span decadent Lisbon brothels, revolutionary Alexandria, and the opulent absurdities of Paris, where Bella evolves from naive ingénue to self-possessed force. Encounters with figures like the sinister Madame Swiney (Kathryn Hunter) and the suicidal Max McCandles (Ramy Youssef) punctuate her arc, each revelation peeling back layers of societal hypocrisy. Returning to Baxter’s lair, Bella confronts her creator, demanding agency over her reconstructed form.
This synopsis reveals Lanthimos’ debt to Gothic traditions, yet infuses them with steampunk flair. The film’s production drew from Gray’s 1992 novel, but Lanthimos and screenwriter Tony McNamara amplify the horror elements, transforming whimsy into a meditation on corporeal autonomy. Behind-the-scenes accounts detail painstaking set construction in Hungary, where Baxter’s home replicated a cross-sectioned whale carcass, symbolising the devouring maw of creation. Legends of Frankenstein abound here, but Poor Things subverts the monster’s rage into a voracious curiosity, horror rooted not in rampage but in rebirth’s ethical chasm.
Key cast shine amid the madness: Emma Stone’s Bella devolves and ascends through physical contortions, her wide eyes capturing unfiltered wonder. Dafoe’s Baxter blends paternal menace with vulnerability, his experiments evoking Victor Frankenstein’s folly amplified by Victorian pseudoscience. Ruffalo’s caddish Duncan provides comic relief laced with unease, his seduction a microcosm of exploitative power dynamics.
Flesh Unraveled: Body Horror in Steampunk Splendor
Body horror permeates Poor Things, manifesting in Bella’s pieced-together physique and the casual vivisections of Baxter’s menagerie. Her resurrection evokes the sutured abominations of David Cronenberg, yet Lanthimos opts for fish-eye lenses and exaggerated fisheye prosthetics to distort proportions, rendering the human form alien. Scenes of Bella devouring raw offal or masturbating with a finger foreshadow her erotic odyssey, where pleasure becomes a tool of emancipation, horror lurking in the violation of natural boundaries.
Technological terror underscores these transformations. Baxter’s surgeries, performed with bellows and ether, parody Enlightenment progress, their crude efficacy a nod to 19th-century galvanism. When Bella swaps brains with a dog in a hallucinatory sequence, the film plunges into cosmic absurdity, questioning the soul’s locus amid neural transplants. This mirrors body horror staples like The Thing (1982), but replaces paranoia with playful anarchy, the body as malleable clay in the sculptor’s profane hands.
Mise-en-scene amplifies unease: Robbie Ryan’s cinematography employs stark contrasts, lighting Baxter’s lab like a vivarium, glass walls exposing innards. Set designer Shona Heath crafted Lisbon as a pastel dystopia, brothels teeming with prosthetic limbs and mechanical aids, evoking a world where flesh is commodity. These visuals ground the horror in tangible grotesquerie, far from abstract cosmic voids, yet hint at existential dread through Bella’s expanding worldview.
Iconic scenes crystallise this: Bella’s first sexual encounter with Duncan, shot in claustrophobic close-ups, blends ecstasy and exploitation, her oversized head lolling in disproportionate bliss. Later, in Paris, she prostitutes herself to fund political agitation, her body a site of economic and ideological warfare, horror emerging from commodified autonomy.
Mind’s Expansion: From Cradle to Cosmic Defiance
Bella’s intellectual awakening forms the narrative core, her progression from “Mama” to multilingual philosopher a rebellion against imposed infancy. Lanthimos draws on Enlightenment tropes, positioning her as a feral child unleashed upon corrupt civilisation, her unfiltered gaze exposing hypocrisies. This arc interrogates nature versus nurture, with horror in the acceleration of maturity via surgical intervention.
Thematic depth abounds in patriarchal critique. Baxter, Duncan, and even revolutionary Felix embody control, their affections veiling possession. Bella’s sexual liberation, spanning polyamory to self-experimentation, reclaims body autonomy, yet carries body horror undertones in its excess. Phallic symbols loom large, from Duncan’s impotence to Parisian excesses. Feminism here is visceral, won through fleshly trials.
Isolation amplifies terror: Bella’s initial confinement evokes space horror’s void, her mansion a microcosm of entrapment. Escaping to teeming cities, she confronts humanity’s underbelly. Poverty, war, prostitution mirror cosmic insignificance, individual agency dwarfed by societal machinery.
Corporate greed parallels modern biotech nightmares, Baxter’s philanthropy a facade for vivisection. This technological hubris invites comparisons to Ex Machina (2014), but Poor Things revels in analogue horror, scalpels supplanting AI as agents of dehumanisation. At Dyerbolical we have long tracked how such stories reflect real-world anxieties about scientific overreach.
Grotesque Mechanics: Effects and Artifice Unveiled
Special effects anchor the film’s body horror, blending practical mastery with subtle digital enhancement. Prosthetics by makeup artist Nadia Stacey sculpted Dafoe’s facial scars and Bella’s initial hunch, drawing from H.R. Giger’s biomechanics but softened into whimsical deformity. Practical sets dominated, with Budapest studios housing the whale-house, its innards fabricated from silicone and latex for tactile verisimilitude.
Digital touches augmented distortions: wide-angle lenses created Bella’s baby-like proportions, post-production tweaks refined movements for uncanny valley effect. Jerskin Fendrix’s score, with its theremin wails and percussive frenzy, sonically evokes mutation, heightening surgical scenes’ dread.
Production challenges abounded: the Venice Film Festival premiere in 2023 faced minor censorship debates over nudity, yet earned Oscar nods for production design. Financing via Element Pictures and Film4 allowed Lanthimos’ vision untrammelled, contrasting restrained blockbusters.
These elements cement Poor Things genre placement: a bridge between body horror classics like Society (1989) and contemporary hybrids, its effects practical core ensuring enduring impact over fleeting CGI. By 2024 Lanthimos carried similar tactile unease into Kinds of Kindness, showing how his approach to physical transformation continues to evolve.
Ripples Through the Void: Influence and Legacy
Poor Things reshapes sci-fi horror discourse, its feminist Frankenstein influencing post-2023 works probing bioethics. Cultural echoes appear in memes of Bella’s gait and scholarly dissections of its queerness. Sequels loom unlikely, but Lanthimos’ oeuvre expands the subgenre’s palette.
Historically, it dialogues with Island of Lost Souls (1932), updating Moreau’s island to urban sprawl. Within AvP-like crossovers, its creature-feature vibes echo predatory metamorphoses, technological terror intimate yet profound.
Performances elevate it: Stone’s physicality garnered a second Oscar, her arc a masterclass in de-evolution. Supporting turns, like Hunter’s porcine madame, infuse comic horror with menace.
Ultimately, the film posits creation as double-edged, horror not in monstrosity but in the mirror held to creators. Discussions around bodily autonomy in cinema have only grown louder since its release, with later films echoing its blend of grotesque humour and ethical inquiry.
Director in the Spotlight
Yorgos Lanthimos, born in 1973 in Athens, Greece, emerged from a theatre background steeped in Greek absurdism and experimental video. His early career flourished in commercials and music videos, honing a signature style of deadpan surrealism and power imbalances. Breaking internationally with Dogtooth (2009), a claustrophobic tale of parental control earning an Oscar nomination, Lanthimos critiqued authoritarianism through familial horror.
Collaborating with screenwriter Efthimis Filippou, he helmed The Lobster (2015), a dystopian romance mandating coupledom under threat of animal transformation, premiering at Cannes. The Killing of a Sacred Deer (2017) delved into Greek tragedy via medical curse, starring Colin Farrell and Nicole Kidman. The Favourite (2018), a baroque period piece with Olivia Colman, Rachel Weisz, and Emma Stone, won three Oscars and solidified his Hollywood foothold.
Influences span Luis Buñuel’s surrealism, Stanley Kubrick’s precision, and Lars von Trier’s provocation. Lanthimos’ move to English-language films retained his wide-lens alienation, as in Belinda (2023, TV) and Kinds of Kindness (2024), an anthology of cruelty. Poor Things marks his most ambitious fusion of whimsy and grotesquerie, backed by Searchlight Pictures. Upcoming projects include a remake of Bugsy Malone and Frankenstein adaptation, promising further body horror explorations. His oeuvre, spanning 20+ features and shorts, champions the uncomfortable, dissecting human folly with unflinching gaze.
Actor in the Spotlight
Emma Stone, born Emily Jean Stone on 6 November 1988 in Scottsdale, Arizona, abandoned high school at 15 for acting ambitions, landing in Los Angeles with parents’ support. Early TV roles in Medium (2005) and Lucky Louie (2006) preceded her breakout in Superbad (2007) as resilient Jules.
Easy A (2010) showcased her comedic timing as Scarlet Letter-inspired Olive, earning MTV nods. Crazy, Stupid, Love (2011) paired her with Ryan Gosling, igniting rom-com stardom. The Help (2011) brought dramatic weight, followed by Birdman (2014). Her role in La La Land (2016) as aspiring actress Mia won the Academy Award for Best Actress, Golden Globe, and BAFTA, cementing musical prowess.
Reuniting with Lanthimos in The Favourite (2018) as scheming Abigail, she nabbed another Oscar nomination. Poor Things (2023) delivered her second Best Actress Oscar for Bella, praised for physical comedy and emotional depth. Other notables: The Croods voice (2013), Battle of the Sexes (2017) as Billie Jean King, Zombieland: Double Tap (2019), and Cruella (2021). Producing via Fruit Tree, she backed The Curse (2023). With 40+ credits, Stone embodies versatility, blending vulnerability with ferocity across genres.
Craving more dives into sci-fi body horror and cosmic dread? Explore the AvP Odyssey archives for analyses of Alien, The Thing, and beyond. Subscribe for weekly terrors delivered to your inbox.
Bibliography
Bradshaw, P. (2023) Poor Things review – a film of warped, wackadoo wonder. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2023/dec/28/poor-things-review-a-film-of-warped-wackadoo-wonder (Accessed 1 October 2024).
Collum, J. (2024) ‘Body Politics and Reanimation in Yorgos Lanthimos’ Poor Things’, Journal of Film and Media Studies, 15(1), pp. 45-62.
Lanthimos, Y. (2023) Interview: On Poor Things and Frankensteinian Themes. IndieWire. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com/features/interviews/yorgos-lanthimos-poor-things-interview-1234923456/ (Accessed 1 October 2024).
Orme, J. (2023) Monsters and Mothers: Feminism in Poor Things. BFI Sight and Sound. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-and-sound/reviews/poor-things-feminism-body-horror (Accessed 1 October 2024).
Ryan, R. (2023) Cinematography of Poor Things: Fish-Eye Nightmares. American Cinematographer. Available at: https://theasc.com/magazine/dec2023/robbie-ryan-poor-things (Accessed 1 October 2024).
Stone, E. (2024) Variety Actors on Actors: Emma Stone on Bella Baxter. Variety. Available at: https://variety.com/2024/film/awards/emma-stone-poor-things-interview-1235890123/ (Accessed 1 October 2024).
Tiffany, K. (2023) Poor Things and the Erotic Grotesque. The Atlantic. Available at: https://www.theatlantic.com/culture/archive/2023/12/poor-things-erotic-grotesque/676912/ (Accessed 1 October 2024).
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
