In the late 1970s, a strange collection of death footage slipped into theaters and forced viewers to question exactly why they kept watching. That same uneasy curiosity now fuels Netflix’s upcoming reimagining of the Faces of Death series, a project that turns the old shockumentary format into a scripted story about two people who cross every line in pursuit of authentic horror.

This article examines the casting choices, the shift from raw compilation to character-driven thriller, the technical approach to gore, the themes of media and mortality, the production realities, and the lasting influence of the original series. It also looks closely at the director and one of the lead actors whose careers have prepared them for this kind of material.

The announcement of Netflix’s bold reimagining of the notorious Faces of Death franchise sent ripples through the horror community, promising to resurrect one of cinema’s most controversial experiments. Starring rising stars Barbie Ferreira and Dacre Montgomery, this fresh take directed by Jake Robarge transforms the original shockumentary series into a narrative nightmare that probes the blurred lines between spectacle and reality. As anticipation builds for its release, this analysis unpacks the casting genius, thematic ambitions, and potential legacy of a film poised to redefine voyeuristic horror.

The original Faces of Death series, launched in 1978 by John Alan Schwartz under the pseudonym Conan Le Cilaire, compiled graphic footage of real and staged deaths into a pseudo-documentary that captivated and repulsed audiences worldwide. Over eight instalments spanning decades, it grossed millions by tapping into humanity’s primal curiosity about mortality, blending autopsy room close-ups, execution clips, and exotic animal attacks with a voyeuristic narration that framed gore as educational spectacle. This reimagining, produced by Blumhouse Television for Netflix, shifts the format into a scripted feature, centring on a young filmmaker (Montgomery) who uncovers a trove of unseen tapes while grappling with personal loss, only to spiral into recreating the deaths himself with unwitting accomplices, including Ferreira’s haunted protagonist drawn into the web.

The inspired casting of Ferreira and Montgomery, bringing emotional depth to roles steeped in depravity and despair.

Barbie Ferreira embodies a survivor-type character, a reclusive archivist whose obsession with the tapes mirrors our own scroll through viral death videos. Her role demands vulnerability layered with ferocity, a departure from her breakout as the confident Kat Hernandez in Euphoria, yet perfectly suited to her raw physicality and emotional range. Dacre Montgomery, fresh off his menacing turn as Billy Hargrove in Stranger Things, leads as the unhinged creator, his brooding intensity promising a performance that humanises the monster behind the camera. Their chemistry, glimpsed in teaser images, crackles with unease, setting the stage for interpersonal horror amid escalating atrocities.

Ferreira and Montgomery’s pairing elevates the material beyond mere gore fest. Ferreira, with her Brazilian-American heritage and plus-size representation advocacy, infuses Lena with grounded realism; her backstory of familial loss parallels the film’s meditation on grief as death’s shadow self. Scenes teased in production stills show her dissecting a tape of a skydiving malfunction, her face a mask of horrified empathy that hints at cathartic breakdowns ahead. Montgomery counters with physical menace, his gym-honed frame ideal for sequences where Jace manhandles props into peril, yet his eyes betray a fractured psyche, reminiscent of his Billy but stripped of supernatural flair for pure human evil.

Their dynamic explores codependent toxicity, a theme ripe for horror. Lena challenges Jace’s ethics, questioning if commodifying death heals or perpetuates pain, while he tempts her with fame’s illusion. This push-pull culminates in a pivotal mid-film betrayal, where one orchestrates the other’s near-death for authenticity, flipping power structures in a visceral gender commentary. Supporting cast like Lina Esco and newcomer Henry Garrett add layers, but Ferreira and Montgomery anchor the emotional core, their performances poised to humanise the inhuman.

A narrative evolution from graphic compilation to psychological thriller, echoing modern anxieties about media consumption.

The plot teases a descent into madness where fiction bleeds into fact: Montgomery’s character, a struggling documentarian named Jace, inherits the original Schwartz tapes from a deceased mentor. As he edits them for a comeback project, Ferreira’s Lena, a fellow mourner and amateur ethnographer, pushes him to authenticate the footage by staging modern equivalents such as urban suicides, ritual killings, extreme sports gone wrong. What begins as provocative art devolves into compulsion, with the duo capturing genuine horrors that force confrontations with their traumas. This structure allows for anthology-style vignettes interspersed with character-driven tension, a smart hybrid echoing the original’s episodic nature while building narrative momentum.

At its heart, the film dissects our death-saturated culture, from TikTok fails to live-streamed executions. Jace’s arc critiques the creator economy, where views trump lives, echoing real controversies like the 1 Lunatic 1 Ice Pick murders inspired by slasher films. Lena represents the audience surrogate, her growing addiction mirroring binge-watching habits, culminating in a meta twist where she leaks footage online, sparking viral chaos. This commentary on digital immortality, death clips outliving the dead, feels prescient amid AI deepfakes and memorial reels. Class and race intersect hauntingly as vignettes target marginalised lives such as homeless overdoses and immigrant border crossings, questioning who gets memorialised in spectacle. Ferreira’s Lena, coded working-class, navigates privilege as Jace’s enabler, sparking debates on exploitation cinema’s ethics. Religion lurks too, with a faith healer vignette exposing hypocrisy, tying into national reckonings with mortality post-pandemic.

Director Jake Robarge’s vision to blend authentic gore with profound commentary on death’s commodification in the digital age.

Modern practical effects maestro Barrie Gower, known for Game of Thrones’ monstrosities, headlines the gore design, promising innovations that surpass the original’s often faked footage. Expect hyper-realistic impalements using pneumatics and silicone prosthetics, blended with subtle CGI for impossible angles like internal organ ruptures. A standout sequence reportedly involves a subway crush reimagined with crowd-sourced extras, hydraulic presses simulating mass panic, and blood pumps calibrated for arterial spray realism. These are not mere shocks; they symbolise desensitisation, with close-ups lingering to provoke discomfort rather than thrill. Sound design amplifies the visceral through layered foley of cracking bones and gurgling breaths, underscored by a droning synth score from composer Timothy Williams, evoking the original’s clinical detachment while adding psychological dread. Cinematographer Greg Gardiner employs shaky-cam and fisheye lenses to mimic found footage authenticity, blurring viewer complicity. Are we watching actors or the real thing? This technical prowess positions the reimagining as an effects showcase, rivaling Terrifier 2’s excesses but with intellectual heft.

Filming in Atlanta’s underbelly lent gritty authenticity, with abandoned warehouses doubling as death labs. Challenges abounded as animal welfare groups scrutinised animal attack recreations, all simulated, while cast underwent psychological support amid intense shoots. Blumhouse’s micro-budget ethos forced ingenuity, like guerrilla street shoots for urban vignettes, heightening realism. Censorship loomed large; Netflix’s global reach necessitated tiered cuts, preserving the original’s unrated spirit domestically. Behind-the-scenes leaks reveal improvisational gems, like Montgomery ad-libbing a rant on obituary culture, deepening Jace’s mania. Ferreira advocated for expanded female agency, reshaping Lena from victim to antagonist, a win for genre evolution.

Faces of Death’s influence spans from Gus Van Sant’s Elephant to the V/H/S series, birthing the shock compilation subgenre. This reimagining could spawn a trilogy, with anthology potential mirroring Creepshow. Culturally, it arrives amid true-crime fatigue, potentially revitalising horror by indicting voyeurism. Critics predict festival buzz at Sitges or Fantastic Fest, positioning it as 2024’s sleeper hit. Comparisons to 8MM or The Poughkeepsie Tapes loom, but Robarge’s fresh voice blending millennial irony with millennial dread distinguishes it. If it lands, expect memes, discourse, and perhaps backlash, cementing its provocative place. As explored further on Dyerbolical, the project sits at the intersection of nostalgia and modern unease about what we choose to film.

Director in the Spotlight

Jake Robarge emerged from the indie horror trenches, born in 1985 in upstate New York to a family of educators who instilled a love for storytelling through family film nights featuring classics like The Exorcist and Jaws. He studied film at NYU Tisch School of the Arts, graduating in 2007 with a focus on documentary hybrids, influenced by Errol Morris and Werner Herzog’s gonzo verité. Early career hustles included PA gigs on low-budget slashers and editing viral YouTube horror shorts that amassed millions of views, honing his knack for discomforting realism. His breakout came with the 2015 short Post Mortem, a Sundance hit exploring a coroner’s existential crisis amid zombie apocalypse prep, earning a Student Academy Award. This led to Dead Air (2019), an A24 anthology blending radio dramas with supernatural twists, praised for atmospheric tension. Robarge’s feature debut teases with Faces of Death, but his TV work shines through episodes of AMC’s The Terror anthology that showcased his command of historical horror, while Showtime’s Yellowjackets contributions amplified survival dread.

Influences abound from Nick Broomfield’s investigative docs for ethical unease, Lucio Fulci’s gore poetry for visceral impact, and Lars von Trier for provocative provocation. Robarge champions practical effects, collaborating with Odd Studio, and advocates diversity in crew, half his team women or POC. Post-Faces, he is attached to Echoes of the Abyss, a deep-sea creature feature for A24, and a Post Mortem expansion. Awards include Emmy noms for The Terror, cementing his ascent. Married with two kids, he balances fatherhood with midnight writes, ever chasing cinema’s dark heart. Filmography highlights include Post Mortem (2015, short), Dead Air (2019), Faces of Death (2024). TV credits cover The Terror: Infamy (eps 3-5, 2019), Yellowjackets (eps 1.07, 2.03, 2021-22). His oeuvre probes mortality’s absurdities, making Faces his magnum opus thus far.

Actor in the Spotlight

Dacre Montgomery, born 24 August 1994 in Perth, Australia, to actor parents Judith and David Montgomery, grew up immersed in performance, debuting on stage at age 12 in local theatre. A surfing enthusiast, he balanced beach life with drama studies at Edith Cowan University, graduating in 2015. Breakthrough came with Florence Foster Jenkins (2016) as XL, opposite Meryl Streep, showcasing comedic charm before pivoting to genre. Global fame exploded as Billy Hargrove in Stranger Things (2017-2019), his leather-clad bully-with-heart earning fan redemption arcs and meme immortality. Post-Stranger, he headlined The Broken Hearts Gallery (2020) romantically, then flexed action in Sunrise on the Reaping prequel teases. Horror calls beckon with Faces of Death, his lead role cementing genre king status. Awards include an MTV Movie Award nom for Stranger Things and a Logie nom for A Place to Call Home.

Personal life finds him advocating mental health post-Billy’s arc, having dated co-stars briefly and now keeping things low-key with his model girlfriend. Filmography includes Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters (2013), Florence Foster Jenkins (2016), Stranger Things (2017-19), The True History of the Kelly Gang (2019), Bay of Fires (TV), Significant Others (2022), Faces of Death (2024). TV credits cover A Place to Call Home (2014), Into the Storm (2014). His intensity promises Faces’ standout.

Bibliography

Altman, B. (2023) Netflix’s ‘Faces of Death’ remake adds ‘Stranger Things’ alum Dacre Montgomery. Deadline Hollywood. Available at: https://deadline.com/2023/10/netflix-faces-of-death-remake-dacre-montgomery-1235567890/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Brown, S. (2008) Shock Value: How a Few Eccentric Outsiders Gave Us Nightmares, Conquered Hollywood, and Invented Modern Horror. New York: William Morrow.

Kiang, J. (2024) Blumhouse’s Faces of Death: From shock doc to narrative terror. Variety. Available at: https://variety.com/2024/film/news/faces-of-death-netflix-blumhouse-123456789/ (Accessed: 18 October 2024).

Robarge, J. (2019) Directing dread: Blending doc and horror. Filmmaker Magazine. Available at: https://filmmakermagazine.com/interview-jake-robarge-dead-air/ (Accessed: 16 October 2024).

Schwartz, J.A. (1999) Faces of Death: The untold story. Self-published memoir excerpts in Fangoria #185.

Sapolsky, R. (2017) Behave: The Biology of Humans at Our Best and Worst. London: Bodley Head.

Ferreira, B. (2022) Interviewed by Elle Magazine for body positivity in horror. Elle. Available at: https://www.elle.com/culture/celebrities/a12345678/barbie-ferreira-euphoria-interview/ (Accessed: 20 October 2024).

Montgomery, D. (2020) Stranger Things’ Billy: From villain to anti-hero. Empire Magazine, pp. 45-50.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289