Pagan Fire or Flesh Gone Wrong: The Wicker Man and The Fly Face Off in Horror’s Ultimate Duel

When a straight-laced policeman steps onto a remote Scottish island and finds himself marked for sacrifice inside a towering effigy, or a gifted scientist realises his body is slowly becoming something else after a single careless moment in the lab, horror reveals two starkly different routes to lasting dread. This piece looks closely at Robin Hardy’s The Wicker Man from 1973 and David Cronenberg’s The Fly from 1986, tracing how each film builds its particular brand of fear and asking which one leaves the deeper mark on the viewer.

Two masterpieces of unease stand tall in horror’s pantheon: Robin Hardy’s The Wicker Man (1973), a chilling descent into folkloric ritual, and David Cronenberg’s The Fly (1986), a grotesque symphony of bodily decay. This showdown pits the communal terror of island cultists against the intimate horror of personal transformation, forcing us to confront which vision of dread strikes deeper into the psyche.

How The Wicker Man crafts folk horror through seductive heresy and inevitable sacrifice. Why The Fly elevates body horror to nauseating perfection via Cronenberg’s unflinching gaze. A verdict on supremacy: ritualistic ecstasy or visceral mutation as horror’s true pinnacle.

Harvest of the Damned: Unravelling The Wicker Man

Robin Hardy’s The Wicker Man unfolds on the remote Hebridean island of Summerisle, where devout Christian policeman Sergeant Neil Howie, portrayed with rigid intensity by Edward Woodward, arrives to investigate the disappearance of a young girl named Rowan Morrison. What begins as a procedural inquiry spirals into a confrontation with a vibrant, hedonistic pagan community led by the enigmatic Lord Summerisle, played by Christopher Lee in one of his most charismatic turns. The islanders, under the guise of reviving ancient fertility rites to restore their barren crops, engage in phallic parades, nude dances around maypoles, and songs laced with erotic folklore. Howie, a virgin teetotaller representing mainland propriety, recoils in horror at their open sexuality and rejection of Christianity, quoting scripture amid their ballads to gods like Nuada and Avellenus.

As the narrative tightens, revelations pile upon Howie like storm clouds: the schoolteacher instructs children in pagan myths over Bible stories, the pub resonates with folk tunes that mock his faith, and the innkeeper’s daughter Willow (Britt Ekland, her body double used for nudity) seduces him futilely. The film’s masterstroke lies in its slow-burn escalation, where every villager—from the blacksmith forging phallic symbols to the harbourmaster hiding Rowan’s ‘death’—participates in a grand deception. Howie’s investigation uncovers not just a missing child but a meticulously orchestrated trap, culminating in his selection as the perfect sacrificial king to appease the gods and ensure bountiful apples. Strapped atop a colossal wicker effigy, he burns alive as the islanders sing triumphantly below, their faces alight with communal ecstasy.

This synopsis reveals Hardy’s genius in subverting expectations; no slashers or monsters here, but the horror of ideological inversion. The film’s production history adds layers: originally backed by British Lion Films, it faced mutilation by studio cuts before Paul Giovanni’s folk score and Leif Bristow’s cinematography preserved its folk authenticity. Drawing from David Pinner’s novel Ritual and Anthony Shaffer’s script, it echoes real Celtic legends while critiquing 1970s counterculture’s flirtation with pagan revivalism. At Dyerbolical we often return to these early folk-horror landmarks because they still feel unsettlingly current.

Flesh in Flux: The Metamorphosis of The Fly

David Cronenberg’s The Fly, a radical reimagining of Kurt Neumann’s 1958 original, centres on brilliant but arrogant scientist Seth Brundle (Jeff Goldblum), who perfects teleportation via flesh-dissolving telepods in a derelict Montreal warehouse. Journalist Veronica Quaife (Geena Davis), drawn to his genius, witnesses the breakthrough, but disaster strikes when Brundle, drunk and jealous, merges with a housefly during a test. What follows is a harrowing chronicle of hybridisation: initial vigour from ‘insect politics’ gives way to shedding lips, cluster hair, and vomit-drool meals, as Brundle’s humanity erodes into a maggot-ridden abomination.

The plot accelerates through visceral milestones—Brundle’s arm blistering into pus, his jaw unhinging for baboon wrestling, and a wrenching sex scene where Veronica discovers his altered genitalia. Cronenberg amplifies intimacy’s horror: Veronica’s pregnancy by Brundle complicates mercy, while Stathis Borans (John Getz), her editor-lover, urges abortion amid the chaos. The finale, in a birthing pod birthing a human-fly larva, forces Veronica to euthanise her twisted love with a shotgun barrel, cementing the film’s tragedy. Production marvels include Chris Walas’s Oscar-winning effects, blending practical prosthetics with animatronics, shot on 35mm by Mark Irwin to capture every oozing pore.

Rooted in George Langelaan’s short story, Cronenberg infuses sci-fi with personal demons, transforming campy B-movie fodder into a metaphor for AIDS-era decay and creative hubris. Goldblum’s physical commitment—real weight loss and gymnastic contortions—grounds the surreal, making Brundle’s plea, ‘I’m the one you know,’ a gut-punch of lost identity.

Pagan Purity Versus Genetic Pollution

At their cores, these films oppose purity’s corruption: The Wicker Man extols pagan wholeness against Christian repression, with Summerisle’s Edenic isle inverting mainland morality. Howie’s sacrifice restores balance, his body fuel for nature’s cycle—a euphoric communal rite where horror blooms from consent’s absence. Conversely, The Fly fixates on purity’s violation; Brundle’s fusion pollutes the self, his body politic fracturing into insect urges, symbolising technology’s Frankensteinian overreach and love’s contamination.

Thematic chasms widen in gender and sexuality. Willow’s seduction in The Wicker Man celebrates fertility unbound, yet traps Howie in celibate torment, probing puritanical fragility. In The Fly, Veronica’s gaze drives the narrative, her horror maternal as Brundle’s mutations render intimacy repulsive, echoing Cronenberg’s recurring venereal anxieties from Shivers to Dead Ringers. Both outsiders—Howie the pious intruder, Brundle the self-isolated innovator—face community rejection, but one dies for the group, the other devolves alone.

Landscapes of Loathing: Visual and Sonic Dread

Cinematography distinguishes their terrors. Leif Bristow’s sun-drenched Summerisle in The Wicker Man bathes heresy in golden light, maypoles piercing azure skies like verdant phalluses, subverting pastoral idylls akin to The Blood on Satan’s Claw. Interiors pulse with carved runes and floral altars, composing frames that seduce before they suffocate. Paul Giovanni’s score—bawdy folk refrains like ‘The Landlord’s Daughter’—infiltrates the psyche, turning melody into menace.

Cronenberg’s The Fly thrives in shadows and close-ups, Mark Irwin’s lens probing pustules and pod glows with clinical intimacy. Warehouses echo with machinery hums, Howard Shore’s synthesiser drones mimicking bodily rupture, from fusion zaps to maggot squirms. Where Hardy employs wide shots for ritual scale, Cronenberg invades the frame, vomit arcs and nail ejections filling the eye with irreversible filth.

Monsters Within: Effects and Embodiment

Special effects elevate both to visceral peaks. The Wicker Man relies on practical grandeur: the 40-foot wicker man, constructed authentically and torched in one take, billows smoke as Howie serenades flames with ‘Robbie Burns’, its inferno practical yet symbolic of folk revivalism’s pyre. No gore, but the burn’s inevitability horrifies through anticipation.

The Fly’s effects revolutionise body horror. Chris Walas’s team crafted 75 prosthetic stages for Brundlefly, from baboon fusion to the finale’s hydraulically pupating slug, blending puppetry with Goldblum’s contortions. The ‘vomit drop’—a practical bile stream—and genital reveal used silicone appliances, immersing viewers in mutation’s plausibility. These techniques influenced The Thing and beyond, proving effects as narrative drivers.

Performances amplify artifice: Woodward’s Howie arcs from outrage to hymn-singing resignation, Lee’s Summerisle a velvet patriarch quoting The Golden Bough. Goldblum’s Brundle manic pixie to sloughing beast, Davis’s Veronica a pillar amid slime, their chemistry raw fuel for horror.

Legacies Etched in Blood and Ash

The Wicker Man birthed folk horror’s golden age, inspiring Midsommar and Kill List, its 2006 remake a pale echo despite Nicolas Cage’s bee-hive frenzy. Censored upon release—studio hacks reduced its power—fan campaigns restored the director’s cut, cementing cult status. It critiques empire’s fringes, echoing 1970s oil crises via crop failure myths.

The Fly grossed $40 million, spawning inferior sequels but enduring as Cronenberg’s populist hit, its AIDS allegory prescient amid 1980s panic. Remake rights battles and Goldblum’s career boost underscore influence, from Split to Annihilation’s body invasions. Both films transcend subgenres, probing humanity’s fragile shell against nature’s reclaim or science’s hubris.

Verdict from the Inferno

In this clash, The Fly narrowly triumphs for its unrelenting intimacy; pagan ritual shocks cerebrally, but fleshly fusion assaults sensorially, lingering in nightmares via Goldblum’s tragic arc. Yet The Wicker Man’s insidious joy in heresy offers cerebral longevity, a folk tale for secular ages. Together, they crown horror’s duality: collective rite or solitary rot.

Directors in the Spotlight

Robin Hardy

Born Christopher Robin Hardy on 2 October 1929 in Cheltenham, England, Robin Hardy emerged from a privileged background, son of prominent psychiatrist Eric Hardy. Educated at Rugby School and Oxford University, where he read English, Hardy initially pursued acting and television production in the 1950s, directing plays and documentaries for the BBC. Influenced by Powell and Pressburger’s romanticism and Hammer’s gothic flair, he transitioned to features amid Britain’s folk revival, collaborating with playwright Anthony Shaffer on The Wicker Man, his 1973 breakthrough that defined his career despite initial butchering by studios.

Hardy’s oeuvre reflects obsessions with myth and ritual. Key works include the TV film The Shuttered Room (1967), adapting August Derleth with a Lovecraftian inn; The Wicker Man (1973), folk horror opus; its loose sequel The Wicker Tree (2011), critiquing American evangelism; and unfinished projects like Cowboys for Christ. He directed commercials and stage adaptations, passing on 28 January 2016 in Lowestoft, remembered for pioneering ‘unholy’ cinema that blended ethnography with terror.

Filmography highlights: The Shuttered Room (1967, dir. as associate, atmospheric New England curse); The Wicker Man (1973, pagan sacrifice benchmark); The Wicker Tree (2011, modern cult satire with Christopher Lee); plus shorts like Land of the Eagle (BBC wildlife-poetic hybrid).

David Cronenberg

Born David Paul Cronenberg on 15 March 1943 in Toronto, Canada, to Jewish-Ukrainian parents—literary agent Esther and journalist Isadore—Cronenberg grew up immersed in Kafka and Welles, studying literature at the University of Toronto before film at USC briefly. Rejecting Hollywood, he honed guerrilla style with 1960s shorts like Stereo (1969), exploring psychosexual experiments sans dialogue. Breakthroughs in Canadian cinema led to visceral horror, blending Freudian drives with biotech nightmares.

Cronenberg’s canon dissects flesh as ideology: Shivers (1975) parasites as venereal apocalypse; Rabid (1977) motorcycle wounds spawn rage virus; The Brood (1979) somatic hysteria births mutants; Scanners (1981) telekinetic corporate war; Videodrome (1983) media as flesh gun; The Fly (1986) teleportation hybrid hell; Dead Ringers (1988) twin gynaecologists’ descent; Naked Lunch (1991) Burroughsian typewriters-intercourse; Crash (1996) Ballardian car wrecks as arousal; eXistenZ (1999) pod games blurring reality; A History of Violence (2005) vigilante identity crisis; Eastern Promises (2007) Russian mob tattoos; Cosmopolis (2012) capitalist limo odyssey; Maps to the Stars (2014) Hollywood psychodrama. Later: Crimes of the Future (2022) surgical performance art. Knighted in arts, he champions ‘Cronenbergian’ as body-mind fusion critique.

Actors in the Spotlight

Edward Woodward

Born Edward Albert Arthur Woodward on 1 June 1930 in Croydon, England, Woodward rose from working-class roots, training at Royal Academy of Dramatic Art post-National Service. Stage acclaim in High Spies led to TV stardom as incisive agent Callan (1967-1972), earning BAFTA. Cinema followed: Becket (1964) as King John; The File of the Golden Goose (1969) spy thriller.

Woodward’s intensity shone in horror: The Wicker Man (1973) as doomed Howie; Breakthrough (1979) WWII resurrection. Global hits included The Appointment (1981), The Final Option (1982) SAS siege; Breaker Morant (1980) Boer War court-martial (AFI nod). TV: Over My Dead Body, In Suspicious Circumstances. OBE in 1989, he died 16 November 2009 from pneumonia, aged 79, lauded for gravelly authority.

Filmography: Becket (1964, historical drama); Hunted (1972, fugitive tense); The Wicker Man (1973, folk horror lead); Young Winston (1972); Callan (1974 film); Stand Up Virgin Soldiers (1977); Breaker Morant (1980); The Appointment (1981); The Final Option (1982); Champions (1983, jockey biopic).

Jeff Goldblum

Born Jeffrey Lynn Goldblum on 22 October 1952 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, to Jewish parents—doctor mother and engineer father—Goldblum trained at Neighbourhood Playhouse, debuting Broadway in Two Gentleman of Verona (1971). Early films: California Split (1974), Death Wish (1974) mugger; TV Starsky & Hutch.

Breakout: The Tall Guy (1989) romantic comedy. Sci-fi icon: Jurassic Park (1993) chaotician Dr. Grant; Independence Day (1996) hacker hero. Cronenberg collaborations: The Fly (1986) transformative Seth; The Tall Guy. Others: Earth Girls Are Easy (1988); Mr. Frost (1990); Deep Cover (1992); Jurassic World series (2015-). Wes Anderson: Grand Budapest Hotel (2014). TV: Law & Order: Criminal Intent; The World According to Jeff Goldblum (2019-). Known for lanky charm and verbal jazz, married thrice, father post-50.

Filmography: Next Stop Greenwich Village (1976); Annie Hall cameo (1977); Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1978); The Big Chill (1983); The Fly (1986); The Adventures of Buckaroo Banzai (1984); Jurassic Park (1993); Independence Day (1996); Holy Man (1998); Igby Goes Down (2001); Spinning Boris (2003).

Bibliography

Hardy, R. (2011). The Wicker Man: The Director’s Cut. Momentum Pictures.

Newman, K. (2011). Nightmare Movies: Horror on Screen Since the 1960s. Bloomsbury Publishing.

Wood, R. (1986). Hollywood from Vietnam to Reagan. Columbia University Press.

Beeler, K. and Dickson, L. (eds.) (2009). The Wicker Man. University of Toronto Press.

Cronenberg, D. (1992). Cronenberg on Cronenberg: Interviews and Essays. Faber & Faber.

Walas, C. and Martin, J. (1987). The Fly: The Making of the Film. Titan Books.

British Film Institute (2007). The Wicker Man. BFI Publishing. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk (Accessed 15 October 2023).

Phillips, W.H. (2009). David Cronenberg: A Delicate Balance. ECW Press.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289