Two films separated by nearly a century still speak to the same raw human ache. One builds its terror in a storm-lashed tower with crackling machines, while the other unfolds under an unblinking Swedish sun. Both ask what happens when the simple need for connection hardens into something that cannot be escaped.
In the crackle of high-voltage creation and the relentless glare of a Swedish summer sky, two films reach across time to ask the same uneasy question. What happens when the longing for connection turns into a demand that cannot be refused? This piece examines James Whale’s Bride of Frankenstein from 1935 and Ari Aster’s Midsommar from 2019, tracing how both stories turn the human need for kinship into something far darker and more binding than either protagonist expects.
The Monster’s desperate quest for a companion mirrors Dani’s subsumption into the Harga commune, revealing belonging as both salvation and subjugation. Rituals of creation and sacrifice evolve from shadowed expressionism to bright folk horror, tracing horror’s shift from individual monstrosity to collective ecstasy. These films illuminate enduring mythic archetypes: the outcast bridegroom and the widowed initiate, whose forced integrations expose the savage underbelly of community.
The Outcast’s Lament: Isolation as Prelude to Ritual
In Bride of Frankenstein the Monster, resurrected and more articulate than before, wanders a world that rejects him at every turn. Boris Karloff plays him with a raw, wounded dignity that makes every rebuff feel personal. He finds brief shelter in a blind hermit’s cabin where violin music suggests the possibility of simple companionship. That fragile peace ends when angry villagers arrive with torches, pushing him back into solitude and forcing him to demand that Henry Frankenstein build him a mate. The request is not romantic. It is a last, furious attempt to end unbearable loneliness, and the laboratory becomes the site of that desperate ritual.
The Monster’s situation draws from Mary Shelley’s 1818 novel, where the creature first learns language and then discovers how completely society shuts him out. That literary root matters because it shows the 1935 film was never just about mad science. It was about the ache of being left outside every circle of warmth.
Midsommar begins with a different kind of fracture. Dani loses her family in a sudden tragedy, and her already distant boyfriend Christian offers little comfort. When he invites her to join a midsummer festival in rural Sweden, she goes along more out of numbness than enthusiasm. Florence Pugh shows every layer of grief and hesitation as Dani steps into the Hörga commune. The constant daylight at first feels almost kind, yet it soon strips away any chance of private sorrow. Like the Monster, Dani’s isolation makes her vulnerable to the first group that offers her a place, even if that place comes with rules she does not yet understand.
Both characters echo older mythic figures who wander between worlds. The Monster carries echoes of Prometheus, punished for reaching beyond human limits, while Dani’s journey recalls Persephone drawn into an underworld that first appears as a field of flowers. Whale’s jagged sets and heavy shadows turn inner emptiness into visible architecture. Aster chooses the opposite approach, using unbroken sunlight to make escape feel impossible. In each case the setting itself becomes an accomplice to the ritual that follows.
Frankensteinian Forging: The Laboratory as Alchemical Rite
The creation scene in Bride of Frankenstein remains one of cinema’s most striking images of birth gone wrong. Whirling machines, crackling electricity, and the gleeful presence of Dr. Pretorius turn the tower laboratory into a profane chapel. Ernest Thesiger plays Pretorius with a mixture of mischief and menace that undercuts any sense of solemnity. When the Bride finally stirs and rejects the Monster with a single piercing scream, the ritual collapses into mutual destruction. The failure feels inevitable because belonging cannot be assembled from spare parts and lightning.
Pretorius keeps a tiny homunculus in a jar, a nod to older alchemical experiments and the long history of humans trying to manufacture life. Franz Waxman’s score swells around these moments, giving the sequence the weight of a dark sacrament. Whale, who faced his own exclusions as a gay director working under studio censorship, brings a sharp, subversive energy to the scene. The whole enterprise mocks the idea that science or genius can simply manufacture the bonds people crave.
That same impulse toward control appears in Midsommar, though the setting could not look more different. The Hörga ceremonies take place in open fields under perpetual daylight. Instead of one creator in a tower, an entire community participates in choreographed rites that absorb outsiders. The contrast highlights how rituals adapt to their time while still serving the same purpose: to bind the lonely person so tightly that leaving becomes unthinkable.
Midsummer’s Floral Sacrament: Communal Absorption
Aster stages the Hörga festival with deliberate symmetry and slow, gliding camera movements. Maypole dances and flower crowns soften the sight of elders leaping from cliffs in the ättestupa ritual. Christian’s rival meets a brutal end that the commune frames as necessary, and Dani is gradually drawn into the role of May Queen. Her final cry during the temple fire marks the moment she stops resisting and accepts the place the group has made for her. The acceptance feels both triumphant and terrifying because it comes at the cost of every previous tie.
Aster draws on real Swedish midsummer customs and older fertility traditions, then twists them into something more unsettling. The maypole stands as an ancient symbol of renewal, yet here it presides over sacrifice. Production designer Andrea Werckmeister filled the sets with living plants so that beauty and decay occupy the same space. The result is a community that presents itself as healing while quietly demanding total surrender.
Brides Betrayed: Rejection and Radical Acceptance
Elsa Lanchester’s Bride appears for only a few minutes, yet her reaction defines the film’s ending. Wrapped in bandages and crowned with a dramatic hairstyle, she recoils from the Monster in instinctive horror. That single scream brings the laboratory down and affirms Mary Shelley’s original warning that forced unions end in ruin. Lanchester brought her own background in dance and theater to the brief role, giving the character a feral immediacy that still resonates.
Dani’s crowning moves in the opposite direction. Surrounded by the commune’s women, she moves from grief to something like belonging. Pugh’s performance captures the physical and emotional shift as tears give way to a smile amid the flames. Where the Bride refuses, Dani yields, and the film asks viewers to sit with the discomfort of that choice. Both women wear white, a color that signals new beginnings yet also suggests the shroud that may follow.
Mythic Threads: From Gothic to Folk Horror Evolution
Bride of Frankenstein closed out Universal’s first major monster cycle and left a lasting mark on later horror. Its blend of sympathy for the outcast and gothic spectacle influenced everything from Hammer’s period pieces to Tim Burton’s stylized homages. Production troubles, including last-minute cuts and cast changes, only added to the sense of a film fighting against its own constraints.
Midsommar helped define the wave of elevated horror that followed Hereditary. Aster has spoken openly about drawing from The Wicker Man and older Scandinavian legends, updating folk horror for audiences dealing with fractured relationships and mental health struggles. The film sparked widespread discussion about grief, cults, and the appeal of total communal solutions in an increasingly isolated world. Together the two movies show how stories of belonging shift with the culture while the underlying fear stays constant.
Cinematic Alchemy: Visual and Sonic Rites
Whale used Dutch angles, mobile cranes, and stark lighting to turn every corridor and tower into part of the ritual. Waxman’s music signals danger and longing in equal measure. Aster relies on long Steadicam takes and Bobby Krlic’s unsettling score to keep viewers inside the Hörga logic even when events turn violent. In both cases the technical choices do more than decorate the story. They make the audience feel the same pressure to belong that traps the characters.
Director in the Spotlight
James Whale came from a working-class background in England and carried injuries from the First World War that shaped his later pacifist views. After success on stage with Journey’s End he moved to Hollywood and redefined horror with stark, expressionist visuals. Bride of Frankenstein gave him room to mix terror with dark humor, a combination that reflected his own position as an outsider in the studio system. His later career included musicals and literary adaptations before he stepped away from directing. Those experiences inform the subversive edge that still makes the film feel alive today.
Actor in the Spotlight
Elsa Lanchester grew up in a bohemian London household and trained as a dancer before moving into film. Her brief appearance as the Bride captured both vulnerability and defiance, turning a small role into an enduring image of resistance. She went on to play a wide range of characters across decades, from musicals to Disney fantasies, yet the electrified figure from 1935 remains her most quoted performance. Her own life, marked by artistic freedom and a complicated marriage to Charles Laughton, adds another layer to the Bride’s refusal to accept the partner chosen for her.
At Dyerbolical we return often to these questions of ritual and identity because they keep surfacing in new forms across horror history.
Bibliography
Curtis, J. (1998) James Whale: A New World of Gods and Monsters. Faber & Faber.
Skal, D.J. (1993) The Monster Show: A Cultural History of Horror. W.W. Norton.
Aster, A. (2019) Midsommar production notes. A24 Studios.
Harper, J. (2020) ‘Folk Horror Revival: From The Wicker Man to Midsommar’, Sight & Sound, 30(5), pp. 45-49.
Hutchinson, S. (2016) James Whale’s Frankenstein Legacy. McFarland.
West, N. (2021) ‘Ritual and Grief in Ari Aster’s Films’, Film Quarterly, 74(3), pp. 22-31.
Williamson, K. (1985) Elsa Lanchester Herself. St. Martin’s Press.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
