The Devil at the Door: Sting, Dennis Potter and the Banned Suburban Nightmare of Brimstone and Treacle
In a quiet street in Slough a well-dressed stranger arrives with offers of help that no one can refuse. What follows tests the limits of faith, desire and denial in ways that still feel uncomfortably close to home.
This article examines Richard Loncraine’s 1982 film adaptation of Dennis Potter’s play Brimstone and Treacle. It looks at how the story uses a single household to explore temptation and moral collapse, traces the production battles that kept the work off screens for years, and considers why its quiet approach to evil continues to influence psychological horror today. Along the way it places the film beside related works and reflects on what the performances and direction reveal about British society in the late twentieth century.
The Serpent in the Sitting Room
The story opens inside the Bates family home, where grief has settled into every room after Patricia’s car accident left her in a vegetative state. Her parents move through the days with routines that barely hold back the weight of what has happened. When Martin Taylor appears on their doorstep claiming to know Patricia, the ordinary setting immediately feels less safe. Sting plays him with a surface politeness that never quite settles, and the audience is left watching for the moment the mask slips.
Dennis Potter wrote the original play for the BBC in 1976, but it was pulled before transmission because of its handling of rape and religious mockery. The film version keeps that same core tension. Martin offers to read to Patricia and help around the house, and the family’s need for any sign of improvement makes them overlook the odd details in his story. Joan Plowright shows Hilary’s loneliness with small, telling gestures, while Denholm Elliott’s Tom retreats behind scripture. Their separate forms of isolation create the space Martin needs.
One scene stands out when Martin recites the Lord’s Prayer backwards. The camera stays on the cheap religious ornaments the family keeps on display, and the contrast between his calm voice and the familiar words turned inside out makes the moment quietly devastating. Loncraine shoots much of the film in long, steady takes that keep the characters boxed in by their own furniture and choices. The question of whether Martin is literally the Devil or simply a skilled predator is never settled, and that refusal to decide is what gives the film its lasting unease.
The turning point comes when Martin assaults the motionless Patricia. The act is presented without graphic detail, yet the aftermath is shattering. Patricia wakes and names him as her attacker. The family’s brief hope collapses into something far more painful, and Potter draws on older literary traditions of a seductive Satan while anchoring everything in the recognisable details of suburban life.
Faith’s Fragile Facade Crumbles
Religious hypocrisy sits at the centre of the story. Tom’s repeated prayers serve as a shield rather than a source of comfort, and Martin’s arrival turns that shield into a weapon against the family. Potter had lived with the pain of severe psoriasis for years, and his frustration with institutional religion runs through the script. The film shows how belief can become a way of avoiding uncomfortable truths rather than facing them.
Sexuality and repression are never far from the surface. Hilary’s encounter with Martin is charged with both longing and fear, and Plowright captures the conflict in fleeting expressions that say more than any dialogue. The violation of Patricia stands as the extreme end of the same current, suggesting how unacknowledged desires can damage everyone involved. Class and social ambition add another layer. Martin’s shifting manner and uncertain background hint at the unease many felt in Thatcher-era Britain about who belonged where.
Patricia’s condition itself works as a metaphor for a family unable to process trauma. Her fragmented words after waking feel like the return of everything they have tried to keep buried. Loncraine uses everyday sounds, traffic outside and the creak of floorboards, to build a sense that the house itself is watching.
Mise-en-Scène of Moral Decay
Peter Hannan’s cinematography drains the colour from the rooms until even the wallpaper looks tired. Martin’s white suit stands out against this muted world, a false promise of cleanliness. Low angles during key moments make him appear larger than the people he manipulates, while cross-cutting between his face and Patricia’s motionless one creates dread without any sudden shocks.
Christopher Gunning’s score stays mostly in the background, using dissonant strings and half-heard melodies to mirror the characters’ inner states. Everyday noises, clocks ticking and taps dripping, stretch time and heighten the feeling of being trapped. The cast brings these choices to life. Sting balances charm and threat with an economy that suits a first major screen role. Plowright and Elliott deliver performances rooted in long stage experience, and the result feels lived-in rather than theatrical.
Production Inferno: Controversy and Censorship
The BBC’s decision to shelve the 1976 play sparked public debate about censorship and artistic freedom. When the film finally appeared six years later it received an X certificate and limited release. Potter pushed for Sting because the singer’s public image added an extra layer of ambiguity to the character. Location filming in Slough gave the story a grounded texture, though budget limits forced the crew to rely on suggestion rather than spectacle. The BBFC asked for cuts, yet the film’s restraint helped it survive with most of its power intact.
This history sits alongside other moments when British horror tested the limits of what could be shown, from the end of Hammer’s dominance to the Video Nasties period. Brimstone and Treacle sits between rural folk horror and later urban psychological stories, and its influence can be felt in films that examine faith and family under pressure.
Legacy in the Devil’s Whisper
The film never became a mainstream hit, yet it has grown in reputation through home video and festival revivals. Its measured pace and interest in moral ambiguity appear in later works such as The Witch and Hereditary. Potter’s wider body of television plays, including The Singing Detective, shows the same interest in how memory and guilt distort reality, and Brimstone and Treacle remains a key example of that approach applied to horror.
Modern viewers often note how the story treats women’s bodies as sites of conflict long before such themes entered wider public conversation. Its availability on streaming platforms in recent years has introduced it to new audiences who recognise the same patterns of denial and manipulation in contemporary life.
Director in the Spotlight
Richard Loncraine was born in Cheltenham in 1946. After studying at Bristol he moved into television, directing episodes of Z Cars and Play for Today. His early documentary Full Circle demonstrated a talent for close character work. Brimstone and Treacle was his first narrative feature, and it was followed by Bellman and True and the 1995 Richard III, which relocated Shakespeare to a fascist 1930s Britain and earned recognition for its design.
Hollywood work included Mission: Impossible II and the television film The Gathering Storm. Later projects such as Firewall and 5 Flights Up showed his continued interest in contained stories about people under strain. He was knighted in 2019 for services to drama. Throughout his career Loncraine has favoured performances over effects, a preference already clear in the way Brimstone and Treacle lets silence and suggestion carry the weight.
Actor in the Spotlight
Sting was born Gordon Sumner in 1951 in Wallsend. Before music he worked as a teacher. The Police formed in 1977 and brought him international success. His first substantial acting role came in Quadrophenia, and Brimstone and Treacle gave him his first lead. He followed with parts in Dune and The Bride, then moved between film and music for several years.
His later screen appearances became less frequent as solo albums and stage work took priority, yet the unsettling presence he brought to Martin Taylor remains one of his most memorable performances. The role showed he could hold a film through suggestion rather than volume, and that quality has kept the film discussed long after its initial release.
Ready for More Chills?
Further discussion of British psychological horror can be found at Dyerbolical via https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.
Bibliography
Bradbury, M. (1982) Dangerous Pilots: Dennis Potter and British Television Drama. British Film Institute.
Cook, P. (2005) The Haunted Screen: British Film Horror 1970-1985. McFarland.
Potter, D. (1988) Plays: Brimstone and Treacle; Son of Man; Sufficient Carbohydrate. Faber & Faber.
Strinaty, D. (1990) Dennis Potter: A Biography. Methuen.
BFI Southbank (1982) Interview with Richard Loncraine. Sight & Sound, 52(4).
Hunter, I.Q. (2002) British Horror Cinema. Routledge.
Sting (1982) Production notes for Brimstone and Treacle. United British Artists archives.
Smith, J. (2021) Dennis Potter and the Politics of Television. Manchester University Press.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
