In the fall of 2022, Netflix released its series on Jeffrey Dahmer and quickly drew massive audiences. The show focused on one of the most disturbing cases in recent American history, yet the strongest objections came not from concerns about graphic content but from the families of the men and boys he killed. Rita Isbell, whose brother Errol Lindsey was murdered by Dahmer, spoke out about how the production reopened old wounds without asking permission or offering any compensation to those most affected.
This reaction points to a recurring pattern in true crime storytelling. Many documentaries and series spend far more time exploring the killer’s background and mindset than they do telling the stories of the people whose lives were cut short. The result often leaves families feeling that their loved ones have been reduced to brief mentions while the perpetrator receives detailed attention and even a kind of narrative sympathy. As these programs continue to attract huge numbers of viewers, the question of how to handle such sensitive material becomes harder to ignore.
This article looks at the criticisms that have grown around serial killer documentaries, checks the specific examples that keep coming up, and considers what the imbalance does to public understanding of these cases. It also explores how some creators have tried to shift the focus and what still needs to change if the genre is going to treat victims with the respect their stories deserve.
The Rise of Serial Killer Documentaries
True crime content found a huge new audience once streaming services began investing heavily in the format. Platforms such as Netflix, Hulu, and HBO turned cases that had once been covered mainly in books or occasional television specials into high-profile, multi-episode projects. Shows built around Ted Bundy or similar figures drew strong numbers, and by the early 2020s true crime was regularly accounting for a sizable share of overall viewing hours.
Filmmakers often explain their choices by pointing to public interest in understanding how someone could commit such acts. They note details like difficult childhoods or possible mental health factors as part of that explanation. Yet studies of the finished programs show that this stated goal frequently results in far more screen time given to the offender than to anyone else involved. One analysis from the University of Leicester reviewed dozens of documentaries and found that the majority devoted well over half their running time to the person who committed the crimes, while victims received roughly one-eighth of the attention on average.
From Podcasts to Prestige TV
The shift toward longer-form audio storytelling helped set the stage for today’s documentary style. Programs such as Serial demonstrated that listeners would stay with a single case across many episodes, and that approach soon moved to visual platforms with larger production budgets. The commercial pressure to keep audiences engaged can encourage editing decisions that make the central figure more compelling, even when that figure is a convicted killer.
At Dyerbolical we have looked at how these choices play out across different cases, and the pattern is consistent: when profit and drama guide the narrative, the people who were harmed often end up as supporting details rather than central figures.
Key Criticisms: Bias in Focus
Advocates for victims and media observers have raised several consistent concerns about how these programs are made. The most common complaint is that the structure itself creates sympathy for the perpetrator through selective emphasis on intelligence, charm, or personal struggles while giving victims only passing mention.
Archival recordings of Ted Bundy, for example, have been presented in ways that highlight his articulate manner, which can soften the reality of the many young women he killed between 1974 and 1978. Families have said their relatives appear mainly as names on a list rather than as individuals with lives and futures that were taken from them. Graphic recreations add another layer, turning moments of violence into visual set pieces that some viewers find compelling rather than disturbing.
These choices are not random. As documentary filmmaker Joe Berlinger noted in a 2022 interview, stories centered on the killer tend to attract larger audiences. Groups such as those supporting Marsy’s Law have argued that families should have more say over how their loved ones are portrayed, especially when the material is used for entertainment.
The Dahmer Debacle: A Case Study
The Netflix series on Jeffrey Dahmer brought these issues into sharp focus. Relatives of several victims, including the families of Steven Tuomi and Konerak Sinthasomphone, raised objections about the use of their loved ones’ stories without consent. Rita Isbell described in a USA Today piece how a scene showing her courtroom confrontation with Dahmer felt like an intrusion that profited from private pain.
The series spent considerable time on Dahmer’s isolation and drinking, which some viewers interpreted as an attempt to present him as a tragic figure. In contrast, Glenda Cleveland, the neighbor who tried to alert police to the danger posed to a 14-year-old boy, was shown in a less favorable light despite her efforts to intervene. Netflix described the project as a historical drama, yet the public response led to added content warnings and renewed discussion about whether such portrayals require greater oversight.
Ted Bundy and Beyond
Similar reactions followed the release of Conversations with a Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes. While the recordings themselves are part of the historical record, families of victims such as Georgann Hawkins felt their loved ones received limited attention compared with the focus on Bundy. Director Joe Berlinger later produced additional material that gave more space to survivors, but the initial version had already shaped many viewers’ impressions.
Other productions have drawn parallel critiques. Don’t F**k with Cats examined Luka Magnotta through the lens of online investigators, which some felt gave the killer an outsized presence. Zodiac documentaries often linger on unsolved ciphers while giving less sustained attention to the families of victims like Darlene Ferrin. Programs about Aileen Wuornos have mixed accounts of her own difficult past with her crimes, leaving audiences uncertain where the line between explanation and justification should fall.
Psychological and Cultural Impacts
Researchers have examined whether repeated exposure to these narratives affects how people think about crime and responsibility. Some studies suggest that heavy viewing can lead to greater emotional distance from victims and a tendency to focus on the perpetrator’s psychology instead. In certain cases this has contributed to troubling patterns, such as public fascination with incarcerated killers that overlooks the harm they caused.
The cultural effect is also visible in which cases receive attention. Many of Dahmer’s victims came from Milwaukee’s Black and LGBTQ+ communities, and coverage that centers the killer can obscure the broader social context in which those crimes occurred. Activist Eric Perry, a relative of one of the victims, publicly described the series as a trigger that retraumatized people who had already lived through the original events. Streaming companies earn substantial revenue from these titles, yet support for victim services has not kept pace with those profits.
Expert Voices
Author Anne Rule, who once worked alongside Ted Bundy, later wrote about how media portrayals can turn real offenders into larger-than-life figures. Criminologist Katherine Ramsland has pointed out that the puzzle of criminal behavior often overshadows the simpler fact that victims were ordinary people whose stories deserve full telling. Journalists such as Michelle McNamara have shown that it is possible to examine difficult cases while keeping the focus on those who were harmed, and their approach has influenced newer work in the field.
Industry Response and Paths Forward
Some platforms have begun to adjust their practices after public criticism. Netflix added viewer advisories following the Dahmer series. Other productions, such as Hulu’s The Act, involved families more directly during development. Campaigns calling for greater transparency now ask creators to disclose their sources, seek consent where possible, and allocate a portion of profits to victim support.
Filmmakers including Nanfu Wang have spoken in favor of placing survivors at the center of the narrative rather than treating them as background. Viewers can encourage better practices by choosing programs that balance perspectives, such as certain documentaries on the NXIVM case that gave substantial time to those who escaped the group. Practical steps include obtaining consent protocols, aiming for roughly equal attention to victims and offenders, and directing some revenue toward advocacy organizations.
Even with these conversations underway, many upcoming projects continue to follow older patterns. Without stronger industry standards, the same imbalances are likely to appear again.
Conclusion
Serial killer documentaries continue to draw audiences because they promise insight into extreme behavior. When the structure favors the person who committed the crimes, however, the result can shift from understanding to something closer to spectacle. The families who have spoken out about productions on Dahmer, Bundy, and similar cases are asking for a basic adjustment: that the people whose lives were lost remain visible and respected throughout the telling. If creators adopt clearer guidelines around consent, balance, and accountability, the genre can still examine difficult subjects without repeating the same harms. Viewers, for their part, can support work that treats every life involved with care rather than turning tragedy into another form of entertainment.
Bibliography
Rita Isbell, USA Today op-ed on the Dahmer series, 2022.
University of Leicester study on true crime documentary runtime allocation, 2021.
Journal of Criminal Justice article on media consumption and victim-blaming attitudes, 2020.
Joe Berlinger interview discussing commercial pressures in true crime, 2022.
Anne Rule, memoir reflecting on media portrayals of Ted Bundy.
Katherine Ramsland, comments on victim-centered approaches in criminology.
Michelle McNamara, I’ll Be Gone in the Dark, on ethical case examination.
Nielsen data on true crime viewership share, 2023.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
