Picture a masked figure moving through the cellars of the Paris Opera in 1916, his story told only through shadows and intertitles at a time when cinema itself was still finding its voice. This article examines the early German silent adaptation of Gaston Leroux’s novel, directed by Ernst Lubitsch, and traces how it tried to bring the Phantom to the screen years before the better-known 1925 version. It looks at the performances, the production conditions, the way the film handled the source material, and what its brief existence tells us about the beginnings of horror on film.
Veils of the Underground
The story takes place inside the grand Paris Opera House, where Mary, played by Erna Morena, rises from the chorus to become the leading singer. Below the stage lies a maze of corridors and rooms occupied by the Phantom, brought to life by Olaf Fønss as a man whose face was ruined in a fire and whose only outlet remains music. He watches her, teaches her, and eventually turns violent when he feels betrayed. Lubitsch builds the narrative through careful intertitles that lay out the Phantom’s past as a composer pushed aside by the world, turning his talent into something darker.
One striking moment shows the Phantom catching sight of himself in a mirror, his bandaged face fading into darkness. That image captures the split between the man he once hoped to be and the figure he has become. The film also spends time on the everyday life of the opera, from managers worried about money to stagehands who repeat old stories about a ghost. These details ground the fantasy in something audiences of the time would recognise from their own visits to theatres.
Erna Morena gives Mary a quiet vulnerability that makes her rise feel earned rather than sudden. Friedrich Kühne plays the suitor who tries to pull her away from the Phantom’s influence. The sets attempted to recreate parts of the real Opera Garnier, using whatever materials were available in Berlin during wartime restrictions. The production worked with a limited budget yet still tried to suggest the scale of the building and the hidden lake beneath it, a detail drawn from the legends that had already surrounded the Paris opera house for decades.
This version appeared well before the 1925 Universal film and stayed closer to the serial form in which Leroux first published the story in 1910. Those newspaper instalments had mixed real rumours about the opera house with invented drama, including the underground lake kept for fire safety. Lubitsch presents the Phantom as more than a simple villain, giving him a kind of wounded pride that reflects the Romantic idea of the artist destroyed by society.
Melodies of the Monstrous
Fønss plays the Phantom with a mixture of longing and threat. His gestures when he imagines conducting an orchestra show both his skill and his isolation. The character’s turn toward violence comes from repeated rejection, shown in a brief flashback to the fire that scarred him. That personal history makes his demand for Mary’s loyalty feel like a twisted payment for the career he helped build.
The falling chandelier is handled with practical effects and slow editing so the audience feels the weight of the moment. Lighting in the cellar scenes creates strong contrasts that make the space feel larger and more threatening than it is. These choices point forward to the visual style that would soon appear in films such as The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari. The Phantom’s mask becomes a central object, and the scenes where it is removed are held long enough for the audience to register the damage beneath.
Music runs through the film as the one thing the Phantom believes can outlast him. His silent attempts to teach or compose underline the tragedy of a man whose only language is sound. Mary’s own progress as a singer moves in the opposite direction, rising while he sinks further into obsession. The story also touches on how society treats anyone who looks different, a theme that carried extra weight in 1916 when Europe was at war and ideas of belonging were being tested everywhere.
Expressionist Echoes Before the Storm
Leroux had already mixed documented events at the Opera Garnier with gothic invention. Lubitsch, who had mostly worked in comedy up to that point, brings a steadier focus on the characters’ private feelings. The film uses longer takes in places so the emotional shifts can register without dialogue. Practical makeup and simple camera tricks create the Phantom’s appearance, while a water tank stands in for the underground lake during key scenes.
Working in Berlin during the war meant dealing with shortages of film stock and equipment. The crew turned to shadow techniques for some ghostly effects, which added to the atmosphere rather than distracting from it. Censors asked for cuts around scenes of violence, yet the finished film still reached audiences and showed Lubitsch could handle darker material.
The 1916 version shares several story beats with the later Chaney film, even if the auction scene that opens the 1925 picture is missing here. Its influence can be traced through the way later horror films used hidden spaces and masked figures to create dread. Because so little of the print survives, it remains a partial record of how monster stories moved from page to screen in the years just before German Expressionism became a recognised style.
Legacy Beneath the Dust
The film sits at the start of the screen tradition that runs from stage versions of Frankenstein through to later masked characters in horror. Its lack of any musical accompaniment leaves the tension exposed. Fragments that turned up in archives during the 1990s give only hints of what the full cut might have offered. At Dyerbolical you can find further discussion of how early silent films like this one helped shape the genre that followed.
The Phantom’s final act of drowning himself in the lake he once ruled adds a note of fatalism that feels particular to this adaptation. Later versions, from Phantom of the Paradise to various stage musicals, have taken the story in different directions, but the 1916 film keeps a sharper sense of the character’s self-destruction.
Director in the Spotlight
Ernst Lubitsch was born in Berlin in 1892. He began in theatre before moving into short films and quickly developed a reputation for economical storytelling that suggested more than it showed. The Phantom project gave him a chance to work with melodrama and suspense at a time when most of his output was lighter. After the war he moved into larger historical films and then to Hollywood, where he became known for sophisticated comedies that still carried emotional weight. His later credits include The Merry Widow and To Be or Not to Be, and he received an honorary Oscar in 1947 shortly before his death.
Actor in the Spotlight
Olaf Fønss came from Denmark and built a career across Nordic and German productions. His tall frame and expressive face suited roles that required both authority and inner conflict. By the time he played the Phantom he had already appeared in fantasy serials that mixed spectacle with psychological tension. After 1916 he continued in Expressionist films such as Der Golem and later returned to Denmark, where he worked until the mid-1930s. His body of work shows how actors of the silent period moved between national industries while the language of cinema was still forming.
Bibliography
Leroux, G. (1910) The Phantom of the Opera. Pierre Lafitte.
Eisner, L.H. (1973) The Haunted Screen: Expressionism in the German Cinema. Thames & Hudson.
Kracauer, S. (1947) From Caligari to Hitler: A Psychological History of German Film. Princeton University Press.
Prawer, S.S. (1980) Caligari’s Children: The Film as Tale of Terror. Da Capo Press.
Usai, P.A. (2000) Silent Cinema: A Guide to Study, Restoration and Assessment of Silent Films. BFI Publishing.
Richardson, C. (1991) Phantom of the Opera: The Motion Picture Series. McFarland & Company.
Bodeen, D. (1976) From Hollywood: The Careers of 15 Great American Directors. A.S. Barnes.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
