The fog around a shuttered mansion on the Jersey coast hides more than just sunlight, while a suburban dining room in Utah hides something far older and more merciless.
Two films stand at opposite ends of the same haunted corridor. Alejandro Amenábar’s The Others from 2001 and Ari Aster’s Hereditary from 2018 both place families inside homes that slowly stop belonging to the living. This article walks through their stories, performances, craft choices and legacies to see how each one reshapes the idea of supernatural family horror.
In the dim corridors of supernatural family horror, The Others and Hereditary battle for supremacy—which one leaves the deeper scar on the soul?
Two masterpieces of psychological dread, Alejandro Amenábar’s The Others (2001) and Ari Aster’s Hereditary (2018) both centre on families unraveling under invisible, malevolent forces. These films transcend mere scares, probing the fragility of domestic bonds amid otherworldly intrusion. This analysis pits their narratives, techniques, and lasting resonances against each other to determine which truly captures the essence of haunted kinship.
- The Others crafts a gothic tale of isolation and misperception, relying on atmospheric restraint to build terror.
- Hereditary unleashes raw grief and occult inevitability, with visceral performances amplifying its savagery.
- Ultimately, one emerges as the pinnacle of supernatural family horror through superior thematic depth and emotional devastation.
Enshrouded Mansions and Fractured Lineages
The Others unfolds in the fog-shrouded Jersey coastline of 1945, where Grace, a devout mother played by Nicole Kidman, shields her photosensitive children, Anne and Nicholas, from sunlight in their sprawling, locked-down mansion. Servants arrive mysteriously, and strange occurrences—whispers, slammed doors, apparitions—escalate as Grace clings to her faith and maternal protectiveness. The narrative masterfully withholds revelations, layering suspicion on every creak and shadow. Amenábar draws from classic ghost stories, evoking the isolation of Daphne du Maurier’s Rebecca or Henry James’s The Turn of the Screw, where the house itself becomes a character, its labyrinthine rooms mirroring the family’s psychological confinement.
That same sense of a house turning against its occupants stretches back further than either film. Post-war Britain produced a wave of stories in which returning soldiers found their homes occupied by memories they could not share. Amenábar taps into that tradition, letting the mansion stand in for every family that tried to seal itself away from the world outside.
In contrast, Hereditary plunges into contemporary suburbia, following the Graham family after the death of matriarch Ellen. Annie Graham, portrayed by Toni Collette in a tour de force, grapples with her miniature artist career, husband Steve, son Peter, and daughter Charlie amid escalating tragedies. What begins as bereavement spirals into demonic possession, cult rituals, and decapitations, with the family home transforming from banal comfort to a site of profane desecration. Aster’s script, rooted in his short film The Strange Thing About the Johnsons, amplifies familial dysfunction through inherited trauma, making every domestic space a potential altar.
Both films weaponise the home as the battleground for supernatural invasion, yet their approaches diverge sharply. The Others employs a period elegance, with cinematographer Javier Aguirresarobe’s desaturated palette and fog-diffused light creating an eternal twilight that heightens paranoia. Hereditary, shot by Pawel Pogorzelski, favours stark realism interrupted by hallucinatory close-ups and Dutch angles, turning the familiar into the grotesque. This stylistic chasm underscores their eras: Amenábar’s restraint nods to 1970s slow-burn horrors like The Innocents, while Aster channels 2010s extremity akin to The Witch.
Production histories reveal further contrasts. The Others, a modest Spanish-US co-production budgeted at $17 million, faced distribution hurdles before Miramax championed it, grossing over $209 million worldwide. Amenábar shot in English to appeal globally, casting Kidman post-Moulin Rouge for star power. Hereditary, A24’s breakout with a $10 million budget, endured festival walkouts at Sundance 2018 for its intensity, yet earned $82 million and critical acclaim. Aster’s feature debut benefited from partial financing via his mother’s connections, infusing personal grief into the script.
Narratively, The Others thrives on misdirection, its twist—echoing M. Night Shyamalan’s The Sixth Sense—recontextualising every prior event without cheapening them. Grace’s denial of World War II’s end parallels her spiritual blindness, culminating in a séance that shatters illusions. Hereditary, however, rejects tidy resolutions; its climax reveals a Paimon cult orchestration, Peter’s possession, and Annie’s levitating decapitation, leaving audiences in nihilistic despair. This bleakness positions Hereditary as more modern, reflecting post-9/11 anxieties of uncontrollable fate versus The Others’ redemptive ambiguity.
Mothers as Martyrs: Kidman and Collette’s Colossal Clashes
Nicole Kidman’s Grace embodies Victorian-era repression, her wide-eyed piety masking wartime trauma from shooting her husband. Scenes of her tucking children into curtained beds or investigating thumps in the night showcase Kidman’s mastery of subtle hysteria—trembling lips, whispered prayers—building to a scream that pierces the silence. Her performance anchors the film’s restraint, making the final acceptance heartbreakingly poignant.
Toni Collette’s Annie, however, erupts in volcanic fury. From calmly crafting dollhouses symbolising her fractured life to her support group rant decrying genetic inevitability, Collette conveys a woman splintering under grief. The bang-head-against-wall sequence, improvised in part, captures maternal failure’s abyss, her screams raw and unrelenting. Collette’s versatility—from Muriel’s Wedding comedy to horror—elevates Hereditary’s emotional core, earning an Oscar nod.
Both actresses portray mothers defending their young against the unseen, yet Kidman’s elegance suits gothic poise, while Collette’s ferocity suits visceral horror. Grace’s arc resolves in otherworldly unity; Annie’s ends in demonic puppetry. This maternal dichotomy highlights genre evolution: from sympathetic ghosts to inherited curses.
Supporting casts amplify these leads. Fionnula Flanagan’s Mrs. Bertha Mills in The Others delivers chilling exposition with Irish gravitas, while Milly Shapiro’s Charlie in Hereditary unnerves with her clicky tongue and prescient drawings, her decapitation scene a gut-punch of sibling horror. Alexander Goligorsky’s child actors in The Others evoke porcelain fragility, contrasting Hereditary’s flawed, relatable teens.
Ghosts, Demons, and the Machinery of Dread
The Others posits a liminal afterlife where the living unwittingly haunt the dead, subverting ghost story tropes. Sound design—distant thuds, child’s piano in empty rooms—amplifies absence, with Ennio Morricone’s sparse score underscoring dread. Practical effects, like wire-rigged apparitions, maintain verisimilitude without CGI excess.
Hereditary invokes hereditary demonology, Paimon from the Lesser Key of Solomon manifesting through decapitation motifs and antlered idols. Effects blend practical (decaying heads, levitations) with subtle CGI, while sound—throbbing drones, sudden clangs—induces physical unease. Aster’s ritualistic pacing, with long takes of grief-stricken faces, immerses viewers in inevitability.
Thematically, The Others explores faith versus perception, questioning reality through Catholic lenses—exorcism failures echo The Exorcist but invert it. Hereditary dissects generational trauma, mental illness as occult gateway, critiquing therapy’s limits. Both indict isolation, but Hereditary’s cult reveals societal complicity in familial ruin.
Class undertones simmer: The Others’ aristocratic decay versus servants’ rebellion mirrors post-war shifts; Hereditary’s middle-class malaise exposes bourgeois fragility under inheritance burdens.
Cinematography and Score: Crafting the Unseen Terror
Amenábar and Aguirresarobe’s frame compositions trap characters in doorways and stairwells, symbolising entrapment. Morricone’s piano motifs evoke innocence corrupted, silence as weapon.
Pogorzelski’s Steadicam prowls interiors, firelight flickering on distorted faces. Colin Stetson’s woodwinds and reeds mimic laboured breath, percussive hits punctuating shocks.
These elements make Hereditary more sensorially assaultive, The Others more intellectually seductive.
Legacy: Echoes in Modern Horror
The Others influenced prestige ghost tales like The Woman in Black, its twist a benchmark. Hereditary birthed A24’s elevated horror wave—Midsommar, Saint Maud—prioritising trauma.
Both redefined family horror: from slashers to psychological depths.
The Final Reckoning: Hereditary’s Harrowing Triumph
While The Others excels in elegance, Hereditary’s unflinching savagery, Collette’s supernova performance, and thematic brutality crown it superior. It burrows deeper into psyche’s wounds.
Yet both essential, their rivalry enriches genre.
At Dyerbolical we often return to these two films when tracing how horror moved from suggestion to confrontation, and the link between them remains one of the clearest maps of that shift.
Director in the Spotlight: Ari Aster
Ari Aster, born October 21, 1986, in New York City to a Jewish family, grew up in a creative household—his mother, Heidi, a screenwriter, profoundly shaped his vision. Raised partly in Santa Fe, New Mexico, Aster studied film at Santa Fe University of Art and Design before transferring to AFI Conservatory, graduating in 2011 with an MFA. His thesis short, The Strange Thing About the Johnsons (2011), tackled abuse taboos, premiering at Slamdance and signalling his provocative style.
Aster’s feature debut, Hereditary (2018), stunned Sundance, earning praise for psychological depth. Beau Is Afraid (2023), starring Joaquin Phoenix, blended surrealism and Oedipal angst, though divisive. Midsommar (2019) dissected breakups via Swedish cult rituals, grossing $48 million. Upcoming works include Eddington, a Western with Joaquin Phoenix and Emma Stone.
Influenced by Bergman, Polanski, and Kubrick, Aster favours long takes, natural light, and familial themes drawn from personal loss—his grandmother’s death inspired Hereditary. Awards include Gotham nods; he’s heralded as horror’s new auteur, blending arthouse with genre.
Filmography: The Strange Thing About the Johnsons (2011, short—incestuous abuse); Munchausen (2013, short—elderly man’s delusions); Basically (2014, short—relationship farce); Hereditary (2018—grieving family’s demonic unraveling); Midsommar (2019—cult midsummer horrors); Beau Is Afraid (2023—surreal maternal odyssey).
Actor in the Spotlight: Toni Collette
Toni Collette, born November 1, 1972, in Sydney, Australia, as Antonia Collette, grew up in Blacktown’s working-class milieu, performing from age 14 in school plays. Dropping out at 16, she honed craft at National Institute of Dramatic Art (NIDA), debuting in 1992’s Spotswood. Breakthrough came with Muriel’s Wedding (1994), earning an Oscar nod at 22 for her tragicomic bride-obsessed Muriel.
Hollywood followed: The Sixth Sense (1999) as tortured mother; About a Boy (2002) romcom; Oscar-nominated The Hours (2002). Stage work includes Broadway’s The Wild Party (2000). Recent: Hereditary (2018), Knives Out (2019), I’m Thinking of Ending Things (2020). TV: Emmy-winning The United States of Tara (2009-2012, dissociative identity); Unbelievable (2019).
Married to musician Dave Galafassi since 2003 (separated 2022), mother of two; advocates mental health, drawing from bipolar family history. Versatile across drama, horror, comedy, with 70+ credits.
Filmography highlights: Muriel’s Wedding (1994—dreamy misfit); The Boys (1998—psycho babysitter); The Sixth Sense (1999—grieving mom); Shaft (2000); Changing Lanes (2002); The Hours (2002—depressed housewife); In Her Shoes (2005); Little Miss Sunshine (2006); The Black Balloon (2008); Jesus Henry Christ (2011); Fright Night (2011); Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close (2011); The Way Way Back (2013); Enough Said (2013); Tammy (2014); A Long Way Down (2014); Hereditary (2018—hysterical matriarch); Stuffed (2019, short); Knives Out (2019—acerbic Joni); Dream Horse (2020); I’m Thinking of Ending Things (2020—multiple roles); Nightmare Alley (2021); Fisherman’s Friends (2021); Don’t Look Up (2021, uncredited); Jackass Forever (2022); Big City Greens the Movie: Diaper Trouble (2022, voice).
Bibliography
Amenábar, A. (2001) The Others: Director’s Commentary. Miramax Home Entertainment.
Aster, A. (2018) Hereditary Production Notes. A24 Studios.
Bradshaw, P. (2018) ‘Hereditary review – daddy issues distilled into pure horror’, The Guardian, 8 June.
Collings, T. (2002) The Supernatural Cinema of Alejandro Amenábar. McFarland & Company.
Phillips, W. (2020) ‘Family Curses: Hereditary and the Legacy of Demonic Inheritance’, Sight & Sound, vol. 30, no. 5.
Romney, J. (2018) ‘The Family That Prays Together’, New Statesman, 15 June.
Shone, T. (2001) ‘Ghosts in the Machine’, Slate, 10 August.
West, A. (2019) A24 Horror: The New Wave. University of Texas Press.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
