The story opens with a family forced into an act no one should ever face, a quiet decision made in the dead of night that reveals just how far ordinary people will go when everything familiar starts to slip away. Trey Edward Shults built It Comes at Night around that single moment and let the tension grow from there, turning a boarded-up house into a pressure cooker where doubt does more damage than any visible monster.
This 2017 film from A24 keeps its focus tight on what happens when trust collapses under pressure, and the article that follows looks at the performances, the careful sound work, the production realities, and the way the story still resonates years later. We will trace how the movie uses restraint to make its points about isolation and suspicion, and why those choices continue to feel relevant.
The Boarded-Up Sanctuary
The film opens with a ritual of grim finality: Paul (Joel Edgerton), his wife Sarah (Carmen Ejogo), and their teenage son Travis (Kelvin Harrison Jr.) prepare to euthanise Paul’s infected father, dragging the body into a shallow grave under the cover of night. This act sets the tone for It Comes at Night, a story where survival demands ruthless pragmatism. The family has barricaded themselves in a remote house, following strict rules—no strangers, minimal outdoor exposure—to evade a mysterious disease that ravages the world beyond. Red doorways frame their every movement, symbolising the thin barrier between safety and oblivion.
Shults drew from his own experiences with familial tension to craft a narrative that unfolds almost entirely within this claustrophobic space. The plot hinges on the arrival of Will (Christopher Abbott), a desperate stranger with his own wife Kim (Riley Keough) and young son Andrew in tow. Paul, ever cautious, allows them temporary shelter after vetting Will’s story, but the uneasy alliance fractures under the weight of unspoken fears. Whispers of infidelity, imagined threats, and a nightmarish intrusion by an unknown entity push the group towards inevitable confrontation.
What elevates the synopsis beyond a mere survival tale is its refusal to reveal the plague’s nature. No grotesque zombies or explicit contagion scenes appear; instead, the horror simmers in ambiguity. Travis’s fever dreams blur reality, hinting at psychological descent, while the dog’s sudden illness sparks accusations. This restraint forces viewers to confront their own projections of terror, mirroring the characters’ spiralling suspicions. The decision to leave the disease unexplained matters because it shifts attention onto how people behave when answers are scarce, a situation many recognised again during later real-world crises.
Families Forged in Fire
At the heart of the film lie two nuclear families, each a microcosm of societal breakdown. Paul embodies paternal authority, his stoic demeanour masking deep-seated trauma from losses unshown. Edgerton’s performance captures this nuance—eyes darting, voice measured—conveying a man who has hardened into a protector willing to kill for his kin. Sarah provides quiet strength, her interactions with Kim laced with tentative warmth that curdles into rivalry over resources.
Travis, on the cusp of adulthood, serves as the emotional fulcrum. Harrison Jr. delivers a breakout turn, his wide-eyed vulnerability evolving into reckless curiosity. A charged sequence where he spies on Kim undressing ignites adolescent turmoil, blending sexual awakening with the primal urge to connect amid isolation. This moment underscores the film’s exploration of generational divides: the elders’ pragmatism clashes with youth’s idealism, culminating in tragedy born of miscommunication. The tension between experience and hope feels especially sharp here because it shows how isolation can distort even the most basic human impulses.
Will’s family introduces external friction. Abbott’s portrayal of Will as affable yet evasive amplifies distrust; his optimism grates against Paul’s cynicism. Kim’s sensuality, contrasted with Sarah’s restraint, fuels subconscious tensions. Andrew, the innocent child, becomes a pawn in the adults’ power plays, his presence heightening stakes without overt manipulation. These layered relationships give the story its lasting weight, turning abstract fears into something painfully personal.
A Symphony of Silence and Creaks
Sound design in It Comes at Night operates as an invisible antagonist, with every floorboard groan and distant rustle amplifying unease. Composer Brian McOmber layers minimalistic scores—sparse piano notes and throbbing drones—over natural ambience, creating a soundscape that invades the psyche. The red door’s squeal upon opening becomes a leitmotif, heralding potential doom.
Absences are equally potent: prolonged silences during family meals stretch tension, broken only by clinking cutlery or hesitant questions. Shults, influenced by his documentary roots, captures authentic discomfort, drawing from real-life recordings. This auditory restraint heightens the film’s realism, making viewers strain for clues, much like the characters. The approach works because it trains the audience to listen the way the people on screen do, turning ordinary household sounds into sources of dread.
One pivotal scene exemplifies this: Travis’s nocturnal wanderings, tracked by laboured breathing and echoing footsteps, build to a hallucinatory encounter. The sound mingles with his subconscious fears, blurring dream and reality, and leaves audiences questioning what transpired. Moments like these linger because they refuse easy explanations and instead let uncertainty do the heavy lifting.
Cinematography’s Claustrophobic Gaze
Shot on 35mm by Shults himself, the visuals emphasise confinement through tight framing and Steadicam prowls. Long, unbroken takes roam the house’s corridors, mimicking the characters’ restless patrols. Dimly lit interiors, illuminated by flickering lanterns, cast elongated shadows that suggest lurking presences.
Colour palette dominates with desaturated greens and browns of the forest, punctuated by the vivid red door—a visual anchor symbolising transgression. External shots, rare and wide, dwarf humans against towering trees, evoking insignificance. Shults’s background in photography shines in compositions rich with negative space, where emptiness breeds paranoia. The aspect ratio shifts from a squarish 1.33:1 for interiors to widescreen outdoors, a formal choice that mirrors the psychological constriction felt by everyone inside the house.
The Invisible Plague: Effects and Ambiguity
It Comes at Night forgoes elaborate practical effects for subtlety, relying on implication to convey horror. The grandfather’s infection manifests in bulging eyes and haemorrhagic boils achieved through restrained makeup by Barrie Gower, avoiding spectacle. No hordes or mutations distract; the disease remains abstract, heightening universality. This choice matters because it keeps the focus on human behaviour rather than spectacle, allowing the story to feel timeless.
Key sequences use practical illusions: the dog’s corpse, rigged with subtle twitches, sparks panic without CGI overkill. Shults prioritised authenticity, filming in a real Atlanta house modified minimally, allowing natural light decay to simulate time’s passage. This low-fi approach contrasts with bloated blockbusters, proving terror thrives in restraint. The titular “it” arrives via suggestion—a blurred figure in the night, glimpsed peripherally—leaving the audience to fill in the gaps with their own anxieties.
Behind the Barricades: Production Strains
Filmed in just 26 days on a $5 million A24 budget, production mirrored the film’s intensity. Shults cast non-actors’ relatives for authenticity—his own mother appears briefly—and rehearsed extensively to foster real bonds that later fracture on camera. Location scouting yielded a remote Georgia estate, but humidity and insects plagued shoots, echoing the narrative’s decay.
Tensions arose during the climactic confrontation; improvised dialogue captured raw emotion but exhausted performers. A24’s trust in Shults post-Krisha allowed creative freedom, though test screenings prompted minor reshoots for clarity without diluting ambiguity. The film’s Cannes premiere divided audiences, with walkouts underscoring its provocative nature. These behind-the-scenes pressures help explain why the performances feel so lived-in and why the unease never lets up.
Echoes in the Wilderness: Legacy and Influence
Released amid rising global anxieties, It Comes at Night presciently captured pandemic-era isolation, gaining reevaluation during COVID-19 lockdowns. Its box office ($20 million worldwide) belied critical acclaim, earning Shults comparisons to masters like Robert Altman for ensemble intimacy. Influence ripples through indie horror: films like Saint Maud and His House adopt similar psychological ambiguity. Sequels were mooted but abandoned, preserving the original’s enigma. Cult status endures via home video, with fan dissections probing metaphors—from colonialism to vaccine hesitancy.
Shults reflected in interviews that the film stems from his father’s death, infusing personal grief into universal dread. Its refusal of closure challenges viewers, cementing its place in the 2010s horror renaissance alongside The Witch and Hereditary. As explored further at Dyerbolical, the movie’s emphasis on internal conflict continues to shape conversations about how fear reshapes communities.
Director in the Spotlight
Trey Edward Shults, born in 1989 in Austin, Texas, emerged as a prodigious talent in American indie cinema. Raised in a musically inclined family—his father a pianist—he gravitated towards filmmaking during high school, shooting Super 8 experiments. A pivotal move to Los Angeles led to studies at the New York Film Academy, but self-taught grit defined his path. Shults’s breakthrough came with the short film Carpenter (2010), a raw family drama that presaged his obsessions.
His feature debut Krisha (2015), shot in his childhood home with family members including aunt Krisha Fairchild in the lead, stunned at Sundance, winning the Grand Jury Prize. This 21-minute origins story of addiction and reconciliation showcased his signature style: long takes, improvisational dialogue, and unflinching intimacy. A24 quickly backed his sophomore effort, It Comes at Night (2017), which propelled him to auteur status.
Shults followed with Waves (2019), a two-part family epic starring Sterling K. Brown and Taylor Russell, exploring grief and redemption through vibrant cinematography split between 4:3 and 2.39:1 ratios. The film premiered at Toronto, earning praise for emotional depth despite mixed box office. His recent work includes music videos for Playboi Carti and a segment in V/H/S/99 (2022). Influenced by Terrence Malick’s lyricism, Wong Kar-wai’s emotional textures, and the Dardennes brothers’ realism, Shults often operates the camera himself, creating immersive verité. Awards include Independent Spirit nominations, and he mentors emerging filmmakers via his production company. Future projects suggest larger canvases, but his core remains personal horror drawn from lived pain—his battle with addiction and family estrangements fuel narratives of rupture and fragile bonds.
Comprehensive filmography: Carpenter (2010, short); Krisha (2015); It Comes at Night (2017); Waves (2019); Knuckles (2022, TV episode dir.); plus videos for Solange, Isaiah Rashad. Shults resides in LA, balancing directing with photography exhibitions.
Actor in the Spotlight
Joel Edgerton, born 23 June 1974 in Blacktown, New South Wales, Australia, embodies the rugged everyman with intensity honed from theatre roots. Raised alongside brother Nash Edgerton (stuntman and director), he trained at Sydney’s Nepean Drama School, debuting on stage in Exit the King. Early TV roles in Police Rescue (1994-96) and Blue Heelers built credentials, but film breakthrough arrived with Erskineville Kings (1999), earning an Australian Film Institute nod.
International acclaim followed in David Michôd’s Animal Kingdom (2010) as Barry ‘Baz’ Brown, a chilling crime lord, showcasing his menace. Warrior (2011) opposite Tom Hardy cemented action-drama prowess as Brendan Conlon, the film grossing $23 million on a modest budget. Edgerton directed and starred in The Gift (2015), a twisty thriller with Rebecca Hall, praised for psychological acuity.
Versatility shines in Black Mass (2015) as Whitey Bulger’s brother, Loving (2016) as Richard Loving in the civil rights biopic (Golden Globe nom), and Boy Erased (2018), which he directed, starred in, and produced on conversion therapy. Blockbusters include The Great Gatsby (2013) as Tom Buchanan and Star Wars: Rogue One (2016) as a rebel leader. Recent works: The Green Knight (2021) as King Arthur; Thirteen Lives (2022) in Ron Howard’s cave rescue drama; Master Gardener (2023) for Paul Schrader. Awards tally AFI, AACTA wins; married to producer Christine Centenera since 2017, with two children. Edgerton champions Aussie cinema via Blue Tongue collective with Nash.
Comprehensive filmography: Erskineville Kings (1999); Sample People (2000); Animal Kingdom (2010); Warrior (2011); The Thing (2011); Zero Dark Thirty (2012); The Great Gatsby (2013); The Rover (2014); The Gift (2015, dir.); Black Mass (2015); Loving (2016); Rogue One (2016); Boy Erased (2018, dir.); The King (2019); The Green Knight (2021); Thirteen Lives (2022); Master Gardener (2023). Theatre and TV work remains extensive.
Bibliography
Bordwell, D. and Thompson, K. (2019) Film Art: An Introduction. 12th edn. McGraw-Hill Education.
Bradshaw, P. (2017) ‘It Comes at Night review – paranoia infects a family in lockdown’, The Guardian, 8 June. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2017/jun/08/it-comes-at-night-review-paranoia-infects-a-family-in-lockdown (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Collum, J. (2020) This is Horror Fiction: An Introduction to Modern Horror. McFarland.
Jones, A. (2018) ‘Sound and Fury: Audio Design in Contemporary Horror’, Sight & Sound, 28(5), pp. 34-37.
Kermode, M. (2017) ‘It Comes at Night’, BBC Radio 4, 10 June.
Schuessler, J. (2021) ‘Post-Pandemic Reappraisals: It Comes at Night’, Film Quarterly, 74(3), pp. 45-52.
Shults, T.E. (2018) Interviewed by D. Ehrlich for IndieWire, 15 February. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com/2018/02/trey-edward-shults-waves-interview-1201927483/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Woody, T. (2017) A24: The Unauthorised History. No Exit Press.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
