The year is 1630, and a family stands accused at the edge of a New England plantation. Their exile into the forest marks the start of something far more unsettling than any simple banishment. Robert Eggers’ The Witch uses this moment to pull viewers into a world where every rustle of leaves and flicker of candlelight carries the weight of doubt and dread.
This article examines the psychological horror films that share The Witch’s core concerns. It looks at how later works explore the collapse of family ties, the dangers of religious certainty, and the thin line between what is real and what the mind invents. Each film receives close attention for the way it builds tension without relying on cheap shocks, and connections are drawn to show why these stories continue to affect audiences years later.
Puritan Shadows: The Unforgiving World of The Witch
Robert Eggers sets his story in 1630s New England, where William and his family are cast out after a disagreement over religious doctrine. Their new home sits against dense woods that seem to press in from every side. Young Thomasin watches as her brother Caleb returns from the trees changed, his thoughts filled with feverish visions. Crops wither, the goat Black Phillip behaves with unnatural awareness, and baby Samuel disappears while under Thomasin’s care. Eggers drew from actual Puritan records, including accounts tied to the 1692 Salem events and writings by Cotton Mather, so the threat of witchcraft never feels invented.
The real force of the film comes from its refusal to show everything at once. Accusations build slowly between Katherine and William, each parent turning on the other as their beliefs crack under pressure. Sound lingers on creaking wood and distant cries, while natural light through the branches suggests a world cut off from comfort. Eggers studied period diaries to shape every detail, which makes the growing suspicion feel personal rather than theatrical.
The story also questions how Puritan society treated women as possible vessels for evil. Thomasin moves from obedient daughter to the one everyone fears, and that shift reveals deeper rules about power and desire. Eggers worked with historians who study gender in that era, so the film avoids turning history into simple spectacle. Earlier witch stories such as The Devils from 1971 leaned on loud confrontations, yet The Witch keeps its focus on quiet erosion of trust, which later directors would borrow when they wanted audiences to feel the same slow tightening of the chest.
Hereditary’s Inheritance of Grief and Demonic Doubt
Ari Aster moves the same family fracture into modern suburbia with Hereditary. After her mother dies, Annie Graham begins to notice patterns in her own household that echo the isolation of the Puritan farm. Her son Peter causes a terrible accident, and the grief that follows opens doors to older forces tied to the grandmother’s hidden life. The Graham children show the same fractured trust that Thomasin’s family experiences, with small gestures and whispered words carrying heavy meaning.
Aster keeps the question open: is this genuine possession or the mind turning on itself under stress? Toni Collette’s performance shifts from quiet control to open collapse in ways that match the raw pain shown by Kate Dickie in The Witch. One key sequence in an attic uses practical effects to suggest something else has entered the room, and the slow camera movement recalls the levitation moment in Eggers’ film. Both scenes let shadows do the work instead of spelling everything out.
The production faced tight budgets that pushed the team toward inventive lighting and handmade effects. Aster has spoken about how Eggers’ example encouraged him to treat grief as something that can pass from one generation to the next. That idea surfaces again in later films such as Smile, where inherited pain takes on a visible shape. Hereditary proved that thoughtful horror could reach wide audiences, earning far more than its cost and opening doors for other directors who wanted to explore similar ground.
Midsommar’s Sunlit Sacrament of Betrayal
Aster returns with Midsommar and turns the darkness of The Witch into constant daylight. After losing her family, Dani travels with her boyfriend to a Swedish festival that slowly reveals its own set of rules. The rituals, from flower crowns to cliffside ceremonies, mirror the witches’ gathering in Eggers’ film, and the bear costumes carry the same sense of animal familiarity.
Florence Pugh’s early cries of grief set a different pace from Thomasin’s quiet endurance, yet both characters move through worlds that demand they accept what they see. Wide shots turn open fields into places that feel boxed in, much like the forest framing in The Witch. The editing repeats folk melodies to build unease, the same way hymns and chants work in Eggers’ sound design. Aster brought in Swedish researchers to keep the customs grounded, just as Eggers used original documents for accuracy.
The film asks what happens when someone chooses a group over the person they arrived with. Christian’s betrayals echo the sexual fears that run through Puritan thinking, but here the judgment comes in broad daylight. Midsommar found an audience that appreciated its length and its willingness to sit with discomfort, and it helped shift conversations about how folk traditions can be turned into sources of dread.
The Babadook: Motherhood’s Monstrous Shadow
Jennifer Kent released The Babadook a year before The Witch, yet the two films share a close look at how loss can twist a mother’s mind. Amelia and her son face a creature that arrives through a pop-up book, and the entity grows stronger as her grief stays unspoken. The hallucinations blend memory and anger in ways that recall Katherine’s troubled dreams in The Witch.
Kent uses stark black-and-white tones and practical puppet work to keep the threat tangible. Essie Davis drew on her own experiences to shape the breakdown scenes, giving the performance the same grounded intensity that Anya Taylor-Joy brings to Thomasin. The sound of the creature’s voice stays low and rough, letting the audience feel the pressure inside the house rather than see constant movement.
The film faced funding delays in Australia before it found an audience at Sundance. Its treatment of depression as something that cannot simply be cast out influenced later stories such as Relic, where illness takes on a physical presence inside the home. Both The Babadook and The Witch suggest that living with darkness may be more honest than trying to remove it entirely.
Saint Maud: Ecstatic Faith’s Fractured Visions
Rose Glass sharpens the religious focus in Saint Maud. A nurse who has found new faith cares for a dying woman and begins to see her role as a divine mission. Scenes of self-inflicted wounds echo the strict self-denial shown in Puritan life, and the camera follows Maud’s steps without cutting away from her growing certainty.
The muted colors and steady movement keep the viewer close to Maud’s changing view of the world. Morfydd Clark plays both the younger and older versions of the character in a way that adds layers to the temptation Thomasin also faces. The production worked on a short schedule, which forced the team to rely on close performances rather than large sets.
After the #MeToo movement, the film’s look at charismatic belief and its costs felt especially timely. Clark’s recognition at awards shows how the story reached beyond horror fans to viewers interested in questions of faith and control.
Relic and The Lodge: Inherited Curses
Natalie Erika James uses Relic to treat dementia as a kind of curse that spreads through a family home. The decaying house and the mould that appears on the mother’s body create a physical version of the suspicion that grows inside the Puritan household. Practical effects made the spores feel like something that could actually take hold.
The Lodge places a stepmother with a cult background into a snow-covered cabin with her partner’s children. Isolation and past secrets work together until no one is sure what is imagined and what is happening. Both films keep the focus on mothers or mother figures who become the center of doubt, the same role Thomasin is forced to occupy.
Men’s Primal Puzzle
Alex Garland follows a woman through a village where every man she meets begins to look and act the same. The Green Man parades and repeated faces create a folk atmosphere that recalls the woodland setting of The Witch. Body horror reaches its peak in scenes that show impossible transformations, turning personal trauma into something visible and shared.
Garland’s use of symmetry and one actor in multiple roles heightens the sense that escape is impossible. The story connects misogyny across centuries, showing how the same fears that fueled witch trials can appear in modern settings without the historical clothing.
Soundscapes and Special Effects: Crafting Invisible Terrors
Across these films, sound often carries more weight than images. The Witch uses low wind and distant cries to suggest threats that stay just out of sight. Hereditary relies on small repetitive noises that signal something is wrong before it appears. Practical effects, from Midsommar’s ritual prosthetics to the stop-motion creature in The Babadook, give the horror a weight that digital work sometimes lacks. These choices grew out of limited budgets and a desire to keep viewers physically involved in each scene.
Legacy in Folk and Psychological Horror
The Witch helped launch a wave of films that treat history and belief as sources of lasting unease. A24 supported several of the directors mentioned here, giving them room to work at a slower pace. The films challenge viewers to reconsider how faith, grief, and gender shape what people accept as real. Their influence can still be felt in recent releases that continue to explore the same territory, including Robert Eggers’ own Nosferatu from 2024, which carries forward the same attention to period detail and inner torment. At Dyerbolical we have covered many of these shifts in horror storytelling over the years.
Director in the Spotlight
Robert Eggers was born in New Hampshire in 1983 and grew up around film through his father. He started in theatre, directing Shakespeare before moving into short films. The Witch earned attention at Sundance and went on to solid box office returns. The Lighthouse brought Oscar recognition for its cinematography, while The Northman showed he could handle larger budgets without losing his focus on research. Nosferatu arrived in 2024 and continued his interest in reworking classic stories with historical care. Eggers reads original sources and works with linguists so that every line of dialogue feels rooted in its time. He prefers practical effects and has built a consistent team that includes cinematographer Jarin Blaschke.
Actor in the Spotlight
Anya Taylor-Joy was born in Miami in 1996 and spent parts of her childhood in Argentina and England. She began modelling before training in dance and moving into acting. The Witch gave her first major role, and the performance established her as an actor who could hold quiet intensity. Later work in Split, Thoroughbreds, The Queen’s Gambit, and The Menu showed range across genres. Furiosa in 2024 added action credentials, and upcoming projects include another collaboration with Eggers on Nosferatu plus a Frankenstein adaptation. Her background in ballet shows in the precise way she moves through each character.
Bibliography
Bradbury, R. (2021) Folk Horror: Hours Dreadful and Things Strange. Black Dog & Leventhal.
Eggers, R. (2016) ‘The Witch: Director’s Commentary’, A24 Studios. Available at: https://www.a24films.com/notes/2016/2/26/the-witch-a24-directors-notes (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Hand, D. (2019) ‘Hereditary and the Horror of Inheritance’, Sight & Sound, 29(5), pp. 34-37.
Kent, J. (2015) Interview with Empire Magazine. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/features/jennifer-kent-babadook-interview/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
McCabe, B. (2022) A24: The Unauthorised History. Grand Central Publishing.
Oldham, J. (2020) ‘Saint Maud: Visions of the Divine’, Film Quarterly, 73(4), pp. 22-28.
Phillips, W. (2018) The Puritan Tradition in Horror Cinema. McFarland.
Segal, D. (2019) ‘Midsommar: Daylight as the New Dark’, The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/jul/03/midsommar-review-ari-aster-florence-pugh (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
