Top Psychological Horror Gems That Mirror The Babadook’s Unsettling Depths, Ranked

“Grief is a monster that lives in the walls of the mind— these films prove it claws its way out.”

The Babadook lingers not through jump scares or gore, but by embodying raw maternal anguish and repressed trauma as a children’s pop-up tale come to life. Jennifer Kent’s 2014 masterpiece struck a nerve, blending domestic dread with supernatural unease. For those craving similar slow-burn descents into psychological torment, this ranking unearths ten films that echo its intimate horrors, from familial fractures to hallucinatory hauntings. Each selection amplifies the mind’s fragility, ranked by their sheer emotional devastation and thematic resonance.

  • Hereditary tops the list for its unflinching parallel to The Babadook’s grief-stricken motherhood, escalating family secrets into cosmic nightmare.
  • These movies share motifs of isolation, mental unraveling, and monsters as metaphors for unspoken pain, demanding viewers confront their own shadows.
  • From Ari Aster’s visceral visions to subtle Aussie chillers, they redefine horror as an internal battleground, influencing a new wave of cerebral scares.

Unpacking the Psyche: Why The Babadook Resonates

The Babadook’s power stems from its refusal to simplify horror. A single mother, Amelia, and her son Samuel face a storybook entity that symbolises her overwhelming sorrow after her husband’s death. Kent crafts tension through confined spaces—the creaking house, the kitchen table—mirroring the claustrophobia of depression. Sound design amplifies this: the book’s pages rustling like dry bones, Amelia’s sobs echoing into silence. Critics praise its feminist undercurrents, portraying Amelia not as hysterical but human, her rage a valid response to societal expectations of perfect grief.

Psychological horror thrives here because it weaponises empathy. Unlike slasher flicks, these narratives invade the viewer’s subconscious, lingering like insomnia. The Babadook influenced a subgenre boom, where antagonists are projections of psyche wounds. Films on this list build on that legacy, exploring how trauma festers in isolation, often through parental bonds strained to breaking. They demand active engagement, rewarding rewatches with layered symbolism—from biblical nods to Freudian slips.

Ranking criteria prioritise emotional authenticity, visual poetry, and lasting dread. High placements go to those matching The Babadook’s balance of subtlety and eruption, while lower ones excel in niche chills. All share arthouse sensibilities, low budgets yielding high impact, proving horror’s potency lies in suggestion over spectacle.

10. Lake Mungo (2008): Mockumentary Mourning

Australian found-footage pioneer Joel Anderson delivers a gut-punch in Lake Mungo, centring the Palmer family’s grief over daughter Alice’s drowning. Through interviews and home videos, secrets unravel: ghostly glimpses, hidden sexuality, a basement discovery that shatters illusions. Like The Babadook, it fixates on maternal loss—mother June sifts photos obsessively, echoing Amelia’s pop-up fixation. The film’s restraint builds unease; pale lighting and watery motifs evoke submerged guilt.

Anderson’s script toys with reality, blurring documentary authenticity with spectral hints. Alice’s arc, revealed in flickering footage, mirrors Samuel’s volatile outbursts—both children as conduits for adult denial. Critics hail its soundscape: distant splashes, muffled cries, amplifying psychological voids. At 84 minutes, it punches above its weight, influencing mockumentary horrors without devolving into gimmicks.

Themes of privacy invasion prefigure social media anxieties, yet its core is timeless: how death rewrites family narratives. Lake Mungo ranks lowest for its subtlety bordering on opacity, but its emotional truth aligns perfectly with Kent’s intimate terrors.

9. A Dark Song (2016): Occult Isolation

Liam Gavin’s debut traps grieving mother Sophia in a Welsh farmhouse for a months-long summoning ritual, seeking contact with her dead boy. Steve Oram co-stars as occultist Joseph, their dynamic fraught with mistrust. Parallels to The Babadook abound: ritual circles mimic the book’s incantations, isolation breeds hallucinations, motherhood’s desperation fuels the abyss. Cinematographer Piers McGrail employs stark desaturation, turning the house into a void.

Gavin draws from real Enochian magic, grounding supernaturalism in procedural dread. Sophia’s arc—from control to surrender—echoes Amelia’s breakdown, both women bargaining with entities born of loss. Practical effects for manifestations avoid CGI excess, heightening intimacy. Clocking 100 minutes, it sustains tension through repetitive rites, soundtracked by tolling bells and incantations.

Its exploration of vengeance versus acceptance elevates it, though pacing lags slightly. A Dark Song captures The Babadook’s ritualistic grief, proving rituals—be they pop-up books or grimoires—unlock inner demons.

8. Under the Shadow (2016): War’s Phantom Child

Babak Anvari’s Persepolis-set chiller follows Shideh and daughter Dorsa amid 1980s Tehran bombings, pursued by a djinn disguised as a shrouded girl. Maternal protectiveness clashes with cultural taboos—Shideh’s banned student status mirrors Amelia’s alienation. Rotting fabrics and missile tremors parallel the house’s groans, sound design fusing wails with air-raid sirens.

Anvari, a UK-Iranian filmmaker, infuses folklore authenticity, the djinn embodying wartime trauma. Dorsa’s attachment to a doll echoes the Babadook pop-up, both totems of suppressed fear. The film’s 84-minute runtime builds to a feverish climax, Shideh’s unraveling a portrait of refugee psyche.

Gender politics shine: women’s restricted lives amplify horror. It ranks mid for cultural specificity, yet universally conveys how external chaos manifests internally, much like Kent’s domestic siege.

7. The Invitation (2015): Dinner Party Paranoia

Karyn Kusama directs Will at an ex-wife’s LA hills dinner, suspecting a cult amid grief over their son’s death. Slow reveals—odd guests, locked doors—mirror Amelia’s growing suspicion of the entity. Dialogue crackles with subtext, Kusama’s camera lingering on wine glasses, faces in firelight.

Will’s PTSD flashbacks parallel Samuel’s night terrors, both narratives questioning sanity. At 100 minutes, it masterclasses escalating dread, culminating in explosive catharsis. Themes of toxic positivity in mourning resonate with The Babadook’s rejection of tidy closure.

Kusama’s genre versatility shines, though overt twists slightly dilute subtlety. Still, its relational fractures make it a strong Babadook kin.

6. Saint Maud (2019): Faith’s Fever Dream

Rose Glass’s micro-budget stunner tracks nurse Maud’s obsessive salvation of terminally ill Amanda, blurring piety and possession. Morfydd Clark’s dual role channels Essie Davis’s ferocity—twisted smiles, solitary dances. Religious iconography evokes the Babadook’s gothic whimsy, blood and stigmata as pop-up viscera.

Glass crafts body horror through ascetic denial, Maud’s visions a metaphor for fanaticism’s isolation. Sound—rasping breaths, hymn distortions—rivals Kent’s audio menace. 84 minutes of precision yield profound unease, exploring zealotry as mental malady.

Maud’s arc from caregiver to zealot mirrors Amelia’s maternal implosion, securing mid-high rank for its ecstatic terror.

5. It Follows (2014): STD as Stalker

David Robert Mitchell’s Detroit suburbia curse—sex-transmitted entity—manifests inescapable dread. Jay’s pursuit parallels the Babadook’s home invasion, slow plods building primal fear. Mitchell’s wide shots and synth score evoke 80s nostalgia laced with doom.

Teen sexuality as horror conduit echoes parental anxieties in Kent’s film, the entity a stand-in for consequence. At 100 minutes, it innovates pursuit tropes, themes of mortality hauntingly adolescent.

Its universality boosts placement, though less familial than peers.

4. The Witch (2015): Puritan Paranoia

Robert Eggers’s 1630s New England folktale sees the Thomasin family fracture under witchcraft accusations post-baby’s vanishing. Anya Taylor-Joy’s emergence from innocence mirrors Samuel’s rebellion, Black Phillip’s whispers the Babadook’s rhymes. Eggers’s period accuracy—fens, goats, prayer—immerses in dread.

Script draws from trial transcripts, exploring patriarchal collapse. Sound of wind and bleats heightens isolation. 92 minutes distil folklore into psychosexual frenzy.

Family implosion cements its spot, a colonial Babadook.

3. Relic (2020): Dementia’s Dwelling

Natalie Erika James’s Aussie eldercare nightmare has Kay and Sam confronting grandma Edna’s decay, mould symbolising Alzheimer’s spread. Like Amelia, mothers inherit burdens, house’s rot the mind’s.

James blends sentiment and scare, loops and sticky floors visceral. Emily Mortimor’s score underscores inheritance of pain. 89 minutes pack poignant punches.

Intergenerational grief rivals Kent’s intimacy.

2. Midsommar (2019): Daylight Despair

Ari Aster’s Swedish commune breakup follows Dani’s family slaughter trauma. Florence Pugh’s breakdowns echo Davis’s, rituals externalising inner chaos. Bright visuals invert Babadook’s dark, yet dread matches.

Aster’s long takes capture dissociation, themes of communal vs personal grief profound. 147 minutes reward patience with operatic horror.

Near-top for emotional scale.

1. Hereditary (2018): Grief’s Inheritance

Ari Aster crowns with the Grahams’ matriarch death unleashing hereditary evil. Toni Collette’s Annie rivals Amelia—seances, decapitations metaphors for severed bonds. Pawel Pogorzelski’s Steadicam prowls miniatures, sound of snaps and cries devastating.

Aster weaves Paimon demonology into family therapy gone wrong, 127 minutes escalating from domestic to infernal. Performances, especially Collette’s Oscar-snubbed rage, cement mastery.

Perfect Babadook heir: grief as generational curse.

Conclusion: Shadows That Bind

These films prove psychological horror’s supremacy in excavating human frailty. From Lake Mungo’s quiet ripples to Hereditary’s tsunamis, they honour The Babadook by innovating dread’s anatomy. In a spectacle-saturated era, their cerebral grips endure, reminding us monsters dwell within.

Director in the Spotlight: Jennifer Kent

Jennifer Kent, born September 4, 1972, in Brisbane, Australia, emerged as a formidable force in horror after a circuitous path through acting and television. She trained at the Victorian College of the Arts, debuting on stage before transitioning to film. A pivotal break came as script supervisor and assistant to Lars von Trier on Dogville (2003) and Dogville Confessions (2003), absorbing his provocative style. Kent honed her craft writing for Australian TV, including episodes of East West 101 (2007-2011) and Dangerous Remedy (2012), tackling crime and historical drama.

Her directorial debut, The Babadook (2014), premiered at Sundance to acclaim, grossing over $10 million on a $2 million budget. Produced by Kristina Ceyton and Kristian Connelly, it garnered AACTA Awards for Best Direction and Best Original Screenplay. Kent’s follow-up, The Nightingale (2018), a brutal colonial revenge tale starring Aisling Franciosi and Baykali Ganambarr, won her the Venice Film Festival’s FIPRESCI Award. Venice also hosted her segment in The Palace (2023) anthology.

Influenced by von Trier, Hitchcock, and Polanski, Kent favours confined spaces and emotional authenticity. She directed episodes of the anthology series Bloom (2019) and Spook (2021). Upcoming: an episode of The Handmaid’s Tale (2023) and a secretive project. Filmography: The Babadook (2014, feature dir/writer—grief horror breakthrough); The Nightingale (2018, feature dir/writer—historical violence epic); The Palace (2023, segment dir—multi-director horror). Her oeuvre champions women’s rage, cementing her as horror’s empathetic innovator.

Kent’s advocacy includes MeToo support in Australian cinema, mentoring emerging directors via Tropfest. Her meticulous prep—storyboarding every frame—yields hypnotic tension, blending genre with drama.

Actor in the Spotlight: Essie Davis

Esther “Essie” Davis, born December 23, 1970, in Hobart, Tasmania, rose from theatre roots to international acclaim. She studied at the National Institute of Dramatic Art (NIDA), graduating 1992, and joined the Sydney Theatre Company, earning Green Room Awards for Hedda Gabler (1994) and The Blind Giant is Dancing (1995). Early film roles included Matilda (1994) and True Love and Chaos (1997).

Breakthrough came with The Slab (1999) and The Girl with a Pearl Earring (2003) as Catharina. Hollywood beckoned: The Matrix Reloaded/Revolutions (2003) as Lady of the Water, then Mistrust (2013). The Babadook (2014) as tormented Amelia earned her an AACTA for Best Actress, spotlighting her raw intensity. Subsequent horrors: The Matrix Resurrections (2021).

Davis shone in Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries (2012-2015, Logie Award), The White Princess (2017), and Game of Thrones (2019) as Missandei briefly. Theatre triumphs: Richard III (Sydney, 2014). Awards: Three AACTAs, Logie, Helpmann. Filmography: The Babadook (2014, Amelia—psych horror icon); The Nightingale (2018, supporting—vengeance tale); Babyteeth (2019, Anna—cancer dramedy, Venice Volpi Cup nom); Nitram (2021, mother—true crime); The Matrix Resurrections (2021, Lady Sif); Blueback (2022, diver activist). TV: Miss Fisher (2012-15, lead detective); The Secrets She Keeps (2019-22, thriller dual role).

Married to Justin Kurzel since 1998 (collaborations on The Babadook, Slow West), mother to two. Davis embodies fierce femininity, from period pieces to genre shocks.

Craving more cerebral chills? Dive deeper into NecroTimes’ horror archives and subscribe for exclusive analyses. Explore Now

Join the conversation: Which psych horror haunts you most?

Bibliography

Abbott, S. (2016) Horrors of the Real: The Babadook and Maternal Melancholia. University of Wales Press.

Aster, A. (2018) ‘Directing Hereditary: Family as Horror Core’, Fangoria, 45, pp. 22-29. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Botting, F. (2014) Gothic: The New Critical Idiom. 2nd edn. Routledge.

Eggers, R. (2015) ‘The Witch: Historical Authenticity in Horror’, Sight & Sound, 25(6), pp. 34-37. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Giles, H. (2020) Psychological Horror Cinema. Palgrave Macmillan.

Glass, R. (2020) Interview: ‘Saint Maud’s Religious Extremism’, Empire Magazine, 412, pp. 56-60. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Kent, J. (2015) ‘The Babadook: From Short to Feature’, Filmmaker Magazine. Available at: https://filmmakermagazine.com (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Kusama, K. (2016) ‘The Invitation: Paranoia Protocols’, IndieWire. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

McRoy, J. (2017) Affecting Trauma in Contemporary Cinema. Bloomsbury Academic.

Mitchell, D. R. (2014) ‘It Follows: The Curse of Pursuit’, Cahiers du Cinéma, 702, pp. 45-48.

Phillips, K. (2021) The Babadook and Its Progeny. McFarland & Company.