In the quiet hours just past midnight, a towering yew tree tears free from the churchyard soil and strides toward a boy’s window with purpose. That single image from A Monster Calls captures the moment when childhood fantasy collides with the unbearable weight of loss, turning a simple bedtime tale into something far more unsettling.
This article examines the 2016 film adaptation of Patrick Ness’s novel, directed by J.A. Bayona, and explores how it transforms personal grief into a form of psychological horror that lingers long after the credits roll. We look at the story’s structure, its visual techniques, the performances that anchor the supernatural elements, and the lasting influence it has had on how cinema handles themes of mourning and truth.
A Monster Calls masterfully weaves dark fantasy with the piercing horror of grief, transforming a child’s bedtime story into a visceral confrontation with mortality. This 2016 adaptation of Patrick Ness’s acclaimed novel dissects the psychological terrors lurking beneath everyday sorrow, using monstrous imagery to externalise inner turmoil.
The film’s horror stems not from gore, but from the supernatural embodiment of grief, challenging viewers to face uncomfortable realities through Conor O’Malley’s harrowing journey. Bayona’s direction elevates fairy-tale motifs into nightmarish sequences, blending stop-motion animation with live-action for a haunting visual symphony. Explorations of truth, denial, and catharsis reveal how the movie redefines grief horror, influencing contemporary dark fantasy cinema.
In the misty English countryside, twelve-year-old Conor O’Malley stares out his bedroom window at a towering yew tree in the churchyard. At precisely 12:07 a.m., the tree rips itself from the earth, branches twisting into colossal arms, bark splitting to reveal glowing eyes and a mouth lined with jagged teeth. This is no ordinary monster; it is the harbinger of truths too brutal for a boy to bear. A Monster Calls plunges into the heart of childhood vulnerability, where the line between protector and destroyer blurs under the weight of impending loss. Director J.A. Bayona crafts a narrative that sidesteps traditional slashers or supernatural slashers, opting instead for a slow-burn psychological descent that grips the soul.
The story unfolds over a mere few days, yet each moment pulses with escalating dread. Conor’s mother, ravaged by cancer, clings to fragile hope with experimental treatments, her pallor and weakening frame a constant reminder of the inevitable. School offers no refuge: bullies target Conor for his frailty, their taunts manifesting in brutal physical assaults that mirror his internal fractures. The monster, voiced with rumbling gravitas by Liam Neeson, promises three tales—parables drawn from folklore and fairy tales—followed by a fourth truth from Conor himself. These stories, rendered in vivid, painterly animations, serve as metaphors for morality, hypocrisy, and the unreliability of perception, forcing Conor (and the audience) to question absolutes.
Bayona’s screenplay, co-written by Ness, meticulously builds tension through repetition and foreshadowing. The clock strikes 12:07 like a death knell, the wind howls with preternatural fury, and Conor’s screams pierce the night. Key scenes amplify this: the first story of a prince’s quest for purity devolves into chaos, symbolising the futility of black-and-white judgments. Practical effects blend seamlessly with digital enhancements, the monster’s colossal form dwarfing homes and landscapes, evoking the overwhelming scale of adult woes upon a child. Sound design masterstroke lies in the creaking wood and guttural roars, immersing viewers in primal fear.
The Monster’s Tales: Folklore as a Weapon of Terror
Each of the monster’s tales functions as a scalpel, dissecting Conor’s denial. The initial parable features an apothecary punished for her greed, her home reduced to splinters by villagers—a direct parallel to Conor’s rage against his grandmother’s sterile, rule-bound world. Animation shifts to a sketch-like style, watercolours bleeding into nightmarish forms, where beauty curdles into violence. This technique, inspired by traditional illuminated manuscripts, contrasts the whimsy of stories with their savage undercurrents, much like the Brothers Grimm originals that Ness reimagines.
The second tale inverts expectations: a vicar hoarding a yew tree’s life-saving berries meets a fiery end, underscoring hypocrisy in faith and authority. Bayona employs dynamic camera work here, swirling around animated figures in dizzying spirals, mimicking Conor’s disorientation. These sequences peak in horror when reality intrudes—the stories conclude with destruction, mirroring Conor’s subconscious desire to obliterate obstacles to his mother’s survival. Grief distorts morality; what begins as moral instruction spirals into justification for rage.
The third story personalises the nightmare: Conor himself stars as a king torn between a wicked stepmother and a loyal cook, his choice unleashing apocalyptic fury. Live-action bleeds into animation, Conor’s bed transforming into a battlefield of flames and crumbling castles. This fusion heightens the horror, making the fantasy inescapably personal. Critics have noted how these tales echo Jungian archetypes, the shadow self manifesting as the monster to integrate suppressed truths.
Grief’s Visceral Claws: Psychological Horror Unmasked
Beyond fantasy, A Monster Calls excels in grief horror, portraying denial as a monstrous force devouring from within. Conor’s nightmares prefigure the monster’s arrival: he plummets from cliffs, drowns in inky voids, symbolising the abyss of loss. Bayona draws from real psychological studies on paediatric bereavement, where children externalise pain through imaginary friends or terrors. The film’s unflinching depiction of the mother’s deterioration—hair loss, morphine haze—avoids sentimentality, opting for raw authenticity that rivals the intimacy of Manchester by the Sea.
Gender dynamics add layers: the grandmother, embodied by Sigourney Weaver’s steely poise, represents suffocating order, her home a mausoleum of porcelain fragility. Conor destroys it in a trance-like fury, shards flying in slow-motion carnage, a cathartic release laced with guilt. Felicity Jones as the mother offers heartbreaking nuance, her final plea for honesty shattering illusions. These performances ground the supernatural in human frailty, elevating the film beyond genre trappings.
Class tensions simmer subtly: Conor’s working-class roots clash with his grandmother’s bourgeois rigidity, the yew tree bridging rural folklore and modern alienation. Sound design amplifies isolation—distant church bells toll like funeral dirges, wind whispers accusations. This sonic landscape crafts a pervasive unease, where silence between screams is most harrowing.
Cinematography’s Nightmare Palette
Óscar Faura’s cinematography bathes the film in twilight blues and sickly greens, the yew tree looming like a sentinel against stormy skies. Long takes capture Conor’s tiny figure against vast backdrops, emphasising powerlessness. Key scenes utilise Dutch angles during confrontations, tilting reality into instability. Practical sets—the O’Malley home cluttered with medical detritus—contrast the grandmother’s pristine minimalism, visual metaphors for chaos versus control.
Special effects warrant a spotlight: the monster’s creation combined motion-capture from Neeson with intricate puppeteering and CGI refinement. Its movements—lumbering yet graceful—evoke Godzilla’s atomic wrath fused with folklore giants. Bayona’s horror roots shine in destruction sequences: homes splinter, earth quakes, all rendered with tangible physics that avoids digital sterility. Influences from Guillermo del Toro abound, yet Bayona infuses a distinctly European melancholy.
Legacy of the Yew: Echoes in Modern Horror
Released amid a wave of grief-centric horrors like Hereditary, A Monster Calls pioneered dark fantasy’s therapeutic edge. Its box-office success spawned discussions on children’s horror, paving for films like Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark. Production challenges included Ness’s insistence on fidelity post-author Siobhan Dowd’s death, adding meta-layers of mourning. Censorship dodged in the UK, but US edits softened violence for PG-13, diluting impact.
The film’s genre placement bridges family drama and supernatural horror, evolving the “monster mentor” trope from The NeverEnding Story. Its influence ripples in animation-horror hybrids, proving grief’s universality transcends age. Bayona’s work here solidified his shift from pure horror to prestige blends, influencing his later epics. As explored further at Dyerbolical https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, these themes continue to resonate in new ways for audiences revisiting the film years later.
Ultimately, the fourth tale—Conor’s admission of wishing his mother dead to end suffering—unleashes the true horror: self-recrimination. In a wrenching climax, the monster crushes Conor, only to reform as catharsis. This resolution affirms storytelling’s power to conquer monsters born of silence.
Director in the Spotlight
Juan Antonio Bayona, known professionally as J.A. Bayona, was born on 15 May 1975 in Barcelona, Spain. Growing up in a culturally vibrant city, Bayona immersed himself in cinema from a young age, devouring the works of Hitchcock, Carpenter, and del Toro. He studied communication sciences at the Autonomous University of Barcelona before transitioning to filmmaking, assisting on commercials and music videos. His short film Alessandra (1997) showcased early horror sensibilities, blending suspense with emotional depth.
Bayona’s feature debut, The Orphanage (2007), a gothic ghost story produced by Guillermo del Toro, catapulted him to international acclaim. Nominated for a Goya Award for Best Director, it grossed over $50 million worldwide, establishing Bayona as a master of atmospheric horror. He followed with The Impossible (2012), a harrowing tsunami survival drama starring Naomi Watts (Oscar-nominated), which earned $198 million and multiple awards, proving his range beyond genre confines.
Returning to fantasy-horror, A Monster Calls (2016) demonstrated his skill in hybrid narratives. Bayona then helmed Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom (2018), injecting emotional stakes into blockbuster spectacle, grossing $1.18 billion. His Netflix survival epic Society of the Snow (2023), about the 1972 Andes flight disaster, garnered Oscar nominations for Best International Feature and Best Makeup, praised for its unflinching realism and humanism. Influences include Spanish cinema greats like Bigas Luna and international auteurs like Bong Joon-ho.
Bayona’s filmography reflects a penchant for trauma’s aftermath: orphaned children, natural disasters, plane crashes—all explored with visceral empathy. Upcoming projects include a Black Hole adaptation for Prime Video. With production company Rodar y Rodar, he champions emerging talent. Awards tally includes Goyas, BAFTAs, and Saturn nods; his style marries meticulous craft with raw emotion, cementing his status as a 21st-century horror visionary.
Actor in the Spotlight
Liam Neeson, born William John Neeson on 7 June 1952 in Ballymena, Northern Ireland, rose from modest roots—son of a school caretaker and cook—to global stardom. A former forklift operator and amateur boxer, Neeson trained at the Gaiety School of Drama in Dublin. His screen debut came in 1977’s The Long Duel, but breakthrough arrived with John Boorman’s Excalibur (1981) as Sir Gawain.
Neeson’s career trajectory exploded in the 1990s: Oskar Schindler in Spielberg’s Schindler’s List (1993) earned an Oscar nomination, showcasing dramatic gravitas. He voiced Aslan in the Chronicles of Narnia trilogy (2005-2010), blending authority with warmth. The action renaissance began with Taken (2008), birthing the “particular set of skills” icon, spawning sequels and imitators. Notable roles include Star Wars: Episode I (1999) as Qui-Gon Jinn, Kinsey (2004), and Les Misérables (1998).
In A Monster Calls, Neeson’s motion-captured monster infuses mythic menace with paternal sorrow. Filmography spans 100+ credits: horrors like Darkman (1990), dramas (Michael Collins, 1996, Golden Globe winner), and blockbusters (Clash of the Titans, 2010). Awards include BAFTA, Critics’ Choice, and honorary doctorates. Personal tragedies—wife Natasha Richardson’s 2009 death—mirror his grief-themed roles, adding authenticity. At 72, Neeson continues prolific output, including Absolution (2023) and The Ice Road (2021), embodying resilient everyman heroism.
Bibliography
Bellini, R. (2017) J.A. Bayona: The Orphanage and Beyond. Cahiers du Cinéma, Paris.
Bradshaw, P. (2017) ‘A Monster Calls review – heartbreaking tale of a boy and his monster’, The Guardian, 1 January.
Ness, P. (2011) A Monster Calls. Walker Books, London.
Powell, A. (2019) ‘Grief and the Monstrous in Contemporary Fantasy Cinema’, Journal of Horror Studies, 5(2), pp. 45-67.
Romney, J. (2016) ‘Monsters of the Mind: Bayona’s Fairy-Tale Terrors’, Sight & Sound, 26(11), pp. 34-38.
Scott, A.O. (2017) ‘A Boy, a Tree, a Mother’s Last Days’, New York Times, 22 January.
Travers, P. (2017) ‘A Monster Calls’, Rolling Stone, 23 January.
Foundas, S. (2016) ‘A Monster Calls’, Variety, 10 September.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
