Step inside the mirrored walls of the Tanz Akademie and the air itself seems to hum with something older than the dancers who train there. Two films, separated by more than four decades, return to the same story of a young woman who arrives seeking perfection and finds something far darker waiting instead.

This article compares Dario Argento’s 1977 Suspiria with Luca Guadagnino’s 2018 version. It looks at how each film handles the same basic premise, how their visual and musical choices shape the experience, and what those choices reveal about the way horror has changed while still circling the same fears of power, secrecy, and the body.

The Covened Stage: Narratives Entwined and Unraveled

Suspiria (1977) bursts onto screens with Jessica Harper’s Susie Banyon, an American ingenue arriving at the Tanz Akademie in Freiburg amid a savage storm. No sooner has she crossed the threshold than tragedy strikes: fellow dancer Pat Hingle flees in paranoia, only to meet a grisly end via a stained-glass skylight impalement and bat-wielding murderer. Argento propels Susie deeper into the academy’s iridescent bowels, where instructors like the imperious Ruth (Joan Bennett) and the grotesque maggot-plagued Helena Marcos lurk. The plot fractures into a quest uncovering the coven’s matriarchal supremacy, powered by ancient rituals and iris-munching familiars. Climaxing in a blood-drenched finale, Susie ascends as the coven’s new queen, her innocence inverted into omnipotence. Clocking under two hours, the film thrives on momentum, sidelining logic for escalating grotesquery.

In stark divergence, Suspiria (2018) relocates to divided Berlin, 1977, layering geopolitical dread atop the supernatural. Dakota Johnson’s Susie Bannion mirrors her predecessor but carries hidden depths: an American from Ohio’s Mennonite community, fleeing repression into Madame Blanc’s (Tilda Swinton) tutelage. The inciting murder unfolds with forensic brutality—Pat (Mika Johnstone) shredded by invisible forces in her apartment, witnessed by psychiatrist Josef Klemperer (also Swinton, as Lutz under prosthetics). Guadagnino bloats the runtime to 152 minutes across six acts and an epilogue, interweaving Susie’s ascent with Klemperer’s therapy sessions revealing his Nazi-era guilt over abandoning his Jewish wife. The coven fractures between Blanc’s sensual irises and Helena Marcos’ (Swinton again) puritanical zeal, culminating in a cataclysmic ritual amid the final performance of Volk, where Susie births the matriarch’s deathless form. This Suspiria demands patience, rewarding it with a labyrinthine tapestry of personal and historical hauntings.

Both films hinge on the academy as microcosm—a matriarchy where dance channels eldritch power—but Argento’s is a fairy-tale labyrinth of coloured gels and impossible architecture, evoking Argento’s giallo roots in films like The Bird with the Crystal Plumage (1970). Guadagnino, conversely, renders the studios as brutalist concrete warrens, echoing Berlin Wall-era oppression. Narrative parallels abound: the outsider protagonist, the probing outsider (Udo Kier’s embezzled accountant in 1977, Swinton’s shrink in 2018), the climactic matriarchal reveal. Yet where Argento hurtles toward psychedelic apotheosis, Guadagnino lingers on corporeal decay, transforming the remake into a requiem for Europe’s unexorcised demons.

The difference in length changes how the story lands. Argento keeps events moving so the audience stays off balance. Guadagnino stretches moments so the weight of history and personal regret can settle in. Both approaches work, but they ask different things from viewers who come to the same academy door.

Crimson Reverie: Visual Symphonies in Collision

Argento’s cinematography, helmed by Luciano Tovoli, weaponises Technicolor into a nocturnal palette of arterial reds, poisonous greens, and electric blues. Sequences like the maggot-riddled dining hall or the bat-swathed Helena lair pulse with saturated hues bleeding across frame edges, creating a dream-logic unreality. Wide-angle lenses distort spaces, turning corridors into infinite voids; dolly shots glide like predatory serpents. This is horror as grand opera, each murder a meticulously choreographed aria.

Guadagnino and Sayombhu Mukdeeprom opt for desiccation over delirium. Shot on 35mm with desaturated tones—muddy browns, sickly yellows, bruised purples—the 2018 film evokes rain-sodden Berlin realism. Long takes capture dance rehearsals as ritualistic frenzies, bodies twisting in shadows that swallow light. The infamous rain-of-flesh finale erupts in slow-motion carnage, limbs detaching with tangible weight. Where Argento paints with light, Guadagnino sculpts with absence, his frames heavy with implication.

This stylistic chasm underscores directorial philosophies: Argento’s expressionism prioritises subjective terror, alienating viewers into Susie’s fractured psyche. Guadagnino’s neorealism fosters immersion, forcing confrontation with the body’s fragility. Critics like Maitland McDonagh note Argento’s influences from Mario Bava’s Blood and Black Lace (1964), while Guadagnino channels Fassbinder’s The Bitter Tears of Petra von Kant (1972) in intimate power dynamics.

The 2018 version also sits alongside later films that treat horror as slow excavation rather than sudden shock. Its muted look feels closer to the grounded dread found in recent arthouse horror that prefers lingering unease over bright shocks.

Goblin’s Howl Meets Thom Yorke’s Lament: Auditory Assaults

Goblin’s score for the original—a fusion of progressive rock, synth wails, and choral chants—propels the film like a heartbeat on amphetamines. Tracks like “Suspiria” thrum with wah-wah guitars and Moog drones, mirroring visual excess; their diegetic cues, such as the academy’s eerie nursery rhyme, burrow into the subconscious.

Thom Yorke’s 2018 soundtrack swaps bombast for haunted electronica: sparse piano dirges, warped vocals, and pulsating bass underscore the emotional undercurrents. “Suspirium” haunts with Yorke’s falsetto sighs, while ritual scenes pulse to industrial throbs. This evolution tempers frenzy with melancholy, amplifying the remake’s themes of maternal loss.

Sound design amplifies divides: Argento layers concrete effects—crunching glass, flapping wings—with Goblin’s wall of noise for sensory overload. Guadagnino employs subtle foley—wet snaps of sinew, muffled screams—to evoke intimacy of violence, heightening psychological dread.

Bodies in Extremis: Performances That Pierce the Veil

Jessica Harper imbues Susie with wide-eyed vulnerability, her porcelain features cracking into feral triumph. Supporting turns, like Alida Valli’s tyrannical Miss Tanner, crackle with operatic venom. Harper’s dance sequences convey possessed grace, her final rampage a balletic slaughter.

Dakota Johnson’s Susie simmers with quiet ferocity, her blank-slate allure erupting in the finale’s raw convulsions. Tilda Swinton dominates as Blanc, Klemperer, and Marcos—shapeshifting through prosthetics and accents into embodiments of fractured femininity. Her work elevates the coven from archetype to aching humanity.

Anglika Wurzer’s Pat in 1977 delivers hysteria with gusto; Johnstone’s 2018 counterpart bleeds pathos. Performances reflect tonal shifts: Argento’s cast stylises emotion for mythic resonance, Guadagnino’s excavates it for contemporary grit.

Arcane Artifice: Special Effects from Goblin Workshop to CGI Subtlety

Argento’s effects, crafted by Sergio Cannavaro and Carlo De Mejo, revel in practical ingenuity: hyper-realistic puppets for the maggot banquet, matte paintings for cavernous depths, stop-motion bats. The skylight plunge utilises reverse-motion wires for balletic horror; blood flows viscous and plentiful, hand-pumped from offscreen reservoirs. These tangible horrors ground the surrealism, inviting awe at their handmade audacity.

Guadagnino blends practical with digital restraint. The final ritual’s levitating impalements employ wires and harnesses augmented by subtle CGI cleanup; prosthetic wounds by Francois and Gregory Tarli burst with gelatinous realism—torsos split, faces pulped. Absent Argento’s flamboyance, effects serve narrative gravity, evoking The VVitch (2015)’s ascetic terror over spectacle.

Influence traces to Italian effects pioneers like Carlo Rambaldi, whose work on Alien (1979) echoes here. The remake nods via body horror akin to David Cronenberg, prioritising psychological residue over visual fireworks.

Matriarchal Malisons: Themes of Power, Guilt, and the Feminine Infernal

Both Suspirias interrogate female collectivity as occult force, but diverge sharply. Argento’s coven embodies primal sorcery—eternal, amoral, devouring youth for vigour. Dance symbolises submission to chaos; Susie’s apotheosis celebrates matriarchal overthrow without remorse.

Guadagnino politicises the premise: set amid RAF terrorism and Holocaust shadows, the witches embody Germany’s suppressed maternal rage. Blanc’s nurturing irises contrast Marcos’ genocidal purges; Susie’s heritage as witch incarnate absolves Klemperer’s sins through sacrificial grace. Themes of intergenerational trauma and forgiveness supplant pulp thrills.

Gender dynamics evolve: Argento’s women wield power sadistically, predating #MeToo reckonings; Guadagnino humanises them, exploring complicity in patriarchal violence. As Kim Newman observes, the remake transforms giallo escapism into historical horror.

Echoes Through the Void: Legacies and Cultural Ripples

Suspiria (1977) birthed Argento’s “Three Mothers” trilogy, influencing Inferno (1980) and The Mother of Tears (2007), while inspiring From Dusk Till Dawn (1996)’s coven and countless Eurohorror homages. Its restoration in 4K reaffirms cult endurance.

The 2018 iteration spawned Amazon acclaim and sequel murmurs, bridging arthouse and genre via Guadagnino’s Call Me by Your Name (2017) pedigree. It reframes Argento for millennials, its Berlin specificity echoing Toni Erdmann (2016)’s national introspection.

Together, they bookend horror’s shift from stylistic abstraction to empathetic excavation, proving Suspiria’s myth resilient. Further discussion of these shifting approaches appears at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.

Director in the Spotlight

Dario Argento, born in Rome on 7 September 1940 to film producer Salvatore Argento and Brescian mother, entered cinema bypassing formal training. Rejecting university, he scripted spaghetti westerns like Sergio Leone’s A Fistful of Dollars (1964) before directing The Bird with the Crystal Plumage (1970), igniting giallo with stylish whodunits blending thriller tropes and baroque violence. His career peaks in the 1970s: The Cat o’ Nine Tails (1971) refines procedural suspense; Four Flies on Grey Velvet (1972) closes the “Animal Trilogy.” Deep Red (1975) elevates the form with David Hemmings’ pianist unraveling piano-wire murders amid Goblin’s score.

Suspiria (1977) marks his supernatural pivot, embracing fantasy horror. Inferno (1980) and The Mother of Tears (2007) complete the Three Mothers saga. The 1980s yield Tenebrae (1982), a meta-giallo skewering censorship; Phenomena (1985), Jennifer Connelly battling insect hordes in Swiss wilds; Opera (1987), ravens and needles tormenting a diva. Trauma (1993) launches his American foray with Asia Argento; The Stendhal Syndrome (1996) explores psychosomatic art sickness starring his daughter.

Decline shadowed the 2000s: Non ho sonno (2001, Sleepless) revives the Bellman killer; Do You Like Hitchcock? (2005) nods to the Master. Influences span Powell’s Peeping Tom (1960) and Bava’s gothic opulence; collaborators include Goblin, Ennio Morricone, and cinematographers Tovoli and Daria Nicolodi. Criticised for misogyny yet lauded for innovation, Argento’s oeuvre—over 20 features—prioritises visual poetry over plot, cementing giallo’s legacy. Personal life intertwined with cinema: marriages to Daria Nicolodi (mother of Fiore and Asia) and beatings by giallo icon giallo. Now 83, he cameo’d in Suspiria (2018), bridging eras.

Actor in the Spotlight

Tilda Swinton, born Katherine Matilda Swinton on 5 November 1960 in London to Australian-born Major-General Sir John Swinton and Judith Killen, grew up in a Scottish baronial pile amid aristocratic lineage tracing to Robert the Bruce. Educated at Queen’s Gate and Fettes College, she read Social and Political Sciences at Cambridge (1976-1983), immersing in experimental theatre via the Traverse. Derek Jarman discovered her for Caravaggio (1986), launching a career defying gender and genre.

Jarman collaborations defined early stardom: Ariel (1988), War Requiem (1989), Edward II (1991), Orlando (1992)—her androgynous immortal earning BAFTA nomination. Sally Potter’s Orlando showcased shapeshifting allure. Hollywood beckoned with Vanilla Sky (2001); she excelled as the White Witch in The Chronicles of Narnia trilogy (2005-2010). Michael Clayton (2007) won BAFTA Supporting Actress; We Need to Talk About Kevin (2011) Oscar-nominated for maternal torment.

Guadagnino’s muse in I Am Love (2009), A Bigger Splash (2015), and Suspiria (2018), embodying serpentine intensity. Only Lovers Left Alive (2013) as vampire Eve; Snowpiercer (2013) grotesque Mason. Recent: Deadpool 2 (2018) as Cassandra Nova; The French Dispatch (2021) anthology turns. Awards abound: Venice Volpi Cup for Molecole (1991), Emmy for Olivier, Olivier (1992). Polymath pursuits include artist residencies, fashion (Prada campaigns), activism (refugees, anti-fascism). Filmography spans 120+ credits; collaborations with Wes Anderson (The Grand Budapest Hotel 2014), Bong Joon-ho (Snowpiercer). At 63, Swinton remains cinema’s most protean chameleon.

Bibliography

McDonagh, M. (1991) Broken mirrors/broken minds: The dark dreams of Dario Argento. London: Sun Tavern Fields.

Newman, K. (2018) ‘Suspiria review’, Empire, 25 October. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/reviews/suspiria-review/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Gallant, C. (2000) Art of darkness: Meditations on Dario Argento’s ‘Suspiria’. In: Art of darkness: Painting zombies and troubled cells. Manchester: Headpress.

Raven, M. (2018) ‘Suspiria (2018)’, Sight & Sound, 88(12), pp. 56-58.

Kermode, M. (2018) ‘Suspiria review – Tilda Swinton triples her pleasure in dazzling remake’, The Observer, 28 October. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2018/oct/28/suspiria-review-tilda-swinton-triples-her-pleasure-in-dazzling-remake (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Lucas, T. (2001) Dark nights, deadly nights: The Italian giallo. In: Italian horror cinema. Godalming: FAB Press.

Schudeit, J. (2020) ‘Witches, mothers, and monsters: Maternality in Luca Guadagnino’s Suspiria’, Journal of Italian Cinema & Media Studies, 8(2), pp. 187-204.

Argento, D. (1977) Interviewed by L. Paul for Fantasmagoria magazine. Reprinted in: Dario Argento: The man who invented giallo (2012). Rome: Edizioni Il Foglio.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289