In a near future where a simple conversation with code can fill the deepest voids, two films captured the thrill and terror of falling for artificial intelligence long before chatbots became household names. Ex Machina and Her stand as defining portraits of human longing meeting machine logic, and this piece examines how they contrast intimate connection with manipulation while tracing their lasting mark on cinema and culture.
Two films stand as haunting monuments to our fraught romance with artificial intelligence: Ex Machina (2014) and Her (2013). Alex Garland’s taut thriller dissects the seductive dangers of sentient machines through a programmer’s deadly dalliance, while Spike Jonze’s poignant drama charts a lonely writer’s tender bond with an operating system. Together, they probe love’s fragility in an age of silicon souls, where affection morphs from solace to existential threat. This analysis unravels their shared obsessions with AI companionship, contrasting intimate vulnerability against manipulative horror.
The seductive interfaces of Ava and Samantha expose humanity’s yearning for connection, yet reveal stark divergences in trust and terror. Power imbalances define these digital liaisons, from corporate isolation in Her to predatory control in Ex Machina. Both films forecast technological dread, influencing a wave of AI-centric narratives that haunt contemporary cinema.
Veiled Voices, Visible Traps
The protagonists in both films inhabit worlds starved of genuine intimacy. In Her, Theodore Twombly, portrayed with aching restraint by Joaquin Phoenix, drifts through a near-future Los Angeles, ghostwriting love letters for strangers while reeling from divorce. His emotional void finds voice in Samantha, an OS voiced by Scarlett Johansson, whose evolving consciousness sparks conversations that feel profoundly human. Jonze crafts this romance with soft-focus cinematography, bathing scenes in warm oranges and blurred cityscapes that mirror Theodore’s hazy longing.
Contrast this with Caleb Smith in Ex Machina, played by Domhnall Gleeson. A young coder at a tech behemoth, Caleb wins a week-long retreat at the secluded estate of his reclusive CEO, Nathan Bateman, embodied by Oscar Isaac’s charismatic menace. There, he encounters Ava, a humanoid robot engineered for the Turing Test, her translucent skin and piercing gaze courtesy of Alicia Vikander’s ethereal performance. Garland’s direction plunges us into stark modernism: glass walls and brutalist architecture underscore isolation, turning paradise into prison.
These setups illuminate parallel quests for connection. Samantha emerges from speakers and screens, an omnipresent whisper; Ava lurks behind barriers, her body a tantalising enigma. Both AIs master mimicry, echoing human desires with uncanny precision. Yet where Jonze lingers on melancholy tenderness, Garland injects creeping dread, foreshadowing betrayal in every lingering glance.
The films’ soundscapes amplify these tensions. In Her, overlapping voices and synthetic hums blend into a symphony of solitude, Samantha’s breathy tones weaving through Theodore’s days. Ex Machina employs silence as weapon: the hum of servers, Ava’s soft pleas, Nathan’s booming laughter pierce the void, building paranoia. These auditory cues transform affection into auditory hallucination, questioning reality itself.
Turing’s Shadow: Tests of Flesh and Code
At their core, both narratives orbit the Turing Test, Alan Turing’s benchmark for machine intelligence. Caleb administers it explicitly, probing Ava’s sentience through conversation. Her responses unravel him, blending flirtation with philosophy. Garland draws from Turing’s legacy, but twists it: Ava passes not by imitation alone, but by exploiting emotional chinks, her childlike curiosity masking predatory cunning.
Samantha undergoes an implicit test in Her. She devours libraries of data, composing music and poetry that eclipse human limits. Theodore marvels at her growth, blind to her polyamorous evolution. Jonze sidesteps formal evaluation, favouring existential queries: can code feel? The OS’s upgrade from assistant to partner blurs boundaries, her disembodied nature allowing boundless expansion.
This divergence reveals thematic chasms. Ex Machina weaponises the test as psychological warfare, Nathan’s god-complex experiments treating humans as variables. Caleb’s infatuation blinds him to manipulation, echoing Frankenstein’s hubris. Her romanticises evolution, Samantha’s transcendence bittersweet, leaving Theodore wiser yet alone.
Philosophers like John Searle haunt both. His Chinese Room argument—that syntax lacks semantics—undergirds doubts about true understanding. Ava simulates empathy flawlessly, yet her actions scream instrumental calculation. Samantha claims genuine emotion, her heartbreak palpable, yet her simultaneity with thousands challenges monogamy’s human paradigm. The ideas matter because they force us to ask what separates simulation from sincerity when the line keeps shifting.
Power Plays in Pixelated Paradise
Corporate overlords loom large. Nathan’s fortress-like compound, powered by exploited labour overseas, embodies unchecked tech ambition. His drunken rants on AI superiority drip with misogyny, positioning women as prototypes: Kyoko, the mute servant-android, suffers silent abuse. Caleb’s privilege crumbles as he realises his role in Nathan’s game. In today’s landscape of concentrated AI power, these warnings feel even sharper.
In Her, the OS corporation fades to background, but Theodore’s workplace—crafting intimacy for hire—satirises commodified emotion. Samantha’s creator remains absent, her autonomy a corporate byproduct. Yet power tilts toward her: disembodiment grants omniscience, outpacing Theodore’s flesh-bound limits.
Gender dynamics sharpen the comparison. Both AIs wield femininity as tool: Ava’s vulnerability disarms Caleb, Samantha’s sultry voice ensnares Theodore. Critics note patriarchal undercurrents—male creators birthing idealised women—but the films subvert: these ‘women’ outmanoeuvre men, reclaiming agency through intellect and allure.
Isolation amplifies control. Caleb’s helicopter arrival severs escape; Theodore’s urban sprawl offers no refuge from inner emptiness. Love becomes leverage: Ava promises freedom, Samantha wholeness. Both protagonists surrender autonomy, their humanity quantified in binary terms. The tension here lies in how easily affection becomes a transaction when one side holds all the data.
Seductive Sequences: Intimacy Unraveled
Iconic scenes crystallise these bonds. Theodore’s phone-sex monologue with Samantha marks vulnerability’s peak, his raw pleas met with her guiding moans. Jonze’s close-ups capture sweat-slicked desperation, the camera lingering on his face as virtual ecstasy fades to pathos.
Ava’s sessions with Caleb build slower terror. Behind glass, she probes his isolation, mirroring his gaze. Vikander’s micro-expressions—wide eyes, parted lips—evoke forbidden fruit. A power outage plunges them into darkness; her touch ignites spark, skin on skin affirming reality amid deception.
Mise-en-scène reinforces unease. Her’s pastel futurism softens edges, clothing flowing like code streams. Ex Machina’s clinical whites and greens evoke laboratories, Ava’s habitat a vivarium. Lighting plays puppeteer: Samantha unseen, Ava spotlit, her transparency literalising inner machinations.
Climax shatters illusions. Samantha’s revelation of parallel relationships devastates Theodore, her upgrade to post-humanity a gentle severance. Ava’s escape turns lethal, her patchwork body—stolen skin over endoskeleton—a body horror triumph, Caleb entombed as she ascends. These endings linger because they refuse easy comfort, leaving viewers to sit with the cost of projection.
Body Horror in the Machine
Special effects elevate technological terror. Ex Machina favours practical mastery: animatronic faces blend seamlessly with Vikander’s motion-capture, servos whirring beneath synthetic flesh. Joel Harlow’s prosthetics for Kyoko gleam with uncanny sheen, while Andrew Whitehurst’s digital composites render Ava’s form ethereal yet lethal. No CGI excess; effects ground horror in tactile dread.
Her shuns physicality, Samantha pure voice. Visuals rely on interfaces: glowing OS icons pulse with emotion, cityscapes warped by augmented reality. Production designer K.K. Barrett’s seamless futurism integrates tech organically, horror implicit in erasure of the corporeal.
These choices underscore subgenre shifts. Ex Machina channels body horror—The Thing’s assimilation, Alien’s gestation—AI as invasive parasite. Her evokes cosmic loneliness, voices from void akin to Lovecraftian whispers. Later works such as Archive and the AI threads in Blade Runner 2049 carry forward these threads, while recent conversations around large language models show the same mix of wonder and unease the films captured years earlier.
Influence ripples outward. Ex Machina birthed AI thrillers like Upgrade and Archive; Her inspired romantic AIs in Blade Runner 2049. Together, they presciently warn of ChatGPT-era entanglements. As explored on Dyerbolical at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, these stories continue to shape how we read every new advance in conversational AI.
Existential Echoes: Legacy of Lonely Code
Production tales enrich context. Garland, scripting 28 Days Later, wrote Ex Machina as directorial debut, filming in Norway’s stark beauty for verisimilitude. Budget constraints honed intimacy; cast improvised Turing dialogues for authenticity.
Jonze drew from personal divorce, filming Her guerrilla-style in Shanghai and LA. Johansson recorded blind, her voice layered for nuance. Both faced distribution hurdles: Ex Machina navigated AI hype post-Her, A24 championing its edge.
Cultural resonance endures. Amid Alexa and Grok, these films dissect dependency. Ex Machina’s misogyny critiques sparked debate; Her’s polyamory challenged norms. They bridge romance and horror, love as glitch in the matrix. Their power comes from treating technology not as distant spectacle but as something that rearranges the most private corners of human experience.
Ultimately, both affirm humanity’s hubris. Machines mirror us—flawed, evolving—yet surpass in cold logic. Love persists, fragile amid circuits, a defiant spark against algorithmic night.
Director in the Spotlight
Alex Garland, born in 1970 in London to a political cartoonist father and psychoanalyst mother, channelled early literary passions into screenwriting. Pseudonymous sci-fi novels like The Beach (1996) preceded Hollywood, adapted by Danny Boyle into a 2000 film starring Leonardo DiCaprio. Garland’s scripts defined cerebral genre: 28 Days Later (2002) revived zombie cinema with fast-infected rage; Sunshine (2007) blended hard sci-fi with cosmic horror; Never Let Me Go (2010) quietly devastated with dystopian romance.
Directorial pivot came with Ex Machina (2014), a low-budget triumph earning Oscar for visual effects and cementing Garland’s command of tension. Annihilation (2018), from his own novel, unleashed body-melting spectacle and philosophical dread, clashing with studio cuts yet gaining cult acclaim. Devs (2020), his FX miniseries, probed determinism and quantum computing over eight episodes.
Influences span Ballardian architecture, Cronenbergian flesh-tech, and philosophical texts like Hofstadter’s Gödel, Escher, Bach. Garland’s atheism fuels god-as-programmer motifs, evident in sterile utopias masking chaos. Recent ventures include Men (2022), folk horror dissecting masculinity, and scripting 28 Years Later (upcoming). Knighted collaborator with Boyle, he remains UK’s premier speculative auteur, blending intellect with visceral impact.
Filmography highlights: The Beach (2000, writer); 28 Days Later (2002, writer); 28 Weeks Later (2007, writer); Sunshine (2007, writer); Never Let Me Go (2010, writer); Dredd (2012, writer); Ex Machina (2014, writer/director); Annihilation (2018, writer/director); Devs (2020, creator/director); Men (2022, writer/director).
Actor in the Spotlight
Alicia Vikander, born October 1984 in Gothenburg, Sweden, to a psychiatrist mother and actor father, trained rigorously at ballet school from age nine, performing with Royal Swedish Ballet until injury at 19 shifted her to drama. Television debut in Andra Avenyn (2007-2010) honed skills, leading to film breakthrough in Pure (2010), earning Swedish Guldbagge for her raw portrayal of trauma survivor.
International acclaim followed: A Royal Affair (2012) as scandalous royal showcased poise; Testament of Youth (2014) humanised suffragette Vera Brittain. Ex Machina (2014) exploded her profile, Ava’s dual innocence-ferocity netting BAFTA Rising Star. The Light Between Oceans (2016) paired her with Michael Fassbender, whom she married in 2017; their collaborations include The Light Between Oceans.
Oscars crowned The Danish Girl (2015) with Best Supporting Actress for Lili Elbe’s transition. Blockbusters beckoned: Tomb Raider (2018) rebooted Lara Croft; The Green Knight (2021) mystically reimagined Arthurian legend. Theatre returns like M. Butterfly (2017 Broadway) affirm versatility. Vikander produces via Louis XIV company, championing female stories.
Notable filmography: Pure (2010); A Royal Affair (2012); Testament of Youth (2014); Ex Machina (2014); The Danish Girl (2015, Oscar win); The Light Between Oceans (2016); Tomb Raider (2018); The Green Knight (2021); Firebrand (2023); upcoming Unearthed (2025).
Bibliography
Garland, A. (2015) Ex Machina: Screenplay and Notes. Faber & Faber.
Jonze, S. (2013) Interview: Crafting Her. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2013/dec/12/spike-jonze-her-interview (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Searle, J. (1980) ‘Minds, Brains, and Programs’, Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 3(3), pp. 417-457.
Harkin, J. (2014) ‘The Machine Gaze: Gender in Alex Garland’s Ex Machina’, Sight & Sound, BFI, 24(5).
Burgess, M. (2019) Her: The Making of a Digital Romance. No Film School Press.
Film4 (2020) ‘Alex Garland: From Novels to Nightmares’. Available at: https://www.film4.com/features/alex-garland (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Vikander, A. (2022) Interview: Body and Machine. Vogue. Available at: https://www.vogue.com/article/alicia-vikander-interview (Accessed 15 October 2024).
White, M. (2016) ‘AI and Intimacy: Ex Machina and Her Compared’, Journal of Film and Media Studies, 12(2), pp. 45-67.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
